1 On that day the votes were counted and they decided that a footbath holding from two logs to nine kavs that was cracked could contract midras uncleanness. For Rabbi Akiva said a footbath must be considered according to its designation.
2 On that day they said: all animal sacrifices that have been sacrificed under the name of some other offering are nevertheless valid, but they do not count toward their owners’ obligations, with the exception of the Passover offering and the sin-offering. This is true of the Passover offering at its proper time and the sin-offering at any time. Rabbi Eliezer says: with the exception also of the guilt-offering. This applies to the Passover offering at its proper time and to the sin-offering and guilt-offering at any time. Rabbi Shimon ben Azzai said: I received a tradition from the seventy-two elders on the day when they appointed Rabbi Elazar ben Azariah head of the college that all animal sacrifices that are eaten and have not been sacrificed under their own name are nevertheless valid, but they do not count toward their owners’ obligations, with the exception of the Passover offering and the sin-offering. Ben Azzai added only to these exceptions the whole burnt offering, but the sages did not agree with him.
3 On that day they said: what is the law applying to Ammon and Moab in the seventh year? Rabbi Tarfon decreed tithe for the poor. And Rabbi Elazar ben Azariah decreed second tithe. Rabbi Ishmael said: Elazar ben Azariah, you must produce your proof because you are expressing the stricter view and whoever expresses a stricter view has the burden to produce the proof. Rabbi Elazar ben Azariah said to him: Ishmael, my brother, I have not deviated from the sequence of years, Tarfon, my brother, has deviated from it and the burden is on him to produce the proof. Rabbi Tarfon answered: Egypt is outside the land of Israel, Ammon and Moab are outside the land of Israel. Just as Egypt must give tithe for the poor in the seventh year, so must Ammon and Moab give tithe for the poor in the seventh year. Rabbi Elazar ben Azariah answered: Babylon is outside the land of Israel, Ammon and Moab are outside the land of Israel. Just as Babylon must give second tithe in the seventh year, so must Ammon and Moab give second tithe in the seventh year. Rabbi Tarfon said: on Egypt which is near, they imposed tithe for the poor so that the poor of Israel might be supported by it during the seventh year. So on Ammon and Moab which are near, we should impose tithe for the poor so that the poor of Israel may be supported by it during the seventh year. Rabbi Elazar ben Azariah said to him: Look, you are like someone who would benefit them financially, yet you are really like someone who causes them to perish. Would you rob the heavens so that dew or rain would not fall? As it is said, “Will a man rob God? Yet you rob me. But you say: How have we robbed You? In tithes and contributionsMalachi 3:8.” Rabbi Joshua said: Look, I will reply on behalf of Tarfon, my brother, but without following his line of argument. The law regarding Egypt is a recent enactment and the law regarding Babylon is an earlier enactment, and the law which is being argued before us is a recent enactment. A recent enactment should be inferred from another recent enactment, but a recent enactment should not be inferred from an earlier enactment. The law regarding Egypt is an enactment of the elders and the law regarding Babylon is an enactment of the prophets, and the law which is being argued before us is an enactment of the elders. An enactment of the elders should be inferred from another enactment of the elders, but an enactment of the elders should not be inferred from an enactment of the prophets. The votes were counted and they decided that Ammon and Moab should give tithe for the poor in the seventh year. And when Rabbi Yose ben Durmaskit visited Rabbi Eliezer in Lod he said to him: what new thing did you have in the house of study today? He said to him: their votes were counted and they decided that Ammon and Moab must give tithe for the poor in the seventh year. Rabbi Eliezer wept and said: “The counsel of the Lord is with those who fear him, and he makes his covenant known to themPsalms 25:14.” Go and tell them: Do not worry about your voting. I received a tradition from Rabbi Yohanan ben Zakkai who heard it from his teacher, and his teacher from his teacher, and so back to a halakhah given to Moses at Sinai, that Ammon and Moab must give tithe for the poor in the seventh year.
4 On that day Judah, an Ammonite convert, came and stood before them in the house of study. He said to them: Do I have the right to enter into the assembly? Rabban Gamaliel said to him: you are forbidden. Rabbi Joshua said to him: you are permitted. Rabban Gamaliel said to him: the verse says, “An Ammonite or a Moabite shall not enter into the assembly of the Lord, even to the tenth generationDeuteronomy 23:3.” Rabbi Joshua said to him: But are the Ammonites and Moabites still in their own territory? Sennacherib, the king of Assyria, came long ago and mixed all the nations, as it is said: “I have removed the boundaries of the peoples, and have robbed their treasures, and have brought down the inhabitants like a mighty manIsaiah 10:13.” Rabban Gamaliel said to him: the verse says, “But afterward I will bring back the captives of the children of AmmonJeremiah 49:6.” they have already returned. Rabbi Joshua said to him: another verse says, “I will bring back the captives of my people Israel and JudahJeremiah 30:3.” Yet they have not yet returned. So they permitted him to enter the assembly.
5 The Aramaic sections in Ezra and Daniel defile the hands. If an Aramaic section was written in Hebrew, or a Hebrew section was written in Aramaic, or Hebrew which was written with Hebrew script, it does not defile the hands. It never defiles the hands until it is written in the Assyrian script, on parchment, and in ink.
6 The Sadducees say: we complain against you, Pharisees, because you say that the Holy Scriptures defile the hands, but the books of Homer do not defile the hands. Rabban Yohanan ben Zakkai said: Do we have nothing against the Pharisees except this? They say that the bones of a donkey are clean, yet the bones of Yohanan the high priest are unclean. They said to him: their impurity reflects how precious they are, so that nobody should make spoons out of the bones of his father or mother. He said to them: the same applies to the Holy Scriptures: their uncleanness reflects how precious they are. The books of Homer, which are not precious, do not defile the hands.
7 The Sadducees say: we complain against you, Pharisees, that you declare an uninterrupted flow of a liquid to be clean. The Pharisees say: we complain against you, Sadducees, that you declare a stream of water that flows from a cemetery to be clean. The Sadducees say: we complain against you, Pharisees, that you say, my ox or donkey that has caused injury is liable, yet my male or female slave who has caused injury is not liable. I am responsible for the damage caused by my ox or my donkey, even though I am not responsible for ensuring that they fulfill religious duties. For my male or female slave for whom I am responsible to see that they fulfill mitzvot, how much more should I be responsible for their damages? They said to them: No, if you argue about my ox or my donkey which have no understanding, can you infer anything from that about a male or female slave who have understanding? If I angered either of them and they went and burned another person’s stack of grain, should I be liable to pay compensation?
8 A Galilean min said: I complain against you Pharisees, that you write the name of the ruler and the name of Moses together on a divorce document. The Pharisees said: we complain against you, Galilean min, that you write the name of the ruler together with the divine name on a single page of Torah? And furthermore, that you write the name of the ruler above and the divine name below? As it is said, “And Pharaoh said, Who is the Lord that I should listen to his voice to let Israel go?Exodus 5:2” But when he was struck what did he say? “The Lord is righteousExodus 9:27.”
Connections in Mishnah Yadayim 4
2 connections
Chapter 4 2 connections
No connections match.