Go to Related Reading
About this book

Odyssey, Book 16

Odysseia 16

Telemachus Returns to the Farm

1 Meanwhile Odysseus and the noble pig herder were in the hut 2 preparing breakfast at dawn after lighting a fire, 3 and had sent the herdsmen out with the gathered pigs. 4 The dogs, usually quick to bark, wagged their tails around Telemachus, 5 and did not bark as he came near. Noble Odysseus noticed 6 the dogs wagging their tails and heard the sound of footsteps. 7 At once he addressed Eumaeus with winged words:

8 “Eumaeus, some companion of yours must be coming, 9 or someone else you know, since the dogs are not barking, 10 but wagging their tails around him. I hear footsteps.”

11 Before he had finished speaking, his own dear son 12 stood in the doorway. The pig herder sprang up in amazement, 13 dropping from his hands the vessels he was using 14 to mix the gleaming wine. He went to meet his master, 15 and kissed his head and both his beautiful eyes 16 and his two hands, and a large tear fell from him. 17 Just as a loving father greets his own dear son 18 returning in the tenth year from a distant land— 19 his only, dearly loved son, for whose sake he has suffered so much sorrow— 20 so the noble pig herder clasped godlike Telemachus in his arms 21 and kissed him all over as if he had escaped death. 22 Weeping, he addressed him with winged words:

23 “You have come, Telemachus, sweet light of my eyes. I thought I would never 24 see you again after you went in your ship to Pylos. 25 Come in, dear child, so that my heart can rejoice 26 at seeing you here in my house, newly returned from other lands. 27 You do not often visit the farm and herdsmen, 28 but stay in town. That, I suppose, is what your heart prefers, 29 to look at the suitors’ destructive crowd.” 30 Then wise Telemachus answered him: 31 “So it will be, father. I came here for your sake, 32 to see you with my eyes and hear you tell me 33 whether my mother is still in the halls 34 or another man has already married her, and Odysseus’ bed 35 perhaps lies without bedding, covered with filthy spiderwebs.”

36 Then the pig herder, a leader of men, answered him: 37 “Yes, she remains with a steadfast heart 38 in your halls. Always in sorrow, 39 the nights and days pass for her as she weeps.” 40 With that he took his bronze spear from him. 41 Telemachus went inside and crossed the stone threshold. 42 As he approached, his father Odysseus rose from his seat to make room for him. 43 But Telemachus stopped him and said:

44 “Stay seated, stranger. We will find a seat elsewhere 45 in our farmstead. There is a man here who will set one out for us.”

46 With that Odysseus went back and sat down again. 47 The pig herder spread green brushwood below and a fleece on top for Telemachus. 48 Odysseus’ dear son sat down there. 49 Then the pig herder set platters before them 50 of roast meat left from their meal the day before. 51 He quickly heaped bread in baskets, 52 mixed honey-sweet wine in an ivy-wood bowl, 53 and sat down himself opposite divine Odysseus. 54 They reached for the good food set before them.

Telemachus Asks About the Stranger

55 When they had satisfied their desire for food and drink, 56 Telemachus said to the noble pig herder:

57 “Father, where did this stranger come from? How did sailors 58 bring him to Ithaca? Who did they say they were? 59 I certainly do not think he came here on foot.”

60 Then you answered him, Eumaeus the pig herder: 61 “My child, I will tell you the whole truth. 62 He says he was born in broad Crete 63 and has roamed through many cities of mortals, 64 wandering. A god has spun this fate for him. 65 Now he has escaped from a Thesprotian ship 66 and come to my farmstead. I will put him in your hands. 67 Do as you wish. He asks for your protection.”

68 Wise Telemachus answered him: 69 “Eumaeus, what you have said stings me to the heart. 70 How can I welcome this stranger into my house? 71 I am still young and do not yet trust my strength 72 to defend myself against a man who grows angry without cause. 73 My mother’s heart in her chest wavers this way and that, 74 whether to stay here with me and keep the house, 75 respecting her husband’s bed and the people’s voice, 76 or to go with whoever is best among the Achaeans 77 and courts her in the halls and offers the most marriage gifts. 78 As for this stranger, now that he has come to your house, 79 I will give him a cloak and tunic, fine clothes, 80 and a two-edged sword and sandals for his feet. 81 I will send him wherever his heart and spirit tell him to go. 82 Or, if you want, keep him here at the farmstead and care for him. 83 I will send clothing here and all his food 84 to eat, so he does not wear you and your men out. 85 But I will not let him go there among the suitors, 86 for they are far too recklessly arrogant. 87 They might mock him, bringing terrible grief on me. 88 It is hard for one man to achieve anything among many, 89 however strong he is, since they are far more powerful.”

Odysseus Questions Telemachus

90 Then the much-enduring, noble Odysseus answered him: 91 “Friend, since I too may speak in reply, 92 your words tear my heart as I listen 93 to the reckless things you say the suitors plan 94 in the halls in defiance of you, such a noble man. 95 Tell me, do you submit to this willingly? Or do the people 96 throughout the land hate you, following a god’s voice? 97 Or do you have cause to blame your brothers, whom a man trusts 98 to fight for him even if a great conflict arises? 99 I wish I were as young as you, with the spirit I have now, 100 either blameless Odysseus’ son or Odysseus himself. 101 ... 102 Then a stranger could cut my head off my neck at once 103 if I did not bring trouble on them all 104 after coming to the halls of Odysseus, son of Laertes. 105 If they overwhelmed me by their numbers, since I was alone, 106 I would far rather be killed in my own halls 107 and die than keep watching these shameful deeds, 108 strangers mistreated and female servants 109 dragged shamefully through the beautiful halls, 110 wine drawn off and wasted, and men devouring my bread 111 carelessly, without limit, with no end to it.”

112 Wise Telemachus answered him: 113 “Stranger, I will tell you everything plainly. 114 The people as a whole bear me no grudge or hatred, 115 nor do I have cause to blame brothers, whom a man trusts 116 to fight for him even if a great conflict arises. 117 The son of Cronus has made our family run in just a single line. 118 Arceisius fathered Laertes as his only son, 119 Laertes in turn fathered Odysseus as his only son. Odysseus 120 fathered me as his only son, left me in his halls, and had no joy from me. 121 So there are countless enemies in the house now. 122 All the princes who rule over the islands— 123 Dulichium, Same, and wooded Zacynthus— 124 and those who lord it over rocky Ithaca, 125 all court my mother and lay waste my house. 126 She neither refuses the hateful marriage nor is she able 127 to complete it. They feast and eat up my 128 household, and before long they will destroy me too. 129 Yet these things lie on the gods’ knees. 130 Father, go quickly to steadfast Penelope 131 and tell her I am safe and have come from Pylos. 132 I will stay here. You must come back here 133 after telling her alone. Let none of the other Achaeans 134 hear of it, for many are plotting harm against me.”

135 Then you answered him, Eumaeus the pig herder: 136 “I understand and am paying attention. You are asking someone with sense. 137 But tell me this truthfully: 138 should I also take news to Laertes on the same journey, 139 that wretched man? For a time, though grieving deeply for Odysseus, 140 he still used to oversee the fields and, with the slaves in the house, 141 eat and drink as the heart in his chest urged him. 142 But now, since the day you went in your ship to Pylos, 143 they say he no longer eats and drinks as before 144 or oversees the fields, but with groaning and wailing 145 he sits and weeps, and the flesh wastes away from his bones.”

146 Wise Telemachus answered him: 147 “That is all the sadder, but we will leave him alone despite our sorrow. 148 If mortals could have everything just by wishing, 149 we would choose first of all the day of my father’s return. 150 Come back after giving your message. Do not wander 151 over the fields looking for Laertes. Tell my mother 152 to send out her female servant, the housekeeper, as quickly as possible, 153 secretly, so she can bring word to the old man.”

Eumaeus Leaves for the City

154 With that he sent the pig herder on his way. Eumaeus took his sandals in his hands 155 and fastened them beneath his feet and left for the city. Athena noticed 156 Eumaeus the pig herder leaving the farmstead.

Athena Appears

157 She came near in the form of a woman, 158 beautiful and tall, skilled in splendid handiwork. 159 She stood opposite the hut’s door, showing herself to Odysseus, 160 but Telemachus did not see or notice her before him. 161 The gods do not appear visibly to everyone. 162 Odysseus and the dogs saw her. The dogs did not bark 163 but whined and slunk in fear to the far side of the farmstead. 164 She signaled with her eyebrows, and noble Odysseus noticed, 165 and went out of the hall, past the courtyard’s great wall, 166 and stood before her. Athena said to him:

167 “Son of Laertes, descended from Zeus, resourceful Odysseus, 168 tell your son who you are now. Do not hide it, 169 so that after you two have planned death and fate for the suitors, 170 you can go to the famous city. I myself will not 171 be away from you two for long, for I am eager for battle.”

Athena Restores Odysseus

172 Athena touched him with her golden wand. 173 First she placed a well-washed cloak and tunic 174 around his chest and increased his stature and youthful bloom. 175 His skin darkened again and his cheeks filled out. 176 The beard around his chin grew dark. 177 After doing this she left, but Odysseus 178 went into the hut. His dear son was amazed 179 and turned his eyes aside in fear, thinking he might be a god. 180 He addressed him with winged words:

181 “Stranger, you look different to me now than you did a little while ago. 182 You have different clothes on, and your skin is no longer the same color. 183 You must be a god, one of those who rule broad heaven. 184 Be gracious, so that we can offer you acceptable sacrifices 185 and finely made golden gifts. But spare us.”

Odysseus Reveals Himself

186 Then the much-enduring, noble Odysseus answered him: 187 “I am no god. Why compare me to the immortals? 188 No, I am your father. It is for my sake that you groan⁠ 189 and suffer so many sorrows, enduring the violence of men.”

190 With that he kissed his son, and from his cheeks 191 a tear fell to the ground. Before this he had always firmly held them back. 192 Telemachus, who still did not believe he was his father, 193 answered him again:

194 “You cannot be my father Odysseus. Some god 195 is deceiving me to make me weep and groan still more. 196 A mortal man could not manage this 197 with his own cleverness unless a god came to him in person 198 and easily made him young or old as he wished. 199 Just now you were an old man, poorly dressed, 200 but now you are like the gods who rule broad heaven.”

201 Resourceful Odysseus answered him: 202 “Telemachus, with your dear father here in the house, 203 you should not wonder so much or be amazed. 204 No other Odysseus will ever come here. 205 Here I am, just as you see me, after suffering and many wanderings. 206 I have come to my native land in the twentieth year. 207 This is the work of Athena, who carries off captured goods. 208 She makes me what she wants, for she has the power, 209 sometimes like a beggar and sometimes 210 like a young man wearing fine clothes around his body. 211 It is easy for the gods who rule broad heaven 212 to give a mortal man glory or bring him low.”

213 With that he sat down. Telemachus 214 threw his arms around his noble father, weeping and shedding tears.

Father and Son Weep

215 Longing to weep welled up in both their hearts. 216 They wailed aloud more intensely than birds, 217 sea eagles or vultures with curved talons, whose young 218 country people have taken from the nest before they could fly. 219 Just so, pitifully, they let tears fall from beneath their brows. 220 They would still have been weeping as the sunlight faded 221 if Telemachus had not suddenly spoken to his father:

222 “Dear father, what kind of ship did sailors bring you here in, 223 to Ithaca? Who did they say they were? 224 I certainly do not think you came here on foot.” 225 And the much-enduring, noble Odysseus answered him: 226 “My child, I will tell you the whole truth. 227 The Phaeacians, famous for their ships, brought me. They send 228 other people on their way too, whoever comes to them. 229 They carried me asleep over the sea in a swift ship 230 and set me down in Ithaca, giving me glorious gifts, 231 abundant bronze and gold and woven clothing. 232 By the gods’ favor these treasures lie in caves. 233 Now I have come here at Athena’s urging 234 so that we can plan how to kill our enemies.

Father and Son Make a Plan

235 “Count the suitors and tell me about them, 236 so I know how many they are and what kind of men. 237 Then I can consider in my noble heart 238 and decide whether we two can stand against them 239 alone, without others, or should seek help from others too.” 240 Then wise Telemachus answered him: 241 “Father, I have always heard of your great fame, 242 that you were a warrior with strong hands and wise judgment. 243 But what you say is too much. I am amazed. 244 Two men could not fight against so many powerful men. 245 There are not just ten suitors, or twenty, 246 but far more. You will learn their number here and now. 247 From Dulichium there are fifty-two 248 chosen young men, with six serving men attending them. 249 From Same there are twenty-four men. 250 From Zacynthus there are twenty young Achaeans, 251 and from Ithaca itself twelve men, all of them the noblest. 252 Medon the herald is with them, along with the divine singer 253 and two attendants skilled at carving meat. 254 If we face all of them in the halls, 255 I fear your coming to avenge their violence will be bitter and disastrous. 256 Consider whether you can think of a helper, 257 someone who would willingly help us both.”

258 Then the much-enduring, noble Odysseus answered him: 259 “I will tell you, so listen carefully to my words 260 and consider whether Athena with Father Zeus 261 will be enough for us two, or whether I should think of another helper.”

262 Wise Telemachus answered him: 263 “These two helpers you mention are certainly good, 264 though they live high in the clouds. They 265 rule over all men alike and the immortal gods.”

266 Then the much-enduring, noble Odysseus answered: 267 “Those two will not stay away long 268 from the fierce battle, when between the suitors and us 269 in my halls the might of Ares is put to the test.

270 “For now, go at daybreak 271 to your house and join the arrogant suitors. 272 The pig herder will lead me to the city later, 273 looking like a miserable old beggar. 274 If they treat me with contempt in the house, 275 let the heart in your chest endure as I am mistreated, 276 even if they drag me by the feet through the house to the door 277 or throw things at me and hit me. Endure the sight of it. 278 Tell them to stop their foolishness, 279 trying to persuade them with gentle words. But 280 they will not listen to you, for their day of doom is near. 281 I will tell you something else. Take it to heart. 282 When Athena, rich in counsel, puts it in my mind, 283 I will nod to you with my head. When you notice it, 284 take all the weapons of war that lie in your halls 285 and put them in the hidden recess of the high storeroom, 286 every one of them. As for the suitors, use gentle words 287 to deceive them when they miss the weapons and question you:

288 “‘I have put them out of the smoke, since they are no longer like 289 what Odysseus left behind when he went to Troy, 290 but are stained wherever the fire’s breath has reached them. 291 The son of Cronus has also put a greater fear in my heart: 292 you might, heated with wine, start a quarrel among yourselves 293 and wound one another, bringing shame on your feast 294 and courtship. Iron itself draws a man to it.’

295 “For us two alone, leave two swords, two spears, 296 and two oxhide shields for our hands to grasp, 297 so that we can rush at them and overpower them. 298 Pallas Athena and Zeus, the counselor, will deceive the suitors. 299 I will tell you something else. Take it to heart.

300 “If you are truly my son and of our blood, 301 let no one hear that Odysseus is home. 302 Neither Laertes nor the pig herder must know, 303 nor anyone in the household, nor Penelope herself. 304 You and I will find out the women’s character on our own. 305 We will also test many of the serving men, 306 to see who honors us both and fears us in his heart, 307 and who does not care for us and scorns you, such a noble man.”

308 His glorious son answered him: 309 “Father, I think you will come to know my spirit 310 in time, for my will is not weak. 311 But I do not think this plan will benefit 312 us both, so I ask you to think carefully. 313 You will spend a long time going about in vain, testing each man 314 as you visit the farms, while those others sit at ease in your halls 315 wasting your wealth insolently and sparing nothing. 316 As for the women, I do urge you to find out 317 who dishonors you and who is innocent. 318 But as for the men at the farmsteads, I would rather 319 we did not test them now. We can deal with that later, 320 if you truly know some sign from Zeus, who carries the aegis.”

321 They spoke to one another like this.

The Ship Returns to Ithaca

322 Meanwhile the well-built ship sailed into Ithaca, 323 bringing Telemachus and all his companions from Pylos. 324 When they entered the deep harbor, 325 they dragged the black ship onto the shore. 326 Proud attendants carried out their armor 327 and immediately brought the beautiful gifts to Clytius’ house. 328 They sent a herald to Odysseus’ house 329 to bring word to wise Penelope 330 that Telemachus was at the farm and had told the ship 331 to sail to the city, so that the noble queen would not grow anxious 332 and let round tears fall. 333 The herald and the noble pig herder met 334 on the same errand, bringing news to the lady. 335 When they reached the godlike king’s palace, 336 the herald spoke among the female servants: 337 “Queen, your son has just come back from Pylos.”

338 The pig herder stood close to Penelope 339 and told her everything her dear son had ordered him to say. 340 When he had delivered the whole message he had been given, 341 he went back to the pigs, leaving the courtyard and hall.

The Suitors Discuss His Return

342 The suitors were dismayed and downcast in spirit. 343 They went out of the hall, past the courtyard’s great wall, 344 and sat down there before the gates. 345 Eurymachus, son of Polybus, was the first among them to speak:

346 “My friends, a great deed has been brazenly accomplished— 347 Telemachus’ journey. We thought he would never manage it. 348 Come, let us launch the best black ship we have 349 and gather seamen as rowers so they can at once 350 bring word to the others to come home quickly.”

351 Before he finished speaking, Amphinomus saw a ship 352 as he turned in his place, inside the deep harbor, 353 and men furling the sail, oars in their hands. 354 Laughing merrily, he spoke to his companions:

355 “We need not send any message now. Here they are at home. 356 Either a god told them of this, or they saw 357 Telemachus’ ship sailing past but could not catch it.”

358 With that they rose and went to the seashore. 359 They quickly dragged the black ship onto the shore, 360 and proud attendants carried out their armor. 361 The suitors went together to the assembly place and allowed no one else, 362 young or old, to sit with them.

Antinous Plans Murder

363 Antinous, son of Eupeithes, spoke among them:

364 “Look how the gods have saved this man from destruction. 365 Day by day watchmen sat on the windy heights, 366 one watch following another. At sunset 367 we never spent the night on shore, but sailed over the deep 368 in our swift ship, waiting for bright Dawn, 369 ambushing Telemachus so we could capture and kill 370 the man himself. Meanwhile a god brought him home. 371 Let us plan a miserable death for him here, 372 for Telemachus. Do not let him escape our hands, for I think 373 our work will not prosper while he lives. 374 He is shrewd in planning and understanding, 375 and the people no longer favor us at all. 376 Come, we must act before he gathers the Achaeans 377 to the assembly place. I do not think he will delay, 378 but will be full of anger and stand up to tell everyone 379 how we plotted to kill him but did not catch him. 380 They will not praise us when they hear of our evil deeds. 381 Be careful that they do not harm us and drive us out 382 of our country, forcing us to a foreign land. 383 Let us act first and seize him in the fields far from the city 384 or on the road. We can keep his possessions and wealth, 385 dividing them fairly among ourselves. As for his house, 386 we would give it to his mother and whoever marries her. 387 But if you dislike this plan and would rather 388 he lived and kept all his ancestral wealth, 389 let us stop eating up his pleasant stores 390 as we gather here. Instead, let each man seek 391 to court her from his own hall with gifts. Then 392 she can marry whoever offers the most and comes as her destined husband.”

393 They all fell silent at his words. 394 Amphinomus addressed their assembly and spoke among them. 395 He was the glorious son of Prince Nisus, son of Aretias, 396 and from Dulichium, rich in wheat and grass, 397 he led the suitors. More than all the others he pleased Penelope 398 with his words, for he had an understanding heart. 399 With good intentions he addressed their assembly and spoke among them:

400 “Friends, I would not choose to kill 401 Telemachus. It is a terrible thing to kill 402 someone of royal blood. First let us ask the gods’ will. 403 If great Zeus’s oracles approve, 404 I will kill him myself and order all the others to do so. 405 But if the gods turn us away from the act, I urge you to stop.”

406 Amphinomus’ words pleased them. 407 They immediately rose and went to Odysseus’ house, 408 entered, and sat on the polished seats.

Penelope Confronts the Suitors

409 Wise Penelope formed another plan, 410 to show herself to the suitors in their outrageous arrogance. 411 She had learned of the threat to her son’s life in her halls. 412 Medon the herald had told her after hearing their plan. 413 She went toward the hall with her female servants. 414 When the beautiful lady reached the suitors, 415 she stood by a doorpost of the well-built hall, 416 holding her shining veil before her face. 417 She rebuked Antinous and said to him:

418 “Antinous, so arrogant, always plotting harm! Yet people say 419 you are the best among all men of your age in Ithaca 420 in planning and speech. But you are not such a man. 421 Madman! Why do you plot death and fate for Telemachus 422 and disregard those who seek protection, for whom Zeus is 423 witness? It is not right before the gods to plot harm against one another. 424 Do you not remember when your father came to this house as a fugitive 425 in terror of the people? They were terribly angry with him 426 because he had joined Taphian pirates 427 and raided the Thesprotians, who were our allies. 428 They wanted to kill him and tear away his dear life, 429 and devour all the great wealth he enjoyed. 430 But Odysseus held them back and stopped them despite their eagerness. 431 Now you eat up his household without paying, court his wife, 432 and seek to kill his son, bringing great distress on me. 433 I tell you to stop, and to tell the others to stop.” 434 Eurymachus, son of Polybus, answered her: 435 “Daughter of Icarius, wise Penelope, 436 take courage. Do not let these things trouble your heart. 437 No man lives, will live, or will ever be born 438 who will lay hands on your son Telemachus 439 while I live and see the light on earth. 440 I will tell you this, and it will come true. 441 That man’s black blood will quickly flow around my 442 spear. Odysseus, the sacker of cities, 443 often sat me too on his knees, 444 put roast meat in my hands, and held red wine to my lips. 445 So Telemachus is by far the dearest of all men to me, 446 and I tell him not to fear death, 447 at least from the suitors. No man can avoid it from the gods.”

448 He spoke to reassure her while plotting her son’s death himself. 449 She went up to her bright upstairs room 450 and wept for Odysseus, her dear husband, until 451 sweet sleep was cast on her eyelids by flashing-eyed Athena.

Eumaeus Returns

452 At evening the noble pig herder 453 came back to Odysseus and his son. They were busy preparing supper, 454 having killed a year-old boar. Athena 455 came close to Odysseus, son of Laertes, 456 struck him with her wand, and made him an old man again. 457 She put poor clothing around his body so that the pig herder would not 458 recognize him on sight and go to steadfast Penelope 459 to bring news instead of keeping the secret firmly in his heart. 460 Telemachus spoke first to the pig herder: 461 “You have come, noble Eumaeus. What news is there in the city? 462 Have the proud suitors already come home 463 from their ambush, or are they still waiting to catch me on my way home?”

464 Then you answered him, Eumaeus the pig herder: 465 “I did not think to ask questions about this 466 as I went through the city. My heart urged me to come back here as quickly as possible 467 after giving my message. 468 A swift messenger from your companions joined me, 469 a herald who was the first to tell your mother the news. 470 I know one more thing, for I saw it with my own eyes. 471 I was above the city, where the hill of Hermes is, 472 going on my way, when I saw a swift ship coming 473 into our harbor. There were many men aboard, 474 and it was loaded with shields and double-pointed spears. 475 I thought it was them, but I do not know.” 476 With that the strong and mighty Telemachus smiled 477 and glanced at his father, avoiding the pig herder’s gaze.

478 When they had finished their work and prepared the meal, 479 they feasted, their hearts fully satisfied with the evenly shared meal. 480 When they had satisfied their desire for food and drink, 481 they thought of rest and accepted the gift of sleep.

Book 17

Connections in Odyssey, Book 16

1 connection

No connections match.

Glossary

Search the Library