Go to Related Reading
About this book

The Special Laws, Book 4

De specialibus legibus 4

Theft and Restitution

1 I have in my previous treatises spoken of the laws relating to adultery and murder, and to all the subordinate offenses which come under those heads, with, as I believe, all the accuracy the subject allows, and now, continuing in order, I must consider the third commandment in the second table, but the eighth in all, if the two tables are taken together, namely, the commandment, “You shall not steal.” 2 Whoever carries off or leads away another’s property without the right to do so, if he does it openly and by sheer force, shall be set down as a common enemy, and shall be prosecuted as one who has with lawless wickedness contrived a shameless act of audacity. But if he has done it secretly, trying to escape notice like a thief, exhibiting some modesty, and making the darkness the veil of his iniquity, he should then be punished privately, as answerable only to the one individual he tried to injure; and he should restore double the value of the thing stolen, making amends by his own most righteous suffering for the unrighteous advantage he has tried to gain.

3 But if he is a poor man, and consequently unable to pay the penalty, let him be sold, for it is fitting that a man who, for the sake of most iniquitous gain, has been willing to become a slave to guilt should be deprived of his freedom, so that the one who has been wronged is not sent away without consolation, his claims seemingly disregarded because of the poverty of the man who robbed him. 4 And let no one accuse this ordinance of inhumanity; for the man who is sold is not left as a slave forever and ever, but within seven years he is released by a common proclamation as I have shown in my treatise on the number seven.

5 And let him be content to pay the double penalty, or even to be sold, since he has committed no slight offense; sinning first because, not content with what he had, he has desired more, encouraging a feeling of covetousness, a treacherous and incurable wickedness. Secondly, because he has cast his eyes on the property of others and longed for it, and has laid plots to deprive his neighbor of his own, depriving the owner of what belongs to him. Thirdly, because through his desire to escape detection, he very often keeps to himself all the advantage that can be derived from the thing he appropriates, and diverts the accusation so as to cause it to fall upon the innocent, thus making the investigation of the truth blind. 6 Such a man seems in some degree to be his own accuser, being convicted by his own conscience of the theft of the things he has secretly stolen, since he is filled with either shame or fear: the one is proof that he considers his action disgraceful, for it is only disgraceful actions which cause shame, and the other is a sign that he thinks it deserves punishment, for punishment causes fear.

Housebreaking

7 If anyone, madly carried away by desire for the property of others, tries to steal it and, unable to carry it off easily, breaks into a house at night, using the darkness as a veil to conceal his wicked action, if he is caught in the act before the sun has risen, he may be killed by the master of the house where he broke in, having accomplished the lesser aim he had set himself, namely, theft, but having been hindered by someone from accomplishing the greater crime which might have followed it, namely, murder; since he came equipped with iron house-breaking tools and other weapons to defend himself from any attack. But if the sun has risen, the master of the house is no longer to kill him with his own hand; he is to be led away and brought before the magistrates and judges, to suffer whatever punishment they condemn him to. 8 For at night, while men stay in their houses and have gone to rest, whether they are rulers or private individuals, in either case there is no refuge or assistance for the person being attacked; so the occupant of the house holds the power of punishment in his own hands, appointed magistrate and judge by the hour itself.

9 But in the daytime the courts of justice and the council chambers are open, and the city is full of persons who will help to arrest the criminal; some of whom have been formally appointed guardians of the laws; and others, without any such appointment, by their natural disposition which hates iniquity, take up the cause of those who are injured; and the thief must be brought before these men; for thus the man who seeks revenge will escape the charge of arrogance or rashness, and appear to be acting in the spirit of democracy. 10 But if, when the sun has risen and is shining upon the earth, anyone kills a robber with his own hand before bringing him to trial, he shall be held guilty, as having been guided by passion rather than by reason, and as having made the laws second to his own impulses. I would say to such a man, “My friend, do not, because a thief has injured you by night, commit a worse theft yourself in daylight, one that affects not money but the principles of justice on which the constitution of the state is founded.”

The Theft of Sheep and Oxen

11 Other thefts are to be atoned for by paying double the value of the thing stolen; but if anyone steals an ox or a sheep, the law thinks such a man worthy of a greater punishment, giving a particular honor and precedence to those animals which are the most excellent among all tame flocks and herds, not only because of the beauty of their bodies but also because of the service they render to human life. For this reason the lawgiver has not set an equal fine for the theft of each animal, but having calculated the use of both and the purposes each serves, he has appraised their value in this way. 12 For he commands that the thief restore four sheep and five oxen in place of the one he has stolen; since a sheep gives four kinds of tribute, milk, and cheese, and its fleece, and a lamb, every year: but an ox furnishes five; three of which are the same as those of the sheep, the milk, the cheese, and the offspring; but two are its own, the plowing of the earth, and the threshing of the grain; the first of which actions is the first step toward the sowing of the crops, and the other is the end, being for the purification of the crop after it is gathered in, so that it can more easily be used for food.

Kidnapping

13 A kidnapper also is a thief; but he is, moreover, a thief who steals the most excellent thing on earth. Now, in the case of inanimate things, and of animals of no very great use in life, he has commanded those who steal them to pay their owners twice their value, as has been said before. And again, in the case of those tame and very useful flocks and herds of sheep and oxen, he has ordered the payment to be fourfold or fivefold. 14 But man, it seems, has been assigned the most preeminent position among the animals, being, as it were, a near relation of God himself, and akin to him in respect of his participation in reason; which makes him immortal, although he is liable to death. For this reason everyone who has any admiration for virtue is full of extreme anger, and is utterly implacable toward kidnappers, who for the sake of most iniquitous gain dare to inflict slavery on those who are free by birth, and who share the same nature as themselves.

15 For if masters act praiseworthily when, moved by their own humanity, they free servants born in their house or bought with money from the slavery in which they are held, even though these have often done them no great service, how heavy should the charge be against those who deprive people who now possess it of that most excellent of all possessions, freedom, when it is something for which a well-born and properly raised man would think it glorious to die? 16 And before now, some men, increasing their own innate wickedness, and directing the natural treachery of their characters to a violation of all rights, have set out to bring slavery not only upon strangers and foreigners, but even upon those of the same nation as themselves; and sometimes, even upon men of the same borough and of the same tribe, disregarding the shared laws and customs in which they were brought up alongside them from earliest infancy, which nature stamps upon their souls as the firmest bond of good will for all who are not very intractable and given to cruelty.

17 Who, for the sake of lawless gain, sell slaves to slave-dealers, and enslave them to anyone who comes along, transporting them to a foreign land, so that they will never again greet their native land, not even in a dream, nor taste any hope of happiness. For these kidnappers would be committing a lighter iniquity if they themselves retained the services of those whom they have enslaved, but as things stand they commit a double wrong, in selling them again, and thus making them two masters instead of one, and raising up two slaveries as enemies to their condition.

18 For they, knowing the former prosperity of those they have carried off, might perhaps repent, feeling a tardy and late compassion for those who have fallen so low, and holding a proper awe of the uncertainty of fortune, which eludes all conjecture. But those who buy people in this condition, not knowing their families, will neglect them as if they came from generations of slaves, with nothing in their souls to move them to show them the gentleness and humanity that it would be natural to keep toward slaves who were born free by nature and only later enslaved. 19 Let those who kidnap and enslave people of another nation suffer whatever punishment the court of justice sentences them to; but on those who kidnap people of their own country and their own blood and sell them as slaves, the unalterable sentence of death shall be passed. For one’s own countrymen are in fact not far from blood relations, and they must come very nearly under the same definition.

Damage to Property

20 “In the field also,” as someone of the old writers has said, “lawsuits arise;” since covetousness and a desire for the possessions of others is found not only in the city but also outside the walls, since it makes its home not only in various places but also in the minds of insatiable and contentious men. 21 For this reason the cities with the best codes of laws elect two sets of superintendents, rulers and providers of public order and safety: one class to manage affairs within the walls, whom they call curators of the city, and the other outside the walls, to whom they also give a fitting name, calling them agrarian magistrates. But what need would there be of agrarian magistrates if there were not some people in the fields who live only to injure their neighbors?

22 If, therefore, any shepherd or goatherd, or oxherd, or in short anyone who keeps any kind of cattle, drives his herds to feed and graze on another man’s land, sparing neither crops nor trees, he shall pay a fine equal to the value of those crops and trees. 23 And he may be well content to escape with this punishment, having met with a very merciful and extremely indulgent law: though he has behaved like implacable foreign enemies, who usually lay waste the land and destroy the cultivated trees of the inhabitants, it has not punished him as a common enemy with death, or exile, or, finally, the confiscation of all his property, but has only sentenced him to make good the damage done to the owner.

24 For since the lawgiver, out of the excessive gentleness and humanity he had by nature and by habit, was always looking for reasons to lighten whatever misfortunes had been suffered, he found an excuse for the shepherd in the fact that cattle are by nature thoughtless and disobedient, especially when they are after food. 25 So let the shepherd be held guilty for having driven his herd into an unsuitable place in the first place, but do not let him bear the blame for everything that followed from it. For it is natural to suppose that as soon as he saw the damage being done he tried to drive them out again, but that his beasts resisted him, reveling in the green pasture, the tender crops and the shoots they were devouring.

Fire and Responsibility

26 Those who devour the property of others with their flocks and herds are not the only ones who do damage; so do those who thoughtlessly and carelessly kindle a fire; for if the power of fire catches hold of any appropriate fuel, it spreads in every direction, and extends and devours all around. And once it has taken hold, it defies every means anyone tries to put it out with, feeding and growing on the very things used for that purpose, until, having consumed everything, it finally burns itself out. 27 It is right, therefore, never to leave any fire either in a house or in any stables in the fields unguarded, since we know well that a single spark has often smoldered for a long time, and at last has been fanned into a flame, and so has consumed great cities, especially when the flame has been carried onward by a favorable wind.

28 So in savage wars the first, the middle and the last force brought into play is fire, which enemies trust more than their squadrons of infantry or cavalry, their fleets, or their unlimited supplies of arms and naval stores. For anyone who shoots a fire arrow with good aim into a large squadron of ships may burn it with all its crews, or may destroy in this way vast camps with all the baggage, furniture and equipment on which the army rested its hopes of victory. 29 If, then, anyone scatters fire among a heap of brambles or thorns, and the fire kindles and burns a threshing floor full of wheat, or barley, or vetches, or sheaves of grain which have been gathered together, or any fertile plain full of pasture, then the man who scattered the fire shall pay the amount of the damage done, so that by suffering he may learn to take good care and guard against the beginnings of things, and not awaken and stir up an invincible power that might otherwise have stayed quiet.

Deposits and Loans

30 A deposit is the most sacred of all the dealings men have with one another over property, since it depends solely on the good faith of the man who has received it. For loans are proved by contracts and written records, and things used openly, apart from loans, have everyone who sees them as witnesses. 31 Deposits are different: the owner, alone, gives them secretly to the receiver, also alone, looking carefully around the place, and not even taking a slave with him to carry the thing to be deposited, however devoted the slave is to his master; for each of the two parties seems anxious to avoid discovery, the one depositing the thing so as to receive it back, and the other wishing no one to know that he has received it. But we ought by all means to regard the invisible God as an unseen third party to every hidden action, whom both parties naturally take as their witness: the receiver calls him to witness that he will return the deposit when it is asked back, and the other calls him to witness that he receives it back at the proper time.

32 So let the man who commits this great wickedness and denies his deposit know well that he has cheated the one who entrusted it to him of his hope, and that he is concealing a wicked disposition under misleading language, and that he is hypocritically pretending to a bastard sort of faith while in reality faithless, showing that all his pledges are worthless and all his oaths disregarded, so that he neglects all human and all divine obligations; and that he is denying two deposits at once; firstly, the deposit of him who entrusted his property to his care; and secondly, the deposit of that most unerring and infallible witness who sees all the actions of all men, and hears all the words of all men, whether they want him to or not. 33 But if the man who has received a deposit as a sacred thing thinks he ought to keep it honestly, duly honoring truth and good faith, and yet others who are always plotting against their neighbors’ property, such as pickpockets or housebreakers, break in treacherously and steal the entrusted deposit, then he shall pay as a penalty double the value of what the thieves have stolen.

34 And if they are not caught, then the man who received the deposit shall go of his own accord before the divine tribunal, and stretching out his hands to heaven shall swear by his own life that he had no hand in the theft out of any desire to take for himself what had been deposited with him, and that he did not voluntarily give it up to anyone else; and, moreover, that he is not falsely reporting a robbery that never took place. For it would be absurd to punish a man who has done no wrong, or for a man who sought refuge in the help of a friend when others were injuring him to become in turn the cause of injury to that friend. 35 And deposits consist not only of inanimate things but also of animals: and with animals the danger is twofold: first, one they share with inanimate things, that they may be stolen, and also one distinct and peculiar to themselves, that they may die. We have until now been speaking only of the first kind of deposit, but we must now also explain the law about the second.

36 If any cattle entrusted as a deposit die, the one who received the deposit shall send for the one who entrusted it to him and show him what has happened, protecting himself from any evil suspicion; but if the depositor is absent, then it is not proper to send for anyone else, whose notice the depositor may perhaps have wanted to avoid; but when the depositor returns home, his friend shall swear to him that he has not been concealing any unjust appropriation of the animals by a false statement of their death. 37 And if anyone receives something not as a deposit but as a loan for his own use, whether a vessel or an animal, then if he is robbed of it, whichever it is, or if the animal dies, while the man who lent it is living with the borrower, the borrower shall not be liable, since the owner himself can be called as a witness that there is no false pretense in the matter; but if the lender is not with him at the time, he shall pay the value.

38 Why? Because it is possible that the man who used the animal when the owner was not present may have either worn the animal out with continual labor until it died, or may have worn out the vessel, by taking no care of property belonging to another, which he ought to have looked after and put away instead of giving thieves an easy chance to steal it.

The Connected Commandments

39 But since our lawgiver was sharper than all other men at seeing the consequences of actions, he goes on to enact a series of prohibitions one after another, keeping them properly connected and taking care that his later commandments are consistent with his earlier ones. In keeping with this harmonious connection in what he was to say, he tells us that he was divinely inspired by God in person, who spoke to him in this way: “You shall not steal. You shall not speak falsely, and bring false accusations against your neighbor. And you shall not swear by my name to achieve an unjust end, and you shall not profane my name.” 40 These commands are given beautifully and very instructively; for the thief, convicted by his own conscience, denies it and speaks falsely, fearing the punishment that would follow his confession. And he who denies an action seeks to attach the imputation to someone else, making a false accusation appear probable; and every false accuser is at once a perjured man, caring little for piety, since he has no just proofs; so he resorts to what is called the inartificial mode of proof, proof by oaths, thinking that by calling on God he will make those who hear him believe him. But let such a person know that he is ungodly and impious, since he is defiling what is by nature undefiled, the good and holy name of God.

False Witness

41 This is the ninth of the ten commandments, the fourth of those on the second table, and one that can bestow ten thousand benefits on human life if it is kept, just as it may injure men in innumerable ways if it is neglected. 42 For the false accuser is to be blamed, but he who bears witness to what is false is more guilty still; for the one acts only from a desire to protect himself, but the other is wicked out of a wish to join another in iniquity. And when wicked men are compared, the one who does wrong for his own sake is less unrighteous than the one who does it for another.

43 And every judge looks with suspicion on an accuser, as likely to pay little attention to truth in order to come off safely himself, which is why the accuser needs a preface to beg the attention of the hearer while he speaks; but if the judge has no personal prejudice against a witness, he receives his evidence with a willing mind and open ears, while the witness is covering over those most excellent things, truth and good faith, with misleading language. And false witnesses use seductive words as a hunter uses bait, to get what he desires and aims at. 44 For these reasons, in many places in his laws, he commands us not to approve of any wicked man or action. For approving what is not virtuous is likely to lead to giving false evidence; since everyone to whom iniquity is a disagreeable and hateful thing is a friend of truth.

45 It is no great wonder that a man has attached himself to one wicked person, who has incited him to an action resembling his own character; but not to follow a multitude to do evil, like a man swept over a precipice by the combined force of a torrent, is the sign of a noble soul and of a disposition practiced in manly resolve. 46 For some among the multitude, judging wrongly, think certain things lawful and just even though they are utterly shameful; for it is good to follow nature, but this impulse of the multitude is wholly at odds with following nature.

47 So if some people, gathered in companies and large crowds, attempt to make innovations, one must not consent to them, since they are adulterating the ancient and approved coinage of the state; for one wise counsel is superior to many attempts, but ignorance combined with numbers is a great evil. 48 But some people carry wickedness to such excess that they not only accuse mortal men, but adhere and cling to their unrighteousness, so as even to raise their lies as high as heaven, and to bear their testimony against the blessed and happy nature of God. And by these men I mean soothsayers, and diviners, and augurs, and everyone else who practices what they call the study of divination, an art without any art, to tell the plain truth, a mere bare imitation of the real inspiration and prophetic gift.

49 For a prophet utters nothing at all of his own, but is only an interpreter, another Being suggesting to him all that he utters, while he is speaking under inspiration, unaware that his own reasoning powers have departed and left the citadel of his soul, while the divine spirit has entered and made its home there, and is working on the whole mechanism of his voice, making it sound out clearly all the prophecies he is delivering. 50 But all who pursue the spurious, pretended kind of prophecy are inverting the order of truth by conjectures and guesses, perverting sincerity, and easily influencing those who are of unstable dispositions, as a violent wind, when blowing in a contrary direction, tosses about and overturns vessels without ballast, preventing them from anchoring in the safe havens of truth. For such people see fit to say whatever they conjecture, not as things they have found out themselves, but as divine oracles revealed to them alone, the better to induce great and numerous crowds to believe a deceit.

51 Our lawgiver very appropriately calls such people false prophets, who adulterate the true prophecy, and overshadow what is genuine by their spurious devices; but in a very short time all their maneuvers are detected, since nature does not choose to stay hidden forever, but, when a suitable opportunity comes, displays her own power with irresistible strength. 52 For just as in eclipses of the sun the rays that have been obscured for a brief moment shine out again a short time later, exhibiting an unclouded and far-seen brilliancy with nothing at all passing over the sun, but one unalloyed blaze beaming from him in a serene sky; so also, even though some persons may deliver predictions, practicing a lying art of prophecy, and disguising themselves under the misleading name of prophetic inspiration, falsely taking the name of God in vain, they will be easily convicted. For the truth will come out again and shine out, shedding a most conspicuous light all around, so that the falsehood that overshadowed it before will disappear.

53 Moses also gave an excellent commandment when he ordained that the judge should “not receive the testimony of one witness.” First, because one person may unintentionally form a false impression of a thing, or may be careless about it and so be deceived. For there are innumerable false opinions, which often arise from an innumerable variety of causes. 54 And second, because it is most unjust to trust one witness against many people, or even against just one: against many, because many deserve more belief than one, since one does not outnumber many; and against one, because equal numbers allow no preponderance; for why should the judge trust a single witness, testifying against another, rather than the defendant pleading on his own behalf? But it seems best to suspend one’s opinion where there is neither deficiency nor excess to guide the judgment.

The Duties of Judges

55 The law thinks that all those who adhere to the sacred constitution, established by Moses, ought to be free from all unreasonable passions, and from all wickedness; and those who are appointed by lot or elected to judge between others ought to be so most of all; for it is absurd that those who undertake to dispense justice to others, and who ought to give a faithful copy of the works of nature, presenting an accurate representation of a model picture, should themselves be open to the charge of error. 56 For just as the power of fire, which spreads warmth to everything else it reaches, was warm in itself long before doing so, and as, conversely, the power of snow cools other things because it was first cold itself, so the judge ought to be full of pure unalloyed justice, if he is to irrigate all who come before him with justice, in order that from him, as from a sweet fountain, a wholesome spring may flow for all who thirst for a dispensation of good law.

57 And this will happen if whoever undertakes the office of judge regards himself as at once judging and being judged, and, when he takes up the pebble to cast his vote, takes up wisdom at the same time so as not to be deceived, and justice so as to dispense to each party what they deserve, and courage so as never to yield to pleas or to feelings of compassion and lessen the punishment due to convicted offenders. 58 For the man who studies these virtues may reasonably be regarded as a common benefactor, like a good pilot calming the storms of affairs so as to secure the preservation and safety of those who have committed their interests to him.

59 First, the law commands the judge not to listen to vain reports. Why is this? The law says, “My good man, let your ears be purified.” And they will be purified if they are continually washed out with a stream of virtuous language, never letting in the long, false, vain and hackneyed protestations, so worthy of ridicule, of storytellers or vain babblers, or of exaggerators who make a great deal of things of no importance. 60 And this is the meaning of the command not to listen to vain reports, and also of another precept somewhat in keeping with it. For, the lawgiver says, whoever listens to those who give hearsay evidence is listening to vanity and not to sound reason, because the eyes stay with the actual events, taking hold of them, so to speak, and comprehending and seizing upon them in all their parts, the light cooperating with them, by means of which all things are illuminated and clearly proved; but the ears, as one of the philosophers of old has very truly said, are less trustworthy than the eyes, since they are not themselves present at the events but are drawn by words, the interpreters of facts, which do not always tell the truth.

61 For these reasons some of the lawgivers among the Greeks, having transcribed some of the laws from the two tables of Moses, appear to have established very wise regulations, forbidding anyone to mention in his testimony anything that he has heard, on the ground that it is right to regard what a man has seen as trustworthy, but what he has heard as not wholly certain.

Bribery and the Price of Justice

62 The second commandment given to a judge is not to receive gifts; for gifts, says the law, blind the eyes that see, and pervert justice, and do not let the mind travel along the level road which leads to righteousness. 63 And taking bribes to aid unjust actions is the act of truly wicked men, and even doing so to further good ends is the conduct of people who are half wicked; for there are some judges deceptively disguised, half wicked, something between just and unjust, who do take up arms for the injured as their champions against those who injure them, yet are unwilling to let them win, though they ought to win, unless they gain some advantage from the victory themselves, and so make their decision corrupt and mercenary.

64 Then, when anyone blames them, they insist that they have not perverted justice, since those who ought to have lost have lost, and those who ought to have won have won their case; this is a most unworthy and false defense; for a righteous judge ought to exhibit two things, a judgment in strict accordance with the law, and incorruptibility; but he who is a judge for bribes, even though he decides justly, without realizing it defiles a thing that is beautiful by nature. 65 Moreover, he also does wrong in two other ways: first, because he is training himself to covet money, which is the beginning of the very greatest iniquities; and second, because he is injuring the man he ought to benefit by making him pay a price for justice.

66 Which is why Moses very instructively commanded that the judge shall pursue what is righteous in a righteous manner; suggesting by this figurative expression that it is possible to pursue it in an unrighteous manner, because of those men who sell just and legal decisions for money, not only in the courts of justice, but everywhere in every part of land and sea, and, I might almost say, in all the transactions of life. 67 For instance, a man who has received a deposit of small value has before now given it back when asked, more to lay a snare for the one who receives it back than with any thought of serving him, so that, using good faith in small things as bait, he may cover up the look of his faithlessness in greater things; and such conduct is nothing other than pursuing justice in an unrighteous manner; for the restitution of what did not belong to him was just, but it was done in an unrighteous manner, since it was done only as bait to attract more.

68 And the main cause of all such offenses is the inclination toward falsehood and the familiar habit of it, to which, from their very birth and swaddling clothes, their nurses and mothers and the whole household, free-born or slave, accustom and familiarize them by words and actions alike, fitting it to and uniting it with their souls as if it were a necessary part of their nature, though, even if it really had been implanted in them by nature, it would have been necessary to root it out by instillling good habits in its place. 69 And what in life is as beautiful as truth, which the all-wise legislator set in the most sacred place, in that part of the dress of the chief priest, where the dominant part of the soul lies, wishing to adorn it with the most beautiful and glorious of all ornaments? And next to truth he placed, as akin to it, a power that he here calls manifestation; the two are images of the two kinds of speech in us, the secret speech and the uttered speech, for the uttered speech requires manifestation, by which the secret thoughts in all our hearts are made known to our neighbor, but the secret speech needs truth for the perfection of life and actions, by means of which the road to happiness is found out.

Impartial Judgment

70 The third commandment given to a judge is to investigate the facts themselves rather than paying any regard to the parties to the suit, and to try in every imaginable way to free himself from all partiality, forcing himself to ignore and forget everything he knows or remembers about them; such as relations, friends, countrymen or foreigners, enemies or hereditary connections, so that neither affection nor hatred may overshadow his knowledge of justice; otherwise he must stumble like a blind man, walking without a staff and with no one to guide him whom he can firmly rely on. 71 For this reason it is fitting that a righteous judge should not even be told who the parties to the suit are, and that he should look at the undisguised, simple nature of the transactions themselves; so that he does not judge by random opinion but by real truth, and is guided by the conviction that judgment belongs to God; and that the judge is the minister and steward of his judgment; and a steward is not allowed to give away his master’s property, since he has received as a pledge the most excellent of all the things which exist in human life, from the most excellent of all beings.

72 And besides what has already been said, another most admirable precept commands the judge “not to show pity upon the poor man in his judgment.” Yet elsewhere the lawgiver has filled nearly the whole of the law with precepts of mercy and humanity, and has uttered great threats against arrogant and insolent men, and has proposed great rewards for those who try to make amends for the misfortunes of their neighbors, and who regard their surplus not as their own exclusive possession, but as the common property of everyone in want. 73 For one of the wise men of old said aptly and truly that men are never more like the gods than when they are bestowing benefits; and what can be a greater good than for mortal men to imitate the everlasting God?

74 So do not let the rich man collect in his house vast quantities of silver and gold, and store them up, but let him bring them out freely, so that his cheerful generosity may soften the hard condition of the poor; nor let any man be puffed up with vain glory, and exalt himself and boast in pride and arrogance, rather, let him honor equality and grant freedom of speech to people of low rank. And let the man who enjoys vigor of body be the prop of those who are weaker, and do not let him, like the men at the gymnastic contests, strive by every means to overthrow those who are inferior in strength, but let him be willing and eager to assist with his own power those who, left to themselves, are ready to faint. 75 For all those who have drunk deep of the fountains of wisdom, having banished envy entirely out of their minds, are of their own accord, and without any prompting, ready to undertake the assistance of their neighbors, pouring the streams of their words into their souls through their ears, so as to give them a share in the same knowledge they have. And when they see young men of good dispositions springing up like flourishing and vigorous shoots of a vine, they rejoice, thinking that they have found proper inheritors for this wealth of their souls, which is the only real riches, and they take them and cultivate their souls with doctrines and good meditations, until they arrive at full strength and maturity, so as to bring forth the fruit of excellence.

76 Many ornaments like these are woven into the laws and set among them to enrich the poor, on whom it is always right to have compassion except when judgment is being given, for compassion is due to misfortunes; but he who behaves wickedly with deliberate purpose is not unfortunate but unrighteous, 77 and punishment is due to the unrighteous just as honors should be conferred on the just, so no wicked man who is in difficulties and conceals the truth ought to escape punishment through the pity his poverty arouses, since what he has done deserves not pity, for how could it, but great anger. And let the man who undertakes the duty of a judge, like a skillful money-changer, divide and distinguish between the natures of things, so that mixing the good with the spurious does not cause confusion.

78 And there are many other things which may be said with respect to false witnesses and judges; but to avoid going on too long we must now move on to the last of the ten commandments, which, like each of the others, is delivered in a concise, summary form: and this commandment is, “You shall not covet.”

The Power of Covetous Desire

79 Every passion is open to blame and deserves it, since every immoderate and violent impulse, and every irrational and unnatural emotion of the soul is also faulty and blameworthy, for what is either of these but a long-standing passion spreading further? So if anyone does not set limits to these feelings or bridle them like restive horses, he will be afflicted by an evil difficult to remedy, and then, without realizing it, he will be carried away by them, because they cannot be restrained, as a charioteer sometimes is by his chariot, and hurried into ravines and pits that are difficult to climb out of and very hard to escape from safely. 80 But of all the passions none is so grievous as covetous desire for what one does not have, for things that seem good but are not really so, a desire that produces grievous anxieties that are hard to satisfy; for such a passion puts the reason to flight, and banishes it to a great distance, involving the soul in great difficulties, while the object which is desired flies away contemptuously, retreating not with its back but with its face turned toward one.

81 For when the desired object perceives covetous desire rushing after it, it rests for a short time to entice it and offer hope of being caught, then withdraws farther away, mocking it; but the passion, left behind and unable to catch up, struggles, inflicting a Tantalus-like punishment on the miserable soul; for it is said that Tantalus, whenever he wanted something to drink, could not get it, because the water retreated from his lips, and if he wished to gather any fruit, it all disappeared, the fruitful trees suddenly becoming barren. 82 For just as those implacable and inexorable mistresses of the body, thirst and hunger, very often strain it more, or at any rate no less, than unhappy people racked by torture even to death are strained, unless, once they have become violent, someone appeases them with food and drink, in the same way covetous desire, having first emptied the soul through its forgetfullness of what is present and its recollection of what is far away, fills it with impetuosity and madness, and introduces into it masters even worse than its former tyrants, but with the same names, namely, hunger and thirst, now, however, not for the things that serve the enjoyment of the belly, but for money, and glory, and authority, and beauty, and for innumerable other things that appear to be objects of desire and contention in human life.

83 And just as the disease that physicians call herpes does not stop in one part of the body, but moves about and overruns the skin, and, as its name shows, creeps about, dierpei, and becomes diffused in every direction, and, spreading widely, seizes and infects by its contact the whole combination of the body’s parts from head to foot, so covetous desire in the same way spreads over the whole soul, and does not leave even the smallest portion of it free from its inroads, imitating the power of fire when supplied with abundant fuel, for fire spreads and burns until it has devoured and destroyed everything it meets.

84 Covetous desire is so great and so excessive an evil; or rather, to tell the plain truth about it, it is the source of all evils. For where else do all the thefts, and acts of plunder, and repudiation of debt, and all false accusations, and acts of insolence, and, moreover, all rapes, and adulteries, and murders, and, in short, all harms, whether private or public, or sacred or profane, come from?

85 For covetous desire may most truly be called the original passion at the bottom of all these harms, and love is one of its offspring, and the most significant, filling the whole world with indescribable evils not once but many times; evils so many that even the whole circumference of the world has not been large enough to contain them, and, carried along as if by a rushing torrent, they have fallen into the sea, and all seas in every region have been filled with hostile fleets. All the terrible evils caused by naval wars have happened because of this passion; and, coming upon all continents and all islands together, have thrown them into confusion, spreading everywhere and retracing their own steps like the runners in the double-course race, or like the ebb and flow of the tides of the sea, returning to the point from which they originally set out. 86 And if we look at it in this way we shall see the power of this passion more clearly. Everything that covetous desire lays hold of, it changes for the worse, like poisonous serpents or deadly poisons. What do I mean by this?

87 If this passion is directed toward money, it makes thieves, and pickpockets, and clothes-stealers, and house-breakers, and taints men with the guilt of repudiating debts, of denying deposits, of bribery and sacrilege, and of all such iniquities. 88 If it is directed toward glory, it makes men insolent, overbearing, fickle, and unstable in their dispositions, depending wholly on what is said to them and on what they hear, humbled and elated at once because of the variety and inconstancy of the crowds who praise and blame them with thoughtless impetuosity, thoughtless in their enmity and in their friendship, so that they easily change from one to the other, and it fills them with all sorts of moods akin to and resembling these.

89 Again, if the desire takes the direction of wishing for authority and power, it makes men’s natures seditious, unequal, and tyrannical, it makes them cruel and inhuman enemies of their native countries, implacable masters unable to restrain themselves, irreconcilable forces against all who are their equals in might, flatterers of those more powerful than themselves, so that they can attack them treacherously. If what is desired is beauty of person, it makes men seducers, rapists, adulterers, pederasts, men given to licentiousness and incontinence, it teaches them to regard the greatest evils as the most fortunate of blessings. This passion also, when it reaches the tongue, often causes innumerable evils. 90 For some persons desire either to be silent about what ought to be mentioned, or to mention what ought to be buried in silence, and avenging justice pursues them if they reveal things improperly, or, on the contrary, if they keep silent at the wrong time.

91 When it affects the parts around the belly it makes men gluttonous, insatiable, intemperate, debauched, admirers of a profligate life, delighting in drunkenness, and devotion to luxurious eating, slaves to strong wine, and fish, and meat, pursuers of feasts and tables, wallowing like greedy dogs; and because of all these things their lives become miserable and accursed, and they are reduced to an existence more grievous than any death.

Reason, Anger, and Appetite

92 For this reason those who have tasted philosophy deeply, not merely with their lips, but feasting thoroughly on its profound doctrines, investigating the nature of the soul, and comprehending its threefold character, and how it is divided into reason, and anger, and appetite, have given the chief post to reason as the principal authority, assigning it the head as its most appropriate home, where the company of the outward senses is also stationed, always present as the bodyguards of the mind, their king. 93 And assigning the breast to anger as its home, partly so that the man, armed with it like a soldier with a breastplate, may be, if not utterly free from all injury, at least difficult to subdue, and partly so that anger, living near the mind, may benefit from its neighbor, which charms it by its wisdom and makes the passions gentle and manageable; and to appetite they assign the region around the navel and the part called the diaphragm.

94 For it was proper that appetite, having the smallest share in reason, should be removed as far as possible from the palace of the mind and placed almost at the very extremities, and that the most insatiable and the most intemperate of all the passions should be confined to the pastures of cattle, where they can find food and opportunities for the propagation of their species.

95 And the most holy Moses seems to me to have had regard to all these circumstances, and for that reason to have commanded men to discard this passion, detesting it as the most disgraceful thing and the cause of most disgraceful actions; and, therefore, to have prohibited it above all other feelings as an engine for the destruction of the soul; but if that engine is destroyed and the soul brought back to obedience, to the guidance of reason, the man will become entirely filled with peace and obedience to law and all sorts of perfect good things, so as to produce complete happiness.

96 But since he was fond of brevity, and accustomed to cut short matters that tended to be countless in number by a mode of teaching confined to general instances, he begins by admonishing and correcting one appetite, the one concerned with the belly, believing that the other appetites will not be as restive, but will be brought to order by learning that the most important and authoritative of them all has become obedient to the laws of moderation. 97 What, then, is the lesson he gives us about this origin of all vices? There are two things of the most comprehensive kind: food and drink. He, then, has left neither of them unrestrained, but has bridled them with special commands best suited to lead them to temperance and to humanity, and to the greatest of all virtues, piety.

First Fruits and Self-Control

98 For he commanded men to offer first fruits of grain, and wine, and oil, and cattle, and other things; and to distribute the first fruits among the sacrificers and the priests; among the sacrificers because of the gratitude due to God for the abundance and fertility of all things, and to the priests because of their sacred ministrations in the temple, for which they deserved to receive wages for their services in the sacred ceremonies. 99 And he utterly forbids anyone to taste anything, or to take any portion of anything, before separating off the first fruits, wishing by this injunction also to teach the practice of temperance, which is most useful; for whoever has learned not to throw himself greedily on all the abundance the seasons of the year have brought, but to wait until the first fruits are consecrated, is likely to be able to restrain the restive obstinacy of the passions, making them gentle and manageable.

Food and the Training of Desire

100 Moreover, Moses has not granted an unlimited possession and use of all other animals to those who partake in his sacred constitution, but he has forbidden with all his might all animals, whether of the land, or of the water, or that fly through the air, which are most fleshy and fat, and apt to excite treacherous pleasure, knowing well that such animals, luring as with bait the most slavish of all the outward senses, namely, taste, produce insatiability, an incurable evil to both souls and bodies, for insatiability produces indigestion, which is the origin and source of all diseases and weaknesses. 101 Of land animals, the swine is admitted by those who eat it to be the most delicious of all meats, and of all aquatic animals the most delicate are the fish which have no scales; and Moses is more skillful than any other man at training and inuring people of good natural disposition to the practice of virtue by frugality and abstinence, endeavoring to remove costly luxury from their characters,

102 at the same time not approving of unnecessary rigor, like the lawgiver of Lacedaemon, nor undue effeminacy, like the man who taught the Ionians and the Sybarites lessons of luxury and license, but keeping a middle path between the two courses, so that he has relaxed what was too strict, and tightened what was too loose, mingling the excesses which are found at each extremity with moderation, which lies between the two, so as to produce an irreproachable harmony and consistency of life, and for this reason he has laid down, not carelessly but in minute detail, what we are to use and what to avoid.

103 One might well suppose it just that beasts which feed on human flesh should receive from men the same treatment they inflict on men, but Moses has ordained that we should abstain from the enjoyment of all such things, and, with due consideration for what suits the gentle soul, he proposes a most gentle and most pleasant banquet; for though it is right that those who inflict evils should suffer similar calamities themselves, it may not be fitting for those they mistreated to retaliate, for fear that they become brutalized by anger without being aware of it, which is a savage passion. 104 And he takes such care to guard against this, that, wishing to banish as far as possible all desire for the animals mentioned above, he forbids with all his energy the eating of any carnivorous animal at all, choosing the herbivorous animals from among the domesticated kinds, since they are tame by nature, feed on the gentle food the earth supplies, and have no disposition to plot evil against anything.

Clean Land Animals

105 The animals that are clean and lawful to eat are ten in number; the heifer, the lamb, the goat, the stag, the antelope, the buffalo, the roebuck, the pygarga, the wild ox, and the chamois, for he always holds to that arithmetical subtlety which he originally devised with the greatest possible accuracy and extends to all existing things, so that he establishes no ordinance, whether important or unimportant, without taking this number and, as it were, fitting it to the ordinance as closely connected with the regulations he is ordaining. Of all the numbers counting up from one, the most perfect is ten, and as Moses says, it is the most sacred of all and a holy number, and by it he now limits the kinds of clean animals, wishing to give their use to all who share in the constitution he is establishing.

106 And he gives two tests, or criteria, for the ten animals so listed, by means of two signs, first, that they must part the hoof, secondly, that they must chew the cud; for those which do neither, or only one of these things, are unclean. Both these signs are symbols of instruction and of the most scientific learning, by which the better is separated from the worse, so that all confusion between them is prevented. 107 For just as the animal that chews the cud, while masticating its food, draws it down its throat, and then by slow degrees kneads and softens it, and after this process sends it down again into the belly, so the man who is being instructed, having taken in through his ears the doctrines and speculations of wisdom from his instructor, derives a considerable amount of learning from him, but still cannot hold it firmly and embrace it all at once until he has turned over in his mind everything he has heard by the continued exercise of his memory, which is the cement connecting ideas, and then he impresses the image of it all firmly on his soul.

108 But it seems that a firm grasp of such ideas is of no advantage to him unless he can discriminate between contrary things and distinguish which it is right to choose and which to avoid, and of this the parting of the hoof is the symbol; since the course of life is twofold, the one road leading to wickedness and the other to virtue, and since we ought to renounce the one and never to forsake the other.

Unclean Land Animals

109 For this reason all animals with solid hoofs, and all with many toes are implicitly declared unclean; the one because, being so, they imply that the nature of good and evil is one and the same; which is just as if one were to say that the nature of a concave and a convex surface, or of a road uphill and downhill, is the same. And the other, because it shows that there are many roads, though, indeed, they have no right to be called roads at all, which lead the life of man to deceit; for it is not easy to choose the most desirable and the most excellent among a variety of paths.

Clean Aquatic Animals

110 Having laid down these definitions for land animals, he proceeds to describe what aquatic creatures are clean and lawful to be used for food; distinguishing these too by two characteristics, fins and scales. For he rejects and prohibits those that have neither one nor the other, and those that have only one of the two. And he must state the cause, which is not lacking in sense and propriety. 111 For all those creatures which lack both, or even one of the two, are sucked down by the current, not being able to resist the force of the stream; but those which have both these characteristics can stem the water, and face it head-on, and strive against it as against an adversary, and struggle with invincible good will and courage, so that if they are pushed they push in their turn; and if they are pursued they turn upon their enemy and pursue it in their turn, making themselves broad roads in a pathless region, so as to have an easy passage to and fro.

112 Both these things are symbols: the former of a soul devoted to pleasure, and the latter of one which loves perseverance and temperance. For the road to pleasure is downhill and very easy, more an engulfing chasm than a path. But the path to temperance is uphill and laborious, yet more advantageous than any other road. And the one leads men downwards, and prevents those who travel by it from retracing their steps until they have reached the very bottom, while the other leads to heaven, making immortal those who do not tire before they reach it, if they are only able to endure its rugged and difficult ascent.

Crawling and Leaping Creatures

113 Holding to the same general idea, the lawgiver asserts that those reptiles which have no feet, and which crawl onwards, dragging themselves along the ground on their bellies, or those which have four legs, or many feet, are all unclean as food. And here, again, when he mentions reptiles he figuratively indicates those who are devoted to their bellies, gorging themselves like cormorants, and who are continually offering up tribute to their miserable belly, that is, tribute of strong wine, and confections, and fish, and, in short, all the superfluous delicacies which the skill and labor of bakers and confectioners are able to devise, inventing all sorts of rare dishes, to stimulate and set on fire the insatiable and unappeasable appetites of man. And when he speaks of animals with four legs and many feet, he means the miserable slaves not of one single passion, appetite, but of all the passions, whose genera are four in number, though their subordinate species are innumerable. So the despotism of one is very grievous, but the despotism of many is most terrible and, it seems, intolerable.

114 Again, Moses calls clean those reptiles which have legs above their feet, so that they can leap from the ground; as, for instance, the different kinds of locusts, and that animal called the serpent-fighter, here again indicating figuratively the manners and habits of the rational soul. For the weight of the body, being naturally heavy, drags down with it those of little wisdom, strangling and pressing them down by the weight of the flesh. 115 But blessed are those whose lot it has been, since they have been well and solidly instructed in the rules of sound education, to resist successfully the power of mere strength, so that, because of what they have learned, they can spring up from the earth and all low things, to the air and the periodical revolutions of the heaven, the very sight of which deserves to be marveled at and earnestly striven for by those who come to it of their own accord, with no indolence or indifference.

Birds

116 Having therefore already gone through, in his ordinances, all the different kinds of land animals and of those that live in the water, and having distinguished them in his code of laws as accurately as it was possible, Moses begins to investigate the remaining class of animals in the air: the innumerable kinds of flying creatures, rejecting all those which prey upon one another or upon man, all carnivorous birds, in short, all animals which are venomous, and all which have any power of plotting against others. 117 But doves, and pigeons, and turtledoves, and all the flocks of cranes, and geese, and birds of that kind, he counts among the domestic, tame and edible creatures, allowing anyone who chooses to eat them with impunity.

118 Thus, in each of the parts of the universe, earth, water, and air, he denies us the use of some kinds of each sort of animal, whether terrestrial, aquatic or aerial; and so, taking fuel from the fire, as it were, he extinguishes appetite.

Carcasses and Animals Killed by Beasts

119 Moreover, Moses commands that no man shall partake of any dead carcass, or of any body which has been torn by wild beasts; partly because it is not fitting that man should share a feast with untamable beasts, so as to become almost a fellow reveler in their carnivorous festivals; partly because it is perhaps injurious and likely to cause disease if the juice of the dead body becomes mingled with the blood, and perhaps also because it is proper to leave untouched what death has already preoccupied and seized beforehand, out of respect for the necessities of nature by which it has been seized.

120 Many lawgivers, among both Greeks and barbarians, praise those who are skillful at hunting, and who seldom fail in their pursuit or miss their aim, and who pride themselves on their successful hunts, especially when they divide the limbs of the animals which they have caught with the huntsmen and the hounds, as being not only brave hunters but men of very sociable dispositions. But anyone who is a sound interpreter of the sacred constitution and code of laws would quite naturally blame them, since the lawgiver of that code has expressly forbidden any enjoyment of carcasses or of bodies torn by beasts for the reasons mentioned before.

121 But if any one of those who devote themselves wholly to meditating on and practicing virtue were suddenly to take a liking to gymnastic exercises and hunting, regarding hunting as a kind of prelude to, and representation of, the wars and dangers to be faced against the enemy, then, whenever such a man is successful in his sport, he ought to give the beasts which he has killed to his dogs as a feast for them, and as a reward or wages for their successful boldness and their irreproachable alliance. But he ought not himself to touch them, since he has already been taught, through the case of irrational animals, what feelings he ought to have toward his enemies. For he ought to carry on war against them, not for the sake of unrighteous gain like those who make a dishonest trade of all their actions, but either in revenge for some calamities which he has previously suffered at their hands, or in view of some he expects to suffer.

Blood, Fat, and Life

122 But some men, with open mouths, carry even the excessive luxury and boundless intemperance of Sardanapalus to such an indefinite and unlimited extent, being wholly absorbed in the invention of senseless pleasures, that they prepare sacrifices which ought never to be offered, strangling their victims, and stifling the essence of life, which they ought to let depart free and unrestrained, burying the blood, as it were, in the body. For it should have been enough for them to enjoy the flesh by itself, without touching any of those parts which have any connection with the soul or life.

123 For this reason Moses, in another passage, establishes a law about blood, that one may eat neither the blood nor the fat. The blood is forbidden for the reason I have already mentioned, that it is the essence of the life; not of the mental and rational life, but of the life of the outward senses, through which we and the irrational animals alike share a common existence. For the essence of the soul of man is the breath of God, especially if we follow the account of Moses, who, in his history of the creation of the world, says that God breathed into the first man, the founder of our race, the breath of life, breathing it into the principal part of his body, namely the face, where the outward senses are established, the bodyguards of the mind, as if it were the great king. And what was breathed into his face in this way was clearly the breath of the air, or whatever else there may be which is even more excellent than the breath of the air, as being a ray emitted from the blessed and threefold-blessed nature of God.

124 But Moses commanded men to abstain from eating fat, because it is gross. And again, he gave us this injunction, to instill temperance and a zeal for an austere life: we should give up what is easy and readily available, and willingly face anxieties and labors to acquire virtue. 125 For this reason these two parts are to be taken out of every victim and burned with fire, as a kind of first fruits, namely, the fat and the blood; the one poured on the altar as a libation, and the other used as fuel for the flame, applied instead of oil, because of its fatness, to the consecrated and holy flame.

The Quails in the Wilderness

126 The lawgiver blames some persons of his time as gluttons, and for believing that the mere indulgence of luxury is the happiest of all possible conditions, not content to live this way only in cities that had abundant supplies and stores of all kinds of necessary things, but carrying their effeminacy even into pathless and untrodden deserts, and choosing to have markets there too for fish and meat, and all things which can contribute to an easy life: 127 then, when a scarcity arose, they assembled together and raised an outcry, and looked miserable, and with shameless audacity impeached their ruler, and did not stop making disturbances until they got what they desired; and they obtained it to their destruction, for two reasons: first, so that it might be shown that all things are possible for God, who can find a way in the most difficult and apparently hopeless circumstances; and secondly, so that punishment might fall on those who were intemperate in their gluttonous appetites, and obstinate resisters of holiness.

128 For a vast cloud rose out of the sea and showered down quails around sunrise, and the birds overshadowed the camp and all the district around it for a day’s journey for a well-equipped active man. And the birds flew at a height of about two cubits from the ground, in order that they might be easily caught. 129 It would therefore have been natural for them, amazed at the marvelous nature of the prodigy they saw, to be satisfied with the sight, and, filled with piety, to nourish their souls on it, and to abstain from eating flesh; but these men, on the contrary, stirred up their desires even more than before, and pursued these birds as the greatest good imaginable, and, seizing them with both hands, filled their bosoms; then, having stored them up in their tents, they went out to catch others, for immoderate covetousness has no limit. And when they had collected every kind of food they devoured it insatiably, about to perish, vain-minded generation that they were, by their own fullness.

130 And indeed before long they did perish by the purging of their bile, so that the place itself took its name from the calamity that fell upon them, for it was called the graves of their lust, and, as the scripture teaches us, there is no greater evil in the soul than lust.

131 For this reason Moses says beautifully in his recommendations, “Do not let every man do that which seems good to his own eyes,” which is equivalent to saying, do not let anyone gratify his own desire, but let each person seek to please God, and the world, and nature, and wise men, repudiating self-love, if he wants to become a good and virtuous man.

The Arrangement of the Laws

132 This may be enough to say, and it is in fact all I am able to put forward, about the laws that bear on appetite and desire by way of filling up the whole body of the ten commandments, and of the subordinate injunctions contained in them; for if we are to regard the brief headings delivered as oracles by the voice of God as the generic laws, and all the particular ordinances which Moses subsequently interpreted and added as the special laws; then great care and skill are needed to keep the arrangement unconfused so that it can be accurately understood, and so I have taken great care, and have assigned and apportioned to each of these generic laws of the whole code all that properly belonged to it.

133 But enough of this. We must not, however, be unaware that just as there are some particular injunctions related separately to each of the ten generic commandments, which have nothing in common with any of the others, so too there are some things to be observed which are common to them all, suited not to one or two, as people say, but to all ten commandments. 134 By this I mean the virtues of common utility, for each one of these ten laws separately, and all of them together, train men and encourage them to prudence, and justice, and piety, toward God and all the rest of the company of virtues, connecting sound words with good intentions, and virtuous actions with wise language, so that the organ of the soul may be wholly and entirely held together in good harmony, producing a well-regulated and faultless innocence and consistency of life.

Justice and Its Practice

135 We have spoken before of that queen of all the virtues, piety and holiness, and also of prudence and moderation; we must now go on to speak of justice, which deals with subjects akin and closely related to them.

136 One portion of justice, and not an unimportant one, relates to courts of justice and to the judge, which indeed I have mentioned before, when I was going through the subject of testimony, and dwelling on it at some length, in order that nothing which belonged to the subject should be omitted; and as I am not fond of repetitions, unless some necessity arising from the urgency of the occasion compels me to it, I will pass over that part of the subject now and turn my attention to the other portions, having said just this much by way of preface.

137 The law says that it is proper to store up justice in one’s heart, and to fasten it as a sign on one’s hand, and as frontlets before one’s eyes, indicating figuratively by the first expression that one ought to commit the precepts of justice, not to one’s ears, which are not trustworthy, for the ears deserve no credit, but to that most important and dominant part, imprinting the best of all lessons there and engraving them with trustworthy seals. 138 And by the second expression, that it is necessary not only to form proper conceptions of what is right, but also to do without delay what one has decided is proper. For the hand is the symbol of actions, to which Moses here commands the people to attach and fasten justice, saying that it shall be a sign, though of what he has not expressly stated, because, as I understand it, it is a sign not of one particular thing but of many, and, I might almost say, of everything the life of man is concerned with.

139 And by the third expression, he implies that justice is seen everywhere as close to the eyes. Moreover he says that these things must have a certain motion; not one that is light and unsteady, but one whose agitation may rouse the sight to the spectacle plainly in front of it; for motion is suited to attract the sight, since it excites and rouses it; or, I should rather say, since it makes the eyes awake and sleepless.

140 But the man who comes to picture with the eyes of his mind things that are not at rest but in motion, exerting their energies in accordance with nature, deserves to be counted a perfect man, and no longer to be numbered among learners and pupils, but among teachers and instructors; and he ought to allow all the young men who wish to do so to drink of his wisdom as of an abundant stream flowing from a living fountain of lessons and doctrines. And if anyone, out of modesty, lacks courage, and so delays and is slow to approach him to learn, the teacher should go to him of his own accord, and pour into his ears a collection of admonitions, until the channels of his soul are filled with them.

141 And he should teach the principles of justice to all his relatives and friends, and to all young men, at home and on the road, and when they are going to bed, and when they get up; so that in all their positions, and in all their motions, and in all places whether private or public, not only waking, but also while asleep, they may be delighted with the image and conception of justice. For there is no delight more exquisite than the delight that comes from the whole soul being entirely filled with justice, while devoted to the study of its everlasting doctrines and meditations, so that it has no empty place through which injustice can enter.

142 Moreover, he commands those who have written out these things to fix them afterwards to every house belonging to a friend, and to the gates in their walls; so that all people, whether coming in or going out, whether citizens or strangers, reading the writing fixed in this way on pillars in front of the gates, may constantly remember all that ought to be said or done; and that everyone may take care neither to do nor to suffer injury; and that all persons, whether going into their houses or going out of them, men and women, children and servants, may do all that is proper and fitting toward one another and toward themselves.

Preserving the Law

143 The lawgiver also gives this most admirable command: that one must not add anything to the law or take anything away from it, but must keep all the ordinances as originally established, unaltered and in the very state in which they were first delivered; for otherwise, it seems, something unjust might be added; since the wise lawgiver has left out nothing that can enable a man to share in entire and perfect justice. 144 Moreover, by this command Moses hints at the perfection of every other virtue; for each separate virtue is free from all deficiency, and is complete, deriving its perfection from itself; so that if anything were added to it or taken away from it, it would be utterly and entirely changed and altered, and take on the opposite character.

145 What I mean is this: all who are not profoundly ignorant and uninstructed, and all who have even the slightest smattering of education, know that courage is a virtue concerned with terrible things, a science that teaches one what he ought to endure and dare. 146 But if anyone, under the influence of the ignorance that comes from insolence, should be so meddlesome as to imagine himself capable of correcting what needs no correction, and should therefore venture to add or take away anything, he is in doing so altering the whole appearance of the thing, turning what had a good character into impropriety; for by any addition to courage he will produce audacity, but if he takes anything away from it he will produce cowardice, not leaving even the name of courage, the most useful of all virtues for life.

147 In the same manner, if anyone makes an addition, however small or however great, to that queen of the virtues, piety, or if he takes anything away from it, he will change and metamorphose its whole appearance, and make it something quite different; for any addition will engender superstition, and any diminution will produce impiety, real piety itself wholly disappearing under the operation, though everyone should pray for it to be continually conspicuous and brilliant, since it is the cause of the greatest of all blessings, since it produces a knowledge of the service of God, which one ought to regard as more important and more precious than any dominion or authority. 148 And we could give similar instances for every other virtue, like what we have said about those just mentioned; but since I am in the habit of avoiding wordiness, I will be content with what has been said, which may be a sufficient guide to what could be said about the virtues we leave unmentioned.

Landmarks and Inherited Customs

149 There is also this commandment, which is of great common benefit: “You shall not move your neighbors’ landmarks which the former men have set up.” And this command is given, it seems, not only with respect to inheritances and the boundaries of the land, to prohibit covetousness about them, but also to guard ancient customs; for customs are unwritten laws, the doctrines of men of old, not engraved on pillars or written on paper which may be eaten by moths, but impressed in the souls of those living under the same constitution.

150 For children ought to inherit from the fathers who gave them being the national customs in which they have been brought up, and in which they have lived from their cradle, and not to despise them merely because they are handed down without being written. For the man who obeys the written laws does not rightly deserve any praise, since he acts under compulsion and the fear of punishment. But the man who keeps the unwritten laws deserves praise, because he shows a spontaneous and unconstrained virtue.

Choosing Rulers

151 Some people have argued that the officers of all magistracies ought to be appointed by lot; but this practice does not benefit the multitude, for the casting of lots shows good fortune, but not virtue; at any rate many unworthy people have often obtained office in this way, men whom a good man holding supreme authority would not allow to be counted even among his subjects: 152 for even those whom some people call lesser rulers, those whom men call masters, do not accept just anyone they can find as their servants, whether born in the house or bought with money; but take only those who are obedient, and at times they sell off in one lot all those of incurably bad disposition, as unworthy to be the slaves of good men.

153 Therefore it is not right to make men who obtain those places by lot the masters and rulers of entire cities and nations, for the lot is a sort of blunder on the part of fortune, an unstable and fickle thing. Beyond all question, the casting of lots has no connection with the ability to care for the sick; for physicians do not obtain their posts by lot, but because their experience has been approved. 154 Again, for the successful voyage and safety of men at sea, it is not just any man who happens to obtain the office of pilot by lot who is sent at once to the stern to steer the vessel, and who might then by his ignorance cause a needless wreck in calm and tranquil weather; rather, the charge is given to the man who appears to have learned and carefully studied the business of a pilot from his earliest youth; this is a man who has made many voyages, and who has traversed every sea, or at all events most seas, and who has carefully learned the character of all the trading ports, and harbors, and anchorages, and places of refuge in the different islands and continents, and who knows the routes over the sea even better than, or at any rate no worse than, the roads on land, through his accurate observation of the heavenly bodies. 155 For by noting the various motions of the stars, and following and being guided by their regular revolutions, he has learned to find for himself an unerring and easy path through the pathless waste of waters, so that, most incredible of all, beings whose nature is to live on land are able to cross the sea, which can only be crossed by sailing.

156 And if anyone were about to undertake the government or regulation of large and populous cities, full of inhabitants, and to attempt to settle their constitution, and to take charge of private, and public, and sacred affairs, a task which anyone may rightly call the art of arts, and the science of sciences, he would not rely on the uncertain chances of time, passing over the accurate and trustworthy test of truth; and the test of truth is proof combined with reason.

157 The all-wise Moses, seeing this by the power of his own soul, makes no mention of any authority being assigned by lot, but chooses to direct that all offices be filled by election; therefore he says, “You shall not appoint a stranger to be a ruler over you, but one of your own brothers,” implying that the appointment is to be a voluntary choice, and an irreproachable selection of a ruler, whom the whole multitude with one accord shall choose; and God himself, the one who confirms all beneficial things, will add his vote in favor of such an election and set his seal on it to ratify it, regarding the man chosen in this way as the flower of his race, just as the sight is the best thing in the body.

158 And Moses also gives two reasons why it is not proper for strangers to be elected to positions of authority: first, so that they may not amass a quantity of silver, and gold, and flocks, and build up great, wickedly earned riches for themselves out of the poverty of those subject to them; and secondly, so that they may not make the nation leave its ancient homes to gratify their own covetous desires, and so compel them to emigrate, and to wander about to and fro in interminable wanderings, holding out to them hopes of gaining greater blessings that will never be fulfilled, and so making them lose the advantages they securely enjoyed.

159 For our lawgiver foresaw, as was natural, that one who was a countryman and a relative, and who also had a special share in the highest relationship of all—one constitution, the same law, and one God whose chosen nation is his own people—would never offend in any way like those I have been describing, but, on the other hand, instead of driving the inhabitants from their homes, he would probably even provide a safe return for those of his countrymen who were scattered in a foreign land; and instead of taking away the property of others, he would even give his own property to those who were in need of it, making his own wealth common.

The Ruler’s Copy of the Law

160 And he orders that from the first day anyone takes office, he is to write out a copy of the book of the Law with his own hand, to give him a summary and concise image of all the laws, because he wants all the ordinances laid down in it to be firmly fixed in his soul; for while a man is reading, the ideas of what he reads slip away, carried off by the speed at which he utters them; but if he is writing, they are stamped on his heart at leisure, and they settle in the heart of each individual as his mind dwells on each detail and settles down to contemplate it, and does not turn away to any other object until it has taken a firm hold of what was put before it.

161 So as he writes, he should take care every day to read and study what he has written, both so that he may gain a continual and unchanging memory of these commands, which are virtuous and beneficial for all men to observe, and so that a firm love of them and desire for them may be planted in him, as his soul is continually taught and trained to apply itself to the study and observance of the sacred laws. For familiarity, bred by long acquaintance, produces a sincere and pure friendship, not only toward men but also toward those branches of learning that are worthy to be loved. 162 And this will happen if the ruler studies not someone else’s writings and records but the ones he has written out himself; for each person’s own works are to some degree easier for him to understand, and also easier to grasp.

163 And besides, a man reading them will have thoughts like these in his mind: “I wrote all this, I, a ruler of such great power, without using anyone else as my scribe, though I had countless servants. Did I do all this to fill up a volume, like those who copy out books for hire, or like men who practice with their eyes and hands, training the eyes to sharpness of sight and the hands to speed of writing? Why should I have done this? No; I did it so that, once I had recorded these things in a book, I might at once go on to impress them on my heart, and stamp their divine and indelible characters on my intellect: 164 other kings carry scepters in their hands and sit on thrones in royal state, but my scepter will be the book of the copy of the law; that will be my boast and my undisputed glory, the signal of my irreproachable sovereignty, created after the image and model of the archetypal royal power of God.

165 “And by always relying on the sacred laws and leaning on them for support, I shall gain the most excellent things. First, equality, and no greater blessing can be found, for insolence and excessive haughtiness are the signs of a narrow-minded soul, which does not foresee the future.

166 “Equality, therefore, will win me the goodwill of all who are subject to my power, and safety, since they will repay my kindness justly; but inequality would bring terrible dangers on me, and I shall escape these by hating inequality, the purveyor of darkness and wars; and my life will be in no danger of being plotted against, because I honor equality, which has nothing to do with rebellions, but which is the parent of light and stability.

167 “Moreover, I shall gain another advantage, namely, that I shall not sway this way and that, like the pans of a scale, through perverting and distorting the commandments laid down to guide me. But I shall try to keep them, walking along the middle of the plain road, keeping my own steps straight and upright, so that I may attain a life free from error or misfortune.”

168 And Moses used to call the middle road the royal one, since it lay between excess and deficiency; and besides, and more especially, because in the number three the middle holds the most important place, binding the extremes on either side with an unbreakable chain, and is attended by those extremes as its bodyguards, as though it were a king.

169 Moreover, Moses says that a long-enduring sovereignty is the reward of a lawful magistrate or ruler who honors equality, and who without any corruption gives just decisions in a just manner, always striving to observe the laws; not to grant him a life of many years spent administering the commonwealth, but to teach those who do not understand that a governor who rules in accordance with the laws, even though he dies, still lives a long life through the actions he leaves behind him, immortal, the indestructible monuments of his piety and virtue.

Sharing the Work of Government

170 And it is fitting for a man who has been thought worthy of the supreme and greatest authority to appoint successors who may govern with him and judge with him, and, in concert with him, may ordain everything which is for the common advantage; for one person would not be able, however willing he were, and even if he were the most powerful man in the world in both body and soul, to bear the weight and number of affairs that would come upon him, as he would faint under the pressure and rapidity of all kinds of business coming in upon him continually every day from all quarters, unless he had a number of people chosen for their excellence to work with him through their prudence, and power, and justice, and godly piety, men who not only avoid arrogance, but even detest it as an enemy and as the very greatest of evils. 171 For these men would stand by, and assist, and cooperate with a virtuous and holy man, one who hated evil as much as they did, and would be the most suitable persons to lighten and relieve his labors. And besides, since some of the matters that would force themselves on his attention are of greater importance and others of less, the chief will very reasonably hand the less important ones to his lieutenants, while he himself would necessarily become the most accurate judge of the weightier matters.

172 But the affairs we ought to regard as the most weighty are not, as some people think, those in which people of reputation are in dispute with other people of reputation, or rich men with rich men, or princes with princes; on the contrary, they are rather those where there are powerful men on one side, and private individuals, men of no wealth, or dignity, or reputation, on the other, men whose sole hope of escaping intolerable evils lies in the judge himself.

173 And we can find clear instances of both kinds in the sacred laws, which we would do well to imitate; for there was once a time when Moses, all by himself, decided all cases and all matters of legal controversy, laboring from morning till night. But after a while his father-in-law came to him, and seeing what a weight of business overwhelmed him, as everyone who had any dispute was constantly coming to him, gave him most excellent advice, counseling him to choose subordinate magistrates, so that they might decide the less important matters, and he might have only the more serious cases to occupy him, and in this way give himself time to rest. 174 And Moses, convinced by the arguments of Jethro, which were indeed for his good, chose the men of the highest reputation in the whole nation and appointed them his lieutenants and judges, telling them to refer the more important cases to him.

175 And the history of the sacred laws duly records this arrangement for the instruction of rulers in all later generations: first, so that they may not despise the help of fellow counselors, as if they could oversee everything themselves, since that all-wise and godly man, Moses, did not reject them; and secondly, so that they may learn to choose subordinates of the second rank and the third, and so make sure they are not driven to neglect matters of greater importance by being wholly taken up with more trifling affairs; for it is impossible for human nature to attend to everything at once.

Justice for the Vulnerable

176 Here we have mentioned one example of what we alluded to before. We must now add an instance of the second kind. I said that the cases of men of humble condition were important; for the widow, and the orphan, and the stranger are powerless and humble. And it is right for the supreme King, the Ruler who has supreme authority over the whole nation, to be the judge in their case; since, according to Moses, even God, the Ruler of the universe, did not exclude them from the provisions of his laws. 177 For when Moses, that holy interpreter of the will of God, raises a hymn in praise of the virtues of the living God in these words, “God is great and mighty, one who is impartial, and who does not take gifts to guide him in his judgment,” he adds for whom he gives judgment: not for satraps, and tyrants, and men who hold power by land and sea, but he gives judgment for the stranger, and the orphan, and the widow.

178 For the first, because he has made his own kinsmen, the only people it was natural for him to have as allies and champions, into his irreconcilable enemies, by leaving their camp and making his home with the truth, and with the honor of the one Being who is entitled to honor, abandoning all the fabulous inventions and polytheistic notions which his fathers, and grandfathers, and ancestors, and all the relatives of the man who undertook this noble migration used to honor. For the second, because he has lost his father and mother, his natural defenders and protectors, and with them the only power bound to stand by him as an ally. And lastly, for the widow, because she has lost her husband, who succeeded her parents as her guardian and protector; for in relationship a husband is to his wife what her parents are to a virgin.

179 And one may almost say that the whole nation of the Jews can be regarded as orphans, compared with all the other nations in other lands; for other nations, whenever they are afflicted by calamities not inflicted by God, do not lack help, because of their frequent contact with other nations through their habitual dealings in common. But this nation of the Jews has no such allies because of the peculiarity of its laws and customs. And their laws are of necessity strict and rigorous, as they are intended to train them to the greatest height of virtue; and what is strict and rigorous is austere. And most people avoid such laws and customs, because they are inclined to pleasure and embrace it.

180 But, nevertheless, Moses says that the great Ruler of the universe, whose inheritance they are, always feels compassion and pity for the orphaned and desolate among his people, because they have been dedicated to him, the Creator and Father of all, as a sort of first-fruits of the whole human race.

181 And the cause of this dedication to God was the excessive and admirable righteousness and virtue of the founders of the nation, which remain like undying plants, bearing fruit that will always flourish for the salvation of their descendants, and to the benefit of all persons and all things, provided only that the sins they commit are curable and not wholly unpardonable.

182 So let no one think that nobility of birth is a perfect good and therefore neglect virtuous actions, bearing in mind that the man who is born of virtuous parents and then brings disgrace on them through the wickedness of his disposition and conduct deserves greater anger; for if he has examples of goodness at home to imitate, and yet never copies them so as to correct his own life and make it healthy and virtuous, he deserves reproach.

Rulers as Protectors

183 By a most just and reasonable prohibition, the law also forbids the man who has undertaken the care and government of the common interests of the state to act treacherously among the people; for a treacherous disposition is the mark of an illiberal and very slavish soul, which seeks to hide its real nature behind hypocrisy.

184 For, in reality, a ruler ought to stand up in defense of his subjects as a father would in defense of his children, so that he may be honored by them as if they were his own real children; and so good rulers are, to tell the plain truth, the common parents of their cities and nations, showing them equal, and sometimes even greater, goodwill. 185 But those men who acquire great power and authority to the injury and damage of their subjects ought to be called not rulers but enemies, since they are acting the part of implacable enemies. Yet those who injure a person treacherously are even more wicked than those who oppose him openly, since the latter can be repelled without difficulty, as they show their hostility undisguised; but the malice of the others is difficult to detect and hard to expose, like the conduct of men on the stage, who wear costumes that do not belong to them, in order to conceal their real appearance.

186 But there is a kind of preeminence and superior authority which, I might almost say, pervades every part of life, varying only in size and quantity; for the first man in a village is what the king of a city is, and so are the master of a house, and a physician among the sick, and a general in his camp, and an admiral with respect to his crew and to his passengers, and a captain of a ship in regard to merchant vessels and transports, and a pilot among common sailors, every one of whom has power to make things either better or worse. But they ought to wish to conduct themselves in everything for the best, and the best is to use all their energies to assist people and not to injure them. 187 For this is to act in imitation of God, since he also has the power to do either good or evil, but his inclination causes him only to do good. And the creation and arrangement of the world shows this, for he has called into existence what previously had no being, creating order out of disorder, and distinctive qualities out of things which had no such qualities, and similarities out of things dissimilar, and identity out of things which were different, and intercommunion and harmony out of things that previously had neither communication nor agreement, and equality out of inequality, and light out of darkness; for he is always anxious to exert his beneficent powers in order to change whatever is disorderly from its present evil condition, and to transform it so as to bring it into a better state.

Referring Difficult Cases to the Priests

188 Therefore it is right for good rulers of a nation to imitate him in these points, if they have any desire to attain likeness to God; but since countless circumstances continually escape and elude the human mind, entangled and hampered as it is by so great a multitude of external senses, which are very well suited to seduce and deceive it with false opinions, since in fact it is, as I may say, buried in the mortal body, which may very properly be called its tomb, let no judge be ashamed to confess that he does not know what he does not know, 189 for in the first place the man who is deceived becomes worse than he was before, because he has expelled truth from the confines of his soul; in the second place, he will do great mischief to those on whose causes he is deciding by delivering a blind decision because he does not see what is just.

190 So when he does not clearly understand a case because its circumstances are tangled and unintelligible and throw uncertainty and darkness around it, he ought to decline giving a decision, and to refer the matter to judges who will understand it more accurately. And who can these judges be but the priests, and the ruler and governor of the priests?

191 For the genuine, sincere worshipers of God are made sharp in intellect by care and diligence, since they are not indifferent even to slight errors, because of the surpassing excellence of the Monarch whom they serve in every point. For this reason the priests are commanded to go to offer sacrifice sober, so that no drug that makes men err, or speak and act foolishly, may enter the mind and cloud its vision, 192 and perhaps because the real, genuine priest is at the same time a prophet, having attained to the honor of being allowed to see the only true and living God, not more because of his birth than because of his virtue. And to a prophet there is nothing unknown, since he has within himself the sun of intelligence, and rays that are never overshadowed, giving him a most accurate understanding of things that are invisible to the outward senses but intelligible to the intellect.

Honest Trade and Prompt Payment

193 Again, merchants and peddlers, and people in the market, and all those who deal in things necessary for life, and who therefore deal in measures, and weights, and balances, since they sell both dry and liquid goods, are placed under the superintendents of the market, and these superintendents are bound to govern them if they act with moderation, doing what is right, not out of fear, but voluntarily, for spontaneous good conduct is always more honorable than good conduct that comes from compulsion. 194 For this reason the law orders these merchants and dealers, and everyone else who has adopted this way of life, to take care to provide themselves with just balances, and measures, and weights, not to practice any wicked tricks to the injury of those who buy from them, but to do and say everything with a free and guileless soul, bearing in mind that unjust gains do harm, but wealth acquired in accordance with justice is something a man cannot be deprived of.

195 And since wages are offered to artisans as a reward for their work, and since artisans are people in need, not men who have an abundance of wealth, the law commands that the payment of their wages shall not be delayed, but that their employers shall pay them the wages agreed upon the same day that they are earned; for it is absurd for the rich to make use of the services of the poor, and yet, living in plenty and affluence, not to give the poor proper payment for those services at once. 196 Are these not very clear examples to teach us to guard against greater offenses? For if he will not allow a payment that is sure to be made eventually to be delayed beyond the proper time, fixing the evening of the day as the time when the artisan, on returning home, is to carry his wages home with him, does he not by such a commandment much more forbid plunder and theft, and the refusal to pay debts, and everything of that sort, shaping and molding the soul according to the approved marks of virtue and piety?

Protecting People With Disabilities

197 This commandment, too, is given with great propriety: it forbids anyone to blaspheme or speak ill, especially of a deaf man, and of one who cannot perceive through his outward senses the injuries done to him, nor retaliate equally in similar circumstances; for the most unjust conflict of all is the one in which one side only acts and the other only suffers. 198 And those who speak ill of the mute, or of people whose sense of hearing is defective, are committing the same offenses as those who put stumbling blocks in the way of the blind, or who offer other obstacles to their progress; for in this case also it is impossible for the blind to step over the obstacles, as they are not aware of their existence, so they stumble over them, and they are both hindered in their progress and hurt their feet.

199 Accordingly, with great propriety and fitness, the law threatens those who devise and execute wickedness of this kind with punishment at the hand of God; since he alone holds his protecting hand over those who are unable to protect themselves and defends them, and all but says in plain words to those who injure the innocent,

200 “Foolish men, do you expect to escape detection while turning the misfortunes of those men into ridicule, and committing offenses against the very parts in which they are unfortunate, attacking their ears by false accusations, and their eyes by putting stumbling blocks in their path? But you will never escape the notice of God, who sees everything and governs everything, while you insult the calamities of miserable men in this way, as though you would never meet similar distresses yourselves, since your bodies are also liable to all kinds of diseases, and your outward senses are susceptible of injury and mutilation, being such that, from a very slight and ordinary cause, they are often not only impaired, but crippled by incurable mutilations.”

201 Why then should those who forget themselves, and who in their arrogance fancy that they themselves are superior to the ordinary natural weakness of mankind, and that they are out of the reach of the invisible and unexpected attacks of fortune, which often aims sudden blows at all people, and which has often wrecked men who up to that moment had enjoyed a prosperous voyage through life, when they had almost arrived in the very harbor of ultimate happiness, why, I say, should such men gloat over and insult the misfortunes of others, having no respect for justice, the ruler of human life, who sits by the side of the great Ruler of the universe, who surveys all things with sleepless and most piercing eyes, and sees what is hidden in recesses as clearly as if it were in pure sunlight?

202 It seems to me that these men would not spare even the dead, in the extravagance of their cruelty, but, according to the proverb so commonly quoted, would even kill the slain over again, since in a sense they see fit to insult and mistreat those of their members which are already dead; for eyes which do not see are dead, and ears which are devoid of the power of hearing are devoid of life; so that if the man himself to whom these members belong were to die, they would then show their merciless and implacable nature, performing none of the humane or compassionate acts that even enemies in irreconcilable wars show to the dead. This is enough to say on this subject.

Mixtures and Unequal Pairings

203 After this the lawgiver goes on to attach to these commandments a somewhat similar harmony or series of injunctions; commanding breeders not to breed from animals of different species; not to sow a vineyard so as to make it bear two crops at once; and not to wear garments woven of two different substances, which are a mixed and inferior work. We have already mentioned the first of these injunctions in our treatise on adulterers, to make it clearer that our people ought not to be eager for marriages with foreigners, which corrupt the dispositions of the women and also destroy the good hopes that might be held for the birth of legitimate children. For the lawgiver, who has forbidden all copulation between irrational animals of different species, appears to have driven all adulterers far away altogether. 204 We must now speak of this rule again in this treatise of ours on justice. For we must take care not to pass over the opportunity of adapting it to as many particulars as possible. It is just, then, to bring together the things which are capable of union; and animals of the same species are by nature capable of union, as, on the other hand, all animals of different species are incapable of any admixture or union, and the man who brings about unlawful unions between such animals is an unjust man, transgressing the ordinances of nature.

205 But the truly sacred law takes such great care to provide for the maintenance of justice, that it will not permit even the plowing of the land to be carried on by animals of unequal strength, and forbids a farmer to plow with an ass and a heifer yoked to the same plow, for fear that the weaker animal, being compelled to exert itself to keep up with the superior power of the stronger animal, might become exhausted and sink under the effort. 206 And the bull is looked upon as the stronger animal, and is enrolled in the class of clean beasts and animals, while the ass is a weaker animal and of the class of unclean beasts; but he has nevertheless not begrudged the animals which appear weaker the help they can derive from justice, in order, I imagine, to teach judges most forcibly that they must never in their decisions give the worse fate to the humbly born, in matters the investigation of which depends not on birth but on virtue and vice.

207 The last commandment concerning things yoked in pairs resembles these injunctions: it is unlawful to wear together substances of a different character, such as wool and linen; for in the case of these substances, not only does the difference prevent any union, but also the superior strength of the one substance is more likely to tear the other than to unite with it when they are put to use.

Sowing a Vineyard With Seed

208 The commandment which came in the middle of the three injunctions about pairs was not to sow a vineyard so as to make it bear two crops at the same time; the object of this law being, in the first place, that things of different species might not be confused by being mixed together; for crops grown from seed have no connection with trees, nor trees with crops grown from seed; for this reason nature has not assigned them both the same time for the production of their fruits, but has assigned the spring to the one as the season of their harvest, and the end of summer to the others as the season for gathering their fruits. 209 Accordingly, at the same period of the year the one have withered, having bloomed earlier, while the others are just budding, having been dried up before; for the crops which are produced from seed begin to flourish in the winter, when the trees are losing their leaves; and in the spring, on the contrary, when all the crops which are produced from seed are drying up, the wood of all trees, whether wild or improved by cultivation, is putting out shoots; and one may almost say that the period in which the crops produced from seed come to perfection is the same as the one in which the crops of the trees begin to be productive.

210 Very naturally, therefore, God has separated things so wholly different from one another, both in their natures and in the period of their flowering, and in the seasons when they produce their appropriate fruits, and has appointed different situations for them, producing order out of disorder; for order is closely connected with arrangement, and disorder with a lack of arrangement.

211 In the second place, so that the two different species may not each inflict injury on the other and suffer it in return, because one kind draws the nourishment away from the other kind; and if that nourishment is divided into small portions, as happens in times of famine and of scarcity of necessaries, all plants of every kind will in every place become weak, and will be either afflicted with barrenness, becoming utterly unproductive, or at any rate will never bear reasonably fine fruit, since they have already been weakened by lack of nourishment.

212 In the third place, so that the naturally fertile land may not be oppressed with burdens beyond its strength, partly by the continued and uninterrupted thickness of the crops which are sown, and of the trees which are planted in the same place, and partly by the double crops exacted from the ground; for it ought to be quite sufficient for the owner to draw one yearly tribute from one spot, just as it is sufficient for a king to receive his tribute from a city once a year; and trying to extract larger revenues is an act of excessive covetousness, which attempts to overturn all the laws of nature.

213 For this reason the law might well say to those who have determined to sow their vineyards with seed out of pure covetousness; “Do not be worse than those kings who have subdued cities with arms and warlike expeditions, for even they, from a prudent regard for the future and from a proper wish to spare their subjects, are content to receive one payment of tribute each year, since they do not wish to reduce them utterly to the very extremity of need and distress in a short time. 214 But if in the spring you exact from the same piece of ground crops of barley and of wheat, and in the summer the crops from the fruit-bearing trees, you will be exhausting it by a double contribution; for then it will very naturally grow faint and fail, like an athlete who is never allowed any time to catch his breath and collect his strength for the beginning of another contest.

215 “But you seem to have rashly forgotten those precepts of general advantage which I instructed you to observe. For certainly, if you had remembered the commandment concerning the seventh year, in which I commanded you to allow the land to remain fallow and sacred, without being exhausted by any agricultural operation of any kind, because of the labors it has gone through and undergone for the six preceding years, producing its crops at the appointed seasons of the year in accordance with the ordinances of nature; you would not now be introducing innovations, and giving vent to all your covetous desires, by seeking unprecedented crops, sowing land fit for growing trees, and especially one planted with vines, in order by two crops every year, both founded on iniquity, to increase your substance out of undue avarice, amassing money by lawless desires.”

216 For the same man would never bring himself to let his land lie fallow every seventh year without exacting any revenue from it, so that his land would not be exhausted by overproduction but could recover by rest, and yet at the same time oppress and overwhelm it by double burdens. 217 Therefore I have judged it necessary to pronounce all acquisition or exaction of wealth in this way unholy and impious; I mean the production of the fruit of trees, and of such crops as are derived from seed, because such fertility in a sense exhausts and destroys the life-giving principle in the good soil, and also because, by requiring so much, the owner of the land is insulting and abusing the bounty and liberality of God, giving full rein to his unrighteous desires, and not restraining them by any limits.

218 Should we not, then, feel attached to commandments such as these, which tend to restrain us from the acts of covetousness common among men and to remove us far from them, blunting the edge of the passion itself? For the private individual who has learned to renounce all unrighteous gain in the matter of his plants, if he should acquire power in weightier matters and become a king, would adopt the same practice toward men and women, not exacting twofold tributes from them, not exhausting his subjects with taxes and contributions; for the habits in which he has been brought up would be sufficient for him, and would be able to soften the harshness of his disposition, and in a sense to educate him and remold him to a better character. And the better character is the one which justice impresses upon the soul.

Justice in War

219 These, then, are the laws which he lays down for each individual to observe. But there are other commandments of a more general nature which he enjoins on the whole nation in common, urging them to observe them not only with regard to their own friends and allies, but also with regard to those who are not part of their alliance. 220 For if, says Moses, they shut themselves up within their walls and make their necks stiff, then let your young men arm themselves well, and being provided with all the preparations necessary for war, go out and fortify their camp all around, and wait watchfully, not indulging their anger so as to neglect reason, but taking care to apply themselves firmly and strenuously to what must be done.

221 Let them, therefore, at once send out heralds to invite the enemy to an agreement, and at the same time let them display the power and formidable character of the encamped force; and if the enemy, repenting of the evil designs which they had conceived, submit and turn to peace in any way, then let the people gladly receive them and make a truce with them; for peace, even though it is very unfavorable, is more advantageous than war.

222 But if they persevere in their folly, and push it further, acting with audacity, then let our people display vigorous confidence, relying also on the invincible alliance of justice, and so let them advance, placing their destructive engines against the walls, and when they have made a breach in some part of them let them all go in together; and hurling their spears with accurate aim, and brandishing their swords, and killing the enemies all around, let them drive them back without flinching, inflicting on them what they themselves were meant to suffer, 223 until they have overthrown the whole army arrayed against them, every man of them, and taken their silver, and their gold, and all the booty. And let them bring fire against their city, and burn it so that it may never again, after an interval of rest, raise its head and excite wars and tumults, and also to terrify and warn the neighboring states, since it is by the calamities of others that men are taught to act with moderation. But let them allow the girls and the women to go free, since they did not expect to suffer any of the evils which war brings upon men at their hands, as they are exempt from all military service through their natural weakness.

224 From all this it is plain that the nation of the Jews is allied with and friendly to all those who are of like mind, and all who are peaceful in their intentions; and that it does not deserve contempt as a nation that submits out of cowardice to those who begin to treat it unjustly; but when it goes forth to defend itself, it distinguishes between those who are habitually plotting against it and those who are not. 225 For eagerness to kill all men, even those who have committed only slight offenses or none at all against one, I would call the conduct of an inhuman and pitiless soul, as I would also call treating women as if they were an addition to the men who carry on war, when their way of life is naturally peaceful and domestic.

Protecting Fruit Trees

226 But our lawgiver implants such a love of justice in all men who live under the institution he has established, that he does not permit them to injure the fertile land of even a hostile city by ravaging it, or by cutting down the trees, so as to destroy the crops.

227 “Why,” he says, “do you bear a grudge against inanimate things, which are in their nature quiet, and which produce wholesome fruits? Does the tree, my friend, display the hostile spirit of a man who is an enemy, so that you are to tear it up by the roots in retaliation for the evils which it has inflicted, or which it has designed to inflict upon you?

228 “On the contrary, it assists you, bestowing on you, when you are victorious, an abundance of necessary food, and of supplies which help to make life happy and luxurious; for it is not men alone who contribute revenues to their lords, but plants offer even more useful tribute at the fixed seasons of the year, a tribute without which men cannot live.”

229 But there is no prohibition against their cutting down those trees which are barren and unproductive, and which are not cultivated for food, for the purpose of making staves, or poles, or posts, or fences; and, when occasion requires, ladders, and engines, and wooden towers; for the chief use of these kinds of trees is for these and similar purposes.

Equality and Justice

230 We have now enumerated the matters which belong to justice; but as for justice itself, what poet or orator could celebrate it in worthy terms, since it is beyond all tribute of praise and all praise? At any rate, it has one most important good which, even if one were to pass over all its other parts in silence, would be an all-sufficient tribute of praise on it. 231 For this is the principle of equality, which is, as those who have accurately investigated the secrets of nature have handed down to us, the mother of justice; and equality is a light which is never shaded; the sun, to speak the plain truth, perceptible to the intellect alone, since inequality, on the contrary, in which both the superior and the inferior are found, is the beginning and source of darkness.

232 It is equality which, by its unchangeable laws and ordinances, has arranged, in their present beautiful order, all the things in heaven and earth; for who does not know this fact, that the days are measured in due proportion to the nights, and the nights in due proportion to the days, by the sun, according to the equality of proportionate distances?

233 Nature, therefore, has marked out those periods in every year, which are called the equinoxes, from the state of things which exists at that time, namely, the spring and the autumnal equinox, so distinctly that even the most illiterate people are aware of the equality which then exists between the length of the days and of the nights.

234 Again, are not the periods of the moon, as she advances and retraces her course, from a crescent to a full circle, and again, from a complete orb to a crescent, also measured by an equality of distances? For her diminution is as great and as long as the period and amount of her increase, in both respects, magnitude and duration, both in the number of days and in the size of her orb.

235 And as equality is especially honored in heaven, that purest of all essences, so she is also honored in the neighbor of heaven, the air. For as the year is portioned out into four divisions, the air is formed by nature to endure changes and alterations at what are called the seasons of the year, and it displays an indescribable regularity in its irregularity; for as the atmosphere is divided by an equal number of months into winter, and spring, and summer, and autumn, it completes the whole year by allotting three months to each season; as, in fact, the very name of the year, eniautos, suggests. For it in itself, autos en autō, contains everything, being complete in itself, though it would not be able to do this if it were not aided by the regular revolutions of the seasons of the year.

236 Again, this same equality extends from the heavenly bodies, and from those which are raised on high, to the things upon earth, raising on high its own pure nature, which is akin to the air, and sending downwards its beams like the sun, as a sort of secondary light,

237 for all the things which are inharmonious or irregular among us are caused by inequality, and all those which have the regularity that befits them are the work of equality, which in the universal essence of the universe one may fairly call the world, in cities may call that best regulated and most excellent of all constitutions, democracy, and in bodies health, and in souls virtue.

238 For, on the contrary, inequality is the cause of diseases and wickednesses; and the life of the longest-lived man of the human race would run out if he were to attempt to enumerate all the praiseworthy qualities of equality, and of its offspring, justice. So it seems best to me to be satisfied with what has already been said, which may be sufficient to rouse the memory of those who are fond of learning, and to leave the remaining matters inscribed in their souls, as divine images in a most sacred place.

Intertextual Commentary on The Special Laws, Book 4

0 commentaries

No commentary on this book yet.

Glossary

Search the Library