Go to Related Reading
About this book

Odyssey, Book 17

Odysseia 17

Telemachus Returns to the Palace

1 As soon as early Dawn appeared, rosy-fingered, 2 fastening beautiful sandals beneath his feet, 3 Telemachus, the dear son of divine Odysseus, 4 took his mighty spear, which fitted his grasp, 5 eager to go to the city. He said to his pig herder:

6 “Father, I am going to the city so my mother can 7 see me. I do not think she will stop 8 her woeful weeping and tearful lamentation 9 until she sees me in person. But I give you this instruction. 10 Take this wretched stranger to the city so he can 11 beg for food there. Whoever wishes can give him 12 a loaf and a cup of water. I cannot take on the burden of everyone 13 when I have grief in my heart. 14 If the stranger is very angry about this, 15 it will be worse for him. I love speaking the truth.”

16 Resourceful Odysseus answered him: 17 “Friend, I do not want to be left here either. 18 It is better for a beggar 19 to beg for food in town than in the fields. Whoever wishes can give it to me. 20 I am too old now to stay at the farmstead 21 and obey an overseer’s orders in everything. 22 Go on your way. This man you have instructed will lead me 23 once I have warmed myself at the fire and the sun has grown hot. 24 These clothes I wear are miserably poor, and I fear 25 the morning frost might overcome me. You say it is far to the city.”

26 With that Telemachus went out through the farmstead 27 with rapid strides, sowing the seeds of trouble for the suitors. 28 When he reached the stately house, 29 he set his spear against a tall pillar, 30 then went inside himself and crossed the stone threshold.

31 Eurycleia the nurse was the first by far to see him, 32 as she spread fleeces on the intricately made chairs. 33 Bursting into tears, she came straight toward him. All the other 34 female servants of steadfast-hearted Odysseus gathered around them, 35 kissing his head and shoulders in loving welcome.

36 Wise Penelope came out of her room, 37 like Artemis or golden Aphrodite, 38 and burst into tears as she threw her arms around her dear son 39 and kissed his head and both his beautiful eyes. 40 Weeping, she addressed him with winged words:

41 “You have come, Telemachus, sweet light of my eyes. I thought I would never 42 see you again after you went in your ship to Pylos, 43 secretly and against my will, to seek news of your dear father. 44 Tell me what you saw of him.” 45 Then wise Telemachus answered her: 46 “Mother, do not stir up weeping or trouble the heart 47 in my chest, now that I have escaped utter destruction. 48 Bathe yourself and dress in clean clothes, 49 then go up to your upstairs room with your female servants 50 and vow to all the gods to offer large sacrificial offerings that bring fulfillment, 51 hoping Zeus may someday bring about deeds of repayment. 52 I will go to the assembly place to invite 53 the stranger who followed me here from Pylos to our house. 54 I sent him ahead with my godlike companions, 55 and told Peiraeus to take him home, 56 welcome him kindly, and honor him until I came.”

57 He spoke, but her words did not take wing. 58 She bathed and dressed in clean clothes 59 and vowed to all the gods to offer large sacrificial offerings 60 that bring fulfillment, hoping Zeus would someday bring about deeds of repayment.

61 Telemachus went out through the hall 62 with his spear in his hand, and two swift dogs followed him. 63 Athena poured wonderful grace over him, 64 and all the people marveled at him as he came. 65 The proud suitors crowded around him, 66 speaking kindly but plotting harm in the depths of their hearts. 67 He avoided their great crowd 68 and went where Mentor, Antiphus, and Halitherses sat, 69 old friends of his father’s house. 70 He sat down there, and they asked him about everything. 71 Peiraeus, the famous spearman, came near, 72 leading the stranger through the city to the assembly place. 73 Telemachus did not stay away from his guest long, but went up to him. 74 Peiraeus spoke first:

75 “Telemachus, send women to my house quickly 76 so I can send you the gifts Menelaus gave you.”

77 Then wise Telemachus answered him: 78 “Peiraeus, we do not know how these things will turn out. 79 If the proud suitors 80 secretly kill me in my hall and divide all my ancestral goods among themselves, 81 I would rather you kept and enjoyed these things than any of them. 82 But if I sow the seeds of death and fate for them, 83 bring everything to my house with joy, as I will be joyful.”

Telemachus Reports on His Journey

84 With that he led the weary stranger to the house. 85 When they reached the stately house, 86 they laid their cloaks on the chairs and high seats, 87 went into the polished baths, and bathed. 88 When the female servants had bathed them, anointed them with oil, 89 and wrapped them in fleecy cloaks and tunics, 90 they came out of the baths and sat on the chairs. 91 A female servant brought water for their hands and poured it 92 from a beautiful golden pitcher over a silver basin 93 for them to wash, and drew a polished table beside them. 94 The dignified housekeeper brought bread and set it before them, 95 adding plentiful dishes, giving freely from her stores. 96 His mother sat opposite Telemachus by the hall’s doorpost, 97 leaning against a chair and spinning fine threads of yarn. 98 They reached for the good food set before them. 99 When they had satisfied their desire for food and drink, 100 wise Penelope spoke first among them:

101 “Telemachus, I will go to my upstairs room 102 and lie on my bed, which has become a bed of weeping for me, 103 always wet with my tears since Odysseus 104 left with the sons of Atreus for Ilios. Yet you did not take care, 105 before the proud suitors come into this house, 106 to tell me plainly about your father’s return, if you heard anything.”

107 And wise Telemachus answered her: 108 “Mother, I will tell you the whole truth. 109 We went to Pylos and Nestor, the shepherd of the people. 110 He received me in his high house 111 and welcomed me kindly, as a father would his own son 112 returning after a long time from a distant land. Just as kindly 113 he cared for me with his glorious sons. 114 Yet of steadfast-hearted Odysseus, alive or dead, 115 he said he had heard nothing from anyone on earth. 116 He sent me on with horses and a sturdy chariot 117 to Menelaus, son of Atreus, the famous spearman. 118 There I saw Argive Helen, for whose sake 119 Argives and Trojans suffered so much by the gods’ will. 120 Menelaus, good at the war cry, immediately asked 121 what I had come to beautiful Lacedaemon to seek. 122 I told him the whole truth. 123 He answered me:

124 “‘Shame on them! In the bed of a man with a brave heart 125 they wanted to lie, cowards themselves. 126 Just as when a doe, in the thicket where a mighty lion has its den, 127 puts her newborn, nursing fawns to sleep 128 and roams over the mountain slopes and grassy valleys 129 to graze, then the lion comes back to its den 130 and lets a cruel doom loose on both, 131 so Odysseus will let a cruel doom loose on these men. 132 Father Zeus, Athena, and Apollo, I wish 133 that with the same strength he had once in well-built Lesbos, 134 when he rose and wrestled Philomeleides 135 and threw him down with force, to all the Achaeans’ joy, 136 Odysseus would come among the suitors with that strength. 137 Then they would all meet swift destruction and bitterness in their courtship. 138 As for what you ask and beg me to tell, 139 I will not turn aside to speak of other things or deceive you. 140 Of all the unerring old man of the sea told me, 141 I will not hide or conceal a single thing from you. 142 He said he saw Odysseus on an island in terrible distress, 143 in the nymph Calypso’s halls. She keeps him there 144 by force, and he cannot return to his native land. 145 He has no ships with oars or companions 146 to send him over the broad back of the sea.’

147 “That was what Menelaus, son of Atreus, the famous spearman, said. 148 When I had finished all this, I set out for home. 149 The immortals gave me a fair wind and brought me quickly to my dear native land.”

Theoclymenus Foretells Odysseus’ Return

150 His words stirred the heart in her chest. 151 Godlike Theoclymenus also spoke among them:

152 “Honored wife of Odysseus, son of Laertes, 153 he does not know clearly. But listen to my words. 154 I will prophesy to you with certain knowledge and hide nothing. 155 Let Zeus above all gods be my witness, and this table of hospitality 156 and the hearth of noble Odysseus to which I have come, 157 that Odysseus is already in his native land, 158 resting or moving, learning of these evil deeds, 159 and sowing the seeds of trouble for all the suitors. 160 I saw such a clear bird of omen on the ship with its good rowing benches, 161 as I sat there, and told Telemachus about it.”

162 Wise Penelope answered him: 163 “Stranger, I wish your words would come true. 164 Then you would quickly receive kindness and many gifts 165 from me, so that anyone who met you would call you fortunate.”

166 They spoke to one another like this. 167 Meanwhile the suitors, in front of Odysseus’ palace, 168 enjoyed throwing the discus and javelin 169 on leveled ground, as usual, with arrogant hearts. 170 When it was time for dinner and the flocks came in 171 from every side from the fields, led by the men who usually brought them, 172 Medon spoke to the suitors. They liked him best of all the heralds, 173 and he was always at their feasts.

174 “Young men, now that you have all gladdened your hearts with sport, 175 come to the house so we can prepare a feast. 176 It is no bad thing to eat dinner at the proper time.”

177 They listened to his words, got up, and went. 178 When they reached the stately house, 179 they laid their cloaks on the chairs and high seats, 180 and men began slaughtering large sheep and fat goats, 181 fattened pigs, and a heifer from the herd, 182 preparing the meal. Meanwhile, from the fields to the city, 183 Odysseus and the noble pig herder were hurrying to go. 184 The pig herder, a leader of men, spoke first:

Odysseus Sets Out for Town

185 “Stranger, since you are eager to go to the city 186 today, as my master ordered—though I would rather 187 leave you here to guard the farmstead, 188 I respect and fear him, in case 189 he scolds me later, and masters’ rebukes are harsh— 190 let us go now. The day is far advanced, 191 and soon it will be colder toward evening.”

192 Resourceful Odysseus answered him: 193 “I understand and am paying attention. You are telling someone with sense. 194 Come, let us go, and guide me all the way. 195 Give me a staff, if you have one cut somewhere, 196 to lean on, since you said the way was treacherous.”

197 With that he threw his shabby bag over his shoulders, 198 full of holes and hung by a twisted cord. 199 Eumaeus gave him a staff that suited him. 200 The two set out, and the dogs and herdsmen stayed behind 201 to guard the farmstead. The pig herder led his master to the city, 202 looking like a miserable old beggar 203 leaning on a staff, with wretched clothes around his body.

Melanthius Insults Odysseus

204 As they went along the rugged path, 205 they neared the city and came to a finely made, 206 fair-flowing fountain where the townspeople drew water. 207 Ithacus, Neritus, and Polyctor had made it. 208 A grove of water-fed poplars surrounded it, 209 circling on every side. The cold water flowed down 210 from the rock above, with an altar built on top 211 for the nymphs, where all passersby made offerings. 212 There Melanthius, son of Dolius, met them, 213 driving his female goats, the best in all the herds, 214 for the suitors’ feast. Two herdsmen followed him. 215 When he saw them, he addressed them with insults, 216 terrible and shameful words that stirred Odysseus’ heart:

217 “Look, one worthless man leads another. 218 As always, the god brings like and like together. 219 Where are you taking this filthy wretch, you miserable pig herder, 220 this tiresome beggar who spoils our feasts? 221 He will stand rubbing his shoulders on many doorposts, 222 begging for scraps, not swords or cauldrons. 223 If you gave me this fellow to guard my farmstead, 224 sweep the pens, and carry young shoots to the young goats, 225 he might build a sturdy thigh by drinking whey. 226 But he has learned only bad deeds and will not want 227 to work. He would rather skulk through the land, 228 begging to feed his insatiable belly. 229 I will tell you this, and it will come true. 230 If he comes to divine Odysseus’ palace, 231 many footstools hurled at his head from men’s hands 232 will break on his ribs as he is pelted through the house.”

233 With that he foolishly kicked Odysseus as he passed, 234 on the hip, but did not knock him off the path, 235 for he stood firm. Odysseus considered 236 whether to leap at him and kill him with his staff, 237 or seize him around the middle, lift him, and smash his head on the ground. 238 But he endured and held himself back. The pig herder 239 looked the man in the face and rebuked him, raising his hands and praying aloud:

240 “Nymphs of the fountain, daughters of Zeus, if Odysseus 241 ever burned pieces of thighs on your altars, wrapped in rich fat, 242 from lambs or young goats, fulfill this prayer for me. 243 Let my master return, guided by a god. 244 Then he would scatter all the proud airs 245 you now put on so insolently, always roaming around 246 the city while bad herdsmen destroy the flock.”

247 Melanthius the goat herder answered him: 248 “Look how this dog talks, his mind full of mischief. 249 One day I will put him on a black ship with good rowing benches and 250 take him far from Ithaca, so he can earn me much wealth. 251 I wish Apollo of the silver bow would strike Telemachus 252 today in the halls, or the suitors would kill him, 253 as surely as Odysseus’ day of return has been lost in a distant land.”

254 With that he left them there, walking slowly, 255 while he strode ahead and quickly reached the king’s palace. 256 He went in at once and sat among the suitors 257 opposite Eurymachus, whom he loved best of all. 258 The servants set a portion of meat beside him, 259 and the dignified housekeeper brought bread and set it before him, 260 for him to eat. Odysseus and the noble pig herder came near 261 and stopped. The sound of the hollow lyre rang around them, 262 its strings struck for song before the suitors 263 by Phemius. Odysseus took the pig herder’s hand and said:

Odysseus Reaches His Palace

264 “Eumaeus, this must be Odysseus’ beautiful house. 265 It is easy to recognize even among many others. 266 There is building after building, and the courtyard is built 267 with a wall and coping, and the 268 double gates are well protected. No man could scorn it. 269 I can tell that inside the house many 270 men are feasting. The smell of meat rises from it, and 271 the lyre’s voice rings out, which the gods have made the feast’s companion.”

272 Then you answered him, Eumaeus the pig herder: 273 “You noticed it easily, for you are quick-witted in everything. 274 Come, let us consider how to go about this. 275 Either go first into the stately palace 276 and join the suitors while I stay behind here, 277 or, if you want, stay here while I go ahead. 278 But do not linger long, or someone might see you outside 279 and throw things at you or hit you. I urge you to consider this.” 280 Then the much-enduring, noble Odysseus answered him:

281 “I understand and am paying attention. You are telling someone with sense. 282 Go ahead, and I will stay here. 283 I am used to blows and things thrown at me. 284 My heart is steadfast, for I have suffered many troubles 285 among the waves and in war. Let this be added to what came before. 286 But no one can hide a ravenous belly, 287 that cursed plague which brings so many troubles on people. 288 Because of it, ships with good rowing benches are prepared 289 to carry trouble to enemies over the restless sea.”

Argos Recognizes His Master

290 They spoke to one another like this. 291 A dog lying there raised his head and pricked up his ears: 292 Argos, the dog of Odysseus with his steadfast heart. Odysseus 293 had bred him himself but had no joy from him, for he left 294 for sacred Ilios before that. In earlier days young men used to take the dog to hunt 295 wild goats, deer, and hares. 296 Now he lay neglected, his master gone, 297 in deep dung piled before the doors, 298 from mules and cattle, which Odysseus’ slaves 299 were to take away to manure his broad lands. 300 There lay Argos the dog, covered in vermin. 301 When he noticed Odysseus standing near, 302 he wagged his tail and lowered both ears, 303 but no longer had the strength to come 304 closer to his master. Odysseus looked aside and wiped away a tear, 305 easily hiding it from Eumaeus. At once he asked him:

306 “Eumaeus, it is strange that this dog lies here in the dung. 307 He has a fine body, but I do not know clearly 308 whether his speed of foot matched this beauty 309 or he is only like dogs kept by the table 310 which their masters keep for show.”

311 Then you answered him, Eumaeus the pig herder: 312 “Yes, this is the dog of a man who died in a faraway land. 313 If his body and ability were as they were 314 when Odysseus left him to go to Troy, 315 you would soon be amazed to see his speed and strength. 316 Nothing could escape him in the depths of the thick woods, 317 no creature he chased. He had a keen nose for tracking too. 318 Now he is in a miserable state, and his master 319 has died far from his native land. The careless women do not look after him. 320 Slaves, when their masters lose their power, 321 no longer want to serve honestly. 322 Zeus, whose voice carries far, takes away half a man’s worth 323 when the day of slavery overtakes him.”

324 With that he entered the stately house 325 and went straight to the hall to join the noble suitors. 326 The fate of black death seized Argos 327 as soon as he had seen Odysseus in the twentieth year.

328 Godlike Telemachus was the first by far to see 329 the pig herder coming through the hall, and quickly 330 he nodded for him to come to his side. Eumaeus looked around and took a nearby stool 331 where the carver used to sit, 332 carving the many joints of meat for the suitors feasting in the hall. 333 He placed it at Telemachus’ table, 334 opposite him, and sat down himself. A herald 335 took a portion of meat and bread from the basket and set them before him.

Odysseus Begs Among the Suitors

336 Odysseus entered the palace close behind, 337 looking like a miserable old beggar, 338 leaning on a staff, with wretched clothes around his body. 339 He sat on the threshold of ashwood inside the doorway, 340 leaning against a cypress-wood post that a carpenter 341 had skillfully planed and straightened to the line. 342 Telemachus called the pig herder over and spoke to him, 343 taking a whole loaf from the beautiful basket 344 and as much meat as his hands could grasp: 345 “Take this food to that stranger, and tell him to go around 346 and beg from every one of the suitors himself. 347 Shame is no good companion for a man in need.”

348 The pig herder listened to his words and went, 349 and standing near Odysseus addressed him with winged words:

350 “Stranger, Telemachus gives you this and tells you to go around 351 begging from every one of the suitors. 352 Shame, he says, is no good for a beggar.”

353 Resourceful Odysseus answered him: 354 “King Zeus, I beg you, let Telemachus be fortunate among men 355 and have everything his heart desires.”

356 He took the food in both hands and set it down 357 there before his feet on his shabby bag. 358 He ate while the singer sang in the halls. 359 When he had eaten and the divine singer was finishing his song, 360 the suitors broke into an uproar through the halls. Athena 361 came close to Odysseus, son of Laertes, 362 and urged him to go among the suitors gathering bits of bread, 363 to learn which were righteous and which lawless. 364 Even so, she had no intention of saving a single one from ruin. 365 He began begging from every man, starting on the right, 366 stretching his hand out on every side as if he had long been a beggar. 367 They pitied him, gave him food, and marveled at him, 368 asking each other who he was and where he came from.

369 Melanthius the goat herder spoke among them: 370 “Listen, suitors of the glorious queen, 371 about this stranger, for I have seen him before. 372 The pig herder led him here, 373 but I do not know for certain where the man says he was born.”

Antinous Rebukes Eumaeus

374 At this Antinous rebuked the pig herder: 375 “Notorious pig herder, why did you bring this man to the city? 376 Don’t we have enough other drifters, 377 tiresome beggars who spoil our feast? 378 Is it not enough that they devour your master’s possessions, 379 gathering here, that you invited this fellow too?”

380 Then you answered him, Eumaeus the pig herder: 381 “Antinous, your words are not good, though you are noble. 382 Who goes out on his own to find and invite a foreign stranger 383 unless he is a master of a craft that serves the public, 384 a prophet, a healer of sickness, or a builder, 385 or a divine singer whose song gives delight? 386 These men are invited throughout the boundless earth. 387 No one would invite a beggar to burden himself. 388 But you are always the harshest of all the suitors 389 toward Odysseus’ slaves, and most of all toward me. Yet I 390 do not care, as long as my lady, steadfast Penelope, 391 lives in the hall, and godlike Telemachus.”

392 Wise Telemachus answered him: 393 “Be quiet. Do not answer that man at length, I ask you. 394 Antinous always maliciously provokes anger 395 with harsh words, and he urges the others on too.”

396 Then he addressed Antinous with winged words: 397 “Antinous, you care well for me indeed, like a father for his son, 398 telling me to drive that stranger from the hall 399 with a forceful command. May the god never bring that about. 400 Take something and give it to him. I do not begrudge it. I myself tell you to give. 401 Do not worry about my mother in this matter, 402 or any of the slaves in divine Odysseus’ house. 403 But the thought in your chest is quite different: 404 you are much more eager to eat yourself than to give to someone else.” 405 Antinous answered him: 406 “Telemachus, you bragger, reckless in your daring, what a thing to say! 407 If all the suitors gave him as much as I would, 408 this house would keep him away for three full months.”

409 He seized the footstool and showed it from its place beneath the table, 410 on which he used to rest his shining feet while feasting. 411 All the others gave gifts and filled the bag 412 with bread and bits of meat. Odysseus was about to go back to the threshold again 413 and test the Achaeans without paying for it, 414 but he stopped beside Antinous and said to him:

Odysseus Appeals to Antinous

415 “Friend, give me a gift. To my eyes you do not seem the worst of the Achaeans, 416 but the best, for you look like a king. 417 So you should give an even better portion of bread than the others. 418 I would make your fame known throughout the boundless earth. 419 I too once lived among men in my own house, 420 a rich man in a wealthy house. I often gave gifts to wanderers, 421 whoever they were and whatever they needed. 422 I had countless slaves and plenty of all the other things 423 by which people live well and are considered wealthy. 424 But Zeus, son of Cronus, ruined everything—it pleased him, I suppose— 425 and sent me out with roaming pirates 426 to Egypt, a long voyage, so that I would meet my ruin. 427 In the river Aegyptus I moored my curved ships. 428 I ordered my faithful companions 429 to stay there by the ships and guard them, 430 and sent scouts to the lookout points. 431 My companions gave in to reckless violence, trusting in their strength. 432 They immediately began laying waste the Egyptians’ beautiful fields, 433 carrying off the women and little children 434 and killing the men. The alarm quickly reached the city. 435 Hearing the shouting, the people came out at daybreak. 436 The whole plain filled with infantry and chariots 437 and the flash of bronze. Zeus, who hurls the thunderbolt, 438 threw a terrible panic among my companions. No one had the courage 439 to stand and face the enemy, for trouble surrounded us on every side. 440 They killed many of us with sharp bronze weapons 441 and took others alive to their city, to work for them by force. 442 They gave me to a friend who met them to take to Cyprus, 443 Dmetor, son of Iasus, who ruled Cyprus powerfully. 444 From there I have come here, deeply distressed.” 445 Antinous answered him: 446 “What god brought this curse here to trouble our feast? 447 Stand over there in the middle, away from my table, 448 or you will soon find a bitter Egypt and a bitter Cyprus, 449 you bold and shameless beggar. 450 You go up to every man in turn, and they give recklessly. 451 No one hesitates or worries about giving away 452 someone else’s goods, when each has plenty beside him.”

453 Resourceful Odysseus stepped back and said to him: 454 “It seems you do not have the sense to match your beauty. 455 You would not give even a grain of salt from your own stores to someone asking your help. 456 Now, sitting at someone else’s table, 457 you did not have the heart to take any bread and give it to me, though plenty lies at your hand.”

458 At this Antinous grew still angrier in his heart 459 and glared from beneath his brows, addressing him with winged words: 460 “I think you will not leave this hall in good shape now, 461 since you even speak insults.”

Antinous Strikes Odysseus

462 He seized the footstool, hurled it, and struck Odysseus on the right shoulder, 463 at its base where it joins the back. He stood like a rock, 464 firmly, and Antinous’ missile did not make him stagger. 465 He shook his head silently, plotting harm deep in his heart. 466 He went back to the threshold and sat down, 467 setting down his full bag, and spoke among the suitors:

468 “Listen, suitors of the glorious queen, 469 so I can say what the heart in my chest tells me. 470 There is no pain in the heart or grief 471 when a man is struck fighting for his own possessions, 472 his cattle or white sheep. 473 But Antinous struck me for the sake of my wretched belly, 474 that cursed plague which brings so many troubles on people. 475 If there are gods and avengers for beggars, 476 may the doom of death overtake Antinous before his marriage.”

477 Antinous, son of Eupeithes, answered him: 478 “Sit still and eat, stranger, or go elsewhere, 479 or the young men may drag you 480 by hand or foot through the house for words like these and strip off all your skin.”

481 They were all filled with great indignation, 482 and one of the proud young men would say:

483 “Antinous, it was wrong to strike the wretched wanderer. 484 Doomed man, what if he is a god come down from heaven! 485 The gods take the appearance of strangers from distant lands, 486 in all kinds of shapes, and visit cities, 487 watching people’s violence and righteousness.”

488 The suitors said this, but Antinous paid no attention to their words. 489 Telemachus nursed great grief in his heart 490 at the blow, but let no tear fall from his eyelids to the ground. 491 He shook his head silently, plotting harm deep in his heart.

492 When wise Penelope heard that the man had been struck 493 in the hall, she said among her female servants: 494 “May the famous archer Apollo strike you in just the same way.” 495 Eurynome the housekeeper said to her: 496 “I wish our prayers would be fulfilled. 497 Then not one of these men would reach beautiful-throned Dawn.”

498 Wise Penelope answered her: 499 “Nurse, they are all enemies, for they plot harm. 500 But Antinous is most like black fate. 501 Some wretched stranger wanders through the house, 502 begging gifts from the men because need drives him. 503 All the others filled his bag and gave him gifts, 504 but Antinous hurled a footstool and struck him at the base of his right shoulder.”

Penelope Sends for the Stranger

505 She spoke among her female servants like this, 506 sitting in her room while noble Odysseus ate his meal. 507 She called the noble pig herder over and said:

508 “Go, noble Eumaeus, and tell the stranger 509 to come here so I can greet him and ask him 510 whether he has heard of steadfast-hearted Odysseus 511 or seen him with his own eyes. He seems to have wandered far.”

512 Then you answered her, Eumaeus the pig herder: 513 “Queen, I wish the Achaeans would keep quiet. 514 He speaks words that would charm your very soul. 515 I had him with me for three nights and kept him for three days 516 in my hut, for he came to me first after secretly fleeing a ship. 517 He had still not finished telling his sufferings. 518 Just as a man gazes at a singer who, taught by the gods, 519 sings songs of longing to mortals, 520 and they never tire of wanting to hear him whenever he sings, 521 so he charmed me as he sat in my hall. 522 He says he is a friend of Odysseus through ancestral ties, 523 living in Crete, where Minos’ descendants live. 524 From there he has come here, always suffering troubles 525 as he wanders on and on. He insists he has heard news of Odysseus 526 nearby, in the Thesprotians’ rich land, 527 still alive and bringing many treasures home.”

528 Wise Penelope answered him: 529 “Go, call him here, so he can tell me himself to my face. 530 As for these men, let them enjoy their games sitting in the doorway 531 or here in the house, since their hearts are merry. 532 Their own possessions lie untouched at home, 533 bread and sweet wine, which feed their servants. 534 But they themselves crowd our house day after day, 535 slaughtering our oxen, sheep, and fat goats, 536 feasting and drinking the gleaming wine 537 recklessly, and all this wealth is wasted. There is no man here 538 like Odysseus to keep ruin from the house. 539 But if Odysseus came back to his native land, 540 he and his son would immediately take revenge on these men for their violent deeds.” 541 At this Telemachus sneezed loudly, and the whole room gave 542 a tremendous echo. Penelope laughed 543 and at once addressed Eumaeus with winged words:

544 “Please go and call the stranger here before me. 545 Do you not notice that my son sneezed at all my words? 546 So certain death will fall on every one of the suitors, 547 and not one will escape death and the fates. 548 I will tell you something else. Take it to heart. 549 If I find he tells the whole truth, 550 I will dress him in a cloak and tunic, fine clothing.”

551 So she spoke, and the pig herder went when he heard her words. 552 Standing close to Odysseus, he spoke winged words:

553 “Good stranger, wise Penelope calls for you, 554 the mother of Telemachus. Her heart 555 urges her to ask about her husband, though she has suffered many troubles. 556 If she finds that you tell the whole truth, 557 she will dress you in a cloak and tunic, the things you need 558 most of all. As for food, you can beg through the land 559 and feed your belly. Whoever wishes will give it to you.”

Odysseus Asks to Wait Until Sunset

560 Then the much-enduring noble Odysseus answered him: 561 “Eumaeus, I will soon tell the whole truth 562 to the daughter of Icarius, wise Penelope. 563 I know Odysseus well, and we have suffered together. 564 But I am afraid of this crowd of harsh suitors, 565 whose arrogance and violence reach the iron heaven. 566 Even just now, as I walked through the hall, this man 567 struck me and hurt me, though I had done nothing wrong. 568 Neither Telemachus nor anyone else did anything to stop the blow. 569 So now tell Penelope to wait in the halls, 570 eager though she is, until sunset. 571 Then let her ask me about her husband and the day of his return, 572 seating me nearer the fire. For the clothes I wear 573 are poor. You know that yourself, since you were the first I begged for help.”

574 So he spoke, and the pig herder went when he heard these words. 575 As he crossed the threshold, Penelope said to him:

576 “You have not brought him, Eumaeus. What does the wanderer mean by this? 577 Does he fear someone terribly, or does he feel ashamed 578 for no reason in the house? Shame is bad for a beggar.”

579 Then you answered her, Eumaeus the pig herder: 580 “He speaks rightly, as anyone else would judge, 581 seeking to avoid the arrogance of overbearing men. 582 He asks you to wait until sunset. 583 And for you yourself, my queen, it is far more fitting 584 to speak to the stranger alone and hear his words.” 585 Then wise Penelope answered him: 586 “The stranger has sense. He sees how things may turn out. 587 I do not think any other mortal men 588 arrogantly plot such wicked folly as these.”

Eumaeus Returns to the Pigs

589 So she spoke, and the noble pig herder went away 590 into the crowd of suitors, after telling her everything. 591 At once he spoke winged words to Telemachus, 592 holding his head close so the others would not hear:

593 “My friend, I am going out to guard the pigs and everything there, 594 your livelihood and mine. Take charge of everything here. 595 Keep yourself safe above all, and be careful 596 that no harm comes to you. Many Achaeans are plotting evil. 597 May Zeus utterly destroy them before harm comes to us.”

598 Then wise Telemachus answered him: 599 “So it will be, father. Go when you have had supper. 600 Come in the morning and bring fine animals for sacrifice. 601 Everything here will be a concern for me and the immortals.”

602 So he spoke, and the pig herder sat down again on the polished chair. 603 When he had satisfied his heart with food and drink, 604 he went off to the pigs, leaving the courts and the hall 605 full of people feasting. They were enjoying 606 dancing and song, for evening had come.

Book 18

About this book

Odyssey, Book 17

Tradition
Classical
Author
Homer
Written
750–700 BCE
Text
Based on the translation by A. T. Murray (1919) · Public domain

0 connections

No connections in this book yet.

Glossary

Search the Library