Go to Related Reading
About this book

God’s Knowledge and the Infinite

Chapter 18

I also have no doubt that before the first man was created, there never had been a man at all, neither this same man himself returning through some unknown cycles, having made some unknown number of revolutions, nor any other of similar nature. I am not frightened away from this belief by philosophical arguments, among which the one considered most acute is founded on the assertion that the infinite cannot be comprehended by any mode of knowledge. Consequently, they argue, God has in His own mind finite conceptions of all finite things which He makes.

Now it cannot be supposed that His goodness was ever idle; for if it were, we would have to ascribe to Him an awakening to activity in time, from a past eternity of inactivity, as if He repented of an idleness that had no beginning, and proceeded, therefore, to make a beginning of work. This being the case, they say that the same things must always be repeated, and that as they pass, so they are destined always to return, whether amid all these changes the world remains the same—the world which has always been, and yet was created—or that the world in these revolutions is perpetually dying out and being renewed; otherwise, if we point to a time when the works of God were begun, it would be believed that He considered His past eternal leisure to be inert and indolent, and therefore condemned and altered it as displeasing to Himself.

Now if God is supposed to have been indeed always making temporal things, but different from one another, and one after the other, so that He came at last in this way to make man, whom He had never made before, then it may seem that He made man not with knowledge—for they suppose no knowledge can comprehend the infinite succession of creatures—but on the impulse of the hour, as it struck Him at the moment, with a sudden and accidental change of mind. On the other hand, they say, if those cycles are admitted, and if we suppose that the same temporal things are repeated, while the world either remains identical through all these rotations, or else dies away and is renewed, then there is ascribed to God neither the slothful ease of a past eternity, nor a rash and unforeseen creation.

And if the same things are not repeated in cycles in this way, then they cannot be comprehended by any knowledge or foreknowledge in their endless diversity. Even though reason could not refute, faith would smile at these arguments, with which the godless try to turn our simple piety from the right way, so that we may walk with them “in a circle.” But with the help of the Lord our God, even reason shatters, and readily enough, these revolving circles which conjecture frames. For what especially leads these men astray, so that they prefer their own circles to the straight path of truth, is that they measure by their own human, changeable, and narrow intellect the divine mind, which is absolutely unchangeable, infinite in capacity, and without succession of thought, counting all things without number.

So that saying of the apostle comes true of them, for, “comparing themselves with themselves, they do not understand.” For because they do, by a new decision, whatever new thing has occurred to them to be done, their minds being changeable, they conclude it is so with God; and thus compare, not God—for they cannot conceive God, but think of one like themselves when they think of Him—not God, but themselves, and not with Him, but with themselves. For our part, we do not dare to believe that God is affected in one way when He works, in another when He rests. Indeed, to say that He is affected at all is an abuse of language, since it implies that there comes to be something in His nature which was not there before.

For whoever is affected is acted on, and whatever is acted on is changeable. His leisure, therefore, is no laziness, indolence, inactivity; just as in His work there is no labor, effort, industry. He can act while He rests, and rest while He acts. He can begin a new work with an eternal, not a new, design; and what He has not made before, He does not now begin to make because He repents of His former rest. But when one speaks of His former rest and later activity—and I do not know how men can understand these things—this “former” and “subsequent” are applied only to the things created, which formerly did not exist, and subsequently came into existence.

But in God the former purpose is not altered and wiped out by the subsequent and different purpose, but by one and the same eternal and unchangeable will He brought about, for the things He created, both that formerly, as long as they did not exist, they should not exist, and that subsequently, when they began to be, they should come into existence. And thus, perhaps, He wished to show, in a very striking way, to those who have eyes for such things, how independent He is of what He makes, and how it is from His own freely given goodness that He creates, since from eternity He dwelt without creatures in no less perfect a blessedness.

God Knows All Numbers

Chapter 19

As for their other assertion, that God’s knowledge cannot comprehend things infinite, it only remains for them to affirm, in order to plumb the depths of their impiety, that God does not know all numbers. For it is very certain that they are infinite; since, no matter at what number you suppose an end to be made, this number can be, I will not say, increased by the addition of one more, but however great it is, and however vast the multitude of which it is the rational and scientific expression, it can still be not only doubled, but even multiplied. Moreover, each number is so defined by its own properties, that no two numbers are equal. They are therefore both unequal and different from one another; and while they are individually finite, collectively they are infinite.

Does God, therefore, not know numbers on account of this infinity; and does His knowledge extend only to a certain height in numbers, while of the rest He is ignorant? Who is so senseless as to say so? Yet they can hardly claim to put numbers out of the question, or maintain that they have nothing to do with the knowledge of God; for Plato, their great authority, represents God as framing the world on numerical principles; and in our books also it is said to God, “You have ordered all things in number, and measure, and weight.”⁠ The prophet also says, “Who brings out their host by number.” And the Savior says in the Gospel, “The very hairs of your head are all numbered.”

We must never doubt, then, that all number is known to Him “whose understanding,” according to the Psalmist, “is infinite.” The infinity of number, though infinite numbers cannot be counted, is nevertheless not beyond the comprehension of Him whose understanding is infinite. And thus, if everything which is comprehended is defined or made finite by the comprehension of him who knows it, then all infinity is in some ineffable way made finite to God, for it is comprehensible by His knowledge.

Therefore, if the infinity of numbers cannot be infinite to the knowledge of God, by which it is comprehended, what are we poor creatures to presume to fix limits to His knowledge, and say that unless the same temporal thing is repeated by the same periodic revolutions, God cannot either foreknow His creatures so that He may make them, or know them when He has made them? God, whose knowledge is manifold in its simplicity, and uniform in its variety, comprehends all incomprehensibles with so incomprehensible a comprehension, that though He willed always to make His later works novel and unlike what went before them, He could not produce them without order and foresight, nor conceive them suddenly, but by His eternal foreknowledge.

The Ages of Ages

Chapter 20

I do not presume to determine whether God does so, and whether these times which are called “ages of ages” are joined together in a continuous series, and succeed one another with a regulated diversity, and leave exempt from their changes only those who are freed from their misery, and remain without end in a blessed immortality; or whether these are called “ages of ages,” so that we may understand that the ages remain unchangeable in God’s unwavering wisdom, and are the efficient causes, as it were, of those ages which are being spent in time. Possibly “ages” is used for “age,” so that nothing else is meant by “ages of ages” than by “age of age,” as nothing else is meant by “heavens of heavens” than by “heaven of heaven.”

For God called the firmament, above which are the waters, “Heaven,” and yet the psalm says, “Let the waters that are above the heavens praise the name of the Lord.” Which of these two meanings we are to attach to “ages of ages,” or whether there is not some other and better meaning still, is a very profound question; and the subject we are now handling does not prevent us from putting off the discussion of it for the time being, whether we may be able to determine anything about it, or may only be made more cautious by its further treatment, so as to be deterred from making any rash affirmations in a matter of such obscurity. For now we are arguing against the opinion that affirms the existence of those periodic revolutions by which the same things are always recurring at intervals of time.

Now whichever of these suppositions regarding the “ages of ages” is the true one, it does nothing to establish those cycles; for whether the ages of ages are not a repetition of the same world, but different worlds succeeding one another in a regulated connection, with the ransomed souls remaining in well-assured bliss without any recurrence of misery, or whether the ages of ages are the eternal causes which rule what will be and is in time, it equally follows that those cycles which bring the same things around do not exist; and nothing more thoroughly demolishes them than the fact of the eternal life of the saints.

Against the Recurrence of Misery

Chapter 21

What pious ears could bear to hear that after a life spent in so many and severe distresses—if, indeed, that should be called a life at all which is rather a death, so utter that the love of this present death makes us fear that death which delivers us from it—that after evils so disastrous, and miseries of all kinds have at last been expiated and finished by the help of true religion and wisdom, and when we have thus attained to the vision of God, and have entered into bliss by the contemplation of spiritual light and participation in His unchangeable immortality, which we burn to attain—that we must at some time lose all this, and that those who do lose it are cast down from that eternity, truth, and happiness to infernal mortality and shameful foolishness, and are entangled in accursed woes, in which God is lost, truth held in detestation, and happiness sought in iniquitous impurities?

And that this will happen endlessly again and again, recurring at fixed intervals, and in regularly returning periods? And that this everlasting and ceaseless revolution of definite cycles, which remove and restore true misery and deceitful bliss in turn, is contrived so that God may be able to know His own works, since on the one hand He cannot rest from creating and on the other, cannot know the infinite number of His creatures, if He always makes creatures? Who, I say, can listen to such things? Who can accept them or allow them to be spoken? If they were true, it would not only be more prudent to keep silent about them, but, to express myself as best I can, it would even be the part of wisdom not to know them.

For if in the future world we will not remember these things, and will be blessed by this forgetfulness, why should we now increase our misery, already burdensome enough, by the knowledge of them? If, on the other hand, the knowledge of them will be forced on us in the future, let us at least remain in ignorance now, so that in the present expectation we may enjoy a blessedness which the future reality is not to bestow; since in this life we are expecting to obtain everlasting life, but in the world to come are to discover it to be blessed, but not everlasting.

And if they maintain that no one can attain to the blessedness of the world to come, unless in this life he has been instructed in those cycles in which bliss and misery alternate, how can they declare that the more a man loves God, the more readily he attains to blessedness, when they teach what paralyzes love itself? For who would not be more remiss and lukewarm in his love for a person whom he thinks he will be forced to abandon, and whose truth and wisdom he will come to hate; and this, too, after he has quite attained to the utmost and most blissful knowledge of Him that he is capable of? Can anyone be faithful in his love, even to a human friend, if he knows that he is destined to become his enemy?

God forbid that there should be any truth in an opinion which threatens us with a real misery that is never to end, but is often and endlessly to be interrupted by intervals of deceptive happiness. For what happiness can be more deceptive and false than that in whose blaze of truth we still remain ignorant that we shall be miserable, or in whose most secure citadel we still fear that we shall be so? For if, on the one hand, we are to be ignorant of coming calamity, then our present misery is not so shortsighted, for it is assured of coming bliss.

If, on the other hand, the disaster that threatens is not concealed from us in the world to come, then the time of misery which is to be at last exchanged for a state of blessedness, is spent by the soul more happily than its time of happiness, which is to end in a return to misery. And thus our expectation of unhappiness is happy, but of happiness unhappy. And therefore, as we here suffer present ills, and there fear ills that are imminent, it would be truer to say that we shall always be miserable than that we can some time be happy.

But these things are declared to be false by the loud testimony of religion and truth; for religion truthfully promises a true blessedness, of which we shall be eternally assured, and which cannot be interrupted by any disaster. Let us therefore keep to the straight path, which is Christ, and, with Him as our Guide and Savior, let us turn away in heart and mind from the unreal and futile cycles of the godless. Porphyry, Platonist though he was, renounced the opinion of his school, that in these cycles souls are ceaselessly passing away and returning, either being struck with the extravagance of the idea, or sobered by his knowledge of Christianity.

As I mentioned in the tenth book, he preferred saying that the soul, as it had been sent into the world so that it might know evil, and be purged and delivered from it, was never again exposed to such an experience after it had once returned to the Father. And if he renounced the tenets of his school, how much more ought we Christians to detest and avoid an opinion so unfounded and hostile to our faith? But having disposed of these cycles and escaped out of them, no necessity compels us to suppose that the human race had no beginning in time, on the ground that there is nothing new in nature which has not, through some cycles or other, existed at some previous period, and is not to exist again in the future.

For if the soul, once delivered, as it never was before, is never to return to misery, then there happens in its experience something which never happened before; and this, indeed, something of the greatest consequence, namely, the secure entrance into eternal happiness. And if in an immortal nature there can occur a novelty, which never has been, and never will be, reproduced by any cycle, why is it disputed that the same may occur in mortal natures? If they maintain that blessedness is no new experience to the soul, but only a return to that state in which it has been eternally, then at least its deliverance from misery is something new, since, by their own account, the misery from which it is delivered is itself, too, a new experience.

And if this new experience happened by accident, and was not included in the order of things appointed by Divine Providence, then where are those determinate and measured cycles in which no new thing happens, but all things are reproduced as they were before? If, however, this new experience was included in that providential order of nature—whether the soul was exposed to the evil of this world for the sake of discipline, or fell into it by sin—then it is possible for new things to happen which never happened before, and which are nevertheless not foreign to the order of nature.

And if the soul is able by its own imprudence to create for itself a new misery, which was not unforeseen by the Divine Providence, but was provided for in the order of nature along with the deliverance from it, how can we, even with all the rashness of human vanity, presume to deny that God can create new things—new to the world, but not to Him—which He never before created, but nevertheless foresaw from all eternity? If they say that it is indeed true that ransomed souls return no more to misery, but that even so no new thing happens, since there always have been, now are, and always will be a succession of ransomed souls, they must at least grant that in this case there are new souls to whom the misery and the deliverance from it are new.

For if they maintain that those souls out of which new men are daily being made—from whose bodies, if they have lived wisely, they are so delivered that they never return to misery—are not new, but have existed from eternity, they must logically admit that they are infinite. For however great a finite number of souls there were, that would not have sufficed to make perpetually new men from eternity—men whose souls were to be eternally freed from this mortal state, and never afterward to return to it. And our philosophers will find it hard to explain how there is an infinite number of souls in an order of nature which they require to be finite, so that it may be known by God.

And now that we have demolished these cycles which were supposed to bring back the soul at fixed periods to the same miseries, what can seem more in accordance with godly reason than to believe that it is possible for God both to create new things never before created, and in doing so, to preserve His will unaltered? But whether the number of eternally redeemed souls can be continually increased or not, let the philosophers themselves decide, who are so subtle in determining where infinity cannot be admitted. For our own part, our reasoning holds in either case. For if the number of souls can be indefinitely increased, what reason is there to deny that what had never before been created, could be created?

For the number of ransomed souls never existed before, and yet it has not only been made once, but will never cease coming into being anew. If, on the other hand, it is more fitting that the number of eternally ransomed souls be definite, and that this number will never be increased, still this number, whatever it is, certainly never existed before, and it cannot increase, and reach the amount it signifies, without having some beginning; and this beginning never before existed. So that this beginning might exist, therefore, the first man was created.

Texts in conversation

Compare Wisdom of Solomon 11:20 and Augustine, City of God 12.19

Deuterocanon · Early Christian

Share:

Summary

The Christian theologian Augustine uses the Wisdom of Solomon as an authoritative source of teaching and theology, repeating its description of how God orders creation by measure, number, and weight.

Passages

Wisdom of Solomon 11:20

Deuterocanon
18 or newly created and unknown wild animals, full of rage, either breathing out a blast of fiery breath, or belching out smoke, or flashing dreadful sparks from their eyes,19 which had power not only to consume them by their violence, but to destroy them even by the terror of seeing them.20 Yes, and without these they might have fallen by a single breath, being pursued by Justice, and scattered everywhere by the breath of your power, but you arranged all things by measure, number, and weight.21 For you have great strength at all times. Who could withstand the might of your arm?22 Because the whole world before you is like a grain on a scale, and like a drop of dew that comes down on the earth in the morning.

Augustine, City of God 12.19

Early Christian · On the City of God Against the Pagans
Does God, therefore, not know numbers on account of this infinity; and does His knowledge extend only to a certain height in numbers, while of the rest He is ignorant? Who is so senseless as to say so? Yet they can hardly claim to put numbers out of the question, or maintain that they have nothing to do with the knowledge of God; for Plato, their great authority, represents God as framing the world on numerical principles; and in our books also it is said to God, “You have ordered all things in number, and measure, and weight.” The prophet also says, “Who brings out their host by number.” And the Savior says in the Gospel, “The very hairs of your head are all numbered.”

References

"... In affirming the canonicity of the two ‘Solomonic’ books not written by Solomon, Augustine says of Wisdom and Sirach “the Church especially in the West has accepted them as authoritative from antiquity”; City of God 17.20). A survey of patristic comments on the liturgical use of what Rufinus called the ecclesiastical books bears out Augustine’s geographical distinction. Eastern sources restrict the liturgical use of documents to the books of the Jewish canon. Cyril of Jerusalem (Catechesis 4.36–38) emphatically asserts that only the 22 books accepted by the Jews find a place in Christian liturgy, and he advises catechumens to maintain this standard in their private reading. Athanasius (Festal Letters 39) assigns the ecclesiastical books the role of elementary instruction in the faith, as do the Apostolic Canons (canon 85); this position seems to discount their use in the liturgy. The Council of Laodicea is more explicit; in the same context in which it limits the OT canon to 22 books ... However, the matter stood differently among Latin writers: Jerome, Rufinus, and Augustine all affirm that the ecclesiastical books are used in the corporate worship of the Church ... if the Church reads a ‘scriptural’ book, it is a canonical book. Similarly, Augustine responds to the objection of some that the Book of Wisdom is not canonical by arguing that its employment in the liturgy implies its divine authority ..."
Edmon L. Gallagher, Hebrew Scripture in Patristic Biblical Theory: Canon, Language, Text, VCSup 114 (Leiden: Brill, 2012), 54–55.

References are not endorsements of their contents. Read each reference in full to understand its author's intentions in using these texts.

Your feedback

Last updated

Wisdom of Solomon 11:20 and Augustine, City of God 12.19

Leave a comment

Your questions and comments are welcome!

Comments

Glossary

Search the Library