Texts in Conversation

In Jonah, a great fish swallows Jonah whole and carries him three days and nights in its belly. In Tobit, this is reversed as a fish leaps up and tries to swallow Tobias instead, but the angel tells him to grab and overpower it.
Share:
2500 BCE
1000+ CE

Jonah 1:17

Hebrew Bible
15 So they picked Jonah up and threw him into the sea, and the sea stopped raging. 16 The men feared the Lord greatly and earnestly vowed to offer lavish sacrifices to the Lord. 17 (2:1) The Lord sent a huge fish to swallow Jonah, and Jonah was in the stomach of the fish three days and three nights.
Date: 3rd Century B.C.E. (based on scholarly estimates)

Tobit 6:3

Deuterocanon
2 and the dog came out with him and went along with them. So they both journeyed along, and when the first night overtook them they camped by the Tigris river. 3 Then the young man went down to wash his feet in the Tigris river. Suddenly a large fish leaped up from the water and tried to swallow the young man's foot, and he cried out. 4 But the angel said to the young man, "Catch hold of the fish and hang on to it!" So the young man grasped the fish and drew it up on the land. 5 Then the angel said to him, "Cut open the fish and take out its gall, heart, and liver. Keep them with you, but throw away the intestines. For its gall, heart, and liver are useful as medicine." 6 So after cutting open the fish the young man gathered together the gall, heart, and liver; then he roasted and ate some of the fish, and kept some to be salted. The two continued on their way together until they were near Media.
Date: 225-175 B.C.E. (based on scholarly estimates)
Search:

Notes and References

#5592
... In the story of the fleeing prophet, his being swallowed by the fish, becomes the occasion for a special return to God. In fact, once in the fish’s belly (see Jonah 2:1), the “first thing” Jonah does, is pray (see Jonah 2:2–11). That prayer, put by the narrator in Jonah’s mouth, begins with a recognition for God’s salvific action (see Jonah 2:3). In Tobit story, at least at first sight, we do not find a parallel effect, at least not regarding Tobiah. In effect, in Tobit 6, the narrator refrains from characterizing Tobiah from a religious point of view (leaving it to chapter eight). Furthermore, Jonah, spewed out of the fish belly, finally accepts God’s call, and goes to Nineveh to deliver the divine message. After complete victory over the fish, symbolized in Tobiah’s keeping of it as food and medicine, Tobiah accepts freely the divine ordinance of marrying Sarah, fully aware of the deadly threat that expects him in the killer demon Asmodeus. God in both stories is presented as “LORD/God of heaven.” In light of all the evidence just presented, Levine seems correct in seeing Tobiah’s interaction with the big fish an intentional parody of the book of Jonah. In that regard one could say that Tobit’s author depicts Tobiah as an anti-Jonah character ...
Macatangay, Francis M. When I Was a Father to the Poor: The Poetics and Narrative Function of Tobit 6 (pp. 118-119) De Gruyter, 2019

* The use of references are not endorsements of their contents. Please read the entirety of the provided reference(s) to understand the author's full intentions regarding the use of these texts.

Your Feedback:

Leave a Comment

Do you have questions or comments about these texts? Please submit them here.

Anonymous comments are welcome. All comments are subject to moderation.

Find Similar Texts

Search by the same Books

Search by the same Reference

Compare the same Books

Compare the same Text Groups

Glossary

Go to Intertext