Texts in Conversation

The Hebrew version of Jonah uses ambiguous language about the temple, which could be despair or confident resolve. The Greek Septuagint translators interpreted it as an anxious question, so Jonah does not know if he will see the sanctuary again.
Share:
2500 BCE
1000+ CE

Jonah 2:4

Hebrew Bible
3 You threw me into the deep waters, into the middle of the sea; the ocean current engulfed me; all the mighty waves you sent swept over me. 4 I thought I had been banished from your sight and that I would never again see your holy temple. 5 Water engulfed me up to my neck; the deep ocean surrounded me; seaweed was wrapped around my head.
Date: 3rd Century B.C.E. (based on scholarly estimates)

LXX Jonah 2:5

Septuagint
4 You threw me into the depth of the heart of the sea, and rivers surrounded me; all of your swells and your billows have passed over me. 5 And I said, ‘I have been thrust away from your eyes; how shall I proceed to look toward your holy temple? 6 Water is poured over me up to my soul; the abyss surrounds me to the last; my head withdraws into the cleft of the hill.
Date: 1st Century B.C.E. (based on scholarly estimates)
Search:

Notes and References

#6214
“... The verset ʾak ʾōsîp lehabbîṭ ʾel-hêkal qodšekā begins with one of the most contested readings in Jonah. The particle ʾak normally functions in three different ways: temporal (“just as, no sooner”), emphatic/asseverative (“truly, surely”), and restrictive/adversative (“nevertheless, for all that”); see BDB 36. The last two modes are not often mutually compatible, and there are cases in which the choice depends on individual judgment. (The two possibilities are discussed by Muraoka [1985: 130], who also gives a relevant bibliography.) In Jonah’s case, readers choose a meaning to accord with the way they empathize with Jonah’s circumstances. Having just acknowledged his hopeless situation, is Jonah (or the poet) meekly begging God to permit him to achieve that goal (“Truly, I want to continue gazing upon your holy sanctuary”)? Or is he defiantly stating his resolve to seek God’s shrine (“Nevertheless, I continue to gaze upon your holy sanctuary”)? The Renaissance rabbi Sforno is closer to the first interpretation, rendering, “I ask only that I be permitted to gaze upon your holy temple”; quoted in Zlotowitz 1980: 112. The Targum sides with the latter interpretation, using the adversative brm, “nevertheless,” and so does the Septuagint (followed by Arabic) when it frames the sentence as a rhetorical question: “Do you think that I may yet see your holy temple?” ...”

* The use of references are not endorsements of their contents. Please read the entirety of the provided reference(s) to understand the author's full intentions regarding the use of these texts.

Your Feedback:

Leave a Comment

Do you have questions or comments about these texts? Please submit them here.

Anonymous comments are welcome. All comments are subject to moderation.

Find Similar Texts

Search by the same Books

Search by the same Reference

Compare the same Books

Compare the same Text Groups

Glossary

Go to Intertext

Thank you!

We appreciate your feedback.

Got a moment for a quick survey?

This website has good content
Strongly disagree Strongly agree
This website is easy to use
Strongly disagree Strongly agree