Irus Challenges Odysseus
1 Now a public beggar came up, who used to beg through the town 2 of Ithaca. He was known for his greedy belly, 3 eating and drinking without end. He had no strength 4 or power, but his body looked very large. 5 His name was Arnaeus, the name his honored mother had given him 6 at birth. But all the young men called him Irus, 7 because he used to run errands whenever anyone told him to. 8 He came up and tried to drive Odysseus from his own house, 9 insulting him and speaking winged words:
10 “Move away from the doorway, old man, or soon you may be dragged out by the foot. 11 Don’t you see that everyone is winking at me 12 and telling me to drag you out? Yet I am ashamed to do it. 13 Get up, or our quarrel may soon come to blows.”
14 Resourceful Odysseus glared from beneath his brows and answered him: 15 “Good fellow, I do you no harm by word or deed. 16 I do not begrudge anyone giving you even a large portion. 17 This threshold will hold us both. There is no need 18 to be jealous of other people’s goods. You seem to be a wanderer 19 like me. As for good fortune, the gods are the ones likely to give us that. 20 But do not challenge me too much with your fists, or you may anger me, 21 and old though I am, I may stain your chest and lips 22 with blood. Then I would have even greater peace 23 tomorrow, for I do not think you would come back 24 a second time to the hall of Odysseus, son of Laertes.” 25 The wanderer Irus grew angry and said to him: 26 “Look how glibly this filthy wretch talks, 27 like an old woman at the oven. I will make trouble for him, 28 striking with both hands, and knock all the teeth 29 from his jaws onto the ground, as if he were a pig ruining the grain. 30 Tie up your clothes now, so all these men can see us 31 fighting. But how could you fight a younger man?”
32 So, in front of the high doors, 33 on the polished threshold, they roused each other’s anger with all their hearts. 34 Strong and mighty Antinous heard the two 35 and burst into merry laughter, speaking among the suitors:
36 “Friends, nothing like this has ever happened before: 37 a god has brought such sport to this house! 38 That stranger and Irus are provoking each other 39 to a fistfight. Come, let us quickly get them fighting.”
The Suitors Arrange a Fight
40 So he spoke, and they all sprang up laughing 41 and gathered around the beggars in their ragged clothes. 42 Antinous, son of Eupeithes, spoke among them:
43 “Listen, proud suitors, so I can say something. 44 Here are goats’ stomachs in the fire for supper. 45 We filled them with fat and blood and set them there. 46 Whichever of the two wins and proves the stronger, 47 let him get up and choose whichever of these he wants. 48 From then on he will always feast with us, and we will not let any other 49 beggar join our company and beg from us.”
50 So Antinous spoke, and they were pleased with his words. 51 Then resourceful Odysseus spoke among them with a crafty mind:
52 “Friends, an old man burdened with misery cannot fight a younger 53 man. Yet my belly, 54 that worker of evil, urges me on to be overcome by his blows. 55 But come now, all of you swear me a mighty oath, 56 that no one, to do Irus a favor, will strike me with a heavy hand 57 in a reckless, foul blow, and force me to submit to this man.”
58 So he spoke, and they all swore not to strike him, just as he asked. 59 When they had sworn and finished the oath, 60 strong and mighty Telemachus spoke among them again:
61 “Stranger, if your heart and proud spirit urge you 62 to fight this man off, do not fear any other Achaean, 63 for whoever strikes you will have more than just you to fight. 64 I am your host, and the princes agree to this, 65 Antinous and Eurymachus, both men of good sense.” 66 So he spoke, and they all praised his words. Odysseus 67 tied his rags around his hips and showed his thighs, 68 handsome and large. His broad shoulders came into view, 69 and his chest and mighty arms. Athena 70 stood close and made the limbs of the shepherd of the people greater. 71 All the suitors were greatly amazed, 72 and one would glance at his neighbor and say:
73 “Irus will soon be no Irus at all, bringing trouble on himself, 74 judging by the thigh that old man shows beneath his rags.”
75 So they spoke, and Irus’ heart was miserably shaken. 76 Even so, the servants tied up his clothes and forced him out, 77 full of fear, his flesh trembling on his limbs. 78 Antinous rebuked him and addressed him by name:
79 “It would be better if you were not alive, you bragger, and had never been born, 80 if you tremble and are so terribly afraid of this fellow, 81 an old man overcome by the misery that has come on him. 82 I will tell you plainly, and this will surely come true. 83 If he defeats you and proves the stronger, 84 I will throw you into a black ship and send you to the mainland, 85 to King Echetus, the maimer of all men, 86 who will cut off your nose and ears with pitiless bronze, 87 tear out your genitals, and give them raw to dogs to rip apart.”
88 So he spoke, and still greater trembling seized Irus’ limbs. 89 They led him into the ring, and both men raised their hands.
Odysseus Defeats Irus
90 Then the much-enduring noble Odysseus considered 91 whether to strike him so that life would leave him as he fell there, 92 or to give him a light blow and stretch him on the ground. 93 As he thought it over, this seemed the better course: 94 to strike lightly, so the Achaeans would not notice who he was. 95 When they had raised their hands, Irus struck Odysseus’ right shoulder, 96 but Odysseus struck his neck beneath the ear, crushing the bones 97 inward. At once red blood ran from his mouth. 98 He fell in the dust with a moan, clashing his teeth together 99 and kicking the ground with his feet. The lordly suitors 100 raised their hands and almost died laughing. Odysseus 101 seized him by the foot and dragged him out through the doorway to the courtyard 102 and the doors of the porch. He set him down 103 leaning against the courtyard wall and thrust his staff into his hand, 104 addressing him with winged words:
105 “Sit there now and scare off pigs and dogs. 106 Do not lord it over strangers and beggars, 107 wretch that you are, or you may reap some greater trouble.”
108 He spoke and flung his miserable bag over his shoulders, 109 full of holes and hung by a twisted cord. 110 Then he went back to the threshold and sat down. The suitors went inside, 111 laughing merrily, and greeted him with these words:
112 “Stranger, may Zeus and the other immortal gods grant you 113 what you most desire and the dearest wish of your heart, 114 since you have stopped this insatiable fellow from begging 115 through the land. Soon we will take him to the mainland, 116 to King Echetus, the maimer of all men.”
117 So they spoke, and noble Odysseus rejoiced at the word of omen. 118 Antinous set the great stomach before him, 119 filled with fat and blood, and Amphinomus 120 took two loaves from the basket and set them before him. 121 He raised a golden cup to him and said:
122 “Greetings, honored stranger. May good fortune be yours in the future, 123 though now you are a slave to many sorrows.”
Odysseus Warns Amphinomus
124 Resourceful Odysseus answered him: 125 “Amphinomus, you certainly seem to me a man of good sense. 126 Your father was such a man too, for I have heard good reports 127 that Nisus of Dulichium was a brave and wealthy man. 128 They say you are his son, and you seem a man of gentle speech. 129 So I will tell you something. Pay attention and listen. 130 Of all the creatures the earth nurtures, none is feebler than a human, 131 of all that breathe and move on the earth. 132 A man thinks he will never suffer trouble in the future, 133 as long as the gods give him prosperity and his knees are quick. 134 But when the blessed gods bring him sorrow, 135 he bears that too with deep resentment and a steadfast heart. 136 For the spirit of people on earth is just like 137 the day the father of gods and men brings on them. 138 I too once seemed set to prosper among men, 139 but I committed many reckless deeds, yielding to my might and strength 140 and trusting in my father and my brothers. 141 So let no man ever be lawless. 142 Let him quietly keep whatever gifts the gods give him. 143 Yet I see the suitors plotting reckless deeds, 144 wasting the wealth and dishonoring the wife 145 of a man who, I tell you, will not remain far from his friends and native land 146 much longer. He is very near. But may a god 147 lead you away from here to your home, and may you not meet him 148 when he returns to his dear native land. 149 For I do not think they will part without bloodshed, 150 the suitors and that man, once he comes under his roof.”
151 So he spoke, poured a drink offering, and drank the honey-sweet wine, 152 then gave the cup back into the hands of the leader of the people. 153 Amphinomus went through the hall with a heavy heart, 154 bowing his head, for his spirit foresaw ruin. 155 Even so, he did not escape his fate. Athena bound him too, 156 to be killed outright by Telemachus’ hands and spear. 157 He sat down again on the chair from which he had risen.
Athena Prepares Penelope
158 Then the goddess, flashing-eyed Athena, put it into the heart 159 of Icarius’ daughter, wise Penelope, 160 to show herself to the suitors, to set 161 their hearts aflutter and win greater honor 162 from her husband and son than before. 163 She gave a meaningless laugh and addressed the nurse:
164 “Eurynome, my heart longs, as it never has before, 165 to show myself to the suitors, even though they are hateful to me. 166 I would also give my son advice for his own good: 167 he should never associate with the overbearing suitors, 168 who speak kindly to him but plan evil behind his back.”
169 Then Eurynome the housekeeper said to her: 170 “Yes, child, you have spoken rightly in all this. 171 Go and tell your son what you have to say. Do not hide it. 172 But first wash your body and anoint your face. 173 Do not go as you are, with your face stained with tears, 174 for it is bad to grieve forever without ceasing. 175 Your son is grown now, the son you prayed 176 so earnestly to the immortals to see as a bearded man.”
177 Wise Penelope answered her again: 178 “Eurynome, do not coax me like this, though you care for me, 179 to wash my body and anoint myself with oil. 180 The gods who hold Olympus have destroyed 181 all my beauty since the day my lord left in the hollow ships. 182 But tell Autonoe and Hippodameia 183 to come to me and stand beside me in the hall. 184 I will not go alone among men, for I feel ashamed.”
185 So she spoke, and the old woman went out through the room 186 to bring word to the women and urge them to come.
187 Then the goddess, flashing-eyed Athena, thought of another plan. 188 She poured sweet sleep over Icarius’ daughter, 189 who leaned back asleep, all her joints relaxed, 190 there on her couch. Meanwhile the fair goddess 191 gave her immortal gifts, so the Achaeans would marvel at her. 192 First she beautified her lovely face with balm, 193 immortal balm of the kind that beautifully crowned Cytherea 194 uses to anoint herself when she joins the Graces’ lovely dance. 195 She made her taller and statelier to look at, 196 and whiter than freshly sawn ivory. 197 When she had done this, the fair goddess went away, 198 and the white-armed female servants came out of the room, 199 approaching with the sound of their voices. Sweet sleep released Penelope, 200 and she rubbed her cheeks with her hands and said:
201 “Ah, soft sleep enfolded me in my utter misery. 202 I wish pure Artemis would give me a death as soft 203 right now, so I would no longer waste my life away 204 in sorrow at heart, longing for my dear husband’s 205 excellence in every way, for he was outstanding among the Achaeans.”
Penelope Appears Before the Suitors
206 With these words she came down from the bright upstairs room, 207 accompanied by two female servants. 208 When the fair lady reached the suitors, 209 she stood beside a doorpost of the carefully built hall, 210 holding her shining veil in front of her face. 211 A faithful female servant stood on either side of her. 212 At once the suitors’ knees gave way, and love enchanted their hearts. 213 They all prayed to lie beside her. 214 But she addressed Telemachus, her dear son:
215 “Telemachus, your mind and thoughts are no longer steady as before. 216 Even when you were a child, you used to think more cleverly. 217 Now you are grown and have reached manhood, 218 so that a stranger looking at your stature and beauty 219 would call you a rich man’s son, 220 yet your mind and thoughts are no longer right as before. 221 What a thing has happened in these halls, 222 that you let that stranger be treated so shamefully! 223 What if the stranger, sitting here in our house, 224 should suffer some harm from cruel mistreatment? 225 Then shame and disgrace would fall on you among men.”
226 Wise Telemachus answered her: 227 “My mother, I do not blame you for being angry about this. 228 Yet I know and understand in my own heart each thing, 229 good and evil, while before I was only a child. 230 But I cannot plan everything wisely, 231 for these men sit around me on every side and thwart my will 232 with their evil plans, and I have no one to help me. 233 Yet the fight between the stranger and Irus 234 did not go as the suitors wished. The stranger proved stronger. 235 Father Zeus, Athena, and Apollo, I wish 236 the suitors were beaten like that now in our house, 237 hanging their heads, some in the courtyard 238 and some inside the hall, with every man’s limbs loosened, 239 just as Irus now sits over there by the courtyard gate, 240 hanging his head like a drunken man. 241 He cannot stand upright on his feet or go back 242 to wherever his home may be, for his limbs are loosened.”
243 So they spoke to one another. 244 But Eurymachus addressed Penelope:
245 “Daughter of Icarius, wise Penelope, 246 if all the Achaeans throughout Iasian Argos could see you, 247 even more suitors would be feasting in your halls 248 from tomorrow on, for you excel all women 249 in beauty, stature, and the wise heart within you.”
Penelope Recalls Odysseus’ Instructions
250 Then wise Penelope answered him: 251 “Eurymachus, the immortals destroyed all my excellence, beauty, and form 252 on the day the Argives embarked for Ilios, 253 and my husband Odysseus went with them. 254 If only he would come back and watch over my life, 255 my fame would be greater and fairer. 256 But now I grieve. Some god has brought so many troubles on me. 257 When he went away and left his native land, 258 he took my right hand by the wrist and said:
259 “‘Wife, I do not think the Achaeans with their fine shin guards 260 will all come back from Troy safe and unharmed. 261 For people say the Trojans are men of war, 262 men who throw spears and draw the bow, 263 and drivers of swift horses, who most quickly 264 decide the great conflict of evenly matched war. 265 So I do not know whether the god will bring me back or I will be killed 266 there in Troy. Take charge of everything here. 267 Care for my father and mother in the halls 268 as you do now, or even more while I am far away. 269 But when you see my son a bearded man, 270 marry whomever you wish, and leave your house.’
271 “That was what he said, and now it is all coming true. 272 The night will come when I face a hateful marriage, 273 accursed as I am, robbed of happiness by Zeus. 274 But this brings bitter grief to my heart and soul: 275 this was never the way of suitors before. 276 Men who wish to court a woman of worth, a rich man’s daughter, 277 and compete with one another 278 bring their own cattle and fine flocks 279 to provide a banquet for the bride’s friends, and give her glorious gifts. 280 They do not devour another’s livelihood without compensation.”
281 So she spoke, and the much-enduring noble Odysseus was glad, 282 because she drew gifts from them and charmed their hearts 283 with gentle words, while her mind was set on other things.
284 Then Antinous, son of Eupeithes, spoke to her again: 285 “Daughter of Icarius, wise Penelope, 286 accept whatever gifts any Achaean wishes to bring here. 287 It is not good to refuse a gift. 288 But we will not go to our lands or anywhere else 289 until you marry whichever Achaean is best.”
The Suitors Send Gifts
290 So Antinous spoke, and they were pleased with his words. 291 Each man sent a herald to bring his gifts. 292 Antinous’ herald brought a large and beautiful robe, 293 richly embroidered, with twelve brooches, 294 all gold, fitted with curved clasps. 295 For Eurymachus, another at once brought an intricately made necklace, 296 of gold, strung with amber beads, bright as the sun. 297 The attendants brought a pair of earrings for Eurydamas, 298 with three clustering drops. They shone with great grace. 299 From the house of lord Peisander, son of Polyctor, 300 his attendant brought a necklace, an exceedingly beautiful jewel. 301 Each Achaean brought a different beautiful gift. 302 Then the fair lady went up to her upstairs room, 303 and her female servants carried the beautiful gifts for her.
Evening in the Palace
304 The suitors turned to dancing and delightful song, 305 enjoying themselves as they waited for evening to come. 306 While they made merry, dark evening came over them. 307 At once they set up three braziers in the hall 308 to give them light, and placed dry firewood around them, 309 long seasoned and hard, freshly split with an axe. 310 They set torches among it, and the female servants 311 of steadfast-hearted Odysseus took turns kindling the flame. 312 Zeus-born, resourceful Odysseus himself said to them:
313 “Female servants of Odysseus, the master who has long been away, 314 go to the rooms where your honored queen is. 315 Sit beside her, twist the yarn, and gladden her heart 316 as you sit in the room, or card the wool with your hands. 317 I will give light to all these men. 318 Even if they wish to wait for fair-throned Dawn, 319 they will not outlast me. I can endure a great deal.”
Melantho Insults Odysseus
320 So he spoke, and the women laughed and glanced at one another. 321 Fair-cheeked Melantho insulted him shamefully. 322 She was Dolius’ daughter, but Penelope had brought her up, 323 cherishing her as her own child and giving her all the toys she wanted. 324 Even so, she felt no sorrow in her heart for Penelope, 325 but loved Eurymachus and used to sleep with him. 326 She rebuked Odysseus with insulting words:
327 “Wretched stranger, you must be out of your mind. 328 You refuse to go and sleep in a smith’s workshop 329 or a public lodging house, but keep chattering here, 330 boldly among so many lords, with no fear 331 in your heart. Surely wine has taken hold of your wits, or your mind is always 332 like this, making you babble nonsense. 333 Are you beside yourself because you beat that wanderer Irus? 334 Watch out, or someone better than Irus may soon get up 335 and beat you around the head with heavy hands, 336 drench you in blood, and send you out of the house.”
337 Resourceful Odysseus glared from beneath his brows and answered her: 338 “At once I will tell Telemachus what you say, you dog. 339 I will go over there, so he can cut you limb from limb on the spot.”
340 With these words he scattered the women in terror. 341 They fled through the hall, each woman’s limbs giving way 342 with fear, for they thought he spoke the truth. 343 Odysseus stood beside the burning braziers to give light, 344 looking at all the men. His heart 345 pondered other things within him, things that would not go unfulfilled.
Eurymachus Mocks Odysseus
346 But Athena would not let the proud suitors 347 stop their bitter insults, so pain would sink still deeper 348 into the heart of Odysseus, son of Laertes. 349 Eurymachus, son of Polybus, began speaking among them, 350 jeering at Odysseus and making his companions laugh:
351 “Listen, suitors of the glorious queen, 352 so I can say what the heart in my chest tells me. 353 This man has not come to Odysseus’ palace without the gods’ will. 354 At any rate, torchlight seems to shine from him, 355 from his head, for there is no hair on it, not a trace.”
356 With that he addressed Odysseus, sacker of cities: 357 “Stranger, would you be willing to work for wages if I hired you 358 on an outlying farm—I will guarantee your pay— 359 gathering stones for walls and planting tall trees? 360 There I would provide you with food all year, 361 clothe you, and give you sandals for your feet. 362 But since you have learned only evil deeds, you will not want 363 to work. You prefer to skulk through the land 364 so you can feed your insatiable belly.” 365 Resourceful Odysseus answered him: 366 “Eurymachus, I wish the two of us could compete at work 367 in springtime, when the long days come, 368 mowing grass, I with a curved scythe in my hands 369 and you with another like it, so we could test our work, 370 fasting until late evening, with plenty of grass before us. 371 Or I wish we had oxen to drive, the very best, 372 tawny and large, both well fed on grass, 373 the same age, equally matched under the yoke, tireless in strength, 374 and a field of four acres, with soil that yielded to the plow. 375 Then you would see whether I could cut a straight furrow all the way to the end. 376 Or I wish the son of Cronus would bring war on us from wherever he chose 377 today, and I had a shield, two spears, 378 and an all-bronze helmet fitting well at my temples. 379 Then you would see me among the foremost fighters, 380 and would not chatter and taunt me about this belly of mine. 381 But you are very arrogant, and your heart is cruel. 382 No doubt you think yourself a great and mighty man 383 because you keep company with only a few weak men. 384 If Odysseus came back to his native land, 385 those doors, wide though they are, would soon 386 seem far too narrow as you fled out through the doorway.”
387 So he spoke, and Eurymachus grew still angrier in his heart. 388 Glaring from beneath his brows, he addressed him with winged words:
389 “Wretch, I will soon do you harm for talking like this, 390 boldly among so many lords, with no fear 391 in your heart. Surely wine has taken hold of your wits, or your mind is always 392 like this, making you babble nonsense. 393 Are you beside yourself because you beat that wanderer Irus?”
Eurymachus Throws a Footstool
394 With that he seized a footstool, but Odysseus 395 sat down at the knees of Amphinomus of Dulichium, 396 fearing Eurymachus. Eurymachus hurled it and struck a cupbearer on the 397 right hand, and the wine jug fell to the ground with a clang. 398 The man groaned and fell backward in the dust. 399 The suitors broke into an uproar through the shadowy halls, 400 and one man would glance at his neighbor and say:
401 “I wish that stranger had died elsewhere on his wanderings 402 before he came here. Then he would never have brought all this uproar among us. 403 Now we are brawling over beggars, and there will be no joy 404 in our rich feast, since worse things prevail.”
Telemachus Calls for Order
405 Then strong and mighty Telemachus spoke among them: 406 “You strange fellows, you are mad, and you no longer hide 407 that you have eaten and drunk. Some god must be stirring you up. 408 Now that you have feasted well, go home and rest 409 when your hearts tell you to. I am driving no one out.”
410 So he spoke, and they all bit their lips 411 and marveled at how boldly Telemachus spoke. 412 Amphinomus addressed them, 413 the glorious son of lord Nisus, whose father was Aretias:
414 “Friends, when words have been spoken fairly, no one 415 should grow angry and reply with quarrelsome words. 416 Do not abuse this stranger any more, or any other 417 slave in divine Odysseus’ house. 418 Come, let the cupbearer pour drops for drink offerings into the cups, 419 so we can pour drink offerings, go home, and rest. 420 Let us leave this stranger in Odysseus’ halls 421 to Telemachus’ care, for he has come to his house.”
422 So he spoke, and his words pleased them all. 423 Then lord Mulius mixed a bowl for them. 424 He was a herald from Dulichium and an attendant of Amphinomus. 425 He went up to each in turn and served them all. They poured drink offerings 426 to the blessed gods and drank the honey-sweet wine. 427 When they had poured drink offerings and drunk to their hearts’ content, 428 they went away to rest, each to his own house.
About this book
Odyssey, Book 18
0 connections
No connections in this book yet.