Go to Related Reading
About this book

On Prayer

About this book
Chapter 16

Again, I see no reason for the custom some people have of sitting after prayer, except the kind of reason children give. Suppose Hermas, whose writing is generally titled The Shepherd, had done something else after finishing his prayer, instead of sitting on his bed: would we insist that everyone must follow that practice too? Of course not. As it stands, the sentence When I had prayed, and had sat down on my bed, simply describes the sequence of events in the story; it does not establish a rule of conduct.⁠ Otherwise, we would have to pray only where there is a bed! In fact, anyone who sits in a chair or on a bench would be going against that writing. Furthermore, pagans do the same thing: they sit down after worshiping their little images. That alone makes the practice objectionable among us, since it is part of idol worship. It is also disrespectful — as even pagans would understand if they had any sense. If it is disrespectful to sit down in full view of the person you honor and respect most, how much more irreverent is it to do so in the presence of the living God, while the angel of prayer is still standing nearby, unless we mean to complain to God that praying has tired us out!

Texts in conversation

Compare Shepherd of Hermas 25:1 and Tertullian, On Prayer 16

Early Christian

Share:

Summary

The Christian theologian Tertullian’s instructions on prayer use language from the Shepherd of Hermas, where the narrator prays and then sits before receiving a vision. This posture became an example that influenced early Christian tradition.

Passages

Shepherd of Hermas 25:1

Early Christian
1 As I was praying in the house, and sitting on the couch, a man glorious in appearance came in, dressed as a shepherd, with a white skin wrapped around him, and with a bag on his shoulders and a staff in his hand. And he greeted me, and I greeted him in return. 2 He immediately sat down beside me and said to me, “I was sent by the most holy angel, so that I might stay with you for the rest of your days.” 3 I thought he had come to test me, and I said to him, “Who are you? For I know,” I said, “the one I was entrusted to.” He said to me, “Do you not recognize me?” “No,” I said. “I,” he said, “am the shepherd to whom you were entrusted.”
90–140 CE (scholarly estimate) Read in the Shepherd of Hermas

Tertullian, On Prayer 16

Early Christian
Again, I see no reason for the custom some people have of sitting after prayer, except the kind of reason children give. Suppose Hermas, whose writing is generally titled The Shepherd, had done something else after finishing his prayer, instead of sitting on his bed: would we insist that everyone must follow that practice too? Of course not. As it stands, the sentence When I had prayed, and had sat down on my bed, simply describes the sequence of events in the story; it does not establish a rule of conduct. Otherwise, we would have to pray only where there is a bed! In fact, anyone who sits in a chair or on a bench would be going against that writing. Furthermore, pagans do the same thing: they sit down after worshiping their little images. That alone makes the practice objectionable among us, since it is part of idol worship. It is also disrespectful — as even pagans would understand if they had any sense.
200–230 CE (scholarly estimate) Read in Tertullian, On Prayer

References

"... In his 'Treatise on Prayer' Tertullian described the attitude required and correct posture for different occasions of Christian prayer ... Hermas stated in his 'Vision Fifth' that he sat after praying, 'After I had been praying at home, and had sat down on my couch.' It appears that some Christians had taken the example of Hermas, from his popular writings called the Shepherd of Hermas c. 160CE, as a guide to Christian practice ..."
Leon Francis Milroy, Prayer in Earliest Christianity in the Context of the Graeco-Roman World (University of New England, 2001), 56–57.

References are not endorsements of their contents. Read each reference in full to understand its author's intentions in using these texts.

Your feedback

Shepherd of Hermas 25:1 and Tertullian, On Prayer 16

Leave a comment

Your questions and comments are welcome!

Comments

Glossary

Search the Library