Go to Related Reading
About this book

The History of Rome Book 2

Ab Urbe Condita 2

About this book

Liberty and the First Consuls

Chapter 1

1 The new liberty enjoyed by the Roman people, their achievements in peace and war, annual magistracies, and laws superior in authority to men will be my theme from here on. 2 This liberty was all the more welcome because the last king had been so great a tyrant. For his predecessors ruled in such a way that there is good reason to regard them all as successive founders of parts, at least, of the City, which they added to serve as new homes for the numbers they had themselves recruited.

3 Nor is there any doubt that the same Brutus who earned such honor by expelling the haughty Tarquinius would have acted at a disastrous moment for the commonwealth had a premature eagerness for liberty led him to wrest the power from any of the earlier kings. 4 For what would have happened if that rabble of shepherds and vagrants, having deserted their own peoples, and under the protection of inviolable sanctuary having gained liberty, or at least impunity, had thrown off their fear of kings only to be stirred up by the storms raised by tribunician demagogues, breeding quarrels with the senators of a city not their own, 5 before the pledges of wife and children and love of the very place and soil—an affection of slow growth—had firmly united their aspirations? The nation would have crumbled away with dissension before it had matured.

6 But it was favored by the mild restraint of the government, which nurtured it to the point where its ripened powers enabled it to bear good fruit of liberty. Moreover, you may count the beginning of liberty as coming more from the limitation of the consuls’ authority to a year than from any reduction of their power compared with that which the kings had exercised. 7 All the rights of the kings and all their insignia were possessed by the earliest consuls; only one precaution was taken—that the terror they inspired should not be doubled by allowing both to have the rods.

8 Brutus was the first to have them, with his colleague’s consent, and he proved as determined in guarding liberty as he had been in asserting it. 9 To begin with, when the people were still jealous of their new freedom, he obliged them to swear an oath that they would allow no man to be king in Rome, so that they could not later be turned from their purpose by the entreaties or the gifts of princes. 10 In the next place, to strengthen the senate by increasing the numbers of that order, he filled up the list of the Fathers, which had been reduced by the late king’s massacres, drawing on the foremost men of equestrian rank until he had brought the total up to three hundred. 11 From that time, it is said, comes the custom of summoning to the senate the Fathers and the Enrolled, the latter being the name given to the newly appointed senators. This measure was wonderfully effective in promoting harmony in the state and attaching the plebs to the Fathers.

The King of Sacrifices

Chapter 2

1 Next, attention turned to matters of worship. Certain public sacrifices had habitually been performed by the kings in person, and so that their absence would not be felt anywhere, a “king of sacrifices” was appointed. 2 They made this priesthood subordinate to the pontifex, for fear that the office, combined with the title, might somehow prove an obstacle to liberty, which was at that time their chief concern. Perhaps the pains they took to safeguard it, even in trivial details, were excessive.

The Exile of Collatinus

3 For the name of one of the consuls, though he gave no other offense, was hateful to the citizens. “The Tarquinii had become too used to sovereignty. It had begun with Priscus; Servius Tullius had then been king; but not even this interruption had caused Tarquinius Superbus to forget the throne or regard it as another’s; as though it had been the heritage of his family, he had used crime and violence to get it back; Superbus was now expelled, but the supreme power was in the hands of Collatinus. The Tarquinii did not know how to live as private citizens. Their name was galling and a menace to liberty.” 4 Beginning in this way, by cautiously sounding out opinion, the talk spread through the entire nation, and the plebs had become anxious and suspicious, when Brutus summoned them to an assembly.

5 There he first of all recited the oath which the people had taken, that they would tolerate no king in Rome, nor any man who might be dangerous to liberty. They must uphold this oath, he said, with all their might, and not make light of anything that bore on it. He spoke reluctantly, for the man’s sake, and would not have broken his silence if he had not been forced to do so by his love of country. 6 The Roman people did not believe that they had recovered absolute freedom. The royal family, the royal name were not only present in the state, but were actually in authority, an obstacle and a stumbling block in the way of liberty. 7 “This fear,” he cried, “you must remove yourself, Lucius Tarquinius, of your own free will! We remember—we admit it—that you drove out the kings; complete the good work you have begun, and rid us of the royal name. Your possessions will not only be granted to you by the citizens, at my urging, but if they are in any way inadequate they will be generously increased. Leave as our friend, and relieve the state of what is, perhaps, an idle fear. The people are persuaded that with the family of Tarquinius the kingship will vanish from among us.”

8 At first the consul was too astonished at this strange and unexpected turn to utter a word; then, when he tried to speak, the chief men of the state surrounded him, and with many entreaties made the same request. 9 The others had little influence over him, but when Spurius Lucretius, his superior in years and dignity, and his father-in-law besides, began to urge him, with mingled entreaty and advice, to allow himself to yield to the unanimous wish of his fellow citizens, Collatinus became 10 alarmed that when his year of office ended, his misfortunes might be increased by the confiscation of his property and the addition of yet other ignominies. He therefore resigned the consulship, and transferring all his possessions to Lavinium, withdrew from the Roman state.

11 Following a resolution of the senate, Brutus proposed to the people a measure which decreed the exile of all the Tarquinian race. Under his presidency, the centuriate comitia elected as his colleague Publius Valerius, who had helped him to expel the kings.

A Plot to Restore the Kings

Chapter 3

1 Although no one doubted that the Tarquinii would soon go to war, their attack was delayed beyond all expectation; while something men did not fear at all, namely a treasonable plot, almost cost Rome her liberty. 2 Among the young men there were a number of youths, the sons of families of some importance, whose pleasures had been less confined under the monarchy, and who, being the same age as the young Tarquinii and their cronies, had grown used to the unrestrained life of princes. 3 They missed this license now that all enjoyed equal rights, and they had fallen into the habit of complaining to each other that the liberty of the rest had resulted in their own enslavement. A king was a man from whom one could obtain a favor, whether it were just or unjust; there was room for influence and favor; a king could be angry, could forgive, could distinguish between friend and enemy. 4 The law was a thing without ears, inexorable, more salutary and serviceable to the pauper than to the great man; it allowed no relaxation or indulgence if one overstepped its bounds; and, since man is so prone to blunder, it was dangerous to rely on innocence alone.

5 Thanks to such reflections, they were already infected with disloyalty when envoys from the royal family appeared who, without saying anything about the return of the Tarquinii, sought merely to recover their property. The senate, having given them a hearing, debated the question for several days; for they feared that if they refused to make restitution it would be a pretext for war, and if they consented, they would be furnishing the means and assistance to wage it. 6 Meanwhile the envoys were working toward a different purpose. Ostensibly seeking to recover the property, they secretly laid their plans for winning back the kingdom; and, as if in pursuit of their apparent aim, they went about sounding out the attitudes of the youthful nobles. 7 To those who gave them a friendly hearing they delivered letters from the Tarquinii, and plotted with them to admit the royal family secretly by night into the City.

The Conspiracy Exposed

Chapter 4

1 The brothers Vitellii and Aquilii were the first to be entrusted with the project. A sister of the Vitellii had married the consul Brutus, and there were sons of this marriage who were now young men, Titus and Tiberius; their uncles also let them share in the scheme. 2 Several other young nobles were also let in on the secret, but their names are lost in antiquity.

3 Meanwhile the senate had accepted the view of those who favored giving back the property. This very fact gave the agents of the exiles an excuse for lingering in the City, for the consuls had granted them time to obtain vehicles with which to carry away the belongings of the royal family. 4 They spent all this time conferring with the conspirators, whom they urged and finally persuaded to give them letters for the Tarquinii. Otherwise, how could the princes be convinced that the statements of their agents regarding matters of such importance were to be relied on?

5 These letters, being given as a pledge of sincerity, furnished clear proof of the crime. For on the eve of the envoys’ setting out to rejoin their masters it happened that they were dining at the house of the Vitellii, where the conspirators, having dismissed all witnesses, talked at length, naturally enough, about their new design. One of the slaves overheard this conversation. 6 He had for some time sensed what was in the wind, but was waiting for the opportunity which the delivery of the letters to the envoys would provide, so that their seizure would prove his accusation. When he saw that the letters had been given, he laid the matter before the consuls. 7 The consuls left their houses, arrested the agents and the conspirators, and, without making any disturbance, completely crushed the plot, being especially careful not to lose the letters. The traitors were thrown into prison at once. As for the envoys, it was uncertain for a little while what would be done with them, but although they appeared to deserve nothing less than to be treated as enemies, the law of nations prevailed.

The Royal Property and the Tiber Island

Chapter 5

1 The question of the royal property, which they had earlier voted to return, was laid before the Fathers for fresh consideration. This time anger won the day. 2 They refused to return it, and refused to confiscate it for the state, but handed it over to the plebeians to plunder, so that, having had their hands on the princes’ possessions, they would forever give up hope of making peace with them. The land of the Tarquinii, lying between the City and the Tiber, was consecrated to Mars and became the Campus Martius.

3 It happened, they say, that there was then standing on it a crop of spelt, ripe for the harvest. Since this produce of the land could not, for religious reasons, be eaten, the grain was cut, straw and all, by a large body of men, who were set to work on it all at once, and was carried in baskets and thrown into the Tiber, then flowing with a feeble current, as is usually the case in midsummer. 4 So the heaps of grain, caught in the shallow water, settled down in the mud, and out of these and the accumulation of other chance materials such as a river brings down, an island gradually formed. Later, I suppose, embankments were added, and work was done to raise the surface so high above the water and make it strong enough to sustain even temples and porticoes.

The Execution of Brutus’s Sons

5 When the princes’ belongings had been looted, sentence was pronounced and punishment inflicted on the traitors—a punishment all the more conspicuous because the office of consul imposed on a father the duty of exacting the penalty from his sons, and the man who ought to have been spared even the sight of their suffering was the very man whom Fortune appointed to enforce it. 6 Youths of the highest birth stood bound to the stake. But the rest were ignored as if they had been of the rabble: the consul’s sons drew all eyes to themselves. 7 Men pitied them no more for their punishment than for the crime by which they had deserved it. To think that those young men, in that year of all years, when their country was liberated and her liberator their own father, and when the consulship had begun with the Junian family, could have brought themselves to betray all—the senate, the plebs, and all the gods and men of Rome—to one who had formerly been a tyrannical king and was then an enemy exile!

8 The consuls advanced to their tribunal and dispatched the lictors to execute the sentence. The culprits were stripped, scourged with rods, and beheaded, while through it all men gazed at the expression on the father’s face, where they could clearly read a father’s anguish, as he administered the nation’s retribution.

9 When the guilty had been punished, to make the example a notable deterrent to crime in both respects, the informer was rewarded with money from the treasury, emancipation, and citizenship. 10 He is said to have been the first to be freed by the vindicta. Some think that even the word vindicta was derived from his name, which they suppose to have been Vindicius. From his time on it was customary to regard those who had been freed in this way as admitted to citizenship.

Tarquinius Rouses Etruria

Chapter 6

1 When these events had been faithfully reported to Tarquinius, he was stirred not only by disappointment at the collapse of such great hopes, but also by hatred and anger. He saw that the way was now closed to trickery, and believed it was time to resort to open war. 2 He therefore went about as a suppliant among the cities of Etruria, directing his prayers chiefly to the Veientes and the Tarquinienses. Reminding them that he had come from them and was of the same blood as themselves, and that exile and poverty had followed hard on his loss of what had only lately been great power, he begged them not to let him perish, with his youthful sons, before their very eyes. 3 Others had been called in from abroad to be kings in Rome, but he himself, while actually king, and enlarging Rome’s sway by war, had been driven out by his next of kin in a wicked conspiracy. His enemies, seeing that no single claimant was fit to be king, had seized and usurped the power among themselves, and had given up his goods to be plundered by the people, so that no one would be without a share in the guilt. He wished to regain his country and his sovereignty, and to punish the ungrateful Romans.

4 Let them help and support him, and avenge, as well, their own long-standing grievances, the repeated destruction of their armies, and seizure of their lands. This last plea moved the men of Veii, and they cried out threateningly that they ought, at least with a Roman as their commander, to wipe out their disgraces and recover what they had lost in war. 5 The Tarquinienses were influenced by his name and kinship: it seemed a fine thing to them that one of their blood should be king in Rome.

The Deaths of Brutus and Arruns

6 So it came about that two armies, representing two nations, followed Tarquinius, to regain his kingdom for him and to punish the Romans. When they had come into Roman territory the consuls went out to meet the enemy: Valerius led the infantry in defensive formation; Brutus, with the cavalry, went ahead to scout. 7 In the same way the enemy’s cavalry headed their march, commanded by Arruns Tarquinius, the king’s son, while the king himself followed with the legions. Arruns, recognizing the consul from far off by his lictors, and then, as they drew closer, identifying Brutus beyond doubt by his face, blazed with resentment. “There,” he cried, “is the man who drove us into exile from our native land. Look! 8 He comes on proudly, decked out in our own trappings! Gods, avengers of kings, be with us!” Spurring his horse, he charged straight at the consul. Brutus saw that he was the object of the man’s attack. 9 In those days it was to a general’s credit to take part in the actual fighting, so he eagerly accepted the challenge, and they rushed at one another with such desperation, neither of them thinking of his own defense so long as he could wound his opponent, that each was pierced right through his shield by the other’s thrust, and, impaled on the two spears, they fell dying from their horses.

10 At the same time the rest of the cavalry also joined the fight, and not long after the infantry also appeared. In this battle the advantage was divided, and the fortune of war seemed equally balanced: the right wing on each side was victorious, while the left was defeated. 11 The Veientes, used to being beaten by the Roman troops, were routed and dispersed; the men of Tarquinii, a new enemy, not only stood their ground, but drove back the Roman forces which opposed them.

The Voice of Silvanus

Chapter 7

1 Yet despite the indecisive character of the battle, so great a panic came over Tarquinius and the Etruscans that they gave up the enterprise as lost, and that same night both armies, the Veientine and the Tarquiniensian, marched off, every man to his own home. 2 To the story of this fight popular tradition adds a portent: that in the silence of the following night a loud voice was heard coming out of the Arsian forest, which was believed to be the voice of Silvanus, and that this was what he said: “The Tuscans have lost one more man in the battle line; the Romans are the victors in the war.” 3 At all events the Romans left the field like victors, and the Etruscans like an army that has been defeated.

4 For when it grew light and not a single enemy was to be seen, Publius Valerius the consul gathered up the enemy’s arms and returned in triumph to Rome. He celebrated his colleague’s funeral with all the pomp then possible; but a far greater honor to the dead man was the general grief, which was particularly conspicuous because the matrons mourned a year for him, as for a father, since he had been so spirited an avenger of outraged modesty.

Valerius Suspected of Seeking Kingship

5 Soon after this the surviving consul, so fickle are the affections of the mob, became unpopular; not only did the people dislike him, but they actually suspected him and made cruel charges against him. 6 It was rumored that he was aspiring to the power of a king, since he had not had a colleague elected in place of Brutus, and was building a house on the highest part of the Velia, an elevated position of natural strength, men said, which he was converting into an impregnable citadel.

7 The frequency of these remarks and the general acceptance they found, shamefully unjust as they were, distressed the consul. He summoned the people to a council, and with lowered fasces mounted the speaker’s platform. 8 It was a welcome spectacle to the multitude when they saw the emblems of authority lowered before them, in acknowledgment that the people’s majesty and power were superior to the consul’s. Then, calling for their attention, the consul extolled the good fortune of his colleague, who, after his country had thrown off the yoke, had held the highest office she could give, and, fighting for the state, at the height of a reputation as yet untarnished by envy, had met his death. He himself had outlived his glory, and survived to face accusations and ill will.

9 From being the savior of his country he had sunk to the level of the Aquilii and Vitellii. “Will worth and merit, then, never be so firmly established in your minds,” he exclaimed, “that suspicion cannot wrong them? 10 Could I possibly have feared that I, well known as the bitterest enemy of kings, would myself face the charge of seeking kingly power? Could I have believed that, even if I lived in the Citadel and on the Capitol itself, I could be feared by my fellow citizens? Can so trivial a cause ruin my reputation with you? Does your confidence rest on so slight a foundation that it makes more difference where I am than who I am? 11 The house of Publius Valerius will be no threat to your liberties, Quirites; your Velia will be safe. I will not only bring my house down on to level ground, but will even place it under a hill, so that you may live above me, the citizen whom you suspect. Let those who can be trusted with men’s liberty better than Publius Valerius build on the Velia!” 12 Immediately the materials were all brought down below the Velia, and the house was erected where the temple of Vica Pota is now, at the bottom of the slope.

Publicola’s Laws

Chapter 8

1 Laws were then proposed which not only cleared the consul of the suspicion of seeking kingly power, but had such an opposite effect that they even made him popular and caused him to be called Publicola, the People’s Friend. 2 Above all, the law about appealing from the magistrates to the people, and the one that pronounced a curse on the life and property of anyone who plotted to make himself king, were welcome to the commons.

3 When he had carried these measures through alone, so that he could enjoy all the favor arising from them without a rival, he finally held an election to choose a colleague for the unexpired term. 4 The choice fell on Spurius Lucretius, who because of his great age was no longer strong enough for the duties of the consulship, and died within a few days. They elected in Lucretius’s place Marcus Horatius Pulvillus. 5 Some ancient authorities do not list Lucretius as consul, but have Horatius immediately follow Brutus; I suppose that because no exploit lent distinction to Lucretius’s consulship men forgot it. The temple of Jupiter on the Capitol had not yet been dedicated.

The Dedication of the Capitoline Temple

6 The consuls Valerius and Horatius drew lots to determine which should do it. Horatius received the lot, and Publicola set out to conduct the war against the Veientes. With more bitterness than was reasonable, the friends of Valerius resented that the dedication of such a famous temple was given to Horatius. 7 They tried in all sorts of ways to hinder it, but their schemes all came to nothing. Finally, when the consul’s hand was on the doorpost and he was in the midst of his prayers to the gods, they interrupted the ceremony with the terrible news that his son was dead, declaring that while the shadow of death was over his house he could not dedicate a temple. 8 Whether he did not believe the news or had great fortitude, we are not told with certainty, nor is it easy to decide. Without letting the message divert him from his purpose, except to order that the body be buried, he kept his hand on the doorpost, finished his prayer, and dedicated the temple.

9 Such were the achievements, at home and in the field, of the first year after the expulsion of the kings.

Porsinna Takes Up the Tarquinii’s Cause

Chapter 9

1 Next Publius Valerius, for the second time, and Titus Lucretius were made consuls. By this time the Tarquinii had sought refuge with Lars Porsinna, king of Clusium. There they combined advice and entreaty, now begging him not to allow them, Etruscans by birth and of the same blood and the same name as himself, to endure the 2 privations of exile, and now even warning him not to allow the growing custom of expelling kings to go unpunished. Liberty was sweet enough in itself. 3 Unless the energy with which nations sought to obtain it was matched by the efforts which kings put forth to defend their power, the highest would be reduced to the level of the lowest; there would be nothing lofty, nothing that stood out above the rest of the state; it would be the end of monarchy, the noblest institution known to gods or men.

4 Porsinna, believing not only that it was safer for the Etruscans to have a king at Rome, but that it was an honor to have that king of Etruscan stock, invaded Roman territory with a hostile army. 5 Never before had such fear seized the senate, so powerful was Clusium in those days, and so great Porsinna’s fame. And they feared not only the enemy but their own citizens, fearing that the plebs might be terror-stricken and, admitting the princes into the City, even submit to slavery for the sake of peace.

6 Hence the senate at this time granted many favors to the plebs. The food supply received special attention, and some were sent to the Volsci and others to Cumae to buy up grain. Again, the monopoly of salt, the price of which was very high, was taken out of the hands of individuals and wholly assumed by the government. Duties and taxes were lifted from the plebs and shifted to the well-to-do, who could bear the burden; the poor paid enough if they raised children. 7 Thanks to this liberality on the part of the Fathers, the distress which attended the subsequent blockade and famine was powerless to destroy the harmony of the state, which was such that the name of king was as hateful to the lowest as to the highest; 8 nor in later years was there ever a man whose demagogic arts made him so popular as its wise governing at that time made the whole senate.

Horatius at the Bridge

Chapter 10

1 When the enemy appeared, the Romans all withdrew together from their fields into the City, which they surrounded with guards. Some parts seemed to be made safe by their walls, others by the barrier formed by the river Tiber. 2 The pile bridge would almost have given the enemy a way in, had it not been for one man, Horatius Cocles; he was the bulwark on which the fortune of the City of Rome depended that day.

3 He happened to be on guard at the bridge when Janiculum was captured by a sudden attack of the enemy. He saw them as they charged down on the run from Janiculum, while his own people behaved like a frightened mob, throwing away their arms and leaving their ranks. 4 Catching hold first of one and then of another, blocking their way and begging them to listen, he called on gods and men to witness that if they abandoned their post, it was useless to flee; once they had left a passage in their rear by the bridge, there would soon be more of the enemy on the Palatine and the Capitol than on Janiculum. 5 He therefore warned and commanded them to break down the bridge with steel, with fire, with any instrument at their disposal; and promised that he himself would take the enemy’s attack, as far as one man’s body could withstand it.

6 Then, striding to the head of the bridge, conspicuous among the fugitives who were clearly seen to be shirking the fight, he covered himself with his sword and shield and made ready to do battle at close quarters, stunning the Etruscans with his audacity. 7 Yet there were two whom shame kept from leaving him. These were Spurius Larcius and Titus Herminius, both famous for their birth and their deeds. With these he endured the peril of the first rush and the stormiest moment of the battle. 8 But after a while he forced even these two to leave him and save themselves, for there was scarcely anything left of the bridge, and those who were cutting it down called to them to come back.

9 Then, darting glances of defiance around at the Etruscan nobles, he now challenged them in turn to fight, now abused them all together as slaves of haughty kings who, careless of their own liberty, had come to overthrow the liberty of others. They hesitated for a moment, each looking to his neighbor to begin the fight. 10 Then shame made them attack, and with a shout they cast their javelins from every side against their lone enemy. But he caught them all on his shield, and, resolute as ever, stood astride the bridge and held his ground; and now they were trying to dislodge him by a charge, when the crash of the falling bridge and the cheer which burst from the throats of the Romans, delighted at finishing their task, stopped them in mid-charge with sudden dismay. 11 Then Cocles cried, “Father Tiberinus, I solemnly call on you. Receive these arms and this soldier with a kindly stream!” With this prayer, all armed as he was, he leaped down into the river, and under a shower of missiles swam across unhurt to his comrades, having given a proof of valor that was destined to win more fame than belief from later generations.

12 The state was grateful for so brave a deed: a statue of Cocles was set up in the comitium, and he was given as much land as he could plow around in one day. 13 Private citizens showed their gratitude in a striking way alongside his official honors, for despite their great distress everyone gave him some gift in proportion to their means, even if it meant going without their own rations.

The Siege and Valerius’s Ambush

Chapter 11

1 Porsinna, repulsed in his first attempt, gave up the plan of storming the City, and determined to lay siege to it. Placing a garrison on Janiculum, he pitched his camp in the plain by the banks of the Tiber. 2 He gathered ships from every quarter, both to guard the river and keep any grain from being brought into the City, and to send his troops across to plunder whenever the opportunity presented itself at one point or another; 3 and in a short time he made all the territory of the Romans so unsafe that not only were they forced to bring all their other property inside the walls, but even their flocks, and no one dared to drive them outside the gates.

4 The Etruscans were allowed this great freedom not so much out of timidity as by design. For Valerius the consul, who was eager for a chance to attack a large number at once, when they were scattered about and not expecting an attack, cared little to avenge small aggressions, and reserved his punishment for a heavier blow. 5 Accordingly, to lure out the plunderers, he issued orders to his people that on the following day a large number of them should drive out their flocks by the Esquiline Gate, which was the most remote from the enemy, expecting that the enemy would hear of it, since the blockade and famine were causing faithless slaves to desert. 6 And in fact the enemy did hear of it from a deserter’s report, and crossed the river in much greater force than usual, in the hope of making a clean sweep of the booty.

7 Consequently Publius Valerius directed Titus Herminius to lie in ambush with a small force two miles out on the Gabinian Way, and Spurius Larcius with a body of light-armed youths to take up position at the Colline Gate until the enemy passed, and then to throw themselves between them and the river, cutting off their retreat. 8 Of the two consuls, Titus Lucretius went out by the Naevian Gate with several maniples of soldiers; Valerius himself led out some picked cohorts by way of the Caelian Mount. These last were the first to be seen by the enemy. 9 Herminius no sooner saw that the skirmish had begun than he rushed out of his ambush and fell on the rear of the Etruscans, who had turned to meet Valerius. On the right and on the left, from the Naevian Gate and from the Colline, an answering shout went up. 10 Thus the raiders were hemmed in and cut to pieces, for they were no match for the Romans in fighting strength, and were shut off from every line of retreat. This was the last time the Etruscans roamed so far afield.

Gaius Mucius in Porsinna’s Camp

Chapter 12

1 The blockade went on all the same. The grain was running out, and what there was cost a very high price, and Porsinna was beginning 2 to hope that he would take the City by sitting still, when Gaius Mucius, a young Roman noble, thinking it a shame that although the Roman People had not, in the days of their servitude when they lived under kings, been blockaded in a war by any enemies, they should now, 3 when free, be besieged by those same Etruscans whose armies they had so often routed, made up his mind that this indignity must be avenged by some great and daring deed.

4 At first he intended to make his way to the enemy’s camp on his own initiative. Afterward, fearing that if he went without the consuls’ orders and without anyone knowing, he might happen to be arrested by the Roman sentries and brought back as a deserter—a charge which the state of the City would confirm—he went before the senate. 5 “I wish,” he said, “to cross the river, senators, and enter, if I can, the enemy’s camp—not to plunder or take revenge for their devastation. I have a greater deed in mind, if the gods grant me their help.” 6 The Fathers approved. Hiding a sword under his clothes, he set out.

7 When he reached the camp, he took his stand in the thick of the crowd near the royal tribunal. It happened that at that moment the soldiers were being paid; a secretary who sat beside the king, and wore nearly the same costume, was very busy, and most of the soldiers were addressing him. Mucius was afraid to ask which was Porsinna, in case his not knowing the king should betray who he was, and, following the blind guidance of Fortune, killed the secretary instead of the king. 8 As he strode off through the frightened crowd, making a way for himself with his bloody blade, there was an outcry, and at that the royal guards came running in from every side, seized him and dragged him back before the tribunal of the king.

9 But even then, friendless as he was and with Fortune looking so threatening, he was more to be feared than fearful. “I am a Roman citizen,” he cried. “My name is Gaius Mucius. 10 I am your enemy, and as an enemy I would have killed you; I can die as resolutely as I could kill. To act and to suffer bravely is the Roman way. Nor am I the only one who has made this resolve against you: behind me is a long line of men who are seeking the same honor. So prepare yourself, if you think it worth your while, for a struggle in which you must fight for your life from hour to hour with an armed enemy always at your door. 11 Such is the war we, the Roman youths, declare on you. 12 You need not fear massed ranks or a battle; it will be between yourself alone and a single enemy at a time.”

13 The king, at once hot with resentment and aghast at his danger, angrily ordered the prisoner to be flung into the flames unless he immediately revealed the plot he was so vaguely threatening. At that Mucius exclaimed, “Look, so that you may see how cheaply men hold their bodies when their eyes are fixed on glory!” and thrust his hand into the fire that was kindled for the sacrifice. As he let his hand burn as though his mind felt nothing, the king was almost beside himself with wonder. 14 He leaped from his seat and ordered them to remove the young man from the altar. “Go free,” he said, “you who have dared to harm yourself more than me. I would pray for the success of your valor if that valor were used for my country; since that cannot be, I release you from the penalties of war and send you away untouched and unharmed.”

15 Then Mucius, as if to repay his generosity, answered, “Since you honor bravery, my gratitude will give you the information your threats could not force out of me. We are three hundred, the foremost youths of Rome, who have sworn together to attack you in this way. 16 I drew the first lot; the others, in whatever order it falls to them, will attack you, each at his own time, until Fortune delivers you into our hands.”

Peace With Porsinna

Chapter 13

1 The release of Mucius, who was afterward known as Scaevola from the loss of his right hand, was followed by the arrival in Rome of envoys from Porsinna. 2 The king had been so disturbed, both by the danger of the first attack on his life, from which only his attacker’s blunder had saved him, and by the prospect of facing that danger as many more times as there were conspirators left, that he voluntarily proposed terms of peace to the Romans. 3 In these terms Porsinna proposed, without success, that the Tarquinii should be restored to power, more because he had been unable to refuse the princes this demand on their behalf than because he did not know the Romans would refuse it. 4 He succeeded in getting their lands returned to the Veientes; and the Romans were compelled to give hostages if they wished the garrison to be withdrawn from Janiculum. On these terms peace was made, and Porsinna led his army down from Janiculum and evacuated the Roman territory.

5 For his bravery, the Fathers gave Gaius Mucius a field across the Tiber, which was later known as the Mucian Meadows.

The Escape of Cloelia

6 Now that courage had been honored in this way, even the women were inspired to deeds of patriotism. Thus the maiden Cloelia, one of the hostages, slipped past the sentries, when the Etruscans happened to have camped not far from the bank of the Tiber, and heading a band of girls swam the river and, under a rain of enemy javelins, brought them all back in safety to their kinsmen in Rome. 7 When this had been reported to the king, he was at first enraged and sent emissaries to Rome to demand that the hostage Cloelia be given up, for he cared little about the others. 8 Then, admiration getting the better of anger, he asserted that her feat was a greater one than those of Cocles and Mucius, and declared that if the hostage was not returned he would regard the treaty as broken, but if she were given back to him he would send her back safe and unharmed to her family. Both parties kept their word.

9 The Romans returned the pledge of peace, as the treaty required; and the Etruscan king not only protected the brave girl but even honored her, for after praising her heroism he said that he would present her with half the hostages, and that she herself could choose the ones she wished. 10 When they had all been brought out it is said that she selected the young boys, because it was not only more fitting for a maiden but also unanimously approved by the hostages themselves that in freeing them from the enemy she should give preference to those whose age left them particularly exposed to harm. 11 When peace had been established the Romans rewarded this new valor in a woman with a new kind of honor, an equestrian statue, which was set up at the top of the Sacred Way, and represented the maiden seated on a horse.

The Goods of King Porsinna

Chapter 14

1 This peaceful departure of the Etruscan king from Rome does not fit with the custom, handed down from antiquity to our own day among the other formalities observed at sales of booty, of proclaiming “the goods of King Porsinna.” 2 Such a practice must either have arisen during the war and been kept when peace was made, or else have had its origin in some kindlier circumstance than the announcement that an enemy’s goods were for sale would suggest.

3 The most credible of the traditional explanations is that when Porsinna retired from Janiculum he handed over his camp, well stocked with provisions brought in from the neighboring fertile fields of Etruria, as a gift to the Romans, who were then in a destitute condition after the long siege. 4 These supplies were then sold, so that people would not plunder the camp like an enemy if they were given a free hand; and they were called the goods of Porsinna to express thanks for the gift rather than to imply an auction of the king’s property, which was not even in the possession of the Roman People.

Defeat at Aricia

5 On giving up his campaign against the Romans, Porsinna did not want to appear to have led his army into that region to no purpose, and accordingly sent a part of his forces, under his son Arruns, to besiege Aricia. At first the Aricini were paralyzed with surprise. 6 Afterward the auxiliaries they called in from the Latin peoples, and also from Cumae, so encouraged them that they ventured to measure their strength with the enemy in the open field. When the battle began, the attack of the Etruscans was so impetuous that they routed the Aricini at the first charge. 7 The Cumaean troops, using skill against force, swerved a little to one side, and when the enemy had swept by them, turned around and attacked them in the rear, with the result that the Etruscans, caught between two lines, almost in the moment of victory, were cut to pieces.

8 A very small number of them, having lost their leader and finding no nearer refuge, drifted to Rome, unarmed and with all the helplessness and dejected look of suppliants. There they were kindly received and were lodged among the citizens. 9 When their wounds had healed, some departed for their homes to report the hospitality and kindness they had met with, but many were persuaded to remain in Rome by the affection they felt for their hosts and for the City. These were allotted a place to live, which was afterward called the Vicus Tuscus.

Porsinna’s Lasting Peace With Rome

Chapter 15

1 Spurius Larcius and Titus Herminius were the next consuls, and after them came Publius Lucretius and Publius Valerius Publicola. In the latter year Porsinna sent an embassy to Rome for the last time to negotiate for the restoration of Tarquinius to power. The senate replied to these envoys that it would send representatives to the king, and at once dispatched those of the Fathers who were held in the highest esteem.

2 It would not have been impossible, they said, to reply briefly that the royal family would not be received. It was not for that reason that they had preferred to send chosen members of the senate to him rather than to give their answer to his ambassadors in Rome. But they had wanted to end discussion of that question for all time, and, where there were such great obligations on both sides, to avoid mutual irritation from the king’s seeking what was incompatible with the liberty of the Roman people, while the Romans, unless they were willing to sacrifice their existence to their good nature, refused the request of a man to whom they would gladly have refused nothing. 3 The Roman people were not living under a monarchy, but were free. They had resolved to open their gates to enemies sooner than to kings; they were all united in this prayer: that the day which saw the end of liberty in their City might also see the City’s end. 4 They therefore begged him, if he wished Rome well, to allow her to be free.

5 The king, yielding to his better feelings, replied: “Since this is your fixed resolve, I will not pester you by repeatedly insisting on a hopeless plea, nor will I deceive the Tarquinii with the hope of aid which it is not in my power to grant. Let them look elsewhere for a place of exile, whether war or peace is their aim, so that nothing may keep me from being at peace with you.” His words were followed by yet more friendly deeds. 6 He returned the hostages remaining in his hands, and he gave back the Veientine land which he had taken from the Romans by the treaty made on Janiculum.

7 Tarquinius, cut off from all hope of returning, departed for Tusculum, to spend his exile in the home of his son-in-law, Mamilius Octavius. The Romans enjoyed an unbroken peace with Porsinna.

The Coming of Appius Claudius

Chapter 16

1 Next came the consulship of Marcus Valerius and Publius Postumius. This year a successful war was waged against the Sabines, and the consuls triumphed. The Sabines then made more elaborate preparations for war. 2 To confront them, and to guard against any sudden danger from Tusculum, where hostility, though not openly declared, was nonetheless suspected, Publius Valerius was made consul for the fourth time and Titus Lucretius for the second.

3 A split between the advocates of war and of peace among the Sabines transferred part of their strength to the Romans. 4 For Attius Clausus, afterward known at Rome as Appius Claudius, himself a champion of peace, was hard pressed by the turbulent war party, and finding himself no match for them, left Inregillus with a large band of clients, and fled to Rome. These people were made citizens and given land across the Anio. 5 The “Old Claudian Tribe” was the name used later, when new tribesmen had been added, to designate those who came from this territory. Appius, having been enrolled in the senate, soon came to be regarded as one of its leading members.

6 The consuls led an army into the country of the Sabines, and by laying waste their fields, and afterward by a battle, so crushed the enemy’s strength that there was no need to fear any outbreak of hostilities in that region for a long time.

The Death of Publicola

7 They then returned to Rome and triumphed. Publius Valerius, universally regarded as the foremost citizen, both in military and in civil qualities, died in the following year, when Agrippa Menenius and Publius Postumius were consuls. He was a man of extraordinary reputation, but so poor that there was not enough money for his burial, and it was supplied from the state treasury. 8 He was mourned by the matrons as Brutus had been. In the same year two Latin colonies, Pometia and Cora, revolted to the Aurunci. The Aurunci were the first to be attacked. After the defeat of the great army that had boldly marched out to meet the consuls’ invasion of their territory, the whole weight of the Auruncan war fell on Pometia. 9 No quarter was given, during the battle or after it. The dead somewhat outnumbered the prisoners, and the prisoners were indiscriminately slaughtered. Even the hostages, of whom three hundred had been received, were not spared in the rage of war. This year also a triumph was celebrated at Rome.

The Fall of Pometia

Chapter 17

1 The consuls of the next year, Opiter Verginius and Spurius Cassius, attempted to capture Pometia, first by assault and then by using siege sheds and other engines. 2 The Aurunci, driven more by implacable hatred than by any hope or opportunity, rushed out against their besiegers, most of them armed with firebrands instead of swords, and carried death and flames in all directions. 3 The siege sheds were burned, many of the enemy were wounded or killed, and one of the consuls—which one the historians do not say—was seriously wounded, thrown from his horse, and almost killed.

4 The Romans then marched home, defeated. Among the many wounded they brought the consul, hovering between life and death. After a short time, long enough to heal wounds and recruit the army, they returned to attack Pometia with heightened resentment and larger forces. 5 They had repaired their siege sheds and the rest of their equipment, and they were already on the point of sending their men against the walls when the town capitulated.

6 But the Aurunci’s fate was no less terrible for their having surrendered their city than if it had been stormed. Their chief men were beheaded, and the rest of the colonists were sold as slaves. The town was razed; its land was sold. 7 The consuls obtained a triumph, more because they had heavily avenged Rome’s wrongs than because of the magnitude of the war which they had successfully concluded.

The First Dictator

Chapter 18

1 The consuls of the following year were Postumius Cominius and Titus Largius. 2 In this year, during the celebration of the games at Rome, the Sabine youths, as a reckless prank, forcibly carried off some prostitutes. People gathered quickly and there was a brawl which was almost a battle, and, trifling as its origin was, it seemed to threaten a fresh outbreak of the war. 3 Besides the Sabine threat, it was generally known that the thirty Latin cities had already conspired, at the instigation of Octavius Mamilius.

4 Since these serious fears caused general anxiety, the appointment of a dictator was proposed for the first time. But there is no general agreement as to the year, or which consuls were distrusted as being of the Tarquinian faction—for this is included in the tradition—or who was first named dictator. 5 In the oldest writers, however, I find that Titus Largius was the first to be made dictator, and that Spurius Cassius was master of the horse. They chose men of consular rank, as the law passed to regulate the selection of a dictator required. 6 I am therefore more inclined to believe that Largius, a consular, rather than Manius Valerius, the son of Marcus and grandson of Volesus, a man who had not yet held the consulship, was appointed to be the director and superior of the consuls; 7 and indeed if people had especially wanted to choose the dictator from that family, they would much sooner have selected Marcus Valerius the father, a man of proven worth and an ex-consul.

8 When a dictator had been named for the first time at Rome, and people saw the axes carried before him, a great fear came over the plebs and caused them to be more zealous in obeying orders. For in this case there was no turning, as with the consuls, who shared the powers of their office equally, to the man’s colleague for help, nor was there any appeal or any help anywhere except in scrupulous obedience.

9 The Sabines, too, were inspired with fear by the appointment of the dictator, especially since they believed that he had been appointed because of them. 10 Accordingly they sent envoys to negotiate peace. When they requested the dictator and the senate to pardon an error committed by young men, the answer came that young men could be pardoned, but not old men who stirred up one war after another. 11 Nevertheless negotiations for peace were begun, and the Sabines would have been granted peace if they could have brought themselves to guarantee, as the Romans demanded, the sum that had been spent on the war. Hostilities were declared, but an unspoken truce kept the peace through the year.

The Battle of Lake Regillus

Chapter 19

1 In the consulship of Servius Sulpicius and Manius Tullius nothing noteworthy happened. They were succeeded by Titus Aebutius and Gaius Vetusius. 2 During their year of office Fidenae was besieged and Crustumeria taken; Praeneste went over from the Latins to the Romans, and it was no longer possible to postpone the Latin war, which had now been smoldering for several years.

3 Aulus Postumius as dictator, and Titus Aebutius as master of the horse, set out with large forces of infantry and cavalry, and at Lake Regillus, in the territory of Tusculum, met the enemy’s advancing column. 4 The Romans had learned that the Tarquinii were with the Latin army, and were so enraged that they could not be held back from attacking at once, and because of this report the battle itself was fought with a good deal more determination and bitterness than any other had been. 5 For the leaders were not only in the field to direct the fighting with their strategy but joined battle and fought in person. Almost none of the nobles on either side came off unscathed, except the Roman dictator.

6 Postumius was in the front rank encouraging his men and forming them, when Tarquinius Superbus, though now weighed down by age and weakened, rode full tilt against him. But the old man received a thrust in the side, and his followers rushed in and rescued him. 7 Similarly on the other wing, Aebutius, the master of the horse, charged Octavius Mamilius. But the Tusculan commander saw him coming, and he too spurred his horse to meet him; 8 and their leveled lances struck with such force as they met that Aebutius’s arm was pierced through, while Mamilius was struck in the breast. 9 The Latins took Mamilius in behind their second line; Aebutius, unable to handle a weapon with his wounded arm, withdrew from the battle.

10 The Latin leader, not the least discouraged by his wound, urged on the fighting, and, because he saw that his men were in retreat, called up a cohort of Roman exiles, commanded by a son of Lucius Tarquinius, and these, fighting more furiously because they had lost their property and native land, restored the battle for a while.

The Roman Victory at Regillus

Chapter 20

1 When the Romans were now beginning to give way in that part of the field, Marcus Valerius, Publicola’s brother, spotted the young Tarquinius, who was boldly inviting attack in the front rank of the exiles. 2 Valerius found in his brother’s glory an additional incentive, and resolving that the family which had the honor of expelling the tyrants should also gain the credit for their death, he dug his spurs into his horse and rode at Tarquinius with leveled spear. 3 Tarquinius drew back among his followers to avoid his desperate opponent. Valerius was plunging blindly into the exiles’ line when one of them attacked him in the flank and ran him through the body. But the rider’s wound did not stop his horse’s charge, and the dying Roman fell in a heap on the ground with his weapons on top of him.

4 When the dictator Postumius saw that so brave a soldier had fallen, that the exiles 5 were advancing boldly at a run, and that his troops were checked and were giving ground, he issued orders to his own cohort, a picked body of men he kept around him as a guard, that if they saw any Roman running away they should treat him as an enemy. 6 Caught between two dangers, the Romans turned to face the enemy, and the battle line was formed again. The dictator’s cohort then entered the fighting for the first time.

7 With fresh strength and spirit they attacked the weary exiles and cut them to pieces. Then another fight between leaders began. The Latin general, seeing that the cohort of the exiles was nearly cut off by the Roman dictator, took a few companies of his reserves and hurried them to the front. 8 As they came marching up, Titus Herminius, the lieutenant, caught sight of them, and in their midst, conspicuous by his dress and equipment, he saw and recognized Mamilius. 9 At that he hurled himself at the enemy’s commander with so much more violence than the master of the horse had shown a little earlier that not only did he pierce Mamilius through the side and kill him with a single thrust, but while stripping his opponent’s body he was himself struck by an enemy javelin, and after being carried off to the Roman camp in the moment of victory, he died just as they began to dress his wound.

10 The dictator then dashed up to the knights and begged them, since the foot soldiers were exhausted, to dismount and enter the fight. They obeyed: they leaped down from their horses, hastened to the front, and covered the front ranks with their shields. 11 The infantry’s courage was at once restored by the sight of the young nobles on even terms with themselves and sharing in the danger. Then at last the Latins were checked, and their battle line was forced to yield. 12 The knights had their horses brought up so that they could pursue the enemy, and they were followed by the infantry. Then the dictator, neglecting no help, divine or human, is said to have vowed a temple to Castor, and to have promised rewards to the soldiers who were first and second to enter the camp of the enemy; 13 and the Romans’ ardor was so great that with a single rush they routed their opponents and took their camp. Such was the battle at Lake Regillus. The dictator and his master of the horse returned to the City and triumphed.

Uncertain Dates

Chapter 21

1 For the next three years there was neither a stable peace nor war. The consuls Quintus Cloelius and Titus Larcius were followed by Aulus Sempronius and Marcus Minucius. 2 In the latter year a temple to Saturn was dedicated and the Saturnalia was established as a holiday. Next Aulus Postumius and Titus Verginius were made consuls. 3 It was not until this year, according to some authorities I have consulted, that the battle of Lake Regillus was fought. They say that Aulus Postumius, because his colleague was of doubtful loyalty, resigned the consulship, and was then made dictator. 4 The varying order of the magistrates in different lists creates so many uncertainties about dates that it is impossible to tell which consuls followed which, or what was done in each particular year, when not only events but even authorities are so shrouded in antiquity.

The Death of Tarquinius

5 At the next election Appius Claudius and Publius Servilius were chosen consuls. This year was marked by the announcement of Tarquinius’s death. He died at Cumae, where he had gone to the court of Aristodemus after the collapse of the Latin cause. 6 This news cheered the Fathers and encouraged the plebs. But the Fathers, in their rejoicing, became too high-handed; and the plebs, who until then had been treated with the greatest deference, began to feel the oppression of the nobles.

7 The same year the colony of Signia, which King Tarquinius had founded, was reinforced with new colonists and founded a second time. At Rome twenty-one tribes were formed. The temple of Mercury was consecrated on the fifteenth of May.

The Volsci and the Loyal Latins

Chapter 22

1 During the Latin war there had been neither peace nor open hostilities with the Volscian race; for the Volsci had raised troops to send to the aid of the Latins if the Roman dictator did not move quickly, and the Romans did move quickly, so that they would not have to fight both nations in the same battle. Over this grievance the consuls led their legions into the country of the Volsci, who, not expecting to be held to account for their intentions, were surprised and overwhelmed. 2 They had no thought of resisting, and surrendered as hostages three hundred children of the nobility of Cora and Pometia, and so the legions were withdrawn without a fight.

3 Yet it was not long before the Volsci, relieved of their fear, went back to their natural duplicity; again they made secret preparations for war, and formed a military alliance with the Hernici, and also sent envoys in every direction to stir the Latins to rebellion. 4 But the disaster that had recently struck the Latins at Lake Regillus so filled them with rage and hate against anyone who advised them to go to war, that they did not even refrain from violating an embassy, but seized the Volsci and brought them to Rome. There they delivered them up to the consuls with the information that the Volsci and the Hernici were preparing to attack the Romans.

5 When this service had been reported to the senate the Fathers were so grateful that they released to the Latins six thousand captives, and referred the question of a treaty, which they had almost refused forever, to the incoming magistrates. 6 Then, indeed, the Latins rejoiced at the action they had taken, and the advocates of peace were held in high regard. They sent a golden crown as a gift to the Capitoline Jupiter. With the envoys who brought the gift came a huge crowd: the captives who had been returned to their families. 7 Going to the homes of those whom they had each served, they thanked them for the liberality and consideration which had been shown them in their adversity, and formed bonds of hospitality with them. Never before had there been so close a union, both official and personal, between the Latin name and the Roman state.

The Debtors’ Uprising

Chapter 23

1 But not only was war with the Volsci imminent; the citizens were at loggerheads among themselves, and internal dissensions between the Fathers and the plebs had burst into a blaze of hatred, chiefly because of those who had been bound into servitude for their debts. 2 These men complained loudly that while they were abroad fighting for liberty and dominion they had been enslaved and oppressed at home by fellow citizens, and that the freedom of the plebeians was more secure in war than in peace, among enemies than among citizens. This bitter feeling, which was growing on its own, was fanned into flame by one man’s striking misfortune.

3 Old, and bearing the marks of all his misfortunes, the man rushed into the Forum. His clothes were covered with filth, and the condition of his body was even worse, for he was pale and half dead with emaciation. 4 Besides this, his unkempt beard and hair had given his face a savage look. Yet despite his hideous appearance he was recognized, and word went around that he had commanded a company; other military honors too were openly credited to him by the compassionate bystanders, and the man himself displayed the scars on his chest that bore witness to his honorable service in various battles. 5 When they asked the reason for his condition and his squalor, he replied, while the crowd gathered around him almost like an assembly, that during his service in the Sabine war not only had the enemy’s depredations deprived him of his crops, but his cottage had been burned, all his belongings plundered, and his flocks driven off. 6 Then taxes had been levied at a bad moment for him, and he had contracted debts. When these had been swollen by interest, they had first stripped him of the farm which had been his father’s and his grandfather’s, then of the remnants of his property, and finally, like an infection, they had attacked his body, and he had been carried off by his creditor, not to slavery, but to the prison and the torture chamber. 7 He then showed them his back, disfigured with the welts of a recent flogging. The sight and the man’s story caused a great uproar.

8 The disturbance was no longer confined to the Forum, but spread in all directions through the entire City. Those who had been bound for debt, whether in chains or not, broke out into the streets from every side, and begged the Quirites to protect them. 9 At no point was there any lack of volunteers to join the rising; everywhere crowds were streaming through the different streets and shouting as they hurried to the Forum. 10 The senators who happened to be in the Forum and ran into the mob were in great danger, and the mob would not have stopped short of violence had not the consuls, Publius Servilius and Appius Claudius, hurriedly intervened to put down the insurrection. But the crowd turned on them and showed their chains and other hideous signs of their treatment. 11 These, they cried, were the rewards they had earned, and they bitterly recounted the campaigns they had each served in various places. They demanded, in a tone more threatening than pleading, that the consuls convene the senate; and they surrounded the Curia so that they themselves

12 could witness and control the deliberations of the state. The consuls succeeded in collecting only a few of the senators whom chance had thrown in their way. 13 The rest were afraid to enter not only the Curia but even the Forum, and nothing could be done because those present were too few. At this the people concluded they were being mocked and put off, that the missing senators were absent not by accident or from fear but to block action, and that the consuls themselves were stalling; they had no doubt that their misery was being treated as a joke. 14 A little more and not even the majesty of the consuls could have held back the angry crowd, when the absent Fathers, unsure whether they risked more by staying away or by coming, finally came into the senate; but when the required number had at last assembled, not only the senators, but even the consuls themselves were unable to agree.

15 Appius, a headstrong man, wanted to settle the matter by exercising consular authority; when one or two men had been arrested, the others, he said, would calm down. Servilius, more inclined to gentle measures, believed that it was safer, as well as easier, to soothe their fury than to crush it.

The Volscian Alarm and Servilius’s Edict

Chapter 24

1 In the middle of the debate a greater alarm arose from a new direction, for some Latin horsemen galloped up with the alarming news that a Volscian army was advancing to attack the City. This report stirred very different feelings in the Fathers and the plebs—so completely had their quarrels split the state in two. 2 The commons were jubilant; they said that the gods were taking a hand in punishing the arrogance of the senators. They urged one another not to enlist; it would be better to perish all together than alone. Let the Fathers serve, let the Fathers take up arms, so that those who received the rewards of war would bear its dangers.

3 The Curia, on the other hand, was downcast and dismayed. In their twofold fear—of their fellow citizens and of the enemy—they begged the consul Servilius, whose character appealed to the people more than his colleague’s did, to rescue the state from the terrible dangers that surrounded it. 4 The consul then adjourned the senate and went before the people. There he declared that the Fathers were eager to look after the interests of the plebs, but that their deliberations about that very important part of the state—but only a part, after all—had been interrupted by their fears for the entire nation. 5 It was impossible, when the enemy was almost at the city gates, to give anything priority over the war; and even if there were some slight breathing space there, it would neither be to the plebs’ credit to refuse to arm for their country unless they were paid first, nor honorable for the Fathers to be driven by fear into passing measures for the relief of their fellow citizens which they would have passed later of their own free will.

6 He then backed up his speech with a proclamation ordering that no one should hold a Roman citizen in chains or confinement so as to keep him from enlisting with the consuls, and that no one should seize or sell a soldier’s property while he was in camp, or interfere with his children or his grandchildren. 7 When this edict had been published, the debtors who were present at once enlisted, and from every part of the City they hurried from the houses where their creditors no longer had the right to detain them, and rushed into the Forum to take the military oath.

8 It was a great crowd, and no soldiers showed more conspicuous courage and usefulness in the Volscian war. The consul led his troops against the enemy, and pitched his camp at a short distance from theirs.

Servilius Defeats the Volsci

Chapter 25

1 The next night the Volsci, counting on the lack of harmony among the Romans, attacked their camp in the hope that the darkness might encourage desertions or treachery. But the sentries spotted them, the army was roused, and at the signal it rushed to arms. 2 Thus the design of the Volsci came to nothing, and both armies spent the rest of the night sleeping. On the following day at dawn the Volsci filled up the trenches and assaulted the rampart, and soon they were everywhere pulling down the palisades.

3 On every side the consul’s men were clamoring for the signal—none more loudly than the debtors. He waited a moment to test the soldiers’ mood. When there could no longer be any doubt of their great ardor, he finally gave the command for a sortie and let them loose, eager for the fight. At the very first charge the enemy were routed. 4 While they ran, the foot soldiers struck at them from behind as long as they could keep up the pursuit; then the horsemen chased them in panic all the way to their camp. Soon the camp itself had been surrounded by the legions, and when the Volsci had fled from it in terror, it was taken and plundered.

5 Next day Servilius led his forces to Suessa Pometia, where the enemy had taken refuge, and within a few days took the town and handed it over to be sacked. This yielded some slight relief to the soldiers, who needed it badly. 6 The consul led his army back to Rome, with great honor to himself. As he was setting out for home, envoys came to him from the Volsci of Ecetra, who were alarmed at their own prospects after the capture of Pometia. A decree of the senate granted them peace, but took away their land.

The Sabine Raid

Chapter 26

1 Immediately after this the Sabines also caused an alarm at Rome—though it was really a commotion rather than a war. One night the City got word that a Sabine army bent on pillage had come as near as the river Anio, and was there plundering and burning farmhouses right and left. 2 The Romans at once dispatched in that direction all their cavalry, under Aulus Postumius, who had been dictator in the Latin war. He was followed by the consul Servilius with a picked body of foot soldiers.

3 The cavalry cut off many stragglers, and when the infantry column drew near, the Sabine troops offered no resistance. Exhausted not only by their march but by their night of pillage as well, a great part of them had gorged themselves in the farmhouses with food and wine, and had barely enough strength to run away.

The Aurunci Defeated

4 A single night had been enough to hear of the Sabine war and end it, and the next day people were hoping that peace was now assured on every side, when envoys from the Aurunci appeared before the senate to say that unless the Romans withdrew from Volscian territory, they would declare war. 5 The Auruncan army had set out from home at the same time as the envoys, and the report that it had already been seen not far from Aricia threw Rome into such a state of confusion that it was impossible to bring the matter before the senate in the regular way or to give a peaceful answer to a people who had already drawn the sword, while the Romans themselves were also arming.

6 They marched on Aricia in fighting order, joined battle with the Aurunci not far from the town, and in a single engagement finished the war.

Appius Enforces the Debt Laws

Chapter 27

1 Having routed the Aurunci and won so many wars within a few days, the Romans were looking for the help which the consul had promised and the senate guaranteed, when Appius, partly out of his natural arrogance, partly to discredit his colleague, began to rule with the utmost severity in suits to recover debts. As a result, not only were those who had been bound for debt before handed back to their creditors, but others were bound as well. 2 Whenever this happened to a soldier he would appeal to the other consul. The people flocked to the house of Servilius: it was he who had made them promises; it was he whom they reproached, as each recounted his service in the wars and showed the scars he had received. They demanded that he either lay the matter before the senate or give his help as consul to his fellow citizens, as general to his soldiers. 3 They moved the consul by this plea, but the situation forced him to stall, so strongly was the other side supported, not only by his colleague, but by the entire party of the nobles. And so he steered a middle course and neither avoided the dislike of the plebs nor gained the goodwill of the Fathers. 4 The Fathers considered him a weak consul and an agitator, while the commons held him to be dishonest; and it soon became clear that he was as heartily hated as Appius.

5 The consuls had fallen into a dispute over which of them should dedicate the temple of Mercury. The senate referred the case to the people for decision. Whichever consul the people ordered to perform the dedication was to take charge of the grain supply, establish a guild of merchants, and perform the solemn rites in the presence of the pontifex. 6 The people assigned the dedication to Marcus Laetorius, a centurion of the first rank—a choice easily understood as intended not so much to honor Laetorius, who had been given a commission too exalted for his station in life, as to humiliate the consuls.

7 Appius and the Fathers were certainly furious then; but the plebeians had taken heart and threw themselves into the struggle with far more spirit than they had shown at first. 8 For, despairing of help from consuls and senate, they no sooner saw a debtor being dragged off than they rushed to help him from every side. It was impossible for the consul’s decree to be heard above the din and shouting, and when it had been pronounced nobody obeyed it. 9 Violence was the order of the day, and fear and danger had completely shifted from the debtors to the creditors, who were singled out and mistreated by large crowds in full sight of the consul.

10 To crown these troubles came the fear of a Sabine invasion. A levy was decreed, but no one enlisted. Appius raged and railed against his colleague’s scheming; who, he said, to make himself popular, was betraying the state by his inactivity; and, on top of refusing to rule in debt cases, was adding a new offense by refusing to hold the levy as the senate had directed. 11 Even so, he said, the state was not entirely abandoned, nor the authority of the consulship given up; he would single-handedly uphold both his own majesty and the senate’s. 12 When the usual daily crowd of lawless men was standing around him, he gave orders to seize a man who was a prominent leader of their disturbances. The lictors were already dragging the man away, when he appealed; and the consul would not have allowed the appeal, since there was no question what the people’s decision would be, had his stubbornness not been overcome with difficulty, more by the advice and influence of the nobles than by the popular outcry, so steeled was he to endure men’s hate.

13 From that moment the trouble grew worse each day, and not only were there open disturbances, but, what was far more dangerous, secret meetings and conferences. At last the consuls whom the plebeians so hated went out of office. Servilius had the goodwill of neither party, but Appius was highly regarded by the senators.

Night Meetings and a Failed Levy

Chapter 28

1 Aulus Verginius and Titus Vetusius then took office as consuls. At this the plebs, unsure what sort of consuls they would turn out to be, held nightly meetings, some on the Esquiline and others on the Aventine, so that they would not, by meeting in the Forum, be frightened into ill-considered measures and handle all their business rashly and haphazardly. 2 The consuls considered this a harmful practice, as indeed it was. They laid the matter before the Fathers, but their report could not be discussed in an orderly fashion, so tumultuously was it received, with shouts from every part of the house and expressions of indignation from the senators, that something which ought to have been settled by consular authority should be referred by the consuls to the senate to shift the unpopularity onto it. 3 Clearly, if there were real magistrates in the state, there would be no assembly in Rome but the assembly of the people; as it was, the government was broken up into a thousand separate curias and meetings. One single man—which means more than a consul—like Appius Claudius would have broken up those gatherings in a moment.

4 When the consuls, rebuked in this way, asked the Fathers what they wanted them to do, and 5 promised to handle the matter with all the energy and firmness the senate wished, it was resolved that they should hold a levy with the utmost severity: it was idleness that made the plebeians lawless.

6 Having adjourned the senate, the consuls mounted the tribunal and called up the young men by name. When no one answered to his name, the crowd, which had gathered around as if for a public meeting, declared that it was impossible to deceive the commons any longer; 7 the consuls would never have a single soldier unless a public guarantee was given: liberty must first be restored to every man before arms were given him, so that he might fight for his country and his fellow citizens, not for a master.

8 It was clear to the consuls what the senate had told them to do; but of all those who had made belligerent speeches within the walls of the Curia, they found not one at their side to share the unpopularity, and they saw before them a terrible struggle with the people. 9 Accordingly they thought it best, before taking extreme measures, to consult the senate a second time. When it met, the youngest senators all rushed up in a fury to the consuls’ seats, telling them to resign their office and to lay down an authority which they lacked the spirit to support.

Riot at the Levy

Chapter 29

1 Having weighed both courses open to them, the consuls finally said, “So that you cannot say you were not warned, Conscript Fathers: we are on the verge of a great mutiny. We demand that those who are loudest in accusing us of cowardice stand by us while we hold the levy. 2 Since that is your wish, the most severe among you will guide our proceedings.” They returned to the tribunal, and deliberately ordered one of those present to be called up by name. When he stood still without answering, in the middle of a small knot of men who had gathered around him for fear of violence, the consuls sent a lictor to him.

3 The lictor was driven back. At that, with a cry of “Shame!” the senators who were attending the consul rushed down from the tribunal to assist the lictor. 4 But when the mob turned from the officer, whom they had only kept from arresting the man, and attacked the senators, the consuls intervened and checked the brawl, in which no stones had been thrown nor any weapons used, and there were more shouts and angry words than injuries.

The Senate Debates Debt Relief

5 The senate was convened in confusion, and they deliberated in still greater confusion. Those who had been roughly handled demanded an investigation, and all the more violent members pressed for it, not only with speeches but with shouts and uproar. 6 When at last their passions had cooled, and the consuls berated them for showing as little sanity in the Curia as the people had shown in the Forum, they began to deliberate in an orderly manner.

7 Three proposals were made. Publius Verginius advised against general relief; only those who, relying on the promise of the consul Publius Servilius, had fought in the Volscian, Auruncan, and Sabine wars should, he thought, be considered. 8 Titus Largius held that this was no time merely to reward services; the whole commons was submerged in debt, and the situation could not be remedied unless provision was made for all; indeed, if some were treated in one way and some in another, it would increase the discontent instead of easing it.

9 Appius Claudius, naturally harsh, and made savage by the hatred of the plebs on the one hand and the praises of the Fathers on the other, said that it was not misery but license that had stirred up such an uproar, and that the plebs were suffering from insolence rather than anger. 10 That was exactly the trouble the right of appeal had caused; for the consuls could threaten but not command when those who shared in the guilt could act as the court of appeal. 11 “Come,” he said, “let us appoint a dictator, from whom there is no appeal. 12 This frenzy that has now set everything ablaze will be quieted at once. Let anyone strike a lictor then, knowing that the right to flog and behead him rests with the one man whose majesty he has violated!”

Manius Valerius Named Dictator

Chapter 30

1 Many felt, and with reason, that the proposal of Appius was stern and cruel; the proposals of Verginius and Largius, on the other hand, set a dangerous precedent, particularly Largius’s, since it destroyed all credit. Verginius’s plan was thought the most reasonable and moderate, with its regard for both sides. 2 But because of partisanship and regard for private interests, which have always harmed public deliberations and always will, Appius prevailed, and came very near 3 to being appointed dictator himself, a step that would certainly have alienated the commons, and at a most dangerous moment, since the Volsci, the Aequi, and the Sabines all happened to be up in arms at once.

4 But the consuls and the older senators saw to it that an office made formidable by its supreme authority was entrusted to a man of gentle temperament, and chose for dictator Manius Valerius, son of Volesus. 5 Though the plebs saw that the appointment of a dictator was aimed at them, they had no fear of any harsh or oppressive act from a member of that family, since it was through a law proposed by a brother of Valerius that they had the right of appeal. 6 An edict the dictator soon issued strengthened their confidence. 7 It was essentially the same as Servilius’s edict; but Valerius and the office he held inspired greater confidence, and men stopped resisting and enlisted. So large an army had never been enrolled before.

8 Ten legions were raised; each consul was given three of these, and the dictator had four. Nor could war be put off any longer, for the Aequi had invaded Latin territory. Envoys from the Latins begged the senate either to send them help or to allow them to take up arms themselves in defense of their country. 9 It seemed safer to defend the Latins without arming them than to allow them to take up their weapons again. The consul Vetusius was dispatched to them, and this ended the pillaging. The Aequi left the fields, and, trusting more to their position than to their arms, took refuge on the tops of the ridges.

Victory Over the Volsci

10 The other consul marched against the Volsci. So as not to waste time as well, he provoked the enemy, chiefly by ravaging their lands, to bring their camp nearer and do battle with him. 11 In the plain between the camps the two armies formed their lines, each in front of its own stockade. 12 The Volsci were somewhat superior in numbers, and so they came on in loose and careless order. The Roman consul did not advance, nor did he let his men answer the enemy’s shout. He commanded his men to plant their spears in the ground and stand still until the enemy had come to close quarters; then they were to attack them with all their might, and settle the question with the sword. 13 The Volsci, weary with running and shouting, hurled themselves on the Romans, who seemed to be numb with fear. But when the attackers found that their charge was firmly met and saw the swords flash in their faces, they were just as confused as if they had fallen into an ambush, and turned and fled; and even flight was beyond their strength, since they had been running as they entered the battle. 14 The Romans, on the other hand, having stood still at the beginning of the fight, were fresh and strong; they readily caught up with the exhausted Volsci, and having taken their camp with a rush, pursued their enemies beyond it to Velitrae, where the defeated and the victors burst into the city together. 15 More blood was shed there, in the indiscriminate slaughter of all kinds of people, than had been in the battle itself. A very few, who came unarmed and surrendered, were spared.

Valerius Defeats the Sabines

Chapter 31

1 While these things were going on in the Volscian country, the dictator routed the Sabines—by far Rome’s most important enemy—and captured their camp. 2 Attacking with his cavalry, he wrecked their center, which they had weakened too much by extending their wings too widely; and in the middle of the confusion the infantry attacked them. By a single rush the camp was captured and the war ended. 3 No battle of those days since the fight at Lake Regillus was more famous. The dictator entered the City in triumph. In addition to the customary honors, he was given a place in the circus from which he and his descendants could watch the games, and a curule chair was put there for him.

4 The conquered Volsci were stripped of the Veliternian land; colonists were sent from the City to Velitrae and a colony was founded. Soon after this there was a battle with the Aequi, though the consul was against it, since they would have to approach the enemy over unfavorable ground; 5 but his men accused him of dragging out the campaign so that the dictator would give up his office before they returned to the City, and his promises would come to nothing, as the consul’s promises had done before. Vetusius was driven to order a reckless advance up the mountains facing him. 6 The enemy’s cowardice turned this ill-advised move into a success, for before the Romans had come within a spear’s throw, the Aequi, appalled at their audacity, abandoned the camp they had held in a highly defensible position, and threw themselves down into the valleys on the other side. There the Romans gained considerable booty and a bloodless victory.

Valerius Resigns the Dictatorship

7 Though three victories had been won in the war, neither senators nor plebeians were relieved of their anxiety about how things would turn out at home, so great was the cunning, as well as the influence, with which the moneylenders had laid their plans to thwart not only the commons but even the dictator himself. 8 For after the return of the consul Vetusius, the first business Valerius brought before the senate was on behalf of the victorious people: he asked the senate to declare its policy on the treatment of those bound for debt.

9 When this motion failed, the dictator said, “You do not like my urging harmony. You will soon wish, I assure you, that the Roman plebs had men like me for their spokesmen. For my part, I will not be the means of disappointing my fellow citizens any further, nor will I be dictator to no purpose. 10 Internal strife and foreign war made this office necessary to the nation; peace has been secured abroad, but at home it is being blocked; when the revolt breaks out, I will play my part as a private citizen rather than as dictator.” With these words he left the Curia and laid down his office.

11 It was evident to the people that resentment at the wrongs done to them had led him to resign. And so, as though he had kept his pledge—for it had not been his fault that it was not being carried out—they escorted him home with shows of favor and approval.

The Secession to the Sacred Mount

Chapter 32

1 Then the senators became alarmed, fearing that if the army were disbanded there would again be secret meetings and conspiracies. And so, although the levy had been held by order of the dictator, because the men had been sworn in by the consuls they regarded the troops as bound by their oath, and, on the pretext that the Aequi had resumed hostilities, gave orders to lead the legions out of the City. 2 This brought the revolt to a head. At first, it is said, there was talk of killing the consuls so that the men would be freed from their oath; but when it was explained to them that no sacred obligation could be dissolved by a crime, they took the advice of a certain Sicinius, and without orders from the consuls withdrew to the Sacred Mount, which lies across the river Anio, three miles from the City.

3 This version of the story is more widely held than Piso’s, according to which the Aventine was the place of their secession. 4 There, without any leader, they fortified their camp with a stockade and trench and stayed there quietly for several days, taking nothing but what they needed to live on, neither receiving provocation nor giving any.

5 There was a great panic in the City, and mutual fear brought all activity to a halt. The plebeians left behind by their friends feared violence at the hands of the senators; the senators feared the plebeians who were left behind in Rome, unsure whether they would rather have them stay or go. 6 Besides, how long would the seceding crowd stay peaceful? What would happen next if some foreign war broke out in the meantime? 7 Surely no hope was left except in harmony among the citizens, and they concluded they must restore this to the state by fair means or foul.

The Fable of the Belly and the Members

8 They therefore decided to send Agrippa Menenius as an envoy to the commons, an eloquent man and dear to the plebeians because he was one of them by birth. Admitted to the camp, he is said simply to have told this fable, in the quaint and rough style of that age: 9 In the days when man’s members did not all agree with one another, as they do now, but each had its own ideas and a voice of its own, the other parts thought it unfair that they should have the worry and the trouble and the labor of providing everything for the belly, while the belly stayed quietly in their midst with nothing to do but enjoy the good things they gave it; so they conspired together that the hands should carry no food to the mouth, nor the mouth accept anything that was given it, nor the teeth grind up what they received.⁠ 10 While they sought in this angry spirit to starve the belly into submission, the members themselves and the whole body were reduced to the utmost weakness. 11 From this it became clear that even the belly had no idle task, and was no more nourished than it nourished the rest, by giving out to all parts of the body what we live and thrive on, when it has been divided equally among the veins and is enriched with digested food—that is, the blood. 12 By drawing a parallel to show how the internal dissension of the body’s members resembled the anger of the plebs against the Fathers, he won over the minds of his hearers.

The First Tribunes of the People

Chapter 33

1 Steps were then taken toward harmony, and a compromise was reached on these terms: the plebeians were to have magistrates of their own, who would be inviolable and would have the right to help the people against the consuls, and no senator was to be allowed to hold this office. 2 And so they chose two “tribunes of the people,” Gaius Licinius and Lucius Albinus. These appointed three others as their colleagues. One of these, all agree, was Sicinius, the instigator of the revolt; the identity of the other two is less certain. 3 Some hold that there were only two tribunes elected on the Sacred Mount, and that the law of inviolability was enacted there. During the secession of the plebs Spurius Cassius and Postumus Cominius began their consulship.

Marcius at Corioli

4 In this year a treaty was made with the Latin peoples. To make this treaty, one of the consuls stayed in Rome, while the other was dispatched to the Volscian war and defeated and routed the Volsci of Antium. Forcing them to take refuge in the town of Longula, he pursued them and captured the place. 5 From there he went on to take Polusca, another Volscian town, after which he launched a strong attack on Corioli. There was in camp at that time among the young nobles Gnaeus Marcius, a young man quick in mind and action, who afterward gained the surname of Coriolanus.

6 The Romans were laying siege to Corioli and were focused on the townspeople shut up inside the walls, with no thought of any attack that might be coming from outside, when they suddenly found themselves attacked by a Volscian army from Antium, and simultaneously by the besieged, who made a sortie from the town. It happened that Marcius was on guard. 7 Taking a picked body of men he not only drove back the sortie, but boldly forced his way through the open gate, and, after spreading slaughter through the nearby part of the town, snatched up a firebrand on the spur of the moment and threw it onto the buildings which overhung the wall. 8 At this the townspeople raised a shout, mingled with the kind of wailing of women and children usually heard at the first alarm. This brought new courage to the Romans and threw the Volsci into confusion—as was natural when the city they had come to relieve was taken.

9 Thus the men of Antium were routed, and Corioli was won. The glory of Marcius so completely overshadowed the consul’s fame that, were it not for the record, on a bronze column, of the treaty with the Latins concluded by Spurius Cassius alone in the absence of his colleague, people would have forgotten that Postumus Cominius had waged war on the Volsci.

The Death of Agrippa Menenius

10 That same year saw the death of Agrippa Menenius, a man who throughout his life had been equally beloved by patricians and plebeians, and who after the secession was even dearer to the commons. 11 This mediator and arbiter of civic harmony, this ambassador of the senators to the people, this restorer of the plebs to Rome, did not leave enough money to pay for a funeral. He was buried by the commons, who contributed a sextans each to the cost.

Famine at Rome

Chapter 34

1 The consuls next chosen were Titus Geganius and Publius Minucius. This year, though no war was causing trouble from outside and the breach at home had been healed, another and much more serious misfortune struck the nation; 2 for first the price of grain went up, because the fields had not been farmed during the withdrawal of the plebs; and this was followed by a famine like those that strike a besieged city. 3 It would have meant starvation for the slaves, at least, and the plebeians, had not the consuls met the situation by sending agents far and wide to buy up grain, not only to Etruria, northwards along the coast from Ostia, and south past the Volsci by sea, all the way to Cumae, but even to Sicily—so far afield had the hostility of Rome’s neighbors driven her to seek help.

4 When grain had been bought at Cumae, the tyrant Aristodemus held back the ships as compensation for the property of the Tarquinii, whose heir he was. Among the Volsci and Pomptini the agents could not even make any purchases, and they were actually in danger from the violence of the people. 5 Grain came in from the Tuscans by way of the Tiber, and with this the plebs were kept alive. A disastrous war would have been added to the hardships caused by the food shortage had not a severe plague struck the Volsci just as they were beginning hostilities. 6 Its ravages so terrified the enemy that even after the worst of it was over they did not fully recover from their fear, and the Romans increased the number of colonists at Velitrae and sent out a new colony to Norba, in the mountains, as a stronghold for the Pomptine country.

Coriolanus and the Price of Grain

7 Next year, in the consulship of Marcus Minucius and Aulus Sempronius, a large quantity of grain was imported from Sicily, and the senate debated at what price it should be sold to the plebeians. 8 Many thought the time had come to crush the commons and take back the rights they had forced from the Fathers by their secession. Conspicuous among these was Marcius Coriolanus, an enemy of the tribunes’ power, who said, “If they want grain at the old price, let them restore to the senate its ancient rights. 9 Why do I see plebeian magistrates, why must I, sent under the yoke and ransomed, as it were, from bandits, see Sicinius in power? 10 Am I to endure these humiliations any longer than I must? I would not tolerate Tarquinius as king; must I tolerate Sicinius? Let him secede now and call out the plebs; the way lies open to the Sacred Mount and the other hills. Let them seize grain from our fields as they did two years ago. Let them enjoy the grain prices they have brought about by their own madness. 11 I dare say this miserable situation will tame them so thoroughly that they will sooner farm the land themselves than withdraw under arms and keep others from farming it.”

12 It is less easy to say whether this would have been the right thing to do than it is clear, I think, that the Fathers had it in their power to set conditions for lowering the price of grain that would have freed them from the tribunician authority and all the terms which they had unwillingly agreed to.

The Trial of Coriolanus

Chapter 35

1 Even the senate considered the proposal too harsh, and the plebs were so angry that they almost resorted to arms. Starvation, they said, was now being used against them, as though they were public enemies, and they were being defrauded of their food and sustenance; the imported grain, their only supply, unexpectedly given them by Fortune, was to be snatched from their mouths unless the tribunes were handed over in chains to Gnaeus Marcius, unless he could work his will on the bodies of the Roman plebeians; in him a new executioner had risen up against them, who told them to choose between death and slavery. 2 When he came out of the Curia they would have attacked him had the tribunes not, in the nick of time, set a day for his trial; at that their anger subsided, for every man saw that he himself had been made his enemy’s judge and held the power of life and death over him.

3 At first Marcius listened to the tribunes’ threats with contempt, claiming that the office had been granted the right to help, not to punish, and that they were tribunes not of the Fathers, but of the plebs. But the commons had risen in such a storm of anger that the Fathers had to sacrifice one man to appease them. 4 Even so, they resisted their opponents’ hatred and called on the private resources of individual senators, as well as the strength of the entire order. At first they tried, by posting their clients here and there, to frighten people from meeting to deliberate, hoping in this way to break up their plans. 5 Then they came out in a body—you would have said all the members of the senate were on trial—and begged the plebs to release to them one citizen, one senator; if they were unwilling to acquit him as innocent, let them give him up, though guilty, as a favor.

6 But when Marcius himself, on the day appointed for the hearing, failed to appear, people’s hearts hardened against him. Condemned in his absence, he went into exile with the Volsci, uttering threats against his country, and already breathing hostility. When he came among the Volsci they received him with a kindness that grew from day to day, as he let his hatred of his own people show more and more and was more and more frequently heard to utter both complaints and threats.

Coriolanus and Attius Tullius

7 His host was Attius Tullius, at that time by far the leading man of the Volscian nation and always hostile to the Romans. And so, spurred on, one by long-standing hatred and the other by fresh resentment, they plotted together how to make war on Rome. 8 They believed that it would be no easy matter to persuade the Volscian commons to take up the arms they had so often tried without success; the destruction of their young men in repeated wars, and finally by the plague, had, they supposed, broken their spirit; they must use cunning, since hatred had dulled with the passing of time, to find some new cause of anger to inflame people’s hearts.

The Dream of Titus Latinius

Chapter 36

1 It so happened that at Rome preparations were being made to repeat the Great Games. The reason for the repetition was this: early on the day set for the games, before the show had begun, a certain householder had driven his slave, carrying a yoke, through the middle of the circus, flogging him as he went. 2 The games had then begun as though this had in no way affected their sanctity. Not long after, Titus Latinius, a plebeian, had a dream. He dreamed that Jupiter said that the leading dancer at the games had displeased him; that unless the festival were lavishly repeated, the City would be in danger; that Latinius was to go and announce this to the consuls. 3 Though the man’s conscience was far from easy, the awe he felt at the magistrates’ majesty was too great; he was afraid of becoming a laughingstock.

4 He paid a heavy price for his hesitation, for a few days later he lost his son. So that this sudden calamity would leave the wretched man no doubt about its cause, the same phantom appeared again before him in his dreams, and asked him, as he thought, whether he had been repaid enough for spurning the gods, for a greater penalty was at hand unless he went quickly and informed the consuls. 5 This brought the matter closer to home. Yet he still delayed and put off going, until a sudden violent illness laid him low.

6 Then at last the anger of the gods taught him wisdom. And so, worn out with his sufferings, past and present, he called a council of his kinsmen and explained to them what he had seen and heard, how Jupiter had so often confronted him in his sleep, and how the threats and anger of the god had been immediately fulfilled in his own misfortunes. 7 Then, with the unhesitating approval of all present, he was carried on a stretcher to the consuls in the Forum, and from there, by their command, to the Curia, where he had no sooner told the same story to the Fathers, to the amazement of them all, than—another miracle! 8 For it is said that the man who had been carried into the senate house disabled in every limb returned home on his own feet after doing his duty.

Tullius’s Plot at the Games

Chapter 37

1 Games of the greatest possible splendor were decreed by the senate, and at Attius Tullius’s suggestion a large crowd of Volsci came to see them. 2 Before the show began, Tullius, following the plan he and Marcius had made at home, went to the consuls and told them that he had something of public importance which he wished to discuss with them in private.

3 When the bystanders had been removed, “I am reluctant,” he said, “to say anything about my countrymen that may discredit them. Still, I do not come to accuse them of having committed any crime, but to put you on your guard in case they commit one. 4 The temperament of our people is far more fickle than I could wish. 5 Many disasters have taught us the truth of this, since we owe our survival not to our own merit but to your patience. A great crowd of Volsci is now in Rome; there are games; the citizens will be absorbed in the show. 6 I remember what the Sabine youths did in this City when the same opportunity arose; I dread that something ill-advised and rash may happen. It has seemed to me that both on our account and on yours I ought to tell you this beforehand, consuls. 7 For my part, I intend to go home at once, so that I am not on the spot to be implicated in some act or word and compromised.” With this he departed. The consuls laid this vague warning, which came from such a reliable source, before the senate.

8 It was the source, as often happens, rather than the story that persuaded them to take precautions, even if they might turn out to be unnecessary. The senate decreed that the Volsci should leave the City, and heralds were sent around to order them all to depart before nightfall. 9 At first they were struck with great alarm as they hurried this way and that to the houses of their hosts to get their things. But when they had started, their hearts swelled with indignation, that they should have been driven from the games at festival time like criminals and polluted persons, and shut out, in a way, from the company of men and gods.

Tullius Rouses the Volsci

Chapter 38

1 As they traveled on in an almost unbroken line, Tullius, who had gone ahead, arrived before them at the source of the Ferentina. There, when any of their chief men arrived, he met them with words of complaint and indignation. He led these leaders, who eagerly drank in the words he used to feed their anger, and through their influence the rest of the crowd as well, to a field below the road.

2 There he launched into a speech like a general’s address to his troops. “Even if you forget everything else,” he cried, “the ancient wrongs done by the Roman People and the disasters that have struck the Volscian race, how, I ask you, can you bear the insult which this day has brought to us, making our humiliation serve as the opening of their festival? 3 Or did you not feel that they were triumphing over you today? That you made a spectacle for everyone when you left—to the citizens, to the strangers, to all the neighboring nations? 4 That your wives and children were made a mockery in the eyes of the world? What of those who heard the words of the herald? What of those who saw us going away? What of those who have met this shameful procession? What do you think they all supposed, except that we were surely guilty of some sin; that because our presence at the show would pollute the games and bring down the god’s displeasure, we were being expelled from the home of the righteous and from their gathering and their council? 5 Moreover, does it not occur to you that we are alive because we hurried to leave?—if, indeed, this is a departure and not rather a flight. And this City—do you not regard it as a city of enemies, where, if you had stayed a single day, you would all have had to die? 6 War has been declared on you, and those responsible will bitterly regret it, if you are men.” So, their spontaneous anger fanned into flame, they scattered to their homes, and, with every man rousing his own people, they brought about a revolt of the entire Volscian nation.

Coriolanus Marches on Rome

Chapter 39

1 For this war the nations all agreed on Attius Tullius and Gnaeus Marcius, the Roman exile, as their generals, and Marcius inspired rather more hope than his colleague. 2 He did not disappoint this hope at all, so it was easy to see that Rome’s strength lay more in her commanders than in her armies. Marching first to Circei, he drove the Roman colonists out of that city and handed it over, now freed, to the Volsci. 3 He took Satricum, Longula, Polusca, and Corioli, places which the Romans had recently acquired. 4 He then recovered Lavinium, and then, crossing by side roads to the Latin Way, captured one after another Corbio, Vetelia, Trebium, Labici, and Pedum. 5 From Pedum he finally led his army against Rome and, pitching his camp at the Cluilian Trenches, five miles from the City, laid waste the Roman territory from that base, sending guards out with the raiders to keep untouched the farms of the patricians, whether from anger at the plebs, or to sow dissension between them and the Fathers.

6 And no doubt dissension would have broken out, so fiercely did the tribunes try with their 7 accusations to rouse the already headstrong commons against the nation’s leaders, but fear of invasion, the strongest bond of harmony, tended to unite them, however much they might suspect and dislike one another. 8 On this one point they could not agree: the senate and the consuls saw no hope anywhere but in arms, while the plebs preferred anything to war. Spurius Nautius and Sextus Furius were now consuls.

9 While they were reviewing their levies and posting garrisons around the walls and in the other places where they had decided to station pickets and sentries, a great multitude of people demanding peace first frightened them with their rebellious uproar and then forced them to call the senate together and propose sending envoys to Gnaeus Marcius. The Fathers agreed to the proposal when they saw that the plebeians were growing discouraged, and envoys were sent to Marcius to negotiate peace. 10 The answer they brought back was stern. 11 If the Volsci’s land were restored to them, the question of peace could be taken up; if the Romans wished to enjoy the gains of war without doing anything, he would forget neither the wrong his fellow citizens had done him nor the kindness of his hosts, but would try to show that exile had sharpened his courage, not broken it.

12 When the same envoys were sent back a second time, they were refused entry to the camp. Even priests, wearing their sacred headbands, are said to have gone as suppliants to the enemy’s camp, where they were no more able than the envoys had been to change Marcius’s mind.

Veturia Before Coriolanus

Chapter 40

1 Then the married women gathered in large numbers at the house of Veturia, the mother of Coriolanus, and Volumnia, his wife. 2 Whether this was public policy or women’s fear I cannot discover; in any case they persuaded both Veturia, an old woman, and Volumnia to take the two little sons of Marcius and go with them to the enemy’s camp, so that, since the men’s swords could not defend the City, the women might defend it with their prayers and tears.

3 When they reached the camp, and word came to Coriolanus that a large company of women had arrived, at first, as might be expected of a man whom neither the nation’s majesty, embodied in its envoys, nor the awe of religion, presented to heart and eye in the persons of its priests, could move, he was even more stubborn in resisting women’s tears. 4 Then one of his friends, picking out Veturia from the other women by her striking sadness as she stood between her son’s wife and his little children, said, “Unless my eyes deceive me, your mother is here and your wife and children.”

5 Coriolanus sprang up from his seat like a madman and, running to meet his mother, would have embraced her, but her pleas turned to anger, and she said, “Let me find out, before I accept your embrace, whether I have come to an enemy or a son; whether I am a captive or a mother in your camp. 6 Is this what long life and an unhappy old age have brought me to, that I should see you an exile and then an enemy? Could you bring yourself to ravage this country, which gave you birth and raised you? 7 Did not your anger fall from you, no matter how hostile and threatening your spirit was when you came, as you crossed the border? Did it not occur to you, when Rome lay before your eyes, ‘Within those walls are my home and my gods, my mother, my wife, and my children’? 8 So then, if I had not been a mother, Rome would not be under siege now! If I had no son, I would have died a free woman in a free land! 9 But nothing I could suffer now could be more disgraceful to you or more miserable for me; nor, wretched though I am, will I be so for long. It is these you must think of, for whom, if you go on, early death or long slavery lies in store.” The embraces of his wife and children, following this speech, and the tears of the entire company of women, and their lamentations for themselves and their country, at last broke his resolve.

The Fate of Coriolanus

10 He embraced his family and sent them back, and pulled his forces back from the City. After leading his army out of Roman territory, he is said to have died under the weight of the resentment this act caused, though accounts of his death vary. I find in Fabius, by far the oldest authority, that Coriolanus lived on to old age. 11 At least he reports that Coriolanus often said that exile was far more wretched for an old man. The men of Rome did not envy the fame the women had earned—so 12 free was life in those days from belittling another’s glory—and to preserve its memory the temple of Fortuna Muliebris was built and dedicated. Afterward the Volsci again invaded Roman soil, together with the Aequi, but the Aequi would no longer accept Attius Tullius as their general. 13 The dispute over whether the Volsci or the Aequi should provide a commander for the allied army then led to a quarrel, and this to a bloody battle. There the good fortune of the Roman People destroyed two enemy armies in a single struggle as ruinous as it was stubbornly fought.

14 Next came the consulship of Titus Sicinius and Gaius Aquilius. Sicinius was assigned the Volscian war, and Aquilius the war with the Hernici—for they too were up in arms. This year the Hernici were conquered, while the campaign against the Volsci was indecisive.

Spurius Cassius and the First Land Law

Chapter 41

1 Spurius Cassius and Proculus Verginius were then made consuls. A treaty was struck with the Hernici, and two-thirds of their land was taken from them. The consul Cassius proposed to divide half of this among the Latins and the other half among the plebeians. 2 To this gift he wanted to add some of the land that, he charged, was held by private individuals although it belonged to the state. At this many of the Fathers, who themselves held the land, took fright at the danger to their interests. But the senators were also concerned on public grounds: the consul was using his handouts to build up an influence dangerous to liberty. 3 This was the first proposal for agrarian legislation, and from that day to within living memory it has never been brought up without causing the most serious disturbances.

4 The other consul opposed the handout, and the Fathers supported him; nor were the commons solidly against him, for, to begin with, they resented that the gift had been made general and extended to allies as well as citizens; 5 and besides, they often heard the consul Verginius declare in his speeches, as though he read the future, that destruction lurked in the gift proposed by his colleague; that those lands would bring slavery to the men who received them and were being made a road to monarchy. 6 What reason had there been, he asked, for including the allies and the Latin nation, and for returning to the Hernici, who had been enemies a short time before, a third of the land that had been taken from them, unless it was so that these tribes could have Cassius as their leader in place of Coriolanus?

7 Popular favor now began to shift to the man who opposed and vetoed the land legislation. Each consul then began, as if vying with the other, to pamper the plebs. Verginius said that he would allow lands to be assigned, provided they were assigned to none but Roman citizens. 8 Cassius, who had courted the allies’ support with his proposed land grants and so lowered himself in the eyes of the Romans, wanted to win back his fellow citizens’ affection with another gift, and proposed that the money received from the Sicilian grain should be paid back to the people. 9 But the people rejected this as an outright attempt to buy royal power; their instinctive suspicion of monarchy made them so scornful of his gifts that they acted as if they had more than enough of everything; and Cassius had no sooner laid down his office than he was condemned and executed, as all authorities agree.

Accounts of the Condemnation of Cassius

10 Some say that his father was responsible for his punishment: that he tried the case at home, and that after having his son flogged and put to death, he dedicated the son’s personal property to Ceres, from the proceeds of which a statue was made and inscribed “the gift of the Cassian family.” 11 I find in certain authors—and this is the more credible account—that the quaestors Caeso Fabius and Lucius Valerius brought him to trial for treason, and that he was found guilty by the judgment of the people and his house pulled down by popular decree. Its site is now the open space in front of the temple of Tellus. 12 But whether it was a family trial or a public one, he was condemned in the consulship of Servius Cornelius and Quintus Fabius.

The Fabii and the Land Law

Chapter 42

1 It was not long before the people forgot the anger they had felt against Cassius. Once its author had been removed, the natural appeal of the land law attracted them for its own sake, and their desire for it was heightened by the stinginess of the Fathers, who, after the Volsci and the Aequi were defeated that year, cheated the soldiers of their booty. 2 Fabius sold whatever was taken from the enemy and put the proceeds in the public treasury. The Fabian name was hateful to the plebs, because of the last consul; nevertheless the patricians managed to get Caeso Fabius elected to that office, along with Lucius Aemilius. 3 This increased the rancor of the plebeians, and their unrest at home brought on a foreign war. The war then interrupted the strife at home, as patricians and plebeians, of one mind and purpose, faced the rebellious Volsci and Aequi and, led by Aemilius, defeated them in a successful battle. 4 Yet more of the enemy perished in flight than in the battle, so relentlessly did the cavalry pursue their routed forces.

5 Castor’s temple was dedicated the same year, on the fifteenth of July. It had been vowed during the Latin war by Postumius, the dictator. His son, appointed duumvir for this special purpose, dedicated it.

6 This year the desires of the plebs were again stirred by the attractions of the land law. The tribunes of the plebs tried to win favor for their democratic office with a democratic law, while the senators, who thought the populace was frenzied enough already without being rewarded for it, shuddered at the thought of land grants and encouragements to rashness. 7 The consuls were the most energetic leaders the senatorial opposition could have. Their party was therefore victorious and not only won an immediate success but, besides, elected as consuls for the approaching year Marcus Fabius, Caeso’s brother, and a man the people hated even more for his prosecution of Spurius Cassius, Lucius Valerius. 8 This year also there was a conflict with the tribunes. Nothing came of the legislation, and its supporters were held in contempt for boasting of a measure they could not carry through. From then on the Fabii were held in high regard after their three successive consulships, every one of which had been tested by struggles with the tribunes; so the office, as if well invested, was allowed to stay in that family for some time.

Portents and the Vestal Oppia

9 War then broke out with Veii, and the Volsci revolted. But for foreign wars there were almost more than enough resources, and people misused them in quarreling among themselves. 10 To increase the general anxiety which was now felt, portents showing the anger of the gods occurred almost daily in the City and the country. For this expression of divine anger the soothsayers, when they had inquired into it both officially and privately, sometimes by inspecting entrails and sometimes by observing the flight of birds, gave no other reason than the failure to observe the rites of religion properly. 11 These alarms finally led to the condemnation of Oppia, a Vestal virgin, for unchastity, and her punishment.

Caeso Fabius and the Sullen Army

Chapter 43

1 Quintus Fabius and Gaius Julius were then made consuls. This year there was no less discord at home, and the threat of war was greater. The Aequi took up arms, and the Veientes even raided Roman territory. Amid the growing anxiety caused by these campaigns Caeso Fabius and Spurius Furius were elected to the consulship. 2 Ortona, a Latin city, was being besieged by the Aequi; while the Veientes, who by this time had had their fill of looting, were threatening to attack Rome itself.

3 These alarms, which should have restrained the hostility of the plebeians, actually increased it; and they resumed their custom of refusing service, though not on their own initiative; for it was Spurius Licinius, tribune of the plebs, who, thinking the moment had come to force a land law on the patricians through the direst necessity, had set out to obstruct the preparations for war. 4 But he brought on himself all the hatred attached to the tribunes’ office, and the consuls attacked him no more fiercely than his own colleagues did, and with their help the consuls held a levy.

5 Armies were enlisted for two wars at the same time; Fabius was given command of one, which was to invade the Aequi, while Furius was to oppose the Veientes with the other. 6 Against the Veientes nothing worth recording was accomplished; and in the Aequian campaign Fabius had somewhat more trouble with his fellow Romans than with the enemy. That one man, the consul himself, saved the state, which the army, in its hatred of the consul, would have betrayed as far as it could. 7 For when the consul, besides the many other examples of good generalship he showed in preparing for the war and in his conduct of it, had so drawn up the battle line that a cavalry charge alone was enough to rout the enemy’s army, the infantry refused to pursue the fleeing enemy; 8 nor could their own sense of guilt—to say nothing of the urging of their hated general—nor even the thought of the immediate disgrace to all and the danger they would soon face if the enemy recovered his courage, make them speed up, or, if nothing else, hold their ranks. 9 Contrary to orders they retreated and returned to their camp, so dejected that you would have thought them beaten, cursing now their leader and now the effective work of the cavalry. 10 Ruinous though their example was, the general found no remedy for it; so true is it that noble minds more often lack the qualities by which men govern their fellow citizens than those by which they conquer an enemy.

11 The consul returned to Rome, having earned more hatred from his irritated and embittered soldiers than he gained in military fame. Nevertheless the Fathers insisted on keeping the consulship in the Fabian family. Marcus Fabius was the man they elected, and they gave him Gnaeus Manlius as a colleague.

Appius Divides the Tribunes

Chapter 44

1 This year too a tribune, Tiberius Pontificius, advocated a land law. He took the same path Spurius Licinius had taken, as though Licinius had been successful, and for a time obstructed the levy. 2 The senators were again alarmed, but Appius Claudius told them that the tribunes’ power had been overcome the year before—in practice for the moment, and in principle forever—since a way had been found to turn its own resources against it. 3 For there would always be some tribune who would be willing to gain a personal victory over his colleague, and win the favor of the better class, while doing the nation a service. There would be several tribunes, if several were needed, who would be ready to help the consuls; and a single one was enough, though opposed to all the rest. 4 The consuls, and the leading senators as well, need only make a point of winning over, if not all, at least some of the tribunes to the state and the senate.

5 Acting on the instructions of Appius, the Fathers as a body began to treat the tribunes with courtesy and kindness; and the former consuls, whenever any of them had a personal claim on an individual tribune, used partly personal and partly political influence to make those officials willing to use their powers for the good of the state; and four of them, against one who would have blocked the common good, helped the consuls hold the levy.

Etruria Joins Veii

6 The army then set out for a war with the Veientes, 7 to whose help forces had rallied from every quarter of Etruria, roused not so much by goodwill toward the men of Veii as by hopes that civil strife might bring about the downfall of the Roman state. 8 And indeed the leading men in the councils of all the Etrurian peoples were angrily complaining that there would be no end to the power of the Romans unless factional quarrels set them fighting among themselves. They asserted that this was the only poison, the only rot that had been found to work on wealthy states and make great empires short-lived.

9 For a long time the Romans had withstood this evil, thanks partly to the prudence of the senate, partly to the patience of the plebs; but things had now reached a crisis. Two states had been created out of one: each faction had its own magistrates, its own laws. 10 At first, though they tended to oppose the levies fiercely, when war began they had obeyed their generals. Whatever the state of things in the City, as long as military discipline held, it had been possible to hold out; but now the habit of disobeying magistrates was following the Roman soldier even to his camp. 11 In their latest war, when the army was already drawn up for battle, and at the very moment of combat, they had with one accord actually handed over the victory to the conquered Aequi, had deserted their standards, had left their general on the field, and had returned, against his orders, to their camp. 12 Surely, if her enemies pressed forward, they could defeat Rome through her own soldiers. Nothing more was needed than to declare war and make a show of it; Fate and the gods would of their own will do the rest. Such were the hopes which had led the Etruscans to take up arms, after many shifting fortunes of defeat and victory.

The Army Swears to Conquer

Chapter 45

1 The Roman consuls also felt they had nothing to fear except their own forces and their own arms. The memory of the shameful example set in the last war kept them from offering battle where they would be in danger from two armies at once. 2 Accordingly they kept within their camp, held back by the thought of such a serious danger; time and circumstances might perhaps calm the anger of the men and bring them to their senses.

3 Their enemies the Veientes and the other Etruscans were all the more eager to act for that reason; they attempted to provoke the Romans to fight, at first by riding up to their camp and challenging them to come out, and finally, when they gained nothing by this, by shouting insults both at the consuls themselves and at the army. 4 They said that the Romans were pretending to be at odds among themselves to hide their fear, and that the consuls distrusted the courage of their men even more than their loyalty; it was a strange kind of mutiny where armed men were silent and inactive. 5 To these taunts they added others about the newness of the Romans’ race and origin, partly false and partly true. The consuls endured this abuse, shouted right beneath the rampart and the gates, calmly enough. But the inexperienced rank and file, stirred now by indignation and now by shame, forgot their troubles at home; they did not want their enemies to go unpunished; 6 they did not want the patricians, the consuls, to win a success; hatred of the enemy fought in their hearts with hatred of their fellow citizens. At last the first feeling won out, so proud and insolent was the jeering of the enemy.

7 They gathered in crowds at the praetorium, demanded battle, asked for the signal to be given. The consuls, as though considering the matter, put their heads together and conferred for a long time. 8 They wanted to fight, but they had to hold back and hide that wish so that, by resisting and delaying, they might drive the already eager soldiers to fury. The men were therefore told that it was too soon, that the time for battle had not yet come; that they must keep within the camp. 9 Then the consuls issued an order to abstain from fighting, declaring that if any man fought without orders they should treat him as an enemy. Dismissed with these words, the soldiers grew more eager for the fight the less willing they found the consuls. 10 They were still further exasperated by the enemy, who became much bolder than before once the consuls’ decision not to fight became known; it was clear, they thought, that they could insult the Romans with impunity; their soldiers were not trusted with weapons, the affair would end in outright mutiny, and the end of the Roman power had come. 11 Confident of this, they charged up to the gates, flung gibes at their defenders, and scarcely refrained from assaulting the camp. At this the Romans could no longer stand their insults; from all over the camp they came running to the consuls.

12 There were no more cautious requests made through the chief centurions; instead a general outcry arose on all sides. The time was ripe; nevertheless the consuls hung back. Then Fabius, when his colleague, beginning to fear mutiny, was on the point of yielding to the growing tumult, called for silence with a trumpet blast and said, “I know, Gnaeus Manlius, that these men have the power to conquer, but whether they are willing to, I do not know; and for this they are themselves to blame. 13 I am therefore firmly resolved not to give the signal unless they swear that they will return victorious from this engagement. Once, in a battle, the soldiers betrayed a Roman consul: they will never betray the gods.” 14 There was a centurion named Marcus Flavoleius, who had been among the foremost in demanding battle. “I will return victorious from the field, Marcus Fabius,” he cried, and called down the anger of Father Jupiter, Mars Gradivus, and the other gods on himself if he failed to keep his vow. The entire army then took the same oath in turn, each man calling its penalties down on himself.

15 When they had sworn, the signal sounded. They armed and entered the fight, angry and confident. Now let the Etruscans fling their taunts! 16 Now—they all cried—now, when they were armed, let the loudmouthed enemy face them! On that day they all showed splendid courage, both commoners and nobles, but the Fabian name was especially distinguished. In many political struggles they had alienated the plebs, and they resolved to win back their goodwill in that battle.

The Fabii Lead the Charge

Chapter 46

1 The battle line was drawn up, and the Veientes and the Etruscan troops did not avoid the fight. They felt almost certain that the Romans would no more fight with them than they had fought with the Aequi. It was not too much to hope that, exasperated as they were and given a critical opportunity, they might even commit some greater outrage.

2 But it turned out quite otherwise. For there had never been a war when the Romans went into battle with a keener hostility—so embittered had they been, on the one hand by the enemy’s insults, on the other by the consuls’ delays. 3 The Etruscans had barely had time to deploy when their enemies, who in the first excitement had thrown their javelins at random rather than taking proper aim, were already fighting with swords at close quarters, where fighting is the fiercest.

4 The Fabian clan was conspicuous among the foremost, a spectacle and encouragement to their fellow citizens. One of them, the Quintus Fabius who had been consul three years before, was leading the attack on the tightly packed Veientes, when a Tuscan, proud of his strength and skill with weapons, caught him off guard in the middle of a crowd of enemies and drove his sword through his chest. As the blade was withdrawn, Fabius fell forward onto his wound. 5 It was only one man’s fall, but both armies felt it; and the Romans were giving way at that point, when the consul Marcus Fabius leaped over the body and, covering himself with his shield, cried, “Was this your oath, men, that you would return to your camp in flight? 6 Do you fear the most cowardly of enemies more than Jupiter and Mars, by whom you swore? But I, though I have sworn no oath, will either return victorious or fall fighting here by you, Quintus Fabius!” Caeso Fabius, consul of the year before, answered the consul, “Do you think your words will persuade them to fight, brother? 7 The gods by whom they have sworn will persuade them. And let us, as befits nobles and the name of Fabius, kindle our soldiers’ courage by fighting rather than by speeches!” With that the two Fabii rushed into the thick of the fight with leveled spears and carried the whole line forward with them.

Victory Over Veii

Chapter 47

1 So the fortune of the day was restored in one part of the field. On the other wing the consul Gnaeus Manlius was urging on the fight with no less vigor, when almost the same thing happened. 2 For as Quintus Fabius had done on the other flank, so here the consul Manlius was personally leading the attack on the enemy, whom he had almost routed, since his soldiers followed him bravely, when he was badly wounded and withdrew from the front line. 3 His men believed him to be dead, and faltered; and they would have given up the position had the other consul not galloped up with a few troops of cavalry, calling out that his colleague was alive and that he himself had defeated and routed the other wing and had come to help them, and so stopped their wavering.

4 Manlius also showed himself among them, helping to restore the line; and the soldiers, recognizing the features of their two consuls, took courage. At the same time the battle line of the enemy was now less strong, for, relying on their greater numbers, they had withdrawn their reserves and dispatched them to storm the Roman camp.

5 There, having forced their way in without meeting much resistance, they were wasting their time, their thoughts more taken up with the booty than with the battle, when the Roman reserves, which had been unable to withstand the first charge, sent word to the consuls how things stood, and then closed up their ranks, returned to the praetorium, and on their own renewed the battle. Meanwhile the consul Manlius had ridden back to the camp, and by posting men at all the gates had cut off the enemy’s way out. 6 Desperate at this turn, the Etruscans were driven to something more like madness than recklessness. For when, rushing wherever there seemed a chance of escape, they had made several charges for nothing, one band of youths made a dash at the consul himself, whose armor made him conspicuous. Their first volley of javelins was blocked by the soldiers around him, but after that their violence could not be withstood. 7 The consul fell, mortally wounded, and all those around him fled. The Etruscans grew more reckless than before; the Romans were driven, quaking with terror, right across the camp, and their case would have been desperate, had 8 not the lieutenants picked up the consul’s body and opened a way out for the enemy through one of the gates. Through this they burst out and, escaping in a disorderly column, ran into the other, victorious consul, where they were again cut to pieces and scattered in all directions.

Fabius Declines a Triumph

9 A victory of great importance had been won, but it was saddened by the deaths of two such famous men. 10 So when the senate wanted to vote him a triumph, the consul replied that if the army could triumph without its general, its services in that war had been so remarkable that he would gladly consent; as for himself, while his family was mourning the death of his brother Quintus Fabius, and the state was half orphaned by the loss of the other consul, he would not accept a laurel withered by national and private sorrow. 11 No triumph ever celebrated was more famous than his refusal of one, so true is it that a well-timed rejection of glory sometimes only increases it. The consul then held, one after the other, the funerals of his colleague and his brother, and pronounced the eulogy of each; and while giving them their due praise, he won the very highest praise for himself.

12 Nor did he forget the policy he had adopted at the beginning of his consulship of winning the affection of the plebs, but lodged the wounded soldiers with the patricians to be cared for. He assigned the largest number to the Fabii, and nowhere did they receive better care. For this the Fabii now began to enjoy the favor of the people, and they won it by nothing but conduct that was good for the state.

Caeso Fabius Seeks Harmony

Chapter 48

1 So the senators were now no more eager than the plebeians to choose Caeso Fabius as consul, along with Titus Verginius. On taking office, his first concern was neither war nor raising troops nor anything else except that the hope of harmony, already partly realized, should ripen as soon as possible into a good understanding between the patricians and the plebs. 2 He therefore proposed at the start of his term that before some tribune rose to advocate a land law, the Fathers themselves should get ahead of him by taking up the matter and granting the conquered territory to the plebs as fairly as possible; for it was right that those whose blood and toil had won it should own it. 3 The senators scorned the proposal, and some even complained that too much glory was spoiling and dulling the vigorous mind Caeso had once had.

4 After that there were no outbreaks of strife and faction in the City, but the Latins were plagued by Aequian raids. Caeso was dispatched there with an army and crossed into the Aequians’ own country to lay it waste. The Aequi retired to their towns and kept within their walls. For this reason there was no memorable battle.

5 But the Veientes inflicted a defeat on the Romans because of the other consul’s rashness; and the army would have been destroyed if Caeso Fabius had not come, in the nick of time, to its rescue. From then on there was neither peace nor war with the Veientes, but something very like banditry. 6 When the Roman legions confronted them they would retreat into their city; when they saw the legions had withdrawn they would raid the fields, evading war by a semblance of peace, and peace in turn by war. Hence it was impossible either to let the whole matter go or to end it. Other wars, too, were either immediately threatening—like the one with the Aequi and the Volsci, who would keep the peace only while the pain of their latest defeat was wearing off—or soon to be started by the always hostile Sabines and all Etruria. 7 But the hostility of the Veientes, more persistent than dangerous, and producing insults more often than danger, kept the Romans in suspense, for they were never allowed to forget it or to turn their attention elsewhere.

The Fabii Take On the War With Veii

8 Then the Fabian clan went before the senate, and the consul, speaking for the clan, said, “A permanent body of defenders, rather than a large one, is needed, Conscript Fathers, as you know, for the war with Veii. You attend to the other wars, and assign to the Fabii the task of opposing the Veientes. We promise that the majesty of the Roman name will be safe on that front. 9 We intend to wage this war as if it were our own family feud, at our own expense; the state need not supply men or money for it.” The Fathers enthusiastically voted their thanks. 10 The consul came out of the senate house and, escorted by a column of the Fabii, who had waited in the entrance of the Curia for the senate’s decision, returned home. After being ordered to present themselves armed at the consul’s door the next day, they went to their homes.

The Fabii March Out

Chapter 49

1 The news spreads to every part of the City and the Fabii are praised to the skies. People tell how a single family has taken on its shoulders the burden of a state, how the war with Veii has been turned over to private citizens and private arms. 2 If there were two other clans of equal strength in the City, one could take on the Volsci and the other the Aequi, and the Roman People could enjoy the quiet of peace, while all the neighboring nations were being subdued. On the following day the Fabii arm themselves and assemble at the appointed place.

3 The consul, coming out in a general’s cloak, sees his entire clan drawn up in his forecourt, and, taking his place in their midst, gives the order to march. 4 Never did a smaller army march through the City, or one more celebrated by the applause and wonder of the people: three hundred and six soldiers, all patricians, all of one blood, not one of whom you would have rejected as a leader, and who would have made an admirable senate in any period, were going out to threaten the existence of the Veientine nation with the resources of a single house.

5 They were followed by a crowd made up partly of their own people, their relatives and close friends, whose thoughts were taken up not with small matters of hope or fear but with boundless possibilities; and partly of those moved by concern for the commonwealth, who were beside themselves with enthusiasm and amazement. 6 “Go,” they cry, “with your courage and with good fortune, and may your success be as great as your undertaking!” 7 They tell them to look forward to receiving consulships from them for this work, and triumphs, and all rewards and all honors. As they pass by the Capitol and the citadel and the other temples, they beg whatever gods come before their eyes and their thoughts to accompany 8 that noble band with blessings and prosperity, and to bring them back soon and safely to their native land and their families. Their prayers were in vain.

The Fort on the Cremera

9 Leaving by the Unlucky Way, the right-hand arch of the Porta Carmentalis, they came to the river Cremera, a position that seemed good for building a fort. Lucius Aemilius and Gaius Servilius were then chosen consuls. And as long as nothing more than raiding was going on, the Fabii were not only an adequate garrison for the fort, but throughout the region where Tuscan territory borders the Roman they gave complete security to their own countrymen and trouble to the enemy by ranging along both sides of the border.

10 Then these raids were briefly interrupted, while the men of Veii, having called in an army from Etruria, attacked the post on the Cremera, and the Roman legions, led there by the consul Lucius Aemilius, engaged them in a pitched battle; 11 though in fact the Veientes barely had time to form a battle line, for at the first alarm, while the ranks were falling in behind the standards and the reserves were being posted, a division of Roman cavalry made a sudden charge on their flank and robbed them of the chance not only to attack first but even to stand their ground. 12 And so they were driven back to Saxa Rubra, where they had their camp, and asked for peace. It was granted, but their natural fickleness made them tire of the agreement before the Roman garrison was withdrawn from the Cremera.

The Fabii Destroyed at the Cremera

Chapter 50

1 Again the Fabii were pitted against the people of Veii. No preparations had been made for a great war, yet there were not only raids on farmland and surprise attacks on raiding parties, but at times they fought in the open field in close formation; 2 and a single clan of the Roman People often won victories over what was, for those days, the mightiest state in all Etruria.

3 At first the Veientes bitterly resented this; but they soon adopted a plan, suggested by the situation, to trap their bold enemy, and they even rejoiced as they saw that the frequent successes of the Fabii were causing them to grow more rash. 4 So every now and then they drove flocks into the invaders’ path, as if they had come there by accident; and the country folk would flee from their farms and leave them deserted; and relief parties of armed men, sent to keep off raiders, would flee before them in a panic more often feigned than real. By this time the Fabii had come to despise the enemy so much that they believed themselves invincible and unstoppable, no matter what the place or time.

5 This confidence so took hold of them that when they caught sight of some flocks far from the Cremera, across a wide stretch of plain, they ignored the enemy weapons visible here and there and ran down to capture them. Their rashness carried them swiftly past an ambush that had been laid on both sides of the very road they took. 6 They had scattered this way and that and were seizing the flocks, which had dispersed in all directions, as flocks do when frightened, when suddenly the ambush rose up, and enemies were in front and on every side of them. 7 First the shout which echoed all along the Etruscan line filled them with dismay, and then the javelins began to fall on them from every direction; and as the Etruscans drew together and the Romans were now fenced in by a continuous line of armed men, the harder the enemy pressed them the smaller the space into which they were forced to 8 draw in their circle, which clearly revealed both how few they were and the vast numbers of the Etruscans, whose ranks were multiplied in the narrow space.

9 The Romans then gave up fighting equally on every side, and all turned in one direction. There, by sheer strength and force of arms, they drove their way through in a wedge. Their route led up a gentle slope. 10 There they at first made a stand; then, when their higher position had given them time to catch their breath and recover their spirits after such a fright, they actually routed the troops which were advancing to dislodge them; and a handful of men, with the aid of a good position, were winning the victory, when the Veientes who had been sent round by the ridge appeared on the crest of the hill, thus giving the enemy the advantage again.

11 The Fabii were killed to a man, and their fort was stormed. Three hundred and six men perished, as is generally agreed; one, who was little more than a boy in years, survived to carry on the Fabian line, and so to give the greatest help to the Roman People in its dark hours, on many occasions, at home and in the field.

The Etruscans on Janiculum

Chapter 51

1 When this disaster struck, Gaius Horatius and Titus Menenius had begun their consulship. Menenius was at once sent out to confront the Etruscans, elated by their victory. Again the Roman arms were unsuccessful, and Janiculum was taken by the enemy. 2 They would also have laid siege to Rome, which was suffering not only from war but from a shortage of grain—for the Etruscans had crossed the Tiber—had not the consul Horatius been recalled from the Volscian country; and the invasion came so close to the very walls of the City that battles were fought first at the temple of Hope, where the result was indecisive, and again at the Colline Gate. 3 There, although the Romans gained only a slight advantage, the fight restored the troops’ old spirit and made them better soldiers for the battles that were to come.

4 Aulus Verginius and Spurius Servilius were made consuls. After the defeat the Veientes had suffered in the last fight, they avoided a battle and took to raiding. From Janiculum, as from a citadel, they sent out expeditions far and wide into Roman territory; there was no security anywhere for flocks or country folk. 5 After a time they were caught by the same trick with which they had caught the Fabii. Chasing the flocks that had been driven out here and there on purpose to lure them, they plunged into an ambush, and since their numbers were greater than the Fabii’s, so were their losses. 6 This disaster threw them into a violent rage, which became the cause and beginning of a greater defeat. For they crossed the Tiber in the night and attacked the camp of the consul Servilius. There they were routed with heavy losses and got back to Janiculum with difficulty.

7 The consul himself immediately crossed the Tiber and fortified a camp below the hill. Next day at dawn, partly because he was emboldened by the successful battle of the day before, but more because the grain shortage drove him to the rashest measures as long as they were quick, he was 8 so reckless as to lead his army up Janiculum to the enemy’s camp, and after suffering a more disgraceful defeat than the one he had inflicted the day before, owed his own rescue and his army’s to the arrival of his colleague. 9 Caught between two lines, the Etruscans turned their backs first on one and then on the other, and were cut down with great slaughter. So the Veientine invasion was crushed by a lucky act of rashness.

The Trials of Menenius and Servilius

Chapter 52

1 With the return of peace, the grain market in the City eased; for not only was grain imported from Campania, but now that people had stopped fearing their own future need, they brought out the stores they had hidden. 2 Plenty and idleness again bred a spirit of license in people’s minds, and they began to look at home for the old troubles that were no longer to be found abroad. The tribunes roused the plebs to madness with their usual poison, a land law. The Fathers resisted, but the tribunes incited the people against them, not merely as a body but as individuals.

3 Quintus Considius and Titus Genucius, the sponsors of the land law, summoned Titus Menenius to stand trial. He had earned the dislike of the plebs because of the loss of the outpost on the Cremera, when as consul he had held a permanent camp not far away; 4 and this unpopularity was his undoing, though the senators exerted themselves on his behalf no less than they had done for Coriolanus, and though the favor enjoyed by his father Agrippa had not yet passed away. 5 In the penalty the tribunes showed restraint; though they had charged him with a capital offense, they set the convicted man’s fine at two thousand asses. But it cost him his life; they say he could not bear the shame and grief, and fell ill and died of it.

6 Spurius Servilius was the next to be put on trial. He had laid down the consulship and been succeeded by Gaius Nautius and Publius Valerius, when he was summoned, at the very beginning of the year, by the tribunes Lucius Caedicius and Titus Statius. Unlike Menenius, he met the tribunes’ attacks not with pleas, from himself or the senators, but with great confidence in his innocence and popularity. 7 He too was accused over the battle against the Etruscans at Janiculum. But the man’s fiery courage was no more evident in the nation’s hour of danger than it was now in his own, and he refuted not only the tribunes but the plebs, reproaching them in a daring speech for the condemnation and death of Menenius, to whose father, he declared, the plebs formerly owed their restoration and the possession of those very magistrates and laws which were the tools of their cruelty. This boldness swept away the danger. 8 He was helped, too, by Verginius, his colleague, who, called as a witness, shared his own credit with Servilius. But Menenius’s trial helped him even more, so great a reversal of feeling had set in.

Victories at Veii and on Latin Soil

Chapter 53

1 Strife at home was over; but war broke out with the Veientes, with whom the Sabines had united their arms. The consul Publius Valerius was dispatched to Veii with an army to which had been added auxiliaries from the Latins and the Hernici. He immediately advanced on the Sabine camp, which had been set up in front of their allies’ walls, and threw the enemy into such confusion that, while they were running out in small groups, some one way and some another, to drive back the Romans’ attack, he captured the gate he had first attacked.

2 What followed within the stockade was a massacre rather than a battle. The sounds of confusion in the camp carried even to the city, and the frightened inhabitants rushed to their weapons, as though Veii had been surprised. 3 Some went to the rescue of the Sabines, others attacked the Romans, who were entirely occupied with the camp. For a moment the Romans were thrown off balance and into disorder; then they, too, faced both ways and made a stand, and the cavalry the consul sent into the fight dispersed and routed the Etruscans.

4 In one and the same hour two armies, two of the greatest and most powerful neighboring nations, were defeated. While these victories were being won at Veii, the Volsci and the Aequi had encamped on Latin soil, and had laid waste the country. The Latins, acting on their own with the help of the Hernici but with neither a general nor aid from Rome, stripped them of their camp. 5 They seized immense booty, in addition to recovering their own property. Nevertheless a consul, Gaius Nautius, was sent from Rome against the Volsci. The precedent, I suppose, of allies waging wars with their own forces and their own strategy, without a Roman commander and army, was not welcome. 6 There was no kind of disaster or humiliation that was not inflicted on the Volsci, yet they could not be forced to give battle.

The Death of the Tribune Genucius

Chapter 54

1 Lucius Furius and Gaius Manlius were the next consuls. The command against the Veientes fell to Manlius. But there was no war; a forty-year truce was granted at their request, and grain and a money indemnity were demanded of them.

2 Peace abroad was immediately followed by quarrels at home. The land law the tribunes used to goad the plebs drove them to the point of madness. The consuls, not the least intimidated by the condemnation of Menenius or by the danger Servilius had faced, resisted the measure with the utmost violence. 3 As their term expired, Gnaeus Genucius, a plebeian tribune, dragged them to trial. Lucius Aemilius and Opiter Verginius took office as consuls. In certain annals I find Vopiscus Julius listed as consul instead of Verginius. This year—whoever its consuls were—Furius and Manlius went about among the people as accused men, in mourning clothes, seeking out the younger patricians, as well as the plebeians. 4 They advised and warned them to keep away from holding office and running public business; as for the consular fasces, the purple-bordered toga, and the curule chair, they should regard these as nothing but the trappings of a funeral; for splendid insignia, like the headbands placed on sacrificial victims, doomed the wearer to death. 5 But if the consulship attracted them so much, let them realize at once that it had been shackled and enslaved by the power of the tribunes; that the consul, like a servant of those officials, had to be at their beck and call in all he did; 6 if he stirred himself, if he showed consideration for the patricians, if he believed the state included anyone besides the plebs—let him remember the exile of Gnaeus Marcius, the condemnation of Menenius and his death.

7 Fired by these speeches, the senators began to meet no longer in public but in private, where the people could not learn their plans. In these deliberations there was only one guiding principle: by fair means or foul, the defendants must be freed. The more savage a suggestion was, the more favor it found, and there was no lack of someone to carry out the most daring crime. 8 So on the day of the trial the plebeians were in the Forum, eagerly waiting. At first they were filled with amazement because the tribune did not come down; then, when his delay at last began to look suspicious, they supposed he had been frightened away by the nobles, and began complaining that he had deserted and betrayed the people’s cause; finally, those who had gone to the tribune’s door brought back word that he had been found dead in his house.

9 When this report had spread through the whole gathering, the crowd, like an army which takes to flight at the fall of its general, melted away on every side. The tribunes were particularly dismayed, for the death of their colleague warned them how powerless the laws declaring their sanctity were to protect them. 10 Nor did the senators properly restrain their satisfaction; indeed, so far was anyone from regretting the crime that even the innocent wanted to be thought responsible for it, and men openly declared that punishment must be used to curb the power of the tribunes.

Volero Publilius Defies the Consuls

Chapter 55

1 Immediately after this ruinous victory a levy was announced, which the timidity of the tribunes let the consuls push through without a single veto. 2 But this time the commons were thoroughly roused to anger, more by the silence of the tribunes than by the consuls’ power. They declared that their liberty was finished; that things had gone back to the old ways; that the tribunes’ power had died and been buried with Genucius. 3 They must take another course and make other plans to resist the patricians; and the only way was for the plebs to defend themselves, since they had no one else to help them. The consuls’ entire escort was twenty-four lictors, and even these were plebeians. Nothing was more contemptible or weaker, if only there were people willing to despise them; it was each man’s own imagination that made them great and awe-inspiring.

4 They had been stirring one another up with arguments like these when the consuls sent a lictor to arrest Volero Publilius, a plebeian, who, on the grounds that he had been a centurion, denied their right to make him a common soldier. Volero appealed to the tribunes. 5 When no one came to help him, the consuls gave orders to strip the man and get out the rods. “I appeal,” cried Volero, “to the people, since the tribunes would rather see a Roman citizen flogged with rods before their eyes than be murdered in their beds by you.” But the more boldly he shouted the more roughly the lictor set about tearing off his clothes and stripping him. 6 Then Volero, who was himself a powerful man and was helped by those he had called to his assistance, fought off the lictor and, picking the spot where his supporters were shouting most angrily, plunged into the thick of the crowd, calling out, “I appeal, and beg the protection of the plebs; help, citizens! 7 help, fellow soldiers! It is useless for you to wait for the tribunes, who themselves need help from you.”

8 In their excitement people got ready as if for a battle, and it was clear that anything might happen, that nobody would respect any right, whether public or private. The consuls, caught in this furious storm, quickly learned how insecure majesty is without force behind it. 9 The lictors were roughly handled and their rods were broken, while the consuls themselves were driven out of the Forum into the Curia, with no means of knowing how far Volero might use his victory.

10 Afterward, when the uproar began to die away, they summoned the Fathers into the senate house and complained of the insults they had suffered, the violence of the plebs, and Volero’s outrageous conduct. 11 Though many daring opinions were expressed, the wishes of the older men, who wanted no conflict between an angry senate and a reckless plebs, prevailed.

Volero’s Law on Tribal Elections

Chapter 56

1 Volero, now a favorite of the plebs, was elected plebeian tribune at the next election, for the year in which Lucius Pinarius and Publius Furius were consuls. 2 And contrary to everyone’s expectation that he would use his tribuneship to persecute the consuls of the previous year, he set the general welfare above his private grievance, and, without attacking the consuls with so much as a word, brought a bill before the people providing that plebeian magistrates should be chosen in the tribal assembly. 3 What he proposed in this harmless-looking form was no trivial matter, but one that completely deprived the patricians of the power to use their clients’ votes to choose whatever tribunes they liked. 4 This measure was extremely welcome to the plebs; the Fathers opposed it with all their might, yet neither consuls nor nobles had enough influence to secure the only effective resistance, namely a veto by some member of the college of tribunes. Even so, the legislation, which its very importance made difficult, was dragged out by party strife to the end of the year. 5 The plebs reelected Volero tribune; the senators, thinking the quarrel was sure to come to extremes, made Appius Claudius, son of Appius, consul, a man whose unpopularity with the plebs and hostility toward them went back to the struggles between their fathers. They gave him Titus Quinctius as his colleague.

Laetorius Confronts Appius

6 The new year had no sooner begun than discussion of the law took precedence over everything else, and it was urged not only by its author, Volero, but by his colleague Laetorius as well, whose support for it was both newer and more bitter. 7 He was emboldened by the great reputation he enjoyed as a soldier, since no one of that generation surpassed him in physical strength. While Volero spoke of nothing but the law, and refrained from attacking the consuls personally, Laetorius launched into an indictment of Appius and his family as the most cruel and arrogant toward the Roman plebs. 8 But when he tried to show that the patricians had elected, not a consul, but an executioner, to harass and torture the plebeians, the soldier’s inexperienced tongue could not express his audacity and spirit. 9 Accordingly when words began to fail him he cried, “Since speaking does not come as easily to me, Quirites, as making good on what I have said, be here tomorrow. I will either die here in your sight or carry the law.”

10 The tribunes were the first on the scene next day, and took over the rostra; the consuls and nobles took their stand in the assembly, intending to block the passage of the law. Laetorius ordered everyone except the voters to be removed. 11 The youthful nobles stayed where they were and would not move at the officer’s command. Then Laetorius ordered some of them to be seized. 12 The consul Appius declared that the tribune had no authority over anybody but a plebeian, since he was a magistrate not of the people but of the plebs; and even if he were, he could not, according to the custom of the Fathers, order anyone removed by virtue of his authority, since the formula ran, “If it seems good to you, depart, Quirites.” It was easy to throw Laetorius into a rage by these contemptuous remarks about his rights. 13 So the tribune, blazing with anger, sent his attendant to the consul; 14 while the consul sent his lictor to the tribune, crying out that Laetorius was a private citizen, without power, and no magistrate; and the tribune would have been roughed up had the whole assembly not rallied fiercely to his support against the consul, while people rushed into the Forum from all over the City in an excited crowd.

15 Still, Appius stubbornly held out despite the fury of the storm, and a bloody battle would have followed had Quinctius, the other consul, not charged the senators of consular rank with getting his colleague out of the Forum, by force if there was no other way; while he himself now calmed the raging crowd with soothing pleas and now begged the tribunes to dismiss the assembly. 16 Let them give their anger time; time would not rob them of their power, but would add wisdom to their strength; the Fathers would be subject to the people, and the consul to the Fathers.

The Senate Yields and the Law Passes

Chapter 57

1 It was hard for Quinctius to calm the plebs, and much harder for the senators to quiet the other consul. At last the council of the plebs was adjourned, and the consuls convened the senate. 2 At this meeting hope and fear by turns gave rise to conflicting opinions. But as their passions cooled with the passing of time and gave way to reflection, they turned more and more against the struggle, so much so that they passed a vote of thanks to Quinctius for having calmed the quarrel. 3 They asked Appius to be content with a consular majesty no greater than harmony in the state allowed, pointing out that while tribunes and consuls were each trying to get their own way, the nation as a whole had no strength left, and the commonwealth was torn and mangled, the question being more who controlled it than how it could be kept safe.

4 Appius, on the other hand, called gods and men to witness that the state was being betrayed and abandoned through cowardice; that it was not the consul who was failing the senate, but the senate the consul; that harder terms were being accepted than had been accepted on the Sacred Mount. Nevertheless the senate’s unanimity overruled him, and he fell silent. The law was passed without opposition.

The First Tribal Election

Chapter 58

1 Then for the first time tribunes were elected in the tribal assembly. Piso states that their number was also increased by three, as if there had been only two before. 2 He also gives the names of the tribunes: Gnaeus Siccius, Lucius Numitorius, Marcus Duillius, Spurius Icilius, Lucius Maecilius. While Rome was distracted in this way, the Volsci and the Aequi began war. 3 They had laid waste the fields so that the plebeians, if they seceded, could find refuge with them. Then, when the matter was settled, they withdrew their camp. Appius Claudius was sent against the Volsci; the command against the Aequi fell to Quinctius.

Appius and His Defiant Army

4 In the field Appius showed the same violence he had shown in Rome, and it now had freer rein because the tribunes could not hamper it. He hated the plebs even more than his father had. What? 5 Had he been beaten by them? Was it in his consulship—he who had been chosen as the man best fitted to resist the tribunes’ power—that a law had been passed that earlier consuls had blocked with less effort, though the patricians had nowhere near as much hope of success? 6 His anger and indignation at this thought drove his fierce spirit to torment the army with a savage use of his authority. Yet no violence could subdue them, so deeply had their spirits drunk of defiance. 7 Sloth, idleness, neglect, and obstinacy were in all they did. Neither shame nor fear restrained them. If he wanted the column to move faster, they deliberately slowed down; if he stood by to encourage their work, they would all slack off from the effort they had been making on their own. 8 In his presence they lowered their eyes; as he passed by they cursed him under their breath, until that proud spirit, which the hatred of the plebs had never broken, was at times shaken. 9 After trying every kind of severity without effect, he would have nothing more to do with the men; the centurions, he said, had corrupted the army, and he sometimes sneeringly called them “tribunes of the plebs” and “Voleros.”

The Rout of Appius’s Army

Chapter 59

1 The Volsci knew all of this, and they pressed their enemy all the harder, hoping that the Roman army would show the same spirited opposition to Appius that it had shown toward the consul Fabius. 2 But Appius found his men far more unruly than Fabius had; for not only were they unwilling to conquer, as the Fabian army had been, but they wished to be conquered. When they were drawn up in battle order, they fled shamefully to their camp; nor did they make a stand until they saw the Volsci advancing against their fortifications and inflicting disgraceful slaughter on their rearguard. 3 This forced them to rouse themselves and fight, with the result that the enemy was dislodged from the stockade in the moment of victory. Yet it was clear enough that the capture of their camp was the only thing the Roman soldiers balked at, and that elsewhere they rejoiced at their own defeat and ignominy.

4 None of this daunted the haughty spirit of Appius. But when he wanted to go further and vent his rage on the army, and was ordering an assembly, the lieutenants and tribunes hurriedly gathered around him and warned him on no account to put his authority to the test, since its effectiveness depended entirely on the goodwill of those obeying it. 5 The men, they reported, were saying that they would not go to be lectured, and voices were heard everywhere demanding that the camp be removed from Volscian territory. Only a little while before, the victorious enemy had almost been at their gates and on their wall, and a great disaster was not merely to be feared but was plainly looming before their eyes.

6 Giving in at last, since the soldiers were gaining nothing but a delay of their punishment, he dropped the idea of an assembly and ordered a march for the following day. At daybreak he had the trumpet sound the signal to depart. 7 At the very moment the column was clearing the camp, the Volsci, as though set in motion by the same signal, fell on their rear. From there the confusion spread to the front, and the panic so disordered the standards and the ranks that it was impossible either to hear commands or to form a line. 8 Nobody thought of anything but flight, and the rout was so demoralized, as the men escaped over fallen bodies and discarded weapons, that the enemy stopped pursuing before the Romans stopped fleeing.

9 When at last the soldiers had been collected from their scattered flight, the consul, who had followed his men in a vain attempt to call them back, pitched his camp on friendly soil. Then he called an assembly and sharply rebuked them, not without reason, as an army that had betrayed military discipline and had deserted its standards. 10 Asking them all in turn where their weapons and their standards were, he had the unarmed soldiers and the standard-bearers who had lost their standards, and in 11 addition to these the centurions and the soldiers on double rations who had left their ranks flogged with rods and beheaded; of the rest, every tenth man was chosen by lot for punishment.

Quinctius and His Loyal Army

Chapter 60

1 In contrast to all this, in the Aequian campaign consul and soldiers vied with each other in goodwill and kindness. Not only was Quinctius naturally gentler, but his colleague’s unfortunate harshness had given him all the more reason to be content with his own temperament. 2 The Aequi did not dare oppose such complete harmony between commander and army, but let their enemies lay waste their fields at will; and in fact no earlier war had ever brought in more booty from that country. 3 This was all given to the troops, and to the booty were added words of praise, which cheer a soldier’s heart no less than rewards do. When the army returned, it looked more kindly not only on its leader but, for his sake, on the Fathers as well. The soldiers declared that the senate had given them a parent and the other army a tyrant.

4 Mixed fortune in war and bitter discord at home and in the field had marked the year just ended; but it was most notable for the tribal assembly, which mattered more because the plebeians had won the struggle they had taken on than for its practical results; 5 for the assembly itself lost more dignity through the removal of the patricians than the plebeians gained in strength or the Fathers lost.

The Trial and Death of Appius Claudius

Chapter 61

1 A stormier year followed, under the consuls Lucius Valerius and Titus Aemilius, partly because of strife between the orders over the land law and partly because of the trial of Appius Claudius. 2 He was the bitterest opponent of the law, and was defending the claims of those who held public land as if he were a third consul, when Marcus Duillius and Gnaeus Siccius brought charges against him.

3 Never before had a defendant whom the plebs so detested been brought to trial before the people, weighed down as he was by people’s hatred, both of himself and of his father. 4 The patricians, for their part, had rarely exerted themselves so hard on any man’s behalf. They felt that the champion of the senate and the guardian of their own dignity, who had stood firm against every kind of outbreak by tribunes and plebeians, though he had possibly gone too far in the heat of the struggle, was being exposed to the angry commons.

5 Alone among the Fathers, Appius Claudius himself regarded tribunes, plebs, and his own trial with perfect unconcern. Neither the threats of the plebeians nor the pleas of the senate could ever persuade him—I do not say to put on mourning or to go around begging people for mercy—but even to soften in the slightest the usual sharpness of his tongue, though it was before the people that he had to plead. 6 There was the same expression on his face, the same arrogance in his glance, the same fire in his speech; so much so that a large part of the plebs feared Appius as a defendant no less than they had feared him as consul. 7 He pleaded his case only once, in the tone he always used, that of a prosecutor; and so completely did his firmness overwhelm the tribunes and the commons that they themselves voluntarily adjourned the trial to a later day, and then let the matter drag on.

8 The delay was not very long, but before the appointed day came Appius fell sick and died. 9 When his eulogy was being delivered, the tribunes of the plebs tried to interfere, but the plebs would not let the funeral of so great a man be cheated of the customary honors. Now that he was dead, they listened to his praises with as much goodwill as they had listened to the charges against him while he lived, and attended his burial in crowds.

Campaigns Against the Aequi and the Sabines

Chapter 62

1 The same year the consul Valerius marched with an army against the Aequi and, unable to lure the enemy into battle, launched an attack on their camp. This was foiled by a terrible storm that broke over them with hail and thunderclaps. 2 Their amazement grew when, as soon as the signal to retreat was given, the sky became so calm and cloudless again that, as though some god had defended the camp, they had religious scruples about attacking it a second time and turned all their hostility to laying waste the fields.

3 The other consul, Aemilius, conducted a campaign in the Sabine country. There too the enemy stayed behind their walls, and the Romans laid waste their fields. 4 Afterward, by setting fire not only to farmhouses but even to the villages, where the people lived close together, they provoked the Sabines, who met the raiders, fought an indecisive battle with them, and the next day moved their camp to a safer position. 5 The consul thought this reason enough to leave the enemy as if conquered, and he withdrew before the campaign had properly begun.

War on Three Fronts

Chapter 63

1 While these wars were going on and there was still discord at home, Titus Numicius Priscus and Aulus Verginius were elected consuls. 2 It was clear that the plebs would tolerate no further delay of the land law and were preparing to use violence, when the approach of a Volscian army was announced by the smoke which rose from burning farmhouses and by the flight of the country people. This held back the uprising, which was already ripe and about to break out. 3 The consuls, immediately ordered to do so by the senate, led the young men out of the City to the war, 4 a policy that calmed the plebeians left behind.

5 As for the enemy, they did nothing more than cause the Romans a needless panic and quickly retreated. Numicius marched to Antium against the Volsci, Verginius against the Aequi. In the Aequian campaign an ambush nearly brought the Romans a severe defeat, but the soldiers’ courage saved the day the consul’s carelessness had almost lost. 6 The Volscian expedition was better directed: the enemy were routed in the first engagement and driven in flight to Antium, a very wealthy city for those days. The consul did not dare attack this place, but he captured another town from the Antiates, called Caeno, which was far less wealthy.

7 While the Aequi and Volsci kept the Roman armies busy, the Sabines raided all the way to the gates of the City. A few days later they themselves had to face two armies, for both consuls angrily invaded their territory, and they suffered greater losses than they had inflicted.

A Sabine Raid Avenged

Chapter 64

1 Toward the end of the year there was a brief period of peace, but, as always, a peace disturbed by the strife of patricians and plebeians. 2 The angry plebs refused to take part in the consular elections, so by the votes of the patricians and their clients Titus Quinctius and Quintus Servilius were chosen consuls. Their year was like the one before: quarrels to begin with, then a foreign war and calm. 3 The Sabines made a rapid march across the Crustuminian plains, bringing fire and sword to the country around the river Anio. When almost at the Colline Gate and the City walls they were beaten back, yet they carried off an immense haul of people and cattle. 4 The consul Servilius pursued them with an army, and though he could not overtake the column itself on ground suitable for battle, he laid waste the country so thoroughly that nothing was left untouched by war, and returned with many times the booty the Romans had lost.

Battle With the Volsci and the Aequi

5 Operations in the Volscian country, too, were very successful, thanks both to the general and to his soldiers. First, there was a pitched battle in the open field, with enormous numbers killed and wounded on both sides. 6 The Romans, whose small numbers made them feel their losses more keenly, would have fallen back had it not been for a helpful lie told by the consul, who shouted that the enemy were running away on the other wing, and so raised his troops’ spirits. 7 The Romans charged and, believing themselves to be conquering, they conquered. The consul feared that by pressing the enemy too hard he might renew the struggle.

8 He therefore sounded the recall. For a few days both sides rested, as if they had silently agreed on a truce. Meanwhile a great force of men came in from all their tribes to the camp of the Volsci and Aequi. 9 They had no doubt that the Romans, if they noticed them, would retreat during the night, and so at about the third watch they came to attack the camp.

10 Quinctius calmed the uproar the sudden alarm had caused and, ordering the soldiers to stay quietly in their tents, led out a cohort of Hernici to an outpost, and, putting trumpeters and buglers on horseback, ordered them to blow their instruments in front of the rampart and keep the enemy in suspense until daybreak. 11 For the remainder of the night all was so peaceful in camp that the Romans were even able to sleep. But the Volsci, seeing armed foot soldiers whom they took to be Romans and more numerous than they were, and hearing the stamping and neighing of the horses, which were agitated not only by the unfamiliar riders on their backs but also by the blare of the trumpets, were kept on the alert, expecting an attack.

The Capture of Antium

Chapter 65

1 As soon as it was light, the Romans, who were fresh and had enjoyed a good sleep, were led out in battle formation. 2 The Volsci, worn out from standing and lack of sleep, were driven back at the first attack, though it was more a retreat than a rout, for behind them were hills, to which, under cover of the first line, they withdrew safely and in good order. The consul ordered a halt when his army reached rising ground. The infantry could hardly be held back, loudly demanding permission to press on after the fleeing enemy. 3 The cavalry were even more eager. They swarmed around the general and shouted that they would go on ahead of the standards. While the consul was hesitating, sure of his troops’ courage but doubtful about the ground, the men cried out that they were going, and immediately made good on their word. Planting their spears in the ground to be lighter for the climb, they went up at a run.

4 The Volsci, having thrown their javelins at the first charge, picked up the stones lying under their feet and hurled them at their enemies as they climbed. Confused by this rain of missiles from above, the left wing of the Romans was nearly overrun, and had already begun to retreat, when the consul, reproaching them for both rashness and cowardice, managed to shame them out of their fear. 5 First they made a resolute stand; then, after holding their ground and returning blow for blow, they even dared to press forward and, renewing their cheers, set their line in motion; then with another rush they struggled upward and scaled the height; and they were just reaching the top of the ridge when the enemy turned and fled.

6 Running at full speed and almost as one body, pursued and pursuers reached the Volscian camp, which was captured in the panic. The Volsci who managed to escape headed for Antium, and the Roman army marched to Antium too. 7 After a blockade of a few days the place surrendered; the besiegers had made no new attack, but the Volsci had lost heart from the moment of their failed battle and the capture of their camp.

About this book

The History of Rome Book 2

Tradition
Classical
Author
Livy
Written
27–25 BCE
Text
Based on the translation by B. O. Foster (1919) · Public domain

1 connection

Chapter 32 1 connections

No connections match.

Glossary

Search the Library