Go to Related Reading
About this book

The Special Laws, Book 3

De specialibus legibus 3

Philosophy and Public Affairs

1 There was once a time when, devoting my leisure to philosophy and to the contemplation of the world and the things in it, I reaped the fruit of excellent, desirable and blessed intellectual feelings, living always among the divine oracles and doctrines, on which I fed incessantly and insatiably, to my great delight, never entertaining any low or groveling thoughts, nor ever wallowing in the pursuit of glory or wealth, or the delights of the body, but I seemed to be raised on high and carried aloft by a kind of inspiration of the soul, and to live in the regions of the sun and moon, and to keep company with the whole heaven and the entire universe. 2 At that time, therefore, looking down from above, from the air, and straining the eye of my mind as from a watchtower, I surveyed all the things on the earth in unspeakable contemplation, and considered myself happy to have forcibly escaped all the evil fates that can attack human life.

3 Nevertheless, the most serious of all evils was lying in wait for me, namely envy, which hates everything good and which, attacking me suddenly, did not stop dragging me after it by force until it had seized me and thrown me into the vast sea of political cares, in which I was tossed about, and still am, unable to keep myself afloat on the surface. 4 But though I groan at my fate, I still hold out and resist, retaining in my soul the desire for learning that has been implanted in it since my earliest youth, and this desire, taking pity and compassion on me, continually raises me up and eases my sorrow. And it is through this fondness for learning that I sometimes lift up my head, and with the eyes of my soul, which are indeed dim, for the mist of affairs, wholly inconsistent with their proper objects, has overshadowed their acute clear-sightedness, I still survey, as best I can, all the things around me, eager to absorb something of a life that is pure and unmixed with evils.

5 And if a brief period of tranquility ever unexpectedly arises, a short calm and respite from the troubles of state affairs, I rise aloft and float above the troubled waves, soaring as it were in the air, and being, I might almost say, blown forward by the breezes of knowledge, which often urges me to flee away and spend all my days with her, escaping as it were from my pitiless masters, not only men but also affairs, which pour in on me from every side and at all times like a torrent. 6 Even so, I ought to give thanks to God that, though I am so overwhelmed by this flood, I am not wholly sunk and swallowed up in the depths. Instead I open the eyes of my soul, which in utter despair of any good hope I had believed to be wholly darkened already, and I am lit up with the light of wisdom, since I am not given up for the whole of my life to darkness. So I venture not only to study the sacred commands of Moses, but also with an ardent love of knowledge to investigate each separate one of them, and to try to reveal and explain to those who wish to understand them things about them that the multitude does not know.

The Commandments on the Second Table

7 And since, of the ten commandments that God himself gave to his people without the agency of any prophet or interpreter, the five engraved on the first tablet have already been discussed and explained, as have all the particular injunctions included under them; and since it is now proper to examine and expound to the best of our power and ability the rest of the commandments, those found in the second table, I will try, as before, to fit the particular ordinances implied in them to each of the general laws.

Adultery and Unrestrained Pleasure

8 The first commandment on the second table is “You shall not commit adultery,” because, I suppose, pleasure has great power in every part of the world, and no portion of the world has escaped its dominion, neither of the things on earth, nor of the things in the sea, nor even of those in the air, for all animals, whether walking on the earth, or flying in the air, or swimming in the water, always rejoice in pleasure, and cultivate it, and obey its orders, and look to its eye and to its nod, obeying it with cheerfulness, however arrogant and proud they may be, and all but anticipating its commands through the promptness and unhesitating speed of their service. 9 So even pleasure that accords with nature is often open to blame, when anyone indulges in it immoderately and insatiably, like men who are insatiably voracious in their eating, even if they take no kind of forbidden or unwholesome food; and like men who are madly devoted to association with women, and who indulge themselves immoderately, not with other men’s wives, but with their own. 10 Still, this sort of reproach, as it affects most men, belongs to the body rather than to the soul, since the body has a vehement flame within, which consumes the food which is offered to it, and soon seeks other food, because of the abundant moisture, the stream of which is conveyed into the most secret parts of the body, creating an itching, and stinging, and incessant tickling.

11 But those men who are frantic in their desires for the wives of others, and at times even for those of their nearest relations or dearest friends, and who live to harm their neighbors, trying to corrupt whole families, however numerous, and violating all kinds of marriage vows, and frustrating the hopes men have of having legitimate children, being afflicted with an incurable disease of the soul, must be punished with death as common enemies to the whole race of mankind, so that they may no longer live entirely without fear, free to corrupt other households, nor become teachers of others who may learn evil habits from their example.

Marriage and Close Relatives

12 The law has also laid down other admirable regulations concerning carnal relations; it commands men to abstain not only from the wives of others but also from certain relatives with whom it is not lawful to cohabit. 13 Therefore Moses, detesting and loathing the customs of the Persians, repudiates them as the greatest possible impiety, for the magistrates of the Persians marry even their own mothers, and consider the offspring of such marriages the most noble of all men, and, it is said, think them worthy of the highest sovereign authority.

14 And yet what can be a more heinous act of impiety than to defile the bed of one’s father after he is dead, which it would be right instead to keep untouched as sacred; and to feel no respect either for old age or for one’s mother, and for the same man to be both the son and the husband of the same woman; and again for the same woman to be both the mother and wife of the same man, and for the children of the two to be the brothers of their father and the grandsons of their mother, and for that same woman to be both the mother and grandmother of the children she has borne, and for the man to be at the same time both the father and the uterine brother of the children he has fathered? 15 These enormities once took place among the Greeks in the case of Oedipus, the son of Laius, and the actions were committed out of ignorance and not voluntarily, and yet that marriage brought on such a host of evils that nothing was lacking to complete the sum of utter wretchedness and misery, 16 for there followed from it a continual succession of wars, both domestic and foreign, which were bequeathed like an inheritance from their fathers and ancestors to their children and descendants; and there were destructions of cities which were the greatest in Greece, and destructions of embattled armies, and slaughter of nations and of allies who had come to help either side, and mutual slaughter of the most gallant leaders in each army, and irreconcilable enmities about sovereignty and authority, and fratricides, by which not only the families and countries of the persons immediately concerned were utterly extinguished and destroyed, but the greater portion of the whole Greek nation also, for cities which were previously populous now became desolate and empty of their inhabitants, and were left as a memorial of the calamities of Greece, and a miserable sight for all who saw them.

17 Nor, indeed, do the Persians, among whom such practices are frequent, avoid similar evils, for they are continually involved in military expeditions and battles, killing and being killed, at times invading their neighbors and at others repelling those who rise up against them. And many enemies rise up against them from many quarters, since it is not the nature of the barbarians to rest in tranquility; so before the current revolt is put down, another springs up, and no season of the year is ever spent in peace and quiet, but they are compelled to live under arms night and day, bearing for the greater portion of their lives hardships in the open air while serving in the camps, or else living in cities in the complete absence of any peace. 18 I refrain from mentioning the great and intolerable violence and pride of success exhibited by the kings, whose first contests, from the moment they assume sovereign power, begin with the greatest of all iniquities, fratricide, since they imagine that only in this way will they be safe from all attacks and treachery by their brothers, if they appear to have put them to death with reason and justice. 19 And it seems to me that all these things arise from the unhallowed connections of sons with their own mothers, because justice, who surveys all human affairs, takes revenge in this way on those who act improperly, for their wickedness; for not only do those who act this way commit impiety, but so do those who willingly give their assent to the lawless conduct of those who do such things.

20 But our law guards so carefully against such actions that it does not permit even a stepson, when his father is dead, to marry his stepmother, because of the respect he owes his father, and because the titles mother and stepmother are kindred names, even though the feelings of the soul may not be the same. 21 For the man who is thought to abstain from the woman who has been the wife of another man, because she is called his stepmother, will much more abstain from his own natural mother. And if anyone, out of regard for the memory of his father, shows respectful awe toward the woman who was formerly his wife, it is quite evident that he, because of the respect which he feels toward both his parents, is unlikely to contemplate any improper conduct toward his mother, since it would be downright foolishness for a man who strives to please one half of his family to appear to neglect the family as a whole.

22 Next comes a command not to marry one’s sister, an excellent injunction that contributes very greatly to temperance and good order. Therefore the Athenian lawgiver, Solon, when he permitted men to marry their sisters by the same father, forbade them to marry those by the same mother. But the lawgiver of the Lacedaemonians, on the other hand, allowed marriages between brothers and sisters by the same mothers, but forbade those between brothers and sisters by the same father. 23 The lawgiver of the Egyptians, however, ridiculing the cautious timidity of the others as if they had established imperfect ordinances, gave free rein to lasciviousness, supplying in great abundance that most incurable evil of intemperance both to body and soul, and permitting men fearlessly and with impunity to marry all their sisters, whether by both parents or by one, or by either, whether father or mother, and not only sisters younger than themselves but even those older or of the same age; for twins are very often born, whom nature has severed and separated at their very birth, but whom incontinence and love of pleasure have invited to a union that ought never to be entered into, and to a most discordant agreement.

24 But the most sacred Moses, rejecting all those ordinances with loathing, as quite inconsistent and at odds with any praiseworthy kind of constitution, and as laws which encouraged and trained people to the most disgraceful of all habits, almost peremptorily prohibited any connection with a man’s sister, whether by both parents or only by one of the two. 25 For why should anyone seek to deface the beauty of modesty? And why strip of all modesty the virgins for whom blushing is becoming? And why should anyone be willing to limit the associations and connections with other men, and to confine a most honorable thing within the narrow space of the walls of a single house, which ought rather to be extended and diffused over all continents, and islands, and the whole inhabited world? For intermarriage with strangers produces new relationships, in no way inferior to those that come from ties of blood.

Other Forbidden Marriages

26 For this reason our lawgiver has also forbidden other marriages, commanding that no man shall marry his granddaughter, whether she is his son’s or his daughter’s child; nor his niece; nor his aunt; nor his grandmother, by either father or mother; nor any woman who has been the wife of his uncle, or of his son, or of his brother; nor, again, any stepdaughter, whether virgin or widow, whether his own wife is still alive or even after her death. For, in principle, a stepfather is the same as a father, and therefore he ought to regard his wife’s daughter in the same light as his own.

27 Again, he does not permit the same man to marry two sisters, either at the same time or at different times, even if he has put away the one whom he previously married; for while she is living, whether she is cohabiting with him or whether she is put away, or if she is living as a widow, or if she is married to another man, he still did not consider it holy for her sister to take the place of the one who had been unfortunate, teaching sisters by this injunction not to violate the requirements of justice toward their relations, nor to make a stepping stone of the disasters of one so closely united to them by blood, nor to accept or take pride in attentions from those who have shown themselves enemies of their relatives, or to return any kindnesses received from them. 28 For from such things arise bitter jealousies and quarrels, and enmities that scarcely allow reconciliation but bring on indescribable hosts of misfortunes; for that would be just as if the different members of the body were to abandon the harmony and fellowship in which they are put together by nature, and to quarrel with one another, which would necessarily cause incurable diseases and harms. And sisters are like limbs, which, although they are separated from one another, are nevertheless all adapted to one another by nature and natural relationship. And jealousy, which is the most painful of all passions, is continually producing new, and terrible, and incurable harms.

29 Again, Moses commands: do not form a marriage with someone of another nation, and do not be seduced into complying with customs inconsistent with your own, and do not stray from the right way and forget the path which leads to piety, turning into a road which is no road. Perhaps you yourself will resist, if you have been trained from your earliest youth in the best possible instruction, which your parents have instilled into you, continually filling your mind with the sacred laws. And parents feel no slight anxiety and fear for their sons and daughters, for they may perhaps be lured by harmful customs instead of genuinely good ones, and so they may be in danger of learning to forget the honor belonging to the one God, which is the beginning and end of extreme unhappiness.

30 But if, the lawgiver continues, a woman who has been divorced from her husband on any pretext whatever and has married another has again become a widow, whether her second husband is alive or dead, still she must not return to her former husband, but may be united to any man in the world rather than to him, having violated and forgotten her former ties, and having chosen new allurements in the place of the old ones. 31 But if any man chooses to form an alliance with such a woman, he must be content to bear the reputation of effeminacy and a complete lack of manly courage and vigor, as if he had been castrated and deprived of the most useful portion of the soul, namely, that disposition which hates iniquity, by which the affairs both of houses and cities are placed on a good footing, and as having deeply stamped on his character two of the greatest of all iniquities, adultery and the employment of a procurer; for the reconciliations that take place afterward are proofs of both offenses. Let him therefore suffer the appointed punishment together with his wife.

Marriage and Procreation

32 And there are particular periods affecting the health of the woman when a man may not touch her; during that time he must abstain from all connection with her, respecting the laws of nature. And, at the same time, he must learn not to waste his vigor in the pursuit of an improper and barbarous pleasure; for such conduct would be like that of a farmer who, out of drunkenness or sudden insanity, sowed wheat or barley in lakes or flooded torrents, instead of over the fertile plains; for seed should be cast on fields when they are dry, so that it may bear abundant fruit. 33 But nature each month cleanses the womb, as if it were some field of marvelous fertility, and the husband, like a skillful farmer, must watch for the proper season to fertilize it, so as to withhold his seed and abstain from sowing it at a time when it is inundated; for, if he does not do so, the seed, without his perceiving it, will be swept away by the moisture, not only having all its spiritual energies relaxed, but having them, in fact, utterly dissolved. These are the agents that form animals in that workshop of nature, the womb, and who perfect with the most consummate skill each separate one of the parts of the body and soul. But when the periods of illness I have spoken of cease, then he may with confidence shower his seed into the ground ready to receive it, no longer fearing that there will be any loss of the seed thus sown.

34 But those who plow a hard and stony soil deserve to be reproached. And who can these be but those who have joined themselves to barren women? For such men are only hunters after intemperate pleasure, and in the excess of their licentious passions they deliberately waste their seed. For what other reason could they marry such women? It cannot be in the hope of children, a hope they know must necessarily be disappointed, but rather to gratify their excess in lust and incurable incontinence.

35 So all men who marry virgins without knowing whether they will prove fertile or not, and who, when after a long time they perceive from never having any children that they are barren, do not then put them away, still deserve pardon, being influenced by habit and familiarity, which are motives of great weight, and being also unable to break through the power of those ancient charms which by long habituation are stamped on their souls. 36 But those who marry women who have been previously tested by other men and ascertained to be barren, merely covet carnal enjoyment like so many boars or goats, and deserve to be inscribed on the lists of impious men as enemies to God; for God, being friendly to all the animals that exist, and especially to man, takes all imaginable care to secure preservation and duration to every kind of creature. But those who seek to waste all their power at the very moment of putting it forth are openly enemies of nature.

Sexual Conduct and the Order of Nature

37 Moreover, another evil, much greater than that which we have already mentioned, has made its way into cities and been let loose on them, namely, the love of boys, which was once considered a great infamy even to mention, but this sin is now a subject of boasting not only to those who practice it, but even to those who suffer it, and who, being accustomed to bearing the affliction of being treated like women, waste away in both soul and body, not carrying about them a single spark of a manly character to be kindled into a flame, but having even the hair of their heads conspicuously curled and adorned, and having their faces smeared with vermilion, and paint, and things of that kind, and having their eyes lined underneath, and having their skins anointed with fragrant perfumes, for in such persons as these a sweet smell is a most seductive quality, and being well equipped with everything that makes for beauty or elegance, are not ashamed to devote their constant study and efforts to the task of changing their manly character into an effeminate one. 38 And it is natural for those who obey the law to consider such persons worthy of death, since the law commands that the man-woman who adulterates the precious coinage of his nature shall die without redemption, not allowing him to live a single day, or even a single hour, as he is a disgrace to himself, and to his family, and to his country, and to the whole race of mankind. 39 And let the man who is devoted to the love of boys submit to the same punishment, since he pursues that pleasure which is contrary to nature, and since, as far as it depends on him, he would make the cities desolate, and void, and empty of all inhabitants, wasting his power of propagating his species, and moreover, being a guide and teacher of those greatest of all evils, unmanliness and effeminate lust, stripping young men of the flower of their beauty, and wasting their prime of life in effeminacy, which he ought instead to train to vigor and acts of courage; and last of all, because, like a worthless farmer, he allows fertile and productive lands to lie fallow, contriving to keep them barren, and labors night and day cultivating soil from which he never expects any produce at all.

40 And I suppose the cause of this is that among many nations there are actually rewards given for intemperance and effeminacy. At any rate, one can see men-women continually strutting through the market place at midday, and leading the processions in festivals; and, impious men as they are, receiving by lot the charge of the temple, leading the sacred and initiatory rites, and taking part even in the holy mysteries of Ceres. 41 And some of these persons have even carried their admiration of these delicate pleasures of youth so far that they have wanted to exchange their condition entirely for that of women, and have castrated themselves and have clothed themselves in purple robes, like those who, having been the cause of great blessings to their native land, walk about attended by bodyguards, pushing down everyone they meet. 42 But if there were a general indignation against those who dare to do such things, like that felt by our lawgiver, and if such men were destroyed without any chance of escape as the common curse and pollution of their country, then many other persons would be warned and corrected by their example. For the punishments of those persons who have been already condemned cannot be averted by entreaty, and so act as no slight check on those who are eager to distinguish themselves in the same pursuits.

43 But some persons, imitating the sensual indulgences of the Sybarites and of other nations more licentious still, have in the first place devoted themselves to gluttony and drunkenness, and other pleasures affecting the belly and the parts adjacent to the belly, and then, when fully sated, have behaved with such extraordinary insolence, which naturally follows satiety, that in the insanity of their passion they have gone frantic and become so maddened that they no longer desire human beings, whether male or female, but even brute beasts, as, they say, in ancient times in Crete the wife of King Minos, Pasiphaë by name, fell in love with a bull, 44 and became very violent in her passion out of despair of being able to gratify it, for love that fails of its object usually grows to no ordinary degree, so that at last she told Daedalus, the most skillful of all workmen of his time, of the affliction by which she was overwhelmed. And he, being so ingenious that his contrivances could discover things no one else could, made a cow of wood, and put Pasiphaë into it through one of the sides, and the bull rushed at the wooden cow as if it had been an animal of its own kind. And Pasiphaë, becoming pregnant in due time, gave birth to an animal half man and half beast, called the Minotaur. 45 And it is very likely that there are other Pasiphaës as well, with passions equally unbridled, and that not only women but men too may fall madly in love with animals, from whom, perhaps, indescribable monsters may be born, being memorials of the excessive pollution of men; and perhaps because of this, those unnatural creations, unprecedented and fabulous monsters, will come to exist, such as hippocentaurs and chimeras, and other similar animals.

46 But the holy laws of God take such great precautions against them that in order to prevent the possibility of men ever desiring any unlawful connection, it is expressly commanded that even animals of different kinds shall not be put together. And no Jewish shepherd will try to cross a sheep with a he-goat, or a ram with a she-goat, or a cow with a horse; and if he does, he must pay the penalty as one who breaks a solemn law of nature, which desires to keep the original kinds of animals free from all spurious mixture. 47 And some persons prefer mules to every other kind of animal for the yoke, since their bodies are very compact, and are very strong and powerful; and accordingly, in the pastures and stalls where they keep their horses, they also keep asses of an extraordinary size, which they call celones, in order that they may breed with the mares; and then the mares produce a mixed animal, half horse and half ass, and since Moses knew that its production was wholly contrary to nature, he forbade its existence with all his might by a general injunction that no union or combination between different kinds of animals should on any account be permitted.

48 So in this way he guarded against those evils in a manner suited to and consistent with nature; and from far off, as from a watchtower, he warned men and kept them in the straight path, so that both men and women, learning from his precepts, might abstain from unlawful connections.

49 If, therefore, a man seeks to indulge himself with a quadruped, or if a woman surrenders herself to a quadruped, they shall all die, both the man or woman and the quadruped. The human beings, because they have gone beyond even the bounds of intemperance itself, becoming discoverers of unprecedented appetites, and because with their new inventions they have introduced most detestable pleasures, the very mention of which is infamous; and the beasts shall die, because they have been subservient to such iniquities, and also to prevent them from bearing or siring anything intolerable, as such pollutions would naturally produce. 50 Moreover, those who care even slightly for what is fitting would never use such animals for any purpose in life, but would reject and abominate them, loathing their very sight, and thinking that whatever they touched would at once become impure and polluted. And it is not right that things of no use to life should live at all, since they are only a superfluous burden on the earth, as someone has called them.

51 Again, according to the injunctions of the sacred scriptures the constitution of the law does not recognize a harlot, since she is a person alienated from good order, and modesty, and chastity, and all other virtues, who has filled the souls both of men and women with intemperance, polluting the immortal beauty of the mind, and honoring above it the short-lived, perishable beauty of the body, prostituting herself to every chance comer, and selling her beauty as if it were some commodity in the market, doing and saying everything to catch the young men. And she excites her lovers to contests with one another, offering herself as the most disgraceful prize for those who gain the victory. Let her therefore be stoned as an injury and a harm to the whole state, and a common pollution of it, having corrupted the graces of nature, which she ought to have adorned further by her own excellence.

Suspicions of Adultery

52 The law has pronounced all acts of adultery, if caught in the act, or if proved by undeniable evidence, liable to the punishment of death; but cases in which guilt is only suspected it chooses not to have investigated by men; instead it brings them before the tribunal of nature; since men are able to judge what is visible, but God can also judge what is unseen, since he alone is able to see the soul distinctly, 53 therefore he says to the man who suspects such a thing, “Write an accusation, and go up to the holy city with your wife, and standing before the judges, lay bare the passion of suspicion which affects you, not like a false accuser or treacherous enemy, seeking to gain the victory by any means whatever, but as a man would who wishes to ascertain the truth accurately without any sophistry.”

54 And the woman, having incurred two dangers, one to her life and the other to her reputation, whose loss is worse than any kind of death, shall judge the matter within herself; and if she is pure, let her make her defense with confidence; but if she is convicted by her own conscience, let her cover her face, making her modesty the veil for her iniquities, for persisting in her impudence is the very height of wickedness.

55 But if the charge which is made against her is contested, and if the evidence is doubtful, inclining to neither side, then let the two parties go up to the temple, and let the man stand in front of the altar, in the presence of the priest for the day, and then let him state his suspicions and his grounds for them, and let him produce and offer some barley flour, as a kind of offering on behalf of his wife, to prove that he accuses her, not out of insult, but with an honest intention, because he has a reasonable doubt. 56 And the priest shall take the barley and offer it to the woman, and shall take away from her the headdress on her head, so that she may be judged with her head bare, and deprived of the symbol of modesty, which all completely blameless women are accustomed to wear; and no oil shall be used, nor any frankincense, as in the case of other sacrifices, because the sacrifice now offered is performed not on a joyful occasion but on a very distressing one.

57 And the reason why the flour is to be made of barley is, perhaps, because the food which is made of barley is of a somewhat ambiguous character, and is suited for the use both of irrational animals and of needy men; and is therefore a sign that a woman who has committed adultery differs in no respect from the beasts, whose connections with one another are promiscuous and incessant; but a woman who is free of all such accusations is devoted to the way of life that befits human beings.

58 Then the law goes on to say that the priest shall take an earthen vessel and pour into it pure water drawn from a spring, and shall also bring a lump of clay from the ground of the temple, which, I think, also carries a symbolic reference to the search for truth; for the earthenware vessel is appropriate to the commission of adultery because it is easily broken, and death is the punishment appointed for adulterers; but the earth and the water are appropriate to the purging of the accusation, since the origin, increase and perfection of all things take place through them: 59 and so it was very proper for the lawgiver to mark them both with epithets, saying that the water which the priest was to take must be pure and living water, since a blameless woman is pure in her life, and deserves to live; and the earth too is to be taken, not from just any spot, but from the soil of the ground of the temple, which must necessarily be most excellent, just as a modest woman is.

60 And when all these things have been prepared, the woman with her head uncovered, bearing the barley flour in her hand, as already specified, shall come forward; and the priest standing opposite to her and holding the earthenware vessel that holds the water and the earth, shall speak as follows:

61 “If you have not transgressed the laws of your marriage, and if no other man has been associated with you, so that you have not violated the rights of the man who is joined to you by law, you are blameless and innocent; but if you have neglected your husband and have followed empty appetites, either loving someone yourself or yielding to some lover, betraying your nearest and dearest connections, and adulterating them by a spurious mixture, then learn that you are deservedly liable to every kind of curse, the proofs of which you will exhibit on your body. Come, then, and drink the drink of conviction, which will uncover and lay bare all your hidden and secret actions.” 62 Then the priest shall write these words on a paper and dip it in the water which is in the earthenware vessel, and give it to the woman. And she shall drink it and depart, awaiting the reward of her modesty or the extreme penalty of her incontinence; for if she has been falsely accused she may hope for seed and children, setting aside all fears and anxieties about barrenness and childlessness. But if she is guilty, a great weight and bulk will come on her as her belly swells and fills, and a terribly evil condition of her womb will afflict her, since she did not choose to keep it pure for her husband, who had married her according to the laws of her nation.

63 And the law takes such great pains to prevent any irregularity in marriages, that even in the case of husbands and wives who have come together for legitimate embraces, in strict accordance with the laws of marriage, after they have risen from their beds it does not allow them to touch anything until they have performed washings and ritual bathing; keeping them very far from adultery and from all accusations referring to adultery.

Sexual Violence and Betrothal

64 But if anyone does violence to a widow after her husband is dead, or after she has otherwise been divorced from him, and defiles her, committing a lighter offense than adultery, perhaps about half as serious, he shall not be liable to the death penalty, but he shall be impeached for violence, and insolence, and intemperance, since he has adopted the most infamous conduct as if it were the most creditable; and the tribunal of the judge shall decide and condemn him to the penalty he deserves to suffer.

65 Again, seduction is an offense which is similar and nearly related to adultery, since both spring from one common mother, incontinence. But some people who are in the habit of dignifying shameful actions with misleading names call this love, blushing to admit the real truth about its character. Nevertheless, though it may be akin to adultery, it is not similar to it in every respect, because it is an offense that does not spread so as to affect many families, as is the case with adultery, but it is limited to one house alone, that of the virgin who has been seduced.

66 Therefore we must say to a man who desires to enjoy a virgin who is a free-born citizen, “My good man, reject your shameless rashness and audacity, the sources of treachery and faithlessness, and all such feelings, and do not let yourself be shown to be wicked, either openly or secretly, 67 but if, indeed, you have any legitimate feeling of love for the maiden in your soul, go to her parents, if they are alive, and if they are not, then go to her brother or to her guardians, or to any other persons who happen to be her protectors, reveal to them your feelings for her, as a free-born man should, and ask for her in marriage, and implore them not to consider you unworthy.

68 “For none of those entrusted with the guardianship of the maiden could be so base as to oppose an earnest and persevering entreaty, and especially to refuse you, since you would be found, by strict examination, not to have falsely pretended a passion which you do not feel, or to have conceived only a superficial love for her, but one which is genuine and thoroughly established.”

69 But if anyone, insane and frantic, repudiating and discarding all the suggestions of reason, were to submit himself wholly to passion and desire as his masters, and, as people say, regarding might as stronger than right, were to rape and seduce women, treating free-born women as slaves, and doing acts of war in time of peace, let such a man be led before the judges. 70 And if the young woman who has been forced has a father, let him take counsel and deal with the assailant about marrying her; then if he refuses to do so, he shall give the young woman a dowry for another husband, being fined in a sum of money sufficient for this purpose. But if he consents and registers her as his wife, let him marry her at once without any delay, confessing a second time that he owes her the same dowry, and let him not be permitted to delay or evade the fulfillment of this marriage; both so that his conduct may appear to arise from lawful love rather than lust, and so that the mishap of her first connection with a man may be remedied by a firm marriage, which nothing but death shall ever separate.

71 But if the young woman is an orphan and has no father, then let her be asked by the judges whether she is willing to take this man for her husband or not; and whether she agrees or refuses, let her still have the same dowry that the man would have agreed to give her if her father were still alive.

72 Some people think that a licensed concubinage is an offense somewhere between seduction and adultery, when the two parties come together, and agree to live as man and wife by a certain agreement, but before the marriage ceremony is completed, some other man meets the woman, or forces her, and has relations with her; but in my opinion this also is a kind of adultery; for such an agreement as is here mentioned is equivalent to a marriage, for in it the names of the woman and of the man are both registered, along with all the other things that were to lead to their union. 73 And so the law orders both parties to be stoned if with one and the same mind they agree together to commit adultery; for unless they both set out with the same intention, they cannot be regarded as equal in iniquity, since they would not both have sinned to an equal degree.

74 In any case, the offense is often made greater or lesser by the place where it is committed. For, it seems, such an offense is greater if it is committed in a city, and less if it is committed outside the walls of any city, in a wilderness; for in such a place there is no one to help the maiden, even though she may have said and done everything that could help keep her virginity unattacked and undefiled; but in a city there are halls of council, and courts of justice, and great assemblies of generals, and aediles, and rulers of the markets, and other magistrates; and besides all these there is the populace. 75 For there is in the soul of every man, even though he may be a private individual, a feeling hostile to iniquity which, when it is roused, makes the man who holds it a champion for the moment, and a spontaneous and voluntary defender of the person who appears to be unjustly treated.

76 Therefore justice in every case pursues the man who has committed violence, nor is his iniquity excused by the difference of the place, so that no plea can defend him from the consequences of his violence and lawlessness; but as I have said before, there will be compassion and pardon for the young woman in the one case, and in the other, inexorable punishment will fall on her.

77 And in her case the judge must examine the matter very carefully, not referring everything to the place or making everything depend on it; for it is possible that a woman may be raped against her will even in the middle of the city; and on the other hand, even outside the city, she may have voluntarily given herself up to an illicit connection. So the law, making a very careful and admirably conceived defense on behalf of a young woman raped in the wilderness, says, “for the young woman cried out, and there was no one to help her.” so that if she neither cried out nor resisted, but willingly consented to her assailant, she must be regarded as guilty, having merely put forward the place as a sophistical excuse to make it appear that she had been raped.

78 And yet in the city what use are her efforts to a young woman, who is willing to do everything for the sake of preserving her own reputation, but who is unable to succeed because of the strength of the man who is assaulting her? for what help could she get from those who live in the same house if he were to bind her with ropes, or to gag her mouth, so that she could not utter even a word; for in a sense she is then, though living in a city, really in a wilderness, since she is without any protection; but if she is in a wilderness, and yet willingly gives herself up to her ravisher, she is in no different condition from a woman in a city.

False Accusations Against a Wife

79 There are also some people who are easily satisfied with intercourse with the same woman, being at once mad for women and haters of women, full of promiscuous and irregular dispositions, who immediately give themselves up to their first impulses, whatever they may be; letting the passions they ought to curb run without restraint, and like blind men, without any consideration, without any prudence, stumbling into any body or anything, upsetting, and overturning, and confusing everything in their violent impetuosity and haste, and suffering evils as great as those they inflict.

80 And concerning these men this law has been enacted. When those men who marry virgins in accordance with the law, and who have sacrificed on the occasion and celebrated their marriage feast, but who afterward keep no natural affection for their wives but treat them with insolence, and treat freeborn citizens as if they were courtesans, if they seek a divorce and, unable to find any pretext for such a separation, resort to bringing false accusations, and, lacking any clear grounds for a charge, direct all their charges at things that cannot be proved, and come forward and accuse them, saying that though they thought they were marrying virgins, they found the first time they had intercourse that they were not. When, I say, these men make such charges, let all the elders assemble to decide on the case, and let the parents of the woman who is accused also appear, to make their defense in this danger they share. 81 For in such a case, not only are the daughters themselves in danger, as to their reputation for having preserved the chastity of their bodies, but their guardians are likewise imperiled, not only because they have not kept them safe until the important time when they reached marriageable age, but because they have given in marriage as virgins those who have been defiled by others, deceiving and imposing on those who have taken them as wives.

82 Then if they appear to have justice on their side, let the judges impose a fine of money on those who have invented these false accusations, and let them also sentence those who have assaulted them to bodily punishment, and let them also pronounce what will be the most unpleasant thing of all to those men, a confirmation of their marriage, if their wives are still willing to live with them; for the law permits them at their own choice to remain with them or to abandon them, and will not allow the husbands any option either way, on account of the false accusations which they have brought.

Murder and Its Punishment

83 The name of homicide is given to the man who has killed another; but in truth it is a sacrilege, and the very greatest of all sacrileges, because, of all the possessions and sacred treasures in the whole world, there is nothing more holy in appearance, nor more godlike than man, the all-beautiful copy of an all-beautiful model, a representation admirably made after an archetypal rational idea. 84 We must therefore, without hesitation, pronounce the homicide or murderer an impious and atrociously wicked person, since he commits the greatest of all atrocities and impieties, and he ought to be put to death as having done things which can never be pardoned, since, being worthy of ten thousand deaths, he escapes with only one, because death, being an easy road, does not allow his existence to be prolonged, so as to endure a multitude of punishments; but there can be nothing wrong in his suffering the same treatment he has inflicted on others,

85 and yet how can it be the same, if it differs in its time, in its manner of infliction, in its intention and in the persons involved? Does the violence not begin first, and the repelling of it or retaliation for it come afterward? And is murder not the most lawless of all things, but the punishment of murderers the most lawful action possible? Again, the man who has killed another has satisfied the desire he had when he killed him; but the man who has been killed, since he is now out of the way, can neither attack him in retaliation, nor can he gratify himself by taking revenge. Moreover, the one was able with his own hands to carry out the designs which he conceived by himself; but the other can never succeed in procuring his punishment, unless his relations and friends become his champions, taking compassion on him for the disaster that has happened to him.

86 Now if anyone aims a blow with a sword at anyone, with the intention of killing him, and does not kill him, he will still be guilty of murder, since he was a murderer in his intention, even though the end did not keep pace with his wish. Again, let the same punishment apply to the man who, by previous contrivance and machinations, not daring to behave bravely, and to stand face to face with his enemy and attack him openly, treacherously plots and contrives his slaughter; for such a man is equally liable to the curse denounced against murderers, and even if he is not a murderer with his hands, he is one in his soul. 87 For, in my opinion, just as we must regard as enemies not only those who fight against us by sea or by land, but also those who are prepared for either kind of warfare, and who are erecting battering rams and engines against our harbors and our walls; and just as we do in fact judge them so, even though they come to no actual conflict, so also we must count as murderers not only those who perform the mere act of killing, but those who do anything which tends to killing, whether openly or secretly, even if they do not eventually perpetrate the action.

88 And if out of fear or out of audacity, two very contrary feelings, but both blameworthy, they venture to flee to the temple as if they would find asylum there, we must prevent their doing so, if we can: but if they get there before us and do get in, then we must take them out and give them up for execution, affirming the principle that the temple does not give an asylum to impious men; for everyone who commits actions of incurable guilt is an enemy to God; and murderers do commit such actions, since those who are murdered have suffered disasters which are incurable. 89 Or shall we say that to those who have done no wrong the temple is still inaccessible until they have washed themselves, and sprinkled themselves, and purified themselves with the accustomed purifications; but that those who are guilty of indelible crimes, the pollution of which no length of time will ever efface, may approach and dwell among those holy seats; though no decent person who has any regard for holy things would even receive them into his house?

90 Therefore, since they have heaped iniquity on iniquity, adding lawlessness and impiety to murder, they must be dragged out of the temple to undergo their punishment, since, as I have said before, they have committed actions worthy of ten thousand deaths instead of one; for otherwise the temple would be closed to the relatives and friends of the man who has been so treacherously murdered, if the murderer were living in it, since they could never bear to come into the same place as him. But it would be absurd for a great number of people, and those the very people he has injured, to be excluded from the temple for the sake of one man, and the most lawless of men at that, men who, besides having done no wrong themselves, have even suffered an untimely affliction through his actions. 91 And perhaps, indeed, the lawgiver seeing far into the future by the acuteness of his reasoning powers, was by such commandments guarding against any bloodshed ever taking place in the temple through the entrance of any of the friends of the murdered man, for natural affection, a very ungovernable feeling, would urge them, full of enthusiasm and violent rage as they would be, almost to kill the murderer with their own hands, and if that were to happen it would be a most impious sacrilege; for then the blood of the sacrifices would be mingled with the blood of murderers; what has been consecrated to God with what is wholly impure. This is why Moses commands that the murderer shall be given up, even from the altar itself.

92 But some people who have killed others with swords, or spears, or darts, or clubs, or stones, or something of that kind, may possibly have done so without any previous design, and without having planned this deed in their hearts for some time beforehand, but may have been excited at the moment, yielding to passion more powerful than their reason, to commit the homicide; so that it is only half a crime, since the mind had not been occupied by the pollution for a long time beforehand.

Poisoning and Sorcery

93 But there are also others of the greatest wickedness, men polluted both in hands and mind, who are sorcerers and poisoners, who devote all their leisure and all their solitude to planning well-timed attacks on others, and who invent all kinds of contrivances and devices to bring about disasters on their neighbors. 94 For this reason Moses commands that poisoners and sorceresses shall not be allowed to live one day or even one hour, but that they shall be put to death the moment that they are taken, with no pretext allowed them for even a moment to put off or delay their punishment. For anybody may guard against those who attack one openly and to one’s face; but the cunning of those who plot against one secretly, and who disguise their attacks by the concealed approaches of poison, is not easy to see beforehand.

95 It is necessary, therefore, to anticipate them, inflicting on them the death that others would otherwise have suffered at their hands. Besides this, the man who openly kills someone with a sword, or with any similar weapon, can only kill a few persons at one time; but one who mixes and compounds poisonous drugs with food, may destroy countless companies at once who do not suspect his treachery. 96 Accordingly, it has happened before now that very large parties of men who have come together in good fellowship to eat of the same salt and to sit at the same table, have suffered at such a time of harmony things wholly incompatible with it, being suddenly killed, and have thus met with death instead of feasting. For this reason it is fitting that even the most merciful, and gentle, and moderate of men should approve the execution of such persons, who are all but the same as murderers who kill with their own hand; and that they should think it consistent with holiness not to commit their punishment to others, but to execute it themselves.

97 For how can it be anything but a most terrible evil for anyone to contrive the death of another by the very food that is given as the cause of life, and to change what is nourishing by nature so as to make it destructive; so that those who, in obedience to the necessities of nature, have recourse to eating and drinking, having no previous idea of any treachery, take destructive food as though it were wholesome?

98 Again, let the same punishment fall on those who, though they do not compound drugs that are actually deadly, nevertheless administer drugs that cause long diseases; for death is often a lesser evil than diseases; and especially than those that extend over a long time and have no fortunate or favorable end. For the illnesses which arise from poisons are difficult to cure, and are often completely incurable. 99 Moreover, in the case of men who have been exposed to machinations of this kind, it often happens that diseases of the mind ensue which are worse even than the afflictions of the body; for they are often attacked by delirium and insanity, and intolerable frenzy, through which the mind, the greatest blessing which God has bestowed on mankind, is impaired in every possible way, despairing of any safety or cure, and so is utterly removed from its seat, and expelled, as it were, leaving in the body only the inferior portion of the soul, namely, its irrational part, which even beasts share, since every person who is deprived of reason, which is the better part of the soul, is changed into the nature of a beast, even though the characteristics of the human form remain.

100 The true magical art, a science of discernment, which contemplates and sees the books of nature with a more acute and distinct perception than usual, and so regarded as a dignified and desirable branch of knowledge, is studied not merely by private individuals, but even by kings, and the very greatest of kings, and especially by the Persian monarchs, so much so that they say that among that people no one can possibly succeed to the kingdom unless he has first been initiated into the mysteries of the magi. 101 But there is a certain adulterated form of this science, which may more properly be called wicked imposture, pursued by quacks, cheats and buffoons, and by the vilest of women and slaves, professing to understand all kinds of incantations and purifications, and promising to change the dispositions of those on whom they operate so as to turn those who love to unalterable enmity, and those who hate to the most excessive affection by certain charms and incantations; and thus they deceive and gain influence over men of unsuspicious and innocent dispositions, until they fall into the greatest misfortunes, through which the bonds uniting great numbers of friends and relatives have gradually decayed and then been rapidly destroyed without a sound.

102 And I imagine that the lawgiver, having regard to all these circumstances, would for that reason not permit the punishments due to poisoners to be postponed to any later occasion, but ordained that the executioners should at once proceed to inflict the due penalty on them; for delay rather excites the guilty to make use of the time that is allowed them to carry out their iniquities, since they are already condemned to death, while it fills those who are already suspicious and apprehensive of misfortune with a more urgent fear, as they regard the life of their enemies as their own death.

103 Therefore, just as when we merely see snakes, and serpents, and any other venomous animals, we at once, without a moment’s delay, kill them before they can bite, or wound, or attack us at all, taking care not to expose ourselves to any injury from them because we know the mischief inherent in them; in the same way it is right to punish promptly those men who, though they have had a gentle nature assigned to them by means of that fountain of reason which is the cause and source of all society, nevertheless deliberately change it themselves to the ferocity of untamable beasts, regarding injury to as many people as they can reach as their greatest pleasure and advantage.

Killing in Anger

104 This is enough to say for now about poisoners and magicians. Moreover, we should also be aware that very often unexpected occasions arise in which a person kills a man without ever having prepared himself for this action, but because he has been suddenly transported with anger, which is an intolerable and terrible feeling, and which injures beyond all other feelings both the man who feels it and the man who has provoked it. 105 For sometimes a man who has come into the market-place on some important business meets someone who is inclined to accuse him rashly, or who attempts to assault him, or who begins to pick a quarrel with him and engages him in a conflict, and, to get away from him and escape him more quickly, either strikes his opponent with his fist or takes up a stone and throws it at him and knocks him down.

106 And if the wound which the man has received is mortal, so that he at once dies, then let the man who has struck him also die, suffering himself the same fate he inflicted on the other. But if the man does not die immediately after receiving the blow, but is afflicted by illness in consequence and takes to his bed, and after proper care gets up again, even though he may not be able to walk well without support, but may require someone to support him or a stick to lean on, in that case the man who struck him shall pay a double penalty, one as an atonement for the injury done, and one for the expenses of the cure. 107 And when he has paid this he shall be acquitted of the death penalty, even if the man who has received the blow should subsequently die; for perhaps he did not die of the blow, since he got better after that and recovered enough to walk, but perhaps he died from some other causes, such as often suddenly attack and kill those in the most vigorous bodily health.

Pregnancy and the Protection of Children

108 But if anyone fights with a pregnant woman, and strikes her a blow on her belly, and she miscarries, if the child conceived within her is still unfashioned and unformed, he shall be punished by a fine, both for the assault which he committed and also because he has prevented nature, who was fashioning and preparing that most excellent of all creatures, a human being, from bringing him into existence. But if the child conceived had taken on a distinct shape in all its parts, having received all its proper connective and distinctive qualities, he shall die. 109 For such a creature is a man, whom he has killed while still in the workshop of nature, who had not yet thought it the proper time to bring him into the light, but had kept him like a statue lying in a sculptor’s workshop, requiring nothing more than to be released and sent out into the world.

110 Because of this commandment he also adds another, more important proposition, in which the exposure of infants is forbidden, which has become a very common piece of wickedness among other nations because of their natural inhumanity. 111 For if it is proper to provide for what has not yet been brought into being, because of the definite periods of time such a process requires, so that even it may not suffer any injury from being plotted against, how can it not be even more necessary to take similar care of the child once it has been brought to perfection and born, and sent out, as it were, into that colony which has been assigned to the human race, for the purpose of having a share of the bounties of nature which she sends out from the land, and from the water, and from the air, and from the heaven? Bestowing on men the sight of the heavenly bodies, and the power and supreme authority over all the things on earth, and supplying all the external senses with abundant supplies of all things, and presenting to the mind as the great king, by means of those outward senses as its bodyguards, all the things which are visible to them, and, without employing their agency, all those things which are appreciable only by reason.

112 Accordingly, let those parents who deprive their children of all these blessings, giving them no share of any one of them from the moment of their birth, know that they are violating the laws of nature, and accusing themselves of the very greatest enormities, of a devotion to pleasure, and a hatred of their species, and murder, and the very worst kind of murder, infanticide. 113 For those men are devoted to pleasure who, when they have relations with women, are not moved by the wish to produce children and perpetuate their race, but are like boars or he-goats seeking only the enjoyment that such relations bring. Again, who could hate their own kind more than those who are the implacable and ferocious enemies of their own children? Unless, of course, anyone is so foolish as to imagine that men who act barbarously toward those bound to them by ties of blood can be humane to strangers.

114 And their murders and infanticides are proved beyond all denial, since some of them kill their children with their own hands, stifling their first breath and smothering it altogether, out of a terribly cruel and unfeeling disposition; others tie a weight to them and throw them into the depths of a river or the sea, so that the weight makes them sink to the bottom more quickly. 115 Others carry them out to a deserted place and expose them there, in the hope, so they say, that someone may save them, but in truth to load them with still more painful suffering; for there, with no one to keep them off, all the beasts that devour human flesh attack them and feast on the delicate banquet of the children, while their only guardians, the people bound above all others to protect and save them, their own father and mother, have exposed them. And carnivorous birds fly down and lick up what is left of their bodies, when they have not found them first; when they do find them first, they do battle with the beasts of the earth for the whole carcass.

116 And suppose that someone passing along the road is moved by gentle compassion to take pity on the exposed infants and show them mercy, picking them up, feeding them and giving them the rest of the care they need: what do we think of such a humane act? Do we not regard it as an outright condemnation of the real parents, when people in no way related to the children show the tender foresight of parents, while the parents do not show even the kindness of strangers?

117 So Moses has tacitly but utterly prohibited the exposure of children, when he condemns to death, as I said before, anyone who causes a miscarriage in a woman whose unborn child is already formed. And yet those who have investigated the secrets of natural philosophy say that children still within the belly, while they are contained in the womb, are part of their mothers. The most highly esteemed physicians, who have studied the formation of man by anatomy, scrutinizing both what is easily seen and what is carefully hidden, so that if any case should need their attention nothing may be overlooked through ignorance and so cause serious harm, agree with them and say the same thing. 118 But when the children are born, separated from what is produced with them, and set free on their own, they become real living creatures, lacking nothing that can contribute to the perfection of human nature, so that beyond all question anyone who kills an infant is guilty of homicide, and the law shows its indignation at such an act. The law is guided not by the age but by the species of the creature against whom its ordinances are violated.

119 If it did seem reasonable to take age into account at all, I think one might very reasonably be even more indignant at those who kill infants. For when grown adults are killed, there may be ten thousand plausible excuses for attacks on them or quarrels with them; but against mere infants, only just launched into human life and shown the light of day, not even the greatest liar can invent an accusation, since they are wholly innocent of offense. So those who plot the destruction of these infants ought to be regarded as the most inhuman and pitiless of all men, and the sacred law justly detests such criminals and pronounces them worthy of death.

Unintentional Homicide and Cities of Refuge

120 The sacred law says that a man killed by someone who never intended to kill him has been given up by God into the hands of his killers; in this way it means to excuse the man who appears to have killed him, as if he had killed a guilty person. 121 For the merciful and forgiving God can never be supposed to have given up any innocent person to be put to death; but whoever cleverly escapes the judgment of a human tribunal through his own cunning and wariness is convicted when brought before the invisible tribunal of nature, which alone discerns the uncorrupted truth and is never kept in the dark by the tricks of sophistical argument. For such an investigation admits no arguments at all; it lays bare every device and intention and brings the most secret plans to light; and in one sense it does not hold a man who has killed another liable to justice, since he has sinned only in serving as the minister of a divine judgment; still, he will have incurred a faint and slight kind of defilement, which may, however, be excused and pardoned.

122 For God uses those who commit slight and remediable errors as ministers of punishment against those who have committed enormous and unpardonable crimes; not that he approves of them, but he makes use of them as suitable instruments of punishment, so that no one who is himself pure in his whole life and descended from virtuous parents may have homicide imputed to him, even if he is the greatest man in the world.

123 So the law has sentenced anyone who has killed a man to banishment, yet not banishment to just anywhere, nor forever; for it has assigned six cities, a quarter of what the whole sacred tribe received as its inheritance, to those convicted of homicide, and from the circumstances connected with them it has named them cities of refuge. And it set the length of this banishment at the lifetime of the high priest, permitting the exiles to return home after his death.

124 The reason for the first of these injunctions was this. The tribe just mentioned received these cities as a reward for a justified and holy slaughter, which we must regard as the most illustrious and important of all the gallant deeds ever performed.

125 For when the prophet, called up to the loftiest and most sacred of all the mountains in that district, was divinely instructed in the generic outlines of all the special laws, and was out of his people’s sight for many days, those of the people who were not peaceable by nature filled every place with the evils which arise from anarchy, and crowned all their iniquity with open impiety, ridiculing all the excellent and beautiful lessons concerning the honor due to the one true and living God, making a golden bull, an imitation of the Egyptian Typhos, bringing it unholy sacrifices and unhallowed festivals, and instituting profane and impious dances, with songs and hymns instead of lamentations. 126 Then the tribe just mentioned, intensely indignant at the people’s sudden departure from their former customs, and inflamed with zeal by their natural hatred of iniquity, all became full of rage and divine enthusiasm, and, arming themselves as if at one signal, fell on the people with great contempt in one unanimous attack, while they were drunk with a twofold intoxication of impiety and wine, beginning with their nearest and dearest friends and relations, since they considered those who loved God their only relations and friends. And in a very small part of the day, twenty-four thousand men were killed, and their disaster was a warning to those who would otherwise have joined in their iniquity, but who were now afraid of suffering a similar fate.

127 Since these men had undertaken this expedition of their own accord and spontaneously, in the cause of piety and holy reverence for the one true and living God, and at great danger to those who had entered the contest, the Father of the universe received them with approval, and at once declared those who had killed those men pure from all curse and pollution, and in return for their courage he bestowed the priesthood on them.

128 So the lawgiver commands that a man who has killed unintentionally should flee to one of the cities which this tribe has received as its inheritance, to reassure him and teach him not to despair of safety, and to make him, while kept safe by the privilege of the place, remember and consider that on certain occasions those who have deliberately killed someone are not only forgiven but are even given great and preeminent honors and abundant happiness. And if such honors can ever be granted to those who have killed a man voluntarily, how much more must allowance be made for those who did so with no intent, so that, even if they receive no honor, they may at least not be condemned to death in retaliation. By these injunctions the lawgiver indicates that not every kind of homicide is blameworthy, but only the kind combined with injustice; that some other kinds, committed out of desire and zeal for virtue, are even praiseworthy; and that unintentional homicide is not greatly to be blamed.

129 That is enough to say about the first cause; now we must explain the second. The law sees fit to preserve a man who has killed another without intending to, knowing that he was not guilty in his intention, but that with his hands he has served the justice that presides over all human affairs. For the dead man’s nearest relations lie in wait for him with hostile intent, seeking his death, while others, out of excessive compassion and inconsolable grief for the dead, are eager to avenge them, and in their unreasoning impetuosity disregard both the truth and the justice of nature. 130 So the law directs a man who has committed homicide in these circumstances not to flee to the temple, since he is not yet purified, nor to some neglected and obscure place, for fear that, being despised, he would be handed over to his enemies without resistance; but to flee to the sacred city, which lies on the border between holy and profane ground and is in a way a second temple; for the cities of those consecrated to the priesthood deserve more respect than the others, in the same proportion, I think, as their inhabitants are more venerable than the inhabitants of other cities; for the lawgiver’s intention is to give the fugitives more complete security through the privilege belonging to the city that has received them.

131 Moreover, as I said before, he has appointed the death of the high priest as the time for their return, for the following reason. Just as the relations of each person who has been treacherously killed lie in wait to secure revenge and justice against those who treacherously killed him, so the high priest is the relation and nearest kin of the whole nation; since he presides over all who bring disputes and dispenses justice to them according to the laws, and offers up prayers and sacrifices every day on behalf of the whole nation, and prays for blessings for the people as for his own brothers, and parents, and children, so that every age and every part of the nation, as if it were one body, may be united into one and the same society and union, devoted to peace and obedience to the law. 132 So let everyone who has killed a man unintentionally fear him, as the champion and defender of the cause of the killed, and keep himself close within the city to which he has fled for refuge, no longer venturing outside the walls, if he cares at all for his own safety and for keeping his life out of the reach of danger. 133 So when the law says, do not let the fugitive return until the high priest is dead, it is saying in effect: Until the high priest is dead, who is the common relation of all the people, and who alone is entrusted with deciding the affairs of the living and the dead.

134 This, then, is the reason fit to be spoken into the ears of the younger men. But there is another that may well be set before those who are older and settled in character, and it is this. Private individuals are required only to be pure from voluntary offenses, or, if anyone chooses, he may add the other priests to this list as well; but purity from both kinds, that is, from both voluntary and involuntary offenses, can be given only to the high priest, as a special honor. 135 For it is altogether unlawful for him to touch any pollution whatever, whether intentionally or out of some unforeseen perversion of soul, so that he, as the declarer of the will of God, may be adorned in both respects, with a disposition free from reproach and a prosperous life, a man to whom no disgrace ever attaches.

136 It suits the character of such a man to look with suspicion on those who have killed a man even unintentionally, not regarding them as under a curse, but not as pure and wholly free from offense either, even though they may seem to have obeyed the intention of nature completely, who used them as her instruments to avenge herself on those they killed, whom she had privately judged on her own and condemned to death. That is enough to say about free men and citizens. The lawgiver then proceeds, in due order, to lay down laws about slaves who are killed by violence.

The Killing of Slaves

137 Servants are, indeed, in an inferior condition of life, but they share the same nature as their masters. And under the divine law the rule of justice is not the condition of fortune but the harmony of nature. So masters ought not to use their power over their slaves insolently, displaying by such conduct their insolence, their overbearing disposition and their terrible cruelty; for such conduct is proof not of a peaceful soul, but of one that, unable to govern itself, covets the unaccountable power of a tyrant. 138 For the man who fortifies his own house like a citadel, and does not allow a single person within it to speak freely, but behaves savagely to everyone because of his innate misanthropy and barbarity, which practice has perhaps even increased, is a tyrant in miniature; and his present conduct plainly shows that he will not stop even there if he gains greater power.

139 For then, having first enslaved his own native land, he will at once go out to attack other cities and countries and nations, proving that he is not inclined to show mercy to anyone who ever becomes subject to him. 140 So let such a man be well assured that he will not always escape punishment for his continual ill-treatment of many people; for justice, who hates iniquity and is the helper and champion of those who are treated unjustly, will be his enemy, and she will demand from him a strict account and reckoning for those who have fallen into misfortune through him,

141 even if he says that he only beat them to correct them, not meaning to kill them. For he will not get off at once with a cheerful face; he will be brought before the tribunal and examined by careful investigators of the truth, who will inquire whether he killed him intentionally or unintentionally. And if he is found to have plotted against him with wicked intent, let him die, and let no excuse be made to secure his release on the ground that he is the servant’s master. 142 But if the beaten servants do not die immediately after the blows, but live a day or two, then the master shall no longer be liable to a charge of murder, for he has this strong defense: that he did not kill them on the spot by beating them, nor afterward while he had them in his house, but let them live as long as they could, even if that was not very long. Besides, no one is so foolish as to try to harm another by conduct that will make him a loser too.

143 But anyone who kills his servant injures himself much more, since he deprives himself of the services he received from the servant while he was alive, and loses besides the price he paid for him, which was perhaps a large one. If, however, the servant turns out to have done something worthy of death, let the master bring him before the judges and prove his offense, making the laws, not himself, the arbiters of his punishment.

Deaths Caused by Animals

144 If a bull gores a man and kills him, let him be stoned. For his flesh may neither be offered in sacrifice by the priests nor eaten by men. Why not? Because the law of God does not allow a man to take as food, or as seasoning for his food, the flesh of an animal that has killed a man.

145 But if the owner of the beast knew that it was a savage and ferocious animal and did not confine it, shut it up or look after it, or if he had heard from others that it was not tame and still let it graze freely, he shall be liable to prosecution as guilty of the man’s death. And then the animal that gored the man shall die, and its master shall be put to death too, or else pay a ransom as the price of his safety, and the court of justice shall decide what punishment he ought to suffer or what penalty he ought to pay. 146 And if a slave has been killed, the owner shall pay the slave’s full value to his master; but if the bull has gored not a man but another animal, then the owner of the beast that killed it shall take the dead animal and give its master another like it in its place, because he knew beforehand how fierce his own beast was and did not guard against it. And if the bull has killed a sheep belonging to someone else, he shall again give the man one like it in its place, and be thankful to him for not demanding a greater penalty, since he was the first to do any injury.

Pits and Unprotected Roofs

147 Some people commonly dig very deep pits, either to open springs that may bubble up or to collect rain water, and then they widen drains underground; in that case they ought either to build a wall around their mouths or to put a cover on them; yet out of shameful carelessness or foolishness they often leave such places open, and some people have met their death that way. 148 So if a traveler passing along the road, not knowing beforehand that there is any such pit, steps on the hole, falls in and is killed, any relation of the dead man who chooses may bring an accusation against those who made the pit, and the tribunal shall decide what punishment they ought to suffer, or what penalty they ought to pay. But if a beast falls in and perishes, those who dug the pit shall pay its owner its value as if it were still alive, and they shall keep the dead body for themselves.

149 Again, those who build houses and leave the roof flat, when they ought to protect it with a parapet so that no one unexpectedly falls from it, are also committing an injury akin to and like the one just mentioned. For such men, to tell the plain truth, are committing murder as far as it depends on them, even if no one falls in and perishes; so let them be punished equally with those who leave the mouths of pits open.

Punishment for Murder

150 The law expressly forbids taking any ransom from murderers who ought to be put to death, to lessen their punishment or to substitute banishment for death. For blood must be atoned for by blood: the blood of the one treacherously killed by the blood of the one who killed him.

151 Men of wicked dispositions never tire of offending, but in the excess of their wickedness are always committing atrocious acts, increasing their iniquities and extending them beyond all bounds or limits. The lawgiver would, if it had been in his power, have condemned those men to ten thousand deaths. But since this was not possible, he prescribed another punishment for them, commanding those who had killed a man to be hanged on a tree. 152 And after establishing this ordinance he returned to his natural humanity, treating mercifully even those who had behaved unmercifully toward others, and he declared, “Do not let the sun set on persons hanging on a tree.” but let them be buried under the earth and be concealed from sight before sunset. For it was necessary to raise up high all those who were enemies of every part of the world, to show as plainly as possible to the sun, and to the heaven, and to the air, and to the water, and to the earth, that they had been punished; and after that it was proper to remove them to the region of the dead and bury them, so that they would not pollute the things on the earth.

Individual Responsibility

153 Moreover, there is this further and very fitting commandment: fathers are not to die for their sons, nor sons for their parents, but everyone who has done things worthy of death is to be put to death on his own. This commandment is laid down because of those who set might above right, and also for the sake of those who are too affectionate. 154 For these last, out of extraordinary and extravagant good will, are often cheerfully willing to die for others, the innocent giving themselves up for the guilty and thinking it a great gain not to see them punished; or else sons giving themselves up for their fathers, thinking that, if deprived of them, they would live a miserable life from then on, worse than any kind of death.

155 But to such persons one must say, “This good-will of yours is untimely.” And everything untimely is very properly blamed, just as what is done at the right time is praised for that reason. Moreover, it is right to love those whose actions deserve love. But no wicked man can really be a friend to anyone. And when men violate all the principles of justice, wickedness alienates relations, even the most devoted of them. For agreement on the principles of justice and on the other virtues is a closer tie than relationship by blood; and if anyone violates such an agreement, he is counted not only as a stranger and a foreigner, but even as an irreconcilable enemy.

156 “Why then do you pervert and misapply the name of good-will, a most excellent and humane name, and conceal the truth behind the veil of an effeminate and womanly disposition? For are not people womanly when reason in their minds is overcome by compassion? And you do this to commit a double iniquity, freeing the guilty from punishment and thinking it fair to punish yourselves in their place, though you are in no way to blame.”

157 But these men say in their own defense that they are not pursuing any private advantage for themselves, and that they are moved by excessive affection for their nearest relations, whom they will cheerfully die to save.

158 But who, not just among moderate men but even among those very inhuman in disposition, would not reject such barbarous and truly brutal people as those who, either by secret contrivance or by open audacity, inflict the greatest disasters on one person as a punishment for the faults of another, putting forward as a pretext the plea of friendship, or of relationship, or of fellowship, or something of that kind, as a justification for the destruction of those who have done no wrong? And sometimes they even do these things, without having suffered any injury at all, out of mere covetousness and greed for stolen goods.

159 Not long ago a man who had been appointed tax collector in our country, when some of those who seemed to owe such tribute fled out of poverty, fearing intolerable punishment if they stayed without paying, carried off their wives, and their children, and their parents, and their whole families by force, beating and insulting them, and heaping every kind of insult and ill treatment on them, to make them either reveal where the fugitives were hiding or pay the money in their place, though they could do neither the one thing nor the other; in the first place, because they did not know where they were, and secondly, because they were in still greater poverty than the men who had fled. 160 But this tax-collector did not let them go until he had tortured their bodies with racks and wheels, so as to kill them with newly invented kinds of death, fastening a basket full of sand to their necks with cords, and suspending it there as a very heavy weight, and then setting them in the open air in the middle of the market place, so that some of them, tortured and overwhelmed by all these afflictions at once, the wind, and the sun, and the mockery of the passers by, and the shame, and the heavy burden attached to them, might faint miserably; and that the rest, as spectators, might be grieved and take warning from their punishment,

161 some of whom, feeling such miseries more acutely in their minds than through their eyes, since they sympathized with these unfortunates as if they were themselves suffering in the persons of others, put an end to their own lives by swords, or poison, or halters, thinking it a great piece of good luck for people exposed to such misery to be able to die without torture. 162 But those who did not hurry to kill themselves, and were seized before they could, were led away in a row, as in lawsuits over inheritance, in order of nearness of kin, the nearest relations first, then those next to them in succession, in the second or third place, till they came to the last; and then, when there were no relations left, the cruelty moved on to the friends and neighbors of the fugitives; and sometimes it was extended even into the cities and villages, which soon became desolate, being emptied of all their inhabitants, who all left their homes and scattered to places where they hoped to escape detection.

163 But perhaps it is not surprising if men who are barbarians by nature, utterly ignorant of all gentleness, and under the command of despotic authority, which compelled them to give an account of the yearly revenue, should, to enforce payment of the taxes, extend their harshness not merely to property but also to the persons, and even to the lives, of those from whom they thought they could exact a vicarious payment.

164 But now even those who are the very standard and rule of justice, the lawgivers themselves, looking to appearance rather than truth, have allowed themselves to become standards of injustice instead, commanding the children of a traitor to be put to death with the traitor himself, and, in the case of tyrants, the five families most closely related to them. 165 Why is this, I would ask? For if indeed they have shared in their wickedness, then let them likewise share in their punishment; but if they have not participated in that, and if they have not been imitators of such actions, and if they have not been so elated by their kinsmen’s prosperity as to celebrate it, why should they be put to death? Is it for this reason alone, that they are their relations? Are punishments inflicted, then, for the relationship, or for the lawless conduct?

166 Perhaps you yourselves, you venerable lawgivers, have had virtuous relations; but suppose they had been wicked: then, it seems to me, not only would you never have devised any such commandment yourselves, but you would have been furious with anyone else who proposed such a law, because you would take care that someone living in security should not suffer ruin alongside those in danger or be exposed to the same misfortune. For the one condition is subject to fear, so that a person who guards against it for himself will still not despise the safety of another; but the other state is free from all apprehension, and it has often persuaded men to neglect the safety of innocent men.

167 So our lawgiver, considering these things and seeing the errors of others, rejects and hates them as destructive of the most excellent constitution, and consigns to punishment all who give way to such errors, whether out of indifference or out of inhumanity and wickedness, and never allows any of their countrymen or friends to be substituted for them, adding themselves to the crimes the others have already committed. 168 For this reason he has expressly forbidden sons to be put to death instead of their parents, or parents instead of their sons, thinking it right that they who have committed the crimes should also bear the punishment, whether it is a fine, or lashes and more severe bodily punishment, or even wounds and mutilation, and dishonor, and exile, or any other judicial sentence; for though he names only one kind of punishment, forbidding one person to be put to death for another, he also includes other kinds that he does not expressly mention.

Women and Public Life

169 Market places, and council chambers, and courts of justice, and large companies and assemblies of numerous crowds, and a life in the open air full of arguments and actions relating to war and peace, are suited to men; but taking care of the house and remaining at home are the proper duties of women; the virgins keeping to their rooms in the center of the house within the innermost doors, and the grown women going no further than the vestibule and outer courts. 170 For there are two kinds of states, the greater and the smaller. The larger are properly called cities, and the smaller are called houses. And the oversight and management of these are divided between the two sexes: the men govern the greater, and their government is called a polity; the women govern the smaller, which is called household management.

171 Therefore no woman should concern herself with things beyond the province of household management, but she should cultivate solitude and not be seen going about like a woman who walks the streets in the sight of other men, except when it is necessary for her to go to the temple, if she has any proper regard for herself; and even then she should not go at noon when the market is full, but after most of the people have gone home; like a well-born woman, a real and true citizen, performing her vows and her sacrifices in tranquility, so as to avert evils and to receive blessings.

172 But when men are abusing one another or fighting, it is a blameworthy act, and one of no slight shamelessness, for women to venture to run out on the pretext of helping or defending them, since even, in the times of war and of military expeditions, and of dangers to their whole native land, the law does not want them enrolled as its defenders; it looks to what is fitting, which it thinks should be preserved unchanged at all times and in all places, considering this in itself better than victory, or than freedom, or than any kind of success and prosperity. 173 Moreover, if any woman, hearing that her husband is being assaulted, carried away by affection and love for her husband, should yield to the feelings which overpower her and rush out to aid him, she still should not be so audacious as to behave like a man, outrunning the nature of a woman; but even while aiding him she should remain a woman. For it would be a very terrible thing if a woman, wanting to rescue her husband from an insult, were to expose herself to insult by showing human life to be full of shamelessness and open to great reproach because of her incurable boldness.

174 For should a woman utter abuse in the marketplace and give vent to unlawful language? And if another man uses foul language, will she not stop her ears and run away? But as things are now, some women have reached such a pitch of shamelessness that, though they are women, they not only give vent to intemperate language and abuse among a crowd of men, but even strike men and insult them, with hands practiced in weaving and spinning rather than in blows and assaults, like competitors in the pancratium or wrestlers. Other things may be tolerable, and such as anyone might easily bear, but it is shocking for a woman to go so far in boldness as to seize hold of the genitals of one of the men quarreling. 175 For such a woman must not be let off on the ground that she seems to have done this to help her own husband; she should be brought to trial and suffer the punishment due to her excessive audacity, so that if she is ever inclined to commit the same offense again she will have no opportunity to do so; and other women, also, who might be inclined to rashness, may be taught by fear to be moderate and to restrain themselves. And let the punishment be the cutting off of the hand which has touched what it ought not to have touched.

176 And it is fitting to praise those who have been the judges and managers of the gymnastic games, who have kept women away from the spectacle, so that they would not be thrown among naked men and so mar the approved coinage of their modesty, neglecting the ordinances nature has appointed for each section of our race; for it is not right either for men to mix with women when they have taken off their clothes, but each of the sexes ought to avoid the sight of the other when they are naked, in accordance with the promptings of nature. 177 Well then, if we are to keep our eyes from these things, are the hands not much more to be blamed for touching them? For the eyes, though wholly free, are nevertheless often forced to see things which they do not wish to see; but the hands are among the parts completely under our control, and obey our commands, and are subservient to us.

An Allegorical Interpretation

178 This is the reason many people often give. But I have also heard another, put forward by people of high character, who regard most of the injunctions in the law as plain symbols of obscure meanings, and expressed hints of what may not be expressed. This other reason is as follows. There are two kinds of soul, just as there are two sexes among human beings; the one a masculine soul, belonging to men; the other a female soul, as found in women. The masculine soul is the one that devotes itself to God alone, as the Father and Creator of the universe and the cause of all things that exist; but the female soul is the one that depends on all created things, which as such are liable to destruction, and that puts out, as it were, the hand of its power so that it may blindly lay hold of whatever comes its way, clinging to generation, which undergoes countless changes and variations, when it ought rather to cling to the unchangeable, blessed, and three times happy divine nature. 179 It is natural, therefore, that the law commands the executioner to cut off the woman’s hand that has laid hold of what it should not, speaking figuratively, and implying not that the body should be mutilated by being deprived of its most important part, but rather that it is proper to root out all the ungodly reasonings of the soul that use created things as a stepping-stone; for the things which the woman is forbidden to take hold of are the symbols of procreation and generation.

180 Moreover, keeping consistently to nature, I will also say this, that the unit is the image of the first cause, and the number two is the image of divisible matter, which is acted on. Whoever, therefore, accepts the number two and honors it above the unit must be taught that in doing so he approves of matter more than of God. For this reason the law has seen fit to cut off this apprehension of the soul as if it were a hand; for there can be no greater impiety than to ascribe the power of the agent to what is passive.

Punishment Matching the Injury

181 Here anyone may rightly blame those who decree punishments for offenders that in no way correspond to the offenses, imposing financial penalties for assaults, or stigma and infamy for wounds and mutilations, or banishment beyond the borders of the land for intentional murders, and everlasting exile or imprisonment for thefts; for irregularity and inequality are enemies of a constitution that is eager for the truth. 182 And our law, being the interpreter and teacher of equality, commands that offenders undergo a punishment like the offense they have committed: for instance, that they be punished in their property if they have injured their neighbor in his property; in their persons, if they have injured him in his body, or in his limbs, or the organs of his outward senses; and, if their evil designs have extended to his life, then the law commands that the punishment fall on the life of the wrongdoer. For to exact a different and wholly unequal punishment which has no connection with or resemblance to the offense, but is wholly at odds with it in every respect, is the conduct of those who violate the laws rather than of those who would establish them.

183 When we say this, we mean provided no circumstances arise that put the matter in a different light; for it is not the same thing to inflict blows on one’s father and on a stranger, nor to speak ill of a ruler and of a private person, nor to do anything which is forbidden on common ground or in holy places, or at the time of a festival, or of a solemn assembly, or of a public sacrifice; or, again, on the days on which there is no holiday or sacred observance, or on those which are completely common and profane. All other matters of this kind must be examined in order to judge whether it is proper to increase or reduce the punishment.

Injured Slaves and Their Freedom

184 Again. “If,” says the law, “anyone strikes out the eye of a servant or of a handmaiden, he shall let them depart free.” For just as nature has assigned the chief position in the body to the head, giving it the position best suited to that preeminence, as one might give a citadel to a king, for having sent it out to govern the body it has established it on a height, placing the whole frame of the body from the neck to the feet beneath it, as a pedestal is placed under a statue, so also it has given the preeminence among the organs of the external senses to the eyes. At any rate, it has placed them above all the others, as if they were the chiefs, wishing to honor them not only in other ways but also by this, the most evident and conspicuous of all signs.

185 It would take a long time to list all the needs the eyes supply and all the services they perform for the human race. But we may mention one, the most excellent of all. It is the heaven which has showered philosophy on us, it is the human mind which has received and which contains it, but it is sight that has entertained it and been its host; for sight was the first faculty to see the level roads through the air.

186 And philosophy is the fountain of all blessings, of all things which are really good. Whoever draws from this fountain in order to acquire and use virtue is praiseworthy; but whoever does so to accomplish wicked purposes and condemn others is blameworthy. For the one is like a man at an entertainment, who delights both himself and all who feast with him; but the other is like someone gulping down strong wine to make himself and his neighbor drunk.

187 We must now explain in what way sight may be said to have entertained philosophy as its host. Looking up to heaven, it saw the sun, and the moon, and the planets, and the fixed stars, the most beautiful host of heaven, the ornament of the world. 188 After that it came to perceive the rising and setting of these bodies, and their harmonious motions, and the fixed seasons of their periodical revolutions, and their meetings, and eclipses, and reappearances. Then it went on to understand the increase and decrease of the moon; of the motions of the sun along the breadth of heaven, as he comes from the south toward the north, and again recedes from the north toward the south, for the generation of the fruits of the year, so that they may all be brought to perfection, and ten thousand other wonderful things besides these. And having looked around and surveyed with great diligence the things on the earth, in the sea and in the air, it displayed everything in each of these elements to the mind.

189 But since the mind was unable by itself to comprehend all these things merely by seeing them through the faculty of sight, it did not stop at what it saw; being devoted to learning and fond of what is honorable and excellent, it marveled at what it saw and adopted this probable opinion, that these things are not moved spontaneously and at random by any irrational impulse of their own, but that they are set in motion and guided by the will of God, whom it is proper to regard as the Father and Creator of the world. It also concluded that these things are not without bounds, but are limited by the circumference of one world, as they might be by the walls of a city, the world itself being circumscribed within the outermost sphere of the fixed stars. It further considered that the Father who created the world, by the law of nature, takes care of what he has created, exerting his providence on behalf of the whole universe and of its parts. 190 Next it also considered what the essence of the visible world was, and whether all the things in the world had the same essence, or whether different things had different essences, and also of what substances everything was made, and for what reasons it was made, and by what powers the world was held together, and whether these powers were corporeal or incorporeal.

191 For what can the investigation into these and similar subjects be called but philosophy? And what more fitting name could one give to the man who devoted himself to the investigation of these topics than philosopher? For by his examination of the nature of God, and of the world, and of all the things in it, whether plants or animals, and of those models which are perceptible only to the intellect, and again of the perfected representations of those models which are visible to the outward senses, and of the virtues and vices which exist in all created things, he shows that his disposition is truly devoted to learning, and contemplation, and philosophy; and this greatest of blessings to mortal man is bestowed on him by the faculty of sight.

192 And this faculty seems to me to deserve this preeminence, since it is more closely related to the soul than any of the other outward senses, for they all have some kind of connection with the intellect; but this one holds the first and principal rank, as the closest relative does in a household.

193 Anyone may infer this from many circumstances, for who does not know that when people are delighted their eyes betray their pleasure, and sparkle, but that when they are grieved their eyes are full of depression and heaviness; and if any heavy burden of grief oppresses, and crushes, and overwhelms the mind, they weep; and if anger gains the upper hand, the eyes swell, and become bloodshot and fiery. 194 And become gentle and soft again when the anger subsides. Again, when the man is immersed in deep thought and contemplation, the eyes seem fixed as if in a way they shared his gravity; but in people of little wisdom the sight wanders, because of their empty intellect, and is restless, and in short the eyes sympathize with the affections of the soul, and tend to change along with it in innumerable alternations, on account of the closeness of their connection with it; for it seems to me that God has made nothing visible so complete a representation of something invisible as sight is of the mind.

195 If therefore anyone has ever plotted against this most excellent and most dominant of all the outward senses, namely sight, and has struck out the eye of a free man, let him suffer the same infliction himself, but not so if he has only struck out the eye of a slave; not because he is entitled to pardon, or because the injury which he has done is less, but because the man who has been injured will have a still worse master if he has been mutilated in retaliation, since he will forever bear a grudge against him for the misfortune which has fallen on him, and will revenge himself on him every day as an irreconcilable enemy by harsh commands beyond his power to perform, by which the slave will be so oppressed that he will be ready to die.

196 Therefore the law has provided that the man who has injured his slave in this way shall not be allowed to escape free, and yet has not commanded that the man who has already suffered the loss of his eye should be ill-treated still further, ordering that if anyone strikes out the eye of his servant he shall without hesitation grant him his freedom. 197 For thus he will suffer a double punishment for what he has done, losing both the value of his servant and his services, and thirdly, which is worse than either, being compelled to do good in the most important matters to his enemy, whom he very likely wished to be able to ill-treat forever. And the slave has a double consolation for the evils he has suffered: he is not only emancipated but has also escaped a cruel and inhuman master.

198 The law also commands that if anyone strikes out the tooth of a slave he shall give the slave his freedom. Why is this? Because life is a thing of great value, and because nature has made the teeth the instruments of life, since food is eaten with them. Some of the teeth are suited to eating meat and all other edible food, and on that account are called incisors, or cutting teeth; others are called molars because they further grind and smooth what has been cut by the incisors. 199 For this reason the Creator and Father of the universe, who does not make anything without appointing it for some particular use, did not do with the teeth as he did with every other part of the body, and make them at once, at the first creation of the man, considering that, since as an infant he was meant to be fed only on milk, they would be a superfluous burden to him, and would be a severe injury to the breasts, filled as they are at that time with springs of milk, from which moist food is derived, since the child would bite them while sucking the milk.

200 So he waits for a suitable time, when the child is weaned, and then makes the infant produce the teeth he had prepared for it beforehand, because the most perfect food now supplied to it requires the organs mentioned above, now that the child rejects milk as food.

201 If therefore anyone, yielding to an insolent disposition, strikes out the tooth of his servant, that organ which is the minister and provider of those most necessary things, food and life, he shall emancipate the man he has injured, because by the harm he inflicted on him he has deprived him of the service and use of his tooth. “Is a tooth, then,” someone will say, “of equal value to an eye?” 202 “Each,” I would reply, “is of equal value for the purpose for which it was given, the eye with reference to the objects of sight, the teeth with reference to those which are edible.” But if anyone wanted to make a comparison, he would find that the eye is entitled to the highest respect among all the parts of the body, since it is occupied in contemplating the most glorious thing in the whole world, namely the heaven; and that the tooth is useful as the chewer of food, the most useful thing, since it contributes to life. And he who strikes out a man’s eye does not hinder him from living, but a most miserable death awaits the man who has all his teeth knocked out.

203 And if anyone is thinking of injuring his servants in these parts, let him know that he is causing them an artificial famine in the midst of plenty and abundance; for what good is an abundance of food to a man if the instruments that enable him to use it are taken from him and lost through the doing of his cruel, and pitiless, and inhuman master?

204 It is for this reason that in another passage the lawgiver forbids creditors to exact from their debtors a millstone or an upper millstone as a pledge, giving as a reason that the person who does so is taking a man’s life in pledge; for whoever deprives a man of the instruments of living is moving toward murder, harboring the idea of plotting even against life.

Death, Pollution, and Purification

205 The law has taken such extreme care that no one should ever cause another’s death that it does not regard as pure and clean even those who have touched a body that died a natural death, until they have washed and purified themselves with sprinklings and ritual washing; and even after they are perfectly clean it does not permit them to go into the temple for seven days, instructing them to perform purifying ceremonies on the third and seventh days. 206 And again, in the case of persons who have gone into the house in which anyone has died, the law commands that no one touch them until they have washed both their bodies and the clothes they wore, and, in a word, it regards all the furniture and all the vessels, and everything which is in the house, as unclean and polluted.

207 For the soul of a man is a valuable thing, and when it has left its dwelling and passed to another place, everything it leaves behind is polluted, being deprived of the divine image, since the human mind is made as a copy of the mind of God, having been created after the archetypal model, the most sublime reasoning.

208 And the law says, “Let everything that an unclean man has touched be unclean too, as polluted by sharing in what is unclean.” This sacred injunction seems to have a wide application, not limited to the body alone but apparently extending also to examine the dispositions of the soul, 209 for the unjust and impious man is especially unclean, since he has no respect for either human or divine things, but who throws everything into disorder and confusion by the immoderate vehemence of his passions, and by the extravagance of his wickedness, so that everything he touches becomes faulty, its nature changed by the wickedness of the one who has taken it in hand. In the same way, on the other hand, the actions of the good are all praiseworthy, made better by the energies of those who apply themselves to them, since what is done resembles in some degree the character of the person who does it.

Book 4

About this book

The Special Laws, Book 3

Tradition
Classical
Author
Philo
Written
20–50 CE
Text
Based on the translation by C. D. Yonge (1855) · Public domain

0 connections

No connections in this book yet.

Glossary

Search the Library