Go to Related Reading
About this book

The Theory of Recurring Cycles

Chapter 14

Some philosophers have seen no other acceptable means of solving this controversy than by introducing cycles of time, in which there would be a constant renewal and repetition of the order of nature; and they have therefore asserted that these cycles will ceaselessly recur, one passing away and another coming, though they are not agreed as to whether one permanent world will pass through all these cycles, or whether the world will at fixed intervals die out, and be renewed so as to exhibit a recurrence of the same phenomena—the things which have been, and those which are to be, coinciding. And from this fantastic round of change they do not exempt even the immortal soul that has attained wisdom, consigning it to a ceaseless transmigration between delusive blessedness and real misery.

For how can that be truly called blessed which has no assurance of being so eternally, and is either in ignorance of the truth, and blind to the misery that is approaching, or, knowing it, is in misery and fear? Or if it passes to bliss, and leaves miseries forever, then there happens in time a new thing which time will not end. Why not, then, the world also? Why may not man, too, be a similar thing? So that, by following the straight path of sound doctrine, we escape whatever circuitous paths have been discovered by deceiving and deceived sages.

Some, too, in advocating these recurring cycles that restore all things to their original state cite in favor of their supposition what Solomon says in the book of Ecclesiastes: “What is it that has been? It is what shall be. And what is it that is done? It is what shall be done: and there is no new thing under the sun. Who can speak and say, See, this is new? It has already been in ages past, which was before us.” This he said either of those things of which he had just been speaking—the succession of generations, the orbit of the sun, the course of rivers—or else of all kinds of creatures that are born and die. For there were men before us, there are men with us, and there will be men after us; and so all living things and all plants.

Even monstrous and irregular productions, though differing from one another, and though some are reported as solitary instances, yet resemble one another generally, insofar as they are miraculous and monstrous, and, in this sense, have been, and will be, and are no new and recent things under the sun. However, some would understand these words as meaning that in the predestination of God all things have already existed, and that thus there is no new thing under the sun.

In any case, no true believer should ever suppose that by these words of Solomon those cycles are meant, in which, according to those philosophers, the same periods and events of time are repeated; as if, for example, the philosopher Plato, having taught in the school at Athens which is called the Academy, so, numberless ages before, at long but certain intervals, this same Plato and the same school, and the same disciples existed, and so also are to be repeated during the countless cycles that are still to come—we must never, I say, believe this. For once Christ died for our sins; and, rising from the dead, He dies no more.

Death has no more dominion over Him; and we ourselves after the resurrection shall be “always with the Lord,” to whom we now say, as the sacred Psalmist dictates, “You shall keep us, Lord, You shall preserve us from this generation.” And what follows is also, I think, appropriate enough: “The wicked walk in a circle,” not because their life is to recur by means of these circles, which these philosophers imagine, but because the path in which their false doctrine now runs is circuitous.

God’s Eternal Design

Chapter 15

What wonder is it if, entangled in these circles, they find neither entrance nor exit? For they do not know how the human race, and this mortal condition of ours, took its origin, nor how it will be brought to an end, since they cannot penetrate the inscrutable wisdom of God. For, though He Himself is eternal and without beginning, He caused time to have a beginning; and man, whom He had not previously made, He made in time, not from a new and sudden resolution, but by His unchangeable and eternal design. Who can search out the unsearchable depth of this purpose, who can scrutinize the inscrutable wisdom, with which God, without change of will, created man, who had never existed before, and gave him an existence in time, and increased the human race from one individual?

For the Psalmist himself, when he had first said, “You shall keep us, Lord, You shall preserve us from this generation forever,” and had then rebuked those whose foolish and impious doctrine preserves for the soul no eternal deliverance and blessedness, adds immediately, “The wicked walk in a circle.” Then, as if it were said to him, “What then do you believe, feel, know? Are we to believe that it suddenly occurred to God to create man, whom He had never before made in a past eternity—God, to whom nothing new can occur, and in whom there is no changeableness?” the Psalmist goes on to reply, as if addressing God Himself, “According to the depth of Your wisdom You have multiplied the children of men.”

Let men, he seems to say, imagine what they please, let them conjecture and argue as they see fit, but You have multiplied the children of men according to the depth of Your wisdom, which no man can comprehend. For this is a depth indeed, that God always has been, and that man, whom He had never made before, He willed to make in time, and this without changing His design and will.

Was God Always Lord?

Chapter 16

For my own part, indeed, just as I do not dare to say that there ever was a time when the Lord God was not Lord, so I ought not to doubt that man did not exist before time, and was first created in time. But when I consider what God could be the Lord of, if there was not always some creature, I shrink from making any assertion, remembering my own insignificance, and that it is written, “What man can know the counsel of God? Or who can think what the will of the Lord is? For the thoughts of mortal men are timid, and our devices are but uncertain. For the corruptible body presses down the soul, and the earthly tabernacle weighs down the mind that muses on many things.”⁠

I certainly muse on many things in this earthly tabernacle, because the one thing which is true among the many, or beyond the many, I cannot find. If, then, among these many thoughts, I say that there have always been creatures for Him to be Lord of, who is always and has always been Lord, but that these creatures have not always been the same, but succeeded one another—for we do not wish to seem to say that any is coeternal with the Creator, an assertion condemned equally by faith and sound reason—I must take care not to fall into the absurd and ignorant error of maintaining that by these successions and changes mortal creatures have always existed, while the immortal creatures had not begun to exist until the date of our own world, when the angels were created; if at least the angels are intended by that light which was first made, or, rather, by that heaven of which it is said, “In the beginning God created the heavens and the earth.”⁠

The angels, at least, did not exist before they were created; for if we say that they have always existed, we shall seem to make them coeternal with the Creator. Again, if I say that the angels were not created in time, but existed before all times, as those over whom God, who has always been Sovereign, exercised His sovereignty, then I shall be asked whether, if they were created before all time, they, being creatures, could possibly always exist. It may perhaps be replied, Why not always, since what is in all time may very properly be said to be “always”? Now so true is it that these angels have existed in all time that even before time was they were created; if at least time began with the heavens, and the angels existed before the heavens.

And if time was even before the heavenly bodies, not indeed marked by hours, days, months, and years—for these measures of time’s periods which are commonly and properly called times, plainly began with the motion of the heavenly bodies, and so God said, when He appointed them, “Let them be for signs, and for seasons, and for days, and for years,”—if, I say, time was before these heavenly bodies by some changing movement, whose parts succeeded one another and could not exist simultaneously, and if there was some such movement among the angels which necessitated the existence of time, so that from their very creation they were subject to these temporal changes, then they have existed in all time, for time came into being along with them. And who will say that what was in all time, was not always?

But if I make such a reply, it will be said to me, How, then, are they not coeternal with the Creator, if He and they always have been? How even can they be said to have been created, if we are to understand that they have always existed? What are we to reply to this? Are we to say that both statements are true? That they always have been, since they have been in all time, having been created along with time, or time along with them, and yet that also they were created? For, similarly, we will not deny that time itself was created, though no one doubts that time has been in all time; for if it has not been in all time, then there was a time when there was no time. But the most foolish person could not make such an assertion.

For we can reasonably say there was a time when Rome was not; there was a time when Jerusalem was not; there was a time when Abraham was not; there was a time when man was not, and so on: in short, if the world was not made at the beginning of time, but after some time had elapsed, we can say there was a time when the world was not. But to say there was a time when time was not, is as absurd as to say there was a man when there was no man; or, this world was when this world was not. For if we are not referring to the same object, the form of expression may be used, as, there was another man when this man was not.

Thus we can reasonably say there was another time when this time was not; but not the merest simpleton could say there was a time when there was no time. As, then, we say that time was created, though we also say that it always has been, since in all time time has been, so it does not follow that if the angels have always been, they were therefore not created. For we say that they have always been, because they have been in all time; and we say they have been in all time, because time itself could in no way exist without them. For where there is no creature whose changing movements admit of succession, there cannot be time at all. And consequently, even if they have always existed, they were created; nor, if they have always existed, are they therefore coeternal with the Creator.

For He has always existed in unchangeable eternity; while they were created, and are said to have been always, because they have been in all time, since time is impossible without the creature. But time passing away by its changefulness, cannot be coeternal with changeless eternity. And consequently, though the immortality of the angels does not pass in time, does not become past as if now it were not, nor has a future as if it were not yet, still their movements, which are the basis of time, do pass from future to past; and therefore they cannot be coeternal with the Creator, in whose movement we cannot say that there has been what now is not, or will be what is not yet.

Therefore, if God always has been Lord, He has always had creatures under His dominion—creatures, however, not begotten of Him, but created by Him out of nothing; nor coeternal with Him, for He was before them though at no time without them, because He preceded them, not by the lapse of time, but by His abiding eternity. But if I make this reply to those who ask how He was always Creator, always Lord, if there were not always a subject creation; or how this was created, and not rather coeternal with its Creator, if it always was, I fear I may be accused of recklessly affirming what I do not know, instead of teaching what I know.

I return, therefore, to what our Creator has seen fit for us to know; and those things which He has allowed the abler men to know in this life, or has reserved to be known in the next by the perfected saints, I acknowledge to be beyond my capacity. But I have thought it right to discuss these matters without making positive assertions, so that those who read may be warned to keep away from dangerous questions, and may not think themselves fit for everything. Let them rather try to obey the wholesome instruction of the apostle, when he says, “For I say, through the grace given to me, to every man that is among you, not to think of himself more highly than he ought to think; but to think soberly, as God has dealt to every man the measure of faith.” For if an infant receives nourishment suited to its strength, it becomes capable, as it grows, of taking more; but if its strength and capacity are overtaxed, it wastes away instead of growing.

The Promise Before Eternal Times

Chapter 17

I admit that I do not know what ages passed before the human race was created, but I have no doubt that no created thing is coeternal with the Creator. But even the apostle speaks of time as eternal, and he does so with reference, not to the future, but, which is more surprising, to the past. For he says, “In hope of eternal life, which God, who cannot lie, promised before the eternal times, but has in due times manifested His word.” You see he says that in the past there have been eternal times, which, however, were not coeternal with God. And since God before these eternal times not only existed, but also “promised” eternal life, which He manifested in its own times, that is to say, in due times, what else is this than His word? For this is eternal life.

But then, how did He promise? For the promise was made to men, and yet they did not exist before eternal times? Does this not mean that, in His own eternity, and in His coeternal word, what was to be in its own time was already predestined and fixed?

God’s Knowledge and the Infinite

Chapter 18

I also have no doubt that before the first man was created, there never had been a man at all, neither this same man himself returning through some unknown cycles, having made some unknown number of revolutions, nor any other of similar nature. I am not frightened away from this belief by philosophical arguments, among which the one considered most acute is founded on the assertion that the infinite cannot be comprehended by any mode of knowledge. Consequently, they argue, God has in His own mind finite conceptions of all finite things which He makes.

Now it cannot be supposed that His goodness was ever idle; for if it were, we would have to ascribe to Him an awakening to activity in time, from a past eternity of inactivity, as if He repented of an idleness that had no beginning, and proceeded, therefore, to make a beginning of work. This being the case, they say that the same things must always be repeated, and that as they pass, so they are destined always to return, whether amid all these changes the world remains the same—the world which has always been, and yet was created—or that the world in these revolutions is perpetually dying out and being renewed; otherwise, if we point to a time when the works of God were begun, it would be believed that He considered His past eternal leisure to be inert and indolent, and therefore condemned and altered it as displeasing to Himself.

Now if God is supposed to have been indeed always making temporal things, but different from one another, and one after the other, so that He came at last in this way to make man, whom He had never made before, then it may seem that He made man not with knowledge—for they suppose no knowledge can comprehend the infinite succession of creatures—but on the impulse of the hour, as it struck Him at the moment, with a sudden and accidental change of mind. On the other hand, they say, if those cycles are admitted, and if we suppose that the same temporal things are repeated, while the world either remains identical through all these rotations, or else dies away and is renewed, then there is ascribed to God neither the slothful ease of a past eternity, nor a rash and unforeseen creation.

And if the same things are not repeated in cycles in this way, then they cannot be comprehended by any knowledge or foreknowledge in their endless diversity. Even though reason could not refute, faith would smile at these arguments, with which the godless try to turn our simple piety from the right way, so that we may walk with them “in a circle.” But with the help of the Lord our God, even reason shatters, and readily enough, these revolving circles which conjecture frames. For what especially leads these men astray, so that they prefer their own circles to the straight path of truth, is that they measure by their own human, changeable, and narrow intellect the divine mind, which is absolutely unchangeable, infinite in capacity, and without succession of thought, counting all things without number.

So that saying of the apostle comes true of them, for, “comparing themselves with themselves, they do not understand.” For because they do, by a new decision, whatever new thing has occurred to them to be done, their minds being changeable, they conclude it is so with God; and thus compare, not God—for they cannot conceive God, but think of one like themselves when they think of Him—not God, but themselves, and not with Him, but with themselves. For our part, we do not dare to believe that God is affected in one way when He works, in another when He rests. Indeed, to say that He is affected at all is an abuse of language, since it implies that there comes to be something in His nature which was not there before.

For whoever is affected is acted on, and whatever is acted on is changeable. His leisure, therefore, is no laziness, indolence, inactivity; just as in His work there is no labor, effort, industry. He can act while He rests, and rest while He acts. He can begin a new work with an eternal, not a new, design; and what He has not made before, He does not now begin to make because He repents of His former rest. But when one speaks of His former rest and later activity—and I do not know how men can understand these things—this “former” and “subsequent” are applied only to the things created, which formerly did not exist, and subsequently came into existence.

But in God the former purpose is not altered and wiped out by the subsequent and different purpose, but by one and the same eternal and unchangeable will He brought about, for the things He created, both that formerly, as long as they did not exist, they should not exist, and that subsequently, when they began to be, they should come into existence. And thus, perhaps, He wished to show, in a very striking way, to those who have eyes for such things, how independent He is of what He makes, and how it is from His own freely given goodness that He creates, since from eternity He dwelt without creatures in no less perfect a blessedness.

Texts in conversation

Compare Wisdom of Solomon 9:13 and Augustine, City of God 12.16

Deuterocanon · Early Christian

Share:

Summary

The Christian theologian Augustine quotes the Wisdom of Solomon as an authoritative source in the City of God, drawing on its teaching about the limit of human intellect and the need for wisdom to find divine purpose.

Passages

Wisdom of Solomon 9:13

Deuterocanon
11 For she knows all things and understands, and she will guide me wisely in my actions. She will guard me in her glory.12 So my works will be acceptable. I will judge your people righteously, and I will be worthy of my father’s throne.13 “For who can know the counsel of God? Or who will understand what the Lord wants?14 For the thoughts of mortals are unstable, and our plans are prone to fail.15 For a perishable body weighs down the soul. The tent made of earth burdens a mind that is full of worries.

Augustine, City of God 12.16

Early Christian · On the City of God Against the Pagans
For my own part, indeed, just as I do not dare to say that there ever was a time when the Lord God was not Lord, so I ought not to doubt that man did not exist before time, and was first created in time. But when I consider what God could be the Lord of, if there was not always some creature, I shrink from making any assertion, remembering my own insignificance, and that it is written, “What man can know the counsel of God? Or who can think what the will of the Lord is? For the thoughts of mortal men are timid, and our devices are but uncertain. For the corruptible body presses down the soul, and the earthly tabernacle weighs down the mind that muses on many things.”

References

"... In affirming the canonicity of the two ‘Solomonic’ books not written by Solomon, Augustine says of Wisdom and Sirach “the Church especially in the West has accepted them as authoritative from antiquity”; City of God 17.20). A survey of patristic comments on the liturgical use of what Rufinus called the ecclesiastical books bears out Augustine’s geographical distinction. Eastern sources restrict the liturgical use of documents to the books of the Jewish canon. Cyril of Jerusalem (Catechesis 4.36–38) emphatically asserts that only the 22 books accepted by the Jews find a place in Christian liturgy, and he advises catechumens to maintain this standard in their private reading. Athanasius (Festal Letters 39) assigns the ecclesiastical books the role of elementary instruction in the faith, as do the Apostolic Canons (canon 85); this position seems to discount their use in the liturgy. The Council of Laodicea is more explicit; in the same context in which it limits the OT canon to 22 books ... However, the matter stood differently among Latin writers: Jerome, Rufinus, and Augustine all affirm that the ecclesiastical books are used in the corporate worship of the Church ... if the Church reads a ‘scriptural’ book, it is a canonical book. Similarly, Augustine responds to the objection of some that the Book of Wisdom is not canonical by arguing that its employment in the liturgy implies its divine authority ..."
Edmon L. Gallagher, Hebrew Scripture in Patristic Biblical Theory: Canon, Language, Text, VCSup 114 (Leiden: Brill, 2012), 54–55.

References are not endorsements of their contents. Read each reference in full to understand its author's intentions in using these texts.

Tags

Your feedback

Last updated

Wisdom of Solomon 9:13 and Augustine, City of God 12.16

Leave a comment

Your questions and comments are welcome!

Comments

Glossary

Search the Library