How (not) to murder a king: Variations on a theme in 1 Sam 2...

This study examines the narratives in 1 Samuel 24 and 26, which depict David sparing King Saul's life on two separate occasions. Traditionally viewed as duplicate accounts or editorial reworkings, this analysis challenges that assumption by exploring the literary relationship between the two chapters. The author establishes methodological criteria to distinguish between literary dependency and other forms of textual interrelation, such as shared motifs or genre conventions. Applying these criteria, the study investigates the similarities and differences in narrative structure, character development, and thematic elements within the texts. The findings suggest that 1 Samuel 24 and 26 are not mere duplicates but serve distinct functions within the larger narrative, each contributing uniquely to the portrayal of David's character and his relationship with Saul. The analysis underscores the complexity of biblical storytelling and the importance of nuanced literary examination in understanding scriptural texts.