828a
Athenian: Our next task is to arrange the festivals and establish them by law, with the help of the Delphic oracles, prescribing which sacrifices, and to which deities, it will be good and right for the State to offer. When they are held and how many there are is, in some cases at least, our own business to decide for ourselves. Clinias: Very likely, as far as the number is concerned. Athenian: Then let us state the number first. There shall be no fewer than 365 feasts, so that some official will always be sacrificing to some god or daemon on behalf of the State, its people, and their property. The interpreters, the priests and priestesses, and the prophets shall meet and, together with the Law-wardens, shall establish whatever the lawgiver is obliged to leave out; and these same persons shall also decide what those omissions are. For the law will state that there are to be twelve feasts for the twelve gods after whom the various tribes are named. To each of these gods they shall offer monthly sacrifices and assign choirs and musical contests, as well as gymnastic contests, as suits both the gods themselves and the various seasons of the year. They shall also establish women’s festivals, determining how many of them shall be for women only and how many shall be open to men as well. Further, in keeping with the law, they must determine the rites proper to the gods of the underworld, how many of the celestial gods should be invoked, and which of the rites connected with them should not be mixed but kept separate; and they shall place these in the twelfth month, which is sacred to Pluto. Men who are warriors should not dislike this god, but should honor him as the one who is always best to the human race; for, as I would maintain in all seriousness, union is in no way better for soul and body than separation.
828d–829e
Athenian: Moreover, if these persons are to arrange these matters properly, they must believe that no other State now in existence can compare with ours in the amount of leisure it enjoys and in its command of the necessities of life; and they must also believe that the State, like an individual, ought to live a good life. But the first requirement for a good and happy life is neither to do wrong oneself nor to be wronged by others. The first of these is not very hard, but it is very hard to secure protection from being wronged; in fact, it cannot be gained completely except by becoming completely good. In the same way, a State that becomes good can have a life of peace, but if it is bad, it will have a life of war both abroad and at home. Since this is so, all men must train for war not in wartime, but while they are living in peace. So a sensible State must go out on a military march every month for at least one whole day, or for more, as the rulers decide, paying no attention to cold or hot weather. Everyone shall take part, men, women and children, whenever the rulers decide to march them out all together, and at other times they shall go out in sections. Along with the sacrifices, they must keep devising fine games to serve as festival contests, modeled as closely as possible on the battles of war. At each of these they must hand out prizes and awards for merit, and compose speeches of praise and blame for one another, according to the character each person shows not only in the contests but in his life as a whole, honoring the one who is regarded as best and blaming the one who is not. Not everyone shall compose such speeches. First, no one under fifty years of age shall compose one; and further, no one shall do so who, however skilled he may be in poetry and music, has never yet performed any noble or notable deed. But the poems composed by men who are good themselves and honored in the State as doers of noble deeds shall be sung, even if the poems are not musically accomplished. The judging of these shall rest with the Educator and the other Law-wardens, who shall grant these men the special privilege of being the only ones with freedom of speech in song, while no one else shall be given any such permission. Nor shall anyone dare to sing an unauthorized song, not even if it is sweeter than the hymns of Orpheus or of Thamyris, but only those sacred poems that have won the judges’ approval and been dedicated to the gods, and those by good men that have been judged to distribute praise or blame fittingly. I declare that the same rules shall apply equally to men and to women, both in military expeditions and in freedom of poetic speech.
829e–830c
Athenian: The lawgiver ought to take counsel with himself and reason like this: ‘Come now, what kind of men am I raising, once I have prepared the whole State? Are they not to be competitors in the greatest of contests, in which they will face countless opponents?’ ‘Certainly,’ anyone would rightly answer. ‘What then? Suppose we had been training boxers or pancratiasts or competitors in some similar branch of athletics: would we have gone straight into the contest without first fighting against someone every day? If we were boxers, we would have spent a great many days before the contest learning how to fight and working hard, practicing in imitation all the methods we meant to use on the day we would be fighting for victory, and copying the real thing as closely as possible. So we would put on padded gloves instead of proper boxing thongs, in order to get the best possible practice in landing blows and dodging them. And if we happened to be very short of sparring partners, do you suppose that fear of being laughed at by fools would stop us from hanging up a lifeless dummy and practicing on it? In fact, if we were ever in a desert with no sparring partners, either living or lifeless, would we not resort to shadow-boxing in the most literal sense, against ourselves? Or what else should anyone call the practice of boxing gestures?’
830c
Clinias: There is no other name for it, Stranger, than the one you have just given it. Athenian: What then? Is the fighting force of our State to venture into battle each time, fighting for their lives, their children, their property, and the whole State, with less thorough preparation than the competitors we have been describing? And is their lawgiver, for fear that these practice bouts may look ridiculous to some people, to hold back from making laws that order field exercises? Under such laws, the minor exercises without heavy arms will take place daily if possible, and both choral dancing and all gymnastics shall be directed to this end. He shall order the other exercises, both larger and smaller, to be held in full armor at least once a month. In these exercises they will compete with one another throughout the whole country, contending in capturing strongholds and in ambushes and in every kind of mock warfare;
830e–831b
Athenian: in fact, they shall spar with padded gloves and with darts as close to real ones as possible, though the points of the darts shall be made less dangerous, so that their combat games may not be entirely free of fear, but may produce real alarm and show to some extent who is brave and who is not. To the brave the lawgiver shall rightly assign honors, and to the others disgrace, so that in this way he may prepare the whole State to be useful throughout life in the real contest. Moreover, if a man is killed in these mock fights, since the killing was involuntary, the lawgiver shall declare the killer clean of hands once he has been purified according to law. For he will reflect that when a few men die, others just as good will grow up in their place; whereas once fear is, so to speak, dead, he will be unable to find a test to tell the good from the bad in all such cases, and that is a far greater evil for a State than the other.
831b
Clinias: We, at least, Stranger, would certainly agree that every State should both make laws for these things and practice them. Athenian: Do we all know the reason why such choral dancing and such contests hardly exist anywhere in the States at present, except to a very small extent? Shall we say that it is because of the ignorance of the general public and of those who make their laws? Clinias: Possibly. Athenian: Not at all, my ingenious Clinias! What we ought to say is that there are two causes, and both of them very weighty.
831c
Clinias: What are they? Athenian: The first comes from a lust for wealth that leaves a man no time to attend to anything except his own private property. When every citizen’s soul hangs on this, it cannot attend to anything other than the day’s gain. Whatever branch of learning or pursuit leads to this, each man privately is most eager to learn and practice, while he laughs everything else to scorn. We must declare this to be one particular reason why a State is unwilling to take this, or any other fine and noble pursuit, seriously; and why, on the other hand, every individual, out of his greed for silver and gold, is willing to toil at every art and scheme, noble or disgraceful, if it is likely to make him rich. He is willing, too, to do deeds holy and unholy, and indeed utterly shameful, without a qualm, provided only that he can glut himself to the full, like a beast, with all kinds of food and drink and sexual pleasure.
831e
Clinias: True. Athenian: Then let this cause I am describing be set down as one that prevents the States from adequately practicing either military exercises or any other noble pursuits. It turns men of a quiet nature into merchants, ship-owners, and servants, while it makes the bold into pirates, burglars, temple-robbers, fighters and despots, and this although some of them are not ill-natured, but merely unfortunate.
832a
Clinias: What do you mean? Athenian: Well, how could I describe them as anything other than utterly unfortunate, when they are compelled to go through life with their souls always hungry? Clinias: That, then, is one cause. What is the second cause you mention, Stranger? Athenian: You are right to remind me. Megillus: One cause, as you claim, is this lifelong, insatiable pursuit, which keeps every man completely busy and prevents each and all from properly practicing military exercises. Granted; now tell us the second cause.
832b
Athenian: Do you think I am putting it off because I do not know what to say? Megillus: No; but we think that, out of a kind of hatred for the character you describe, you are punishing it more severely than the argument at hand requires. Athenian: Your rebuke is fair, Strangers; it seems you want to hear what comes next. Clinias: Just go on. Athenian: I maintain that a cause lies in those non-polities I have often mentioned in our earlier discussion, namely democracy, oligarchy, and tyranny. None of these is a polity; the most accurate name for all of them would be ‘faction-State.’ For none of them is a voluntary rule over willing subjects; each is a voluntary rule over unwilling subjects, always accompanied by some kind of force. And the ruler, because he fears his subjects, will never willingly allow them to become noble or wealthy or strong or brave, or warlike in any way at all. These, then, are the two main causes of nearly everything, and certainly of the conditions we have described. The polity we are now legislating for, however, has escaped both causes. For not only does it enjoy a great deal of leisure, but its citizens are also free from one another’s domination, and as a result of these laws of ours they will be the least likely of all men to be lovers of money. So it is both natural and logical that, of all existing polities, this type alone should welcome the system described above, which combines military training with sport, once we have properly completed that description.
832d
Clinias: Very good. Athenian: The next step, then, is to remind ourselves, regarding all gymnastic contests, that every contest that gives training for war should be instituted and have prizes assigned to it, while all those that do not should be set aside. It will be best to describe and establish at the outset what these contests are. First, then, should we not establish contests in running and in speed generally?
832e
Clinias: We should. Athenian: No doubt the most important thing of all for war is general agility of the body, of the hands as well as the feet: agility of foot for flight and pursuit, and of hand for close-quarters grappling and stand-up fighting, which call for sturdiness and strength.
833a
Clinias: No doubt. Athenian: Yet surely neither of these is of the greatest use without weapons. Clinias: Certainly not. Athenian: So at our contests the herald, as is the present custom, shall call the sprinter first. He shall enter fully armed, and we shall offer no prize to a competitor without arms. First, then, the runner of the stadion sprint in armor shall enter; second, the runner of the diaulos double course; third, the runner of the hippios course; fourth, the runner of the dolichos long-distance race; and fifth, the runner whom we shall send off first, fully armed, to run a distance of sixty stades to a temple of Ares and back. He shall be in heavier armor and be called a hoplite, and he shall run over a smooth course, while his rival shall wear the full equipment of an archer and run a course of a hundred stades over hills and varied country to a temple of Apollo and Artemis. Having set up the contests in this way, we shall wait for these runners to return, and we shall award the prize to the winner of each race.
833c
Clinias: Quite right. Athenian: Let us plan these contests in three divisions: one for children, one for youths, and one for men. For the youths’ races we shall set the course at two-thirds of the full length, and for the children at one-half, whether they compete as archers or as hoplites. For females, we shall establish stadion, diaulos, hippios, and dolichos races for girls who have not yet reached puberty; they shall race naked, on the course itself. Girls over thirteen shall continue to take part until they marry, up to the age of twenty at most, or eighteen at the least; but when these come forward to compete in these races, they must be dressed in decent clothing. Let these, then, be the rules for races for men and women. As for contests of strength, in place of wrestling and the other heavy events now in fashion, we shall establish fencing in armor, both in contests of one against one and in team competitions of anything from two to ten a side.
833e–835a
Athenian: As for which blows a winner must land or avoid, and how many points he must score: just as those who deal with the art of wrestling have now laid down by law what counts as good and bad wrestling, so we must call in the experts in armed fencing and ask them to help us draw up laws to decide who is the rightful winner in such fights, what he must do and what he must avoid, and likewise the rules for determining the loser. The same laws shall be laid down for females too, up to the age of marriage. In place of the pancratium we must establish a general contest for peltasts, who shall compete with bows, light shields, javelins, and stones thrown either by hand or by sling; for these too we shall lay down laws for awarding the honors and prizes to the man who best keeps the rules governing such contests. After these, the next thing to establish will be horse-racing. In a country like Crete there is not much need for horses, at least not in large numbers, so inevitably less attention is paid to raising and racing them. As for chariots, no one here keeps them, and no one is likely to have any great ambition regarding them, so that establishing contests for them would go against local custom and would not only seem foolish but be foolish. If, however, we establish prizes for races of riding-horses, for young colts, for three-year-olds, and for full-grown horses, we shall be adapting the sport of horse-racing to the character of the country. Let a competitive contest among these riders be established by law, and let the phylarchs and hipparchs act as public judges of all the races and of the competitors who enter in armor. We would be wrong to establish prizes for competitors without arms, either here or in the gymnastic contests. And since a Cretan earns credit by being a mounted archer or javelin-thrower, we shall also have contests and matches of a sporting kind among these. As for women, it is not worthwhile to make compulsory laws and rules about their taking part in such sports; but if, as a result of earlier training that has become a habit, their nature permits it and does not forbid it, let girls or maidens take part without blame. So now at last we have reached the end both of competition and of instruction in gymnastics, as far as concerns our education by means of contests and of daily teaching. Most of our account of music has likewise been completed. The regulations for rhapsodes and their followers, however, and the choral contests that must accompany festivals, are matters to be arranged once the gods and demigods have had their months, days and years assigned to them; then it will be seen whether these contests should be held every other year or every four years, or in whatever manner and order the gods may suggest.
835a–835d
Athenian: Then also, we may expect, the musical contests will be held in their turn, as arranged by the Masters of the Games, the Educator of the young, and the Law-wardens, who shall meet together for this very purpose and themselves act as legislators to determine when, by whom, and with whom the contests are to be held for all the choruses and choral dancing. The character each of these ought to have in words, songs and tunes, blended with rhythm and dance, has often been stated by the original lawgiver. The secondary lawgivers should follow him in their enactments, and they should arrange the contests at convenient times to suit the various sacrifices, and so appoint festivals for the State to celebrate. Now it is not at all hard to see how these and similar matters should be given legal regulation, nor would shifting their positions bring much gain or loss to the State. But the things that do make no small difference, and about which it is hard to persuade people, are a task above all for God, if it were possible for the commands to come from him. As things are, they are likely to need some bold man who, valuing frankness above everything else, will declare what he thinks best for the city and its citizens. Among corrupted souls he will prescribe what is fitting and consistent with the whole constitution, and he will oppose the mightiest lusts, acting entirely alone, with no human being to help him and Reason as his only guide.
835d
Clinias: What argument are we pursuing now, Stranger? We are still in the dark. Athenian: Naturally; but I will try to explain myself more clearly. When my discussion came to the subject of education, I saw young men and young women associating affectionately with one another. Naturally, a feeling of alarm came over me as I asked myself how anyone is to manage a State like this, in which young men and women are well fed but free from the severe and menial labors that most surely quench wantonness, and where everyone’s chief occupation all through life consists of sacrifices, feasts and dances. In such a State, how will the young keep away from those desires that often plunge many people into ruin, all those desires that reason, in its effort to become law, commands them to abstain from?
835e–836e
Athenian: It is not surprising that the laws already established should keep most desires in check. For example, the ban on excessive wealth is of no small benefit in promoting self-control, and our entire system of education contains laws useful for the same purpose. Besides this, there is the watchful eye of the magistrates, trained always to fix its gaze on this point and to keep constant watch on the young. These means, then, are sufficient, as far as any human means can be, to deal with the other desires. But when we come to sexual desire for boys and girls, and the desire of men for women and women for men, passions that have caused countless woes both to individuals and to whole States, how is one to guard against them, or what remedy can one apply to find a way of escape from such a danger in all these cases? It is extremely difficult, Clinias. For while in many other matters Crete as a whole and Lacedaemon give us considerable help, and rightly so, in framing laws that differ from those in common use, in the matter of sexual passion (since we are alone among ourselves) they flatly contradict us. Suppose we were to follow in nature’s footsteps and enact the law that held good before the days of Laius, declaring that it is right to refrain from the same kind of intercourse with men and boys as with women, citing as evidence the nature of wild animals and pointing out that male does not touch male for this purpose, since it is unnatural. In doing all this we would probably be using a persuasive argument, but one in no way consistent with your States. Moreover, the goal that we say the lawgiver ought always to keep in view does not agree with these practices. For the question we always ask is this: which of the proposed laws leads toward virtue, and which does not? Come, then: suppose we grant that this practice is now made lawful, and that it is noble and in no way shameful. How far would it promote virtue? Will it produce a courageous character in the soul of the one who is seduced, or the quality of self-control in the soul of the seducer? No one would ever believe that. On the contrary, just as everyone will blame the cowardice of the man who always gives in to pleasures and can never hold out against them, will they not likewise reproach the man who plays the woman’s part for the resemblance he bears to his model? Is there anyone, then, who will make such a practice law? No one, I should say, who has any idea of what true law is. What, then, do we declare to be the truth about this matter?
836e–837a
Athenian: If we are to judge these things rightly, we must see the real nature of friendship and desire and what is called love. What causes the greatest confusion and obscurity is the fact that this single term covers these two things and also a third kind compounded of both.
837a
Clinias: How so? Athenian: Friendship is the name we give to the affection of like for like in point of goodness, and of equal for equal; we also give it to the affection of the needy for the rich, which is of the opposite kind. And when either of these feelings is intense, we call it love.
837b
Clinias: True. Athenian: The friendship that arises between opposites is terrible and fierce and is seldom mutual among us, while the friendship based on likeness is gentle and mutual throughout life. The kind that arises from a blend of these two presents difficulties: first, it is hard to discover what the man affected by this third kind of love really wants to obtain; and second, the man himself is at a loss, being pulled in opposite directions by the two tendencies, one of which urges him to enjoy the bloom of his beloved while the other forbids him. For the man who loves the body and hungers after its bloom, as if it were a ripening peach, urges himself on to take his fill of it, paying no respect to the character of the beloved. But the man who treats bodily desire as only secondary, who looks with longing rather than loving, and whose soul truly desires the other’s soul, regards the bodily satisfaction of the body as an outrage. Reverently honoring self-control, courage, nobility and wisdom, he will want to live always in chastity together with the chaste object of his love. And the love that is blended of these two kinds is the one we have just described as the third. Since, then, love has so many varieties, should the law forbid them all and prevent them from existing among us? Or is it not clear that we would want the kind of love that belongs to virtue, and that desires the young to become as good as possible, to exist within our State, while we would forbid the other two kinds, if possible? Or what is our view, my dear Megillus?
837d–837e
Megillus: Your account of the subject, Stranger, is perfectly correct.
837e
Athenian: It seems that I have won your agreement, as I expected; so there is no need for me to examine your law and its attitude toward such matters, but simply to accept your agreement with my statement. Later on I will try to charm Clinias, too, into agreeing with me on this subject. So let what you two have granted me stand at that, and let us by all means go on with our laws. Megillus: Quite right. Athenian: At present I know of a device for enacting this law that is in one way easy, but in another the hardest possible.
838a
Megillus: Explain what you mean. Athenian: Even now, as we know, most men, however lawless they are, are effectively and strictly kept from sexual relations with beautiful persons, and not against their will, but with their own most willing consent. Megillus: On what occasions do you mean? Athenian: Whenever a man has a brother or sister who is beautiful. So too in the case of a son or daughter: the same unwritten law is most effective in keeping men from sleeping with them, either openly or secretly, or from wishing to have any such contact with them. In fact, most men never so much as feel any desire for such relations.
838b
Megillus: That is true. Athenian: Is it not, then, by a brief saying that all such pleasures are quenched? Megillus: What saying do you mean? Athenian: The saying that these acts are not holy at all, but hated by God and the most shameful of shameful things. And does the reason not lie in this: that nobody speaks of them otherwise, but every one of us, from the day of his birth, hears this opinion expressed always and everywhere, not only in comic speech but often also in serious tragedy? We hear it, for instance, when a Thyestes or an Oedipus is brought on stage, or a Macareus who has had secret relations with a sister, and all of them are seen readily inflicting death on themselves as punishment for their sins.
838c–838d
Megillus: This much, at least, you are quite right to say: public opinion has a surprising power, when no one ever attempts to breathe a word that contradicts the law.
838d–838e
Athenian: Then is it not true, as I said just now, that when a lawgiver wants to subdue one of the lusts that most subdue men, it is easy for him at least to learn how to master them? He will secure the firmest foundation for this law by making this public opinion sacred in the eyes of all alike: slave and free, women and children, and the whole State.
838e
Megillus: Certainly; but how will it ever be possible for him to bring it about that everyone is willing to say such a thing... Athenian: A very fair remark. That was exactly why I said that, with respect to this law, I know of a device for making natural use of the intercourse that produces children: on the one hand, by abstaining from males and not deliberately killing off the human race, nor sowing seed on rocks and stones, where it can never take root and grow into fruitful increase; and on the other hand, by abstaining from every female field in which you would not want the seed to spring up. Once this law becomes permanent and prevails, if it rightly comes to rule in other cases as well, just as it now prevails regarding intercourse with parents, it is the source of countless blessings. For, in the first place, it follows the dictates of nature; it keeps men from erotic rage and frenzy and all kinds of fornication, and from all excess in food and drink; and it makes husbands affectionate toward their own wives. Countless other blessings would also follow, if one could make this law secure. Possibly, however, some rash young man standing by, bursting with virility, on hearing that this law had been passed, would denounce us for making foolish and impossible rules and fill the whole place with his shouting. It was with this in view that I said I knew of a device for making this law last once it is passed, one that is at once the easiest of all devices and the hardest. For it is very easy to see that this is possible, and how it is possible, since we maintain that this rule, once properly consecrated, will master every soul and make it fear the enacted laws and obey them completely. Yet things have now come to the point where people think that, even so, it is unlikely to happen. In the same way, in the case of the institution of common meals, people refuse to believe that a whole State could keep up the practice constantly, and this despite the evidence of the facts and the existence of the practice in your countries; and even there, when it is applied to women, the practice is regarded as unnatural. So it was because of the strength of this disbelief that I said it is extremely difficult to get both of these matters permanently established by law.
839d
Megillus: And you were right about that. Athenian: Still, to show that it is not beyond human power but possible, would you like me to try to state an argument that has some plausibility? Clinias: Certainly.
839e
Athenian: Would a man be more ready to abstain from sexual indulgence, and to agree to carry out the law on this matter with moderation, if his body were well trained and in good condition, or if it were in poor condition? Clinias: He would be much more ready if it were well trained. Athenian: Have we not all heard of Iccus of Tarentum, famous for his contests at Olympia and elsewhere? We know how, spurred on by ambition and skill, and having courage combined with self-control in his soul, he never touched a woman, or a boy either, during the whole period of his training, as the story goes. And the same story is told about Crison and Astylus and Diopompus and very many others. And yet, Clinias, these men were not only far worse educated in soul than your citizens and mine, but they also had far more sexual vigor of body.
840b
Clinias: It is indeed true, as you say, that the ancients confidently affirm that this really happened in the case of these athletes. Athenian: Well then, if those men had the fortitude to abstain from what most men regard as bliss, for the sake of victory in wrestling, running and the like, shall our boys be unable to hold out in order to win a much nobler victory? This is the noblest of all victories, as we shall tell them from their childhood on, charming them, we may expect, into believing it by stories, sayings and songs.
840c
Clinias: What victory? Athenian: Victory over pleasures. If they win it, they will live a life of bliss; but if they lose, just the opposite. Furthermore, will the fear that this is an utterly unholy thing not give them the power to master impulses that men inferior to themselves have mastered? Clinias: It is certainly reasonable to suppose so. Athenian: Since we have reached this point in our regulation, but have run into difficulty because of the cowardice of the many, I maintain that our regulation on this point must go forward and declare that our citizens must not be worse than birds and many other animals. These are born in large broods and live chaste and celibate lives without sexual intercourse until they reach the age for breeding. When they reach this age they pair off as instinct moves them, male with female and female with male, and from then on they live in a holy and just way, remaining faithful to their first compacts of love. Surely our citizens should at least be better than these animals. If, however, they are corrupted by most of the other Hellenes or barbarians, through seeing and hearing that among them the lawless Love (as it is called) has very great power, and so become unable to overcome it, then the Law-wardens, acting as lawgivers, must devise a second law for them.
841a
Clinias: What law do you advise them to make if the one now proposed slips out of their grasp? Athenian: Evidently the law that ranks next after it, as second, Clinias. Clinias: What is that? Athenian: One ought to keep the force of the pleasures as far as possible out of practice, diverting its increase and nourishment to another part of the body by means of physical labor. This would come about if sexual indulgence were free of shamelessness; for if, out of shame, people indulged in it only seldom, this rare indulgence would make it a less tyrannical mistress. So let them regard secrecy in such acts as honorable, sanctioned both by custom and by unwritten law; and let them regard lack of secrecy as dishonorable, though not the failure to abstain from such acts altogether. In this way we shall have a second standard of the honorable and the shameful established by law, with a second degree of rightness; and those people of corrupted nature whom we describe as inferior to themselves, who form a single kind, will be hemmed in by three kinds of force and compelled to refrain from breaking the law.
841c
Clinias: What kinds? Athenian: The fear of God, the love of honor, and a desire for beautiful qualities of soul rather than beautiful bodies. What I am now describing is perhaps like the wishful dreams in a story; yet in very truth, if only they were realized, they would prove a great blessing in every State. Possibly, if God grants it, we might enforce one of two things in this matter of sexual relations. Either no one would dare to touch any noble and freeborn person except his own wedded wife, or to sow unholy and bastard seed with concubines, or unnatural and barren seed in sodomy; or else we would abolish love of males entirely. And as for love of women, suppose we enact a law that any man who has intercourse with any women other than those brought into his house with the sanction of the gods and holy marriage, whether purchased or acquired in some other way, and who is detected in it by any man or woman, shall be barred from any public commendation in the State, as being in reality an alien. Such a law would probably be approved as right.
841e–842a
Athenian: So let this law, whether we ought to call it one law or two, be laid down concerning sexual relations and love affairs in general, with regard to right and wrong conduct in our dealings with one another that arise from these desires.
842a
Megillus: For my own part, Stranger, I would warmly welcome this law; but Clinias must tell us himself what his view of the matter is. Clinias: I shall do so, Megillus, when I think the occasion is suitable; but for now let us allow the Stranger to proceed further with his laws. Megillus: You are right.
842b–842e
Athenian: Well, we have now reached this point in our progress: the common meals have been established, something that we say would be difficult elsewhere, though in Crete no one would question that it is right. As for their form, whether we should adopt the Cretan style or the Lacedaemonian, or whether we can find a third style better than either, this does not seem to me a hard problem to settle, nor would settling it bring much benefit, since these meals are already established in a satisfactory way. Next comes the question of organizing the food supply and how to fit it to the meals. In other States the food supply would include all kinds of food and come from many sources, certainly from twice as many as in our State; for most Greeks get their food from both land and sea, but our people will get theirs from the land alone. This makes the lawgiver’s task easier, for here half as many laws, or fewer, will suffice, and the laws will also be better suited to free men. For the lawgiver of our State is free, for the most part, of shipping, trading, peddling, innkeeping, customs duties, mines, loans, interest, and countless other matters of the same kind. He can say goodbye to all of these and make laws for farmers, shepherds and beekeepers, and for the preservation and supervision of the tools used in these occupations. He will do this now that he has already enacted the most important laws, those dealing with marriage, with the birth, rearing and education of children, and with the appointment of magistrates in the State. For now, in his lawmaking, he must turn to the subject of food and of those whose labor helps supply it. First, then, let there be a code of laws called agricultural.
842e–843e
Athenian: The first law, the law of Zeus the Boundary-god, shall be stated as follows: No one shall move the boundary markers of land, whether they belong to a neighbor who is a native citizen or to a foreigner (when the owner holds adjoining land on a frontier), recognizing that to do this is truly to be guilty of moving what is sacred and must not be moved. A man should rather try to move the largest rock that is not a boundary marker than a small stone that marks the boundary, sanctioned by the gods, between friendly and hostile ground. For Zeus the god of kinsmen is witness to the one, and Zeus the god of strangers to the other; and when these gods are roused, they bring the deadliest wars. Whoever obeys the law shall not suffer the evils it inflicts; but whoever despises it shall be liable to a double penalty, the first from the hand of the gods, the second from the law. No one shall willingly move the boundary markers of his neighbors’ land. If anyone does move them, anyone who wishes shall report him to the landholders, and they shall bring him to the court. If a man is convicted, since such an act means that the convicted man is secretly and violently merging lands into one, the court shall assess what the losing party must suffer or pay. Further, many small wrongs are done against neighbors which, through constant repetition, breed an immense amount of hostility and make living as neighbors a harsh and bitter thing. So every neighbor must take the greatest care not to do anything unfriendly to his neighbor, and above all must always take special care never to encroach in the least on his land; for doing harm is easy and open to anyone, but doing good is by no means open to everyone. Whoever encroaches on his neighbor’s land, overstepping the boundaries, shall pay for the damage; and, as a cure for his shamelessness and lack of civility, he shall also pay the injured party twice the cost of the damage. In all such matters the land-stewards shall act as inspectors, judges and assessors: the whole staff of the district, as we said earlier, in the more important cases, and in the less important ones, those of them who are phrourarchs. If anyone encroaches on pasture land, these officials shall inspect the damage, decide the case, and assess it. And if anyone, giving in to his fondness for bees, gets another man’s swarm for himself by attracting it with the rattling of pans, he shall pay for the damage. And if a man, while burning his own brush, fails to take care for his neighbor’s property, he shall pay whatever fine the officials decide.
843e–844e
Athenian: The same applies if a man planting trees fails to leave the proper distance between them and his neighbor’s plot. Many lawgivers have dealt with this adequately, and we should make use of their laws rather than require the chief organizer of the State to legislate on all the many small details that are within the competence of any ordinary lawgiver. In the same way, there are excellent old laws about water supplies already laid down for farmers, which we need not draw into our discussion. Let this suffice: whoever wants to bring water to his own land may do so, starting from the public water sources, but he must not undercut any private person’s exposed wells. He may lead it by whatever route he wishes, except through a house, a temple or a tomb, and he must do no damage beyond the actual work of digging the channel. If, in some places, the rainwater soaks away because of the natural dryness of the soil, and there is a shortage of necessary drinking water, the owner shall dig on his own land down to the clay; and if he finds no water at that depth, he shall get from his neighbors just as much as he needs for drinking for all his household. If his neighbors too are short of supply, he shall apply to the land-stewards for a ration of water, fetch it day by day, and so share the water with his neighbors. If, when rain falls, anyone living on lower ground damages the farmer above him, or the neighbor next door, by blocking its outflow, or, conversely, if the man on higher ground damages the man below by carelessly letting out the floodwater, and if as a result they refuse to cooperate with each other in this matter, anyone who wishes shall call in a city-steward if it is in the city, or a land-steward if it is in the country, and obtain an order as to what each party must do. Whoever does not abide by the order shall be liable to prosecution for envy and a perverse spirit, and if convicted he shall pay the injured party double the damage, for refusing to obey the magistrates. As for the fruit harvest, the rule of sharing for everyone shall be this. This goddess has given us two gifts: one, the plaything of Dionysus, which is not stored; the other, produced by nature for storing. So let this law be enacted concerning the fruit harvest: whoever tastes the common crop of grapes or figs before the vintage season, which coincides with the rising of Arcturus, whether on his own land or on that of others, shall owe fifty sacred drachmas to Dionysus if he picked them from his own trees; a mina if from his neighbor’s trees; and two-thirds of a mina if from anyone else’s.
844e–845e
Athenian: If anyone wants to harvest choice grapes or choice figs, as they are now called, he may gather them however and whenever he likes if they come from his own trees; but if they come from another man’s trees, and without his consent, he shall be fined every time, in accordance with the law, ‘You shall not move what you did not set down.’ If a slave touches any such fruit without the consent of the owner of the land, he shall be flogged with as many lashes as there are grapes in the bunch or figs on the fig tree. If a resident alien buys a choice crop, he may harvest it if he wishes. If a foreigner visiting the country wants to eat some of the crop as he travels along the road, he may, if he wishes, take some of the choice fruit for himself and one attendant free of charge, as a gift of hospitality; but the law shall forbid our foreigners to share in the so-called common fruit and the like. If either a master or a slave touches it in ignorance, the slave shall be punished with lashes, and the free man shall be sent away with a warning and told to touch only the other crop, which is unsuitable for storing to make raisins for wine or dried figs. As for pears, apples, pomegranates and all such fruits, it shall be no disgrace to take them secretly; but a man who is caught at it, if he is under thirty years of age, shall be beaten and driven off without being wounded, and a free man shall have no right to sue over such blows. A foreigner shall be allowed to share in these fruits in the same way as in the grape crop. If a man over thirty touches them, eating them on the spot and taking none away, he shall share in all such fruits as the foreigner does; but if he disobeys the law, he shall be liable to be disqualified from competing for honors, if anyone brings these facts to the attention of the judges at that time. Water is more nourishing than anything else in a garden, but it is easily spoiled. For soil, sun and wind, which together with water nourish growing plants, are not easy to spoil by sorcery, diversion or theft; but all these things can happen to water, and so it needs the help of law. So let this be the law about it: if anyone deliberately spoils another man’s water, whether in a spring or in a pond, by sorcery, digging or theft, the injured party shall sue him before the city-stewards, recording the amount of the damage he has suffered; and anyone convicted of doing damage by poisons shall, in addition to paying the fine, cleanse the springs or the water basin in whatever way the laws of the interpreters declare that the purification should be carried out on each occasion and for each plaintiff.
845e–846e
Athenian: Concerning bringing home all the crops, anyone who wishes shall be allowed to carry his own produce through any place, provided either that he does no damage or that he himself gains three times as much profit as the damage he causes his neighbor. The magistrates shall have authority in this matter, as in all other cases where a man willingly injures an unwilling party, whether by force or secretly, by means of his own property, whether he injures the person himself or some of his property. In all such cases the plaintiff must report to the magistrates to obtain redress, where the damage is under three minas; but if one man has a larger claim than this against another, he shall bring a suit before the public courts and punish the wrongdoer. If any of the magistrates is thought to have given an unjust verdict in deciding the penalties, he shall be liable to pay the injured party double the amount; and anyone who wishes shall bring the magistrates’ wrongdoing before the public courts in each case of complaint. There are countless petty matters for which penalties must be laid down, concerning written complaints, summonses, and witnesses to summonses (whether a summons requires two witnesses or more), and all matters of that kind. These cannot be left without legal regulation, yet they do not deserve the attention of an aged lawgiver. So the young lawgivers shall make laws for them, modeling their small rules on the great ones of our earlier enactments, and learning by experience how far they are needed in practice, until it is decided that all of them have been adequately laid down. Then, having made them permanent, they shall live by them, now that they are set out in proper form. Moreover, we ought to regulate the craftsmen in the following way. First, no resident citizen shall be counted among those who work at technical crafts, nor shall any servant of a resident citizen. For a citizen already has a sufficient craft, one that requires long practice and much study: preserving and maintaining the public order of the State, a task that needs his full attention. And hardly any human being has the capacity to carry on two pursuits or two crafts thoroughly, or even to practice one himself while supervising someone else practicing another.
846e–847e
Athenian: So we must first of all lay down this fundamental rule in the State: no smith shall also work as a carpenter, nor shall a carpenter supervise others doing smith’s work instead of practicing his own craft, on the pretext that, since he supervises many servants working for him, he naturally supervises them more carefully because he earns more from that source than from his own craft. Instead, every craftsman in the State shall have one single craft and earn his living from it. The city-stewards shall work hard to uphold this law. If a resident citizen turns aside to any craft rather than to the pursuit of virtue, they shall punish him with reproaches and disgrace until they bring him back to his own proper course; and if a foreigner practices two crafts, they shall punish him with imprisonment, fines and expulsion from the State, and so compel him to be one man and not many. As for wages owed to craftsmen, the cancellation of work ordered, and any wrongs done to them by others or by them to others, the city-stewards shall act as arbitrators up to a value of fifty drachmas; for larger sums, the public courts shall decide as the law directs. No one in the State shall pay any duty on either exported or imported goods. No one shall import frankincense or any other such foreign spices used in religious rites, or purple and other dyes not produced in the country, or anything belonging to any other craft that requires imported foreign materials for some unnecessary use; nor, on the other hand, shall anyone export any of the goods that must necessarily remain in the country. The inspectors and supervisors of all these matters shall be the twelve Law-wardens who come next in order when the five oldest are left out. As for weapons and all instruments of war, if there is need to import any craft, plant, metal, rope or animal for military purposes, the hipparchs and generals shall control both imports and exports, when the State is both giving and receiving, and the Law-wardens shall enact suitable and adequate laws for this; but no trading for the sake of profit, in this or in any other matter, shall be carried on anywhere within the borders of our State and country. Regarding the food supply and the distribution of agricultural produce, a system close to the one established by law in Crete would probably prove satisfactory. Everyone must divide the whole produce of the land into twelve parts, according to how it is to be consumed.
847e–848b
Athenian: Each twelfth part, of wheat and barley, for example (and all the other crops must be distributed in the same way as these, as well as all the animals for sale in each district), must be divided proportionally into three shares. The first shall be for the freeborn citizens, and the second for their servants. The third share shall be for craftsmen and for foreigners in general, including any resident aliens who may be living among them and need basic sustenance, and all who have come into the country at any time to do either public or private business. This third share of all the necessities shall be the only one subject to compulsory sale; it shall be forbidden to make compulsory sale of any part of the other two shares. What, then, will be the best way to make these divisions? To begin with, it is plain that our division is equal in one way and unequal in another.
848b
Clinias: What do you mean? Athenian: Of each of these products of the land, some parts are necessarily worse and some better. Clinias: Of course. Athenian: In this respect none of the three shares shall have an unfair advantage, neither the share given to the masters, nor the slaves’ share, nor the foreigners’, but the distribution shall give the same equality of likeness to all. Each citizen shall take two shares and have control over distributing them to slaves and free men, in whatever quantity and of whatever quality he chooses. The surplus beyond this must be distributed by weight and number as follows: the owner must take the number of all the animals that are to be fed from the produce of the land, and distribute accordingly. Next, the citizens must have dwellings arranged separately. The following arrangement will suit them. There should be twelve villages, one in the middle of each of the twelve districts. In each village we shall first set apart temples and a marketplace for the gods and demigods; and if there are any local deities of the Magnesians, or shrines of other ancient gods whose memory is still preserved, we shall pay them the same worship that the people of old did. Everywhere we shall build temples to Hestia, Zeus and Athena, and to whatever other deity is the patron of the district concerned. First, buildings shall be put up around these temples, wherever the ground is highest, to form a stronghold for the garrison, as well fortified as possible. All the rest of the land we shall provide for by dividing the craftsmen into thirteen sections. One of these shall settle in the city, and this section shall in turn be subdivided into twelve parts, like the whole city itself, and distributed around it in the suburbs; and in each village we shall settle the kinds of craftsmen who are useful to farmers. The chiefs of the land-stewards shall supervise all of these, determining how many and which craftsmen each place needs, and where they shall live so as to cause the least trouble and be of the greatest use to the farmers.
849a–849e
Athenian: In the same way, the board of city-stewards shall carefully supervise the craftsmen in the city. All matters concerning the markets must be managed by the market-stewards. Besides supervising the temples next to the market, to prevent any damage being done to them, their second duty shall be to supervise personal conduct, keeping an eye on restrained and outrageous behavior, so as to punish whoever needs punishment. They shall watch over the goods offered for sale, to make sure that the sales the citizens are directed to make to foreigners are always conducted lawfully. There shall be this one law: on the first day of the month, the managers, that is, the foreigners or slaves who act as managers for the citizens, shall bring out the portion of the goods that is to be sold to foreigners. The first commodity shall be the twelfth share of grain, and at this first market the foreigner shall buy grain, and everything that goes with it, for the whole month. On the tenth day of the month, enough liquids to last the whole month shall be sold by the one party and bought by the other. Third, on the 20th day, there shall be a sale of livestock, as much as each party needs to buy or sell, and also of all the utensils or goods the farmers have for sale, such as skins or any kind of clothing, woven material, felt, or other such material; and the foreigners must obtain these by buying them from others. But neither these goods, nor barley or wheat ground into flour, nor any other kind of food whatever, may be sold by retail to the citizens or their slaves, nor may anyone buy them from any such retailer. (In the foreigners’ market, however, a foreigner may sell wine and grain to the craftsmen and their slaves, by what is generally called retail trade.) The butchers shall cut up the animals and sell the meat to the foreigners, the craftsmen and their servants. Any foreigner who wishes may buy any kind of fuel in bulk, on any day, from the managers in the districts, and he may sell it to the foreigners in whatever quantity and at whatever time he likes. All other goods and utensils that each party needs shall be brought for sale to the public market, each kind to its appointed place, wherever the Law-wardens and market-stewards, with the help of the city-stewards, have marked out suitable sites and set up the stalls for goods on sale. There they shall exchange money for goods and goods for money, and no one shall hand over his part to the other without receiving its equivalent;
849e–850d
Athenian: and if anyone does hand it over in this way, on credit, he must make the best of his bargain, whether or not he recovers what is owed him, since in such transactions he can no longer sue. If a purchase or sale is larger or more costly than is allowed by the law that states the limits of increase or decrease of property beyond which both of these transactions are forbidden, the amount of the difference must at once be registered with the Law-wardens in the case of an excess, and canceled in the case of a deficiency. The same rule shall apply to the registration of property in the case of resident aliens. Anyone who wishes may take up residence as an alien on fixed terms, since residence is permitted to a foreigner who is willing and able to live here, provided that he has a craft and stays in the country no more than twenty years from the date of his registration. He shall pay no aliens’ tax, not even a small one, except good conduct, nor any other tax on any buying or selling; and when his time has expired, he shall leave, taking his own property with him. If, during those twenty years, he happens to have proved his merit by doing some notable service to the State, and if he believes he can persuade the Council and the Assembly to grant his request and authorize a postponement of his departure, or even permission to stay for life, then whatever he succeeds in persuading the State to grant him shall be carried out for him in full. For the children of resident aliens who are craftsmen and over fifteen years of age, the period of residence shall begin from their fifteenth year. Such a person, after staying for twenty years from that point, shall go wherever he likes; or if he wishes to remain, he may do so after obtaining permission in the same way. Whoever leaves shall go only after first canceling the entries he previously made in the register at the magistrates’ office.
About this book
Laws, Book 8
0 connections
No connections in this book yet.