Go to Related Reading
About this book

Genesis Rabbah

Aggadah

About this book
Chapter 23

“Cain was intimate with his wife and she conceived, and gave birth to Ḥanokh; he was the builder of a city, and he called the name of the city after the name of his son Ḥanokh” (Genesis 4:17). “Cain was intimate with his wife.” “Their houses will endure in their midst forever” (Psalms 49:12). Rabbi Yudan and Rabbi Pinḥas, Rabbi Yudan said: What do the wicked believe? “Their houses will endure in their midst forever…they name their lands after themselves” (Psalms 49:12); Tiberias after Tiberius, Alexandria after Alexander, Antioch after Antiochus. Rabbi Pinḥas said: “Their houses will endure in their midst (kirbam) forever”; tomorrow their house will become their graves (kivram). “Their abodes will remain for all generations” (Psalms 49:12), as they will neither live nor be judged [at the resurrection]. Moreover, “they name their lands after themselves” – “he was the builder of a city, and he called the name of the city after the name of his son Ḥanokh.” “Irad was born to Hanokh and Irad begot Mehuyael and Mehuyael begot Metushael and Metushael begot Lemekh” (Genesis 4:18). “Irad was born to Hanokh…” – Rabbi Yehoshua ben Levi said: These are all expressions of rebellion. Irad – ‘I will expel them [ored] from the world’; Meḥuyael – ‘I will eradicate them [moḥeh] from the world’; Metushael – ‘I will uproot them [metish] from the world’; Lemekh – ‘What do I have to do with Lemekh and his offspring?’ “Lemekh took for himself two wives; the name of one was Ada, and the name of the other Tzila” (Genesis 4:20). Rabbi Azarya said in the name of Rabbi Yehuda bar Simon: This is what the people of the generation of the Flood would do: Each one would take two wives for himself, one for procreation and one for intercourse. The one that was designated for procreation would sit as though she were a widow in her lifetime [variant reading: in the life of her husband]. The one that was designated for intercourse, he would give her a sterility potion so she would not bear children, and she would sit by him adorned like a harlot. That is what is written: “He consorts with the barren who will not give birth, and to the widow he will do no good” (Job 24:21). You may know that it is so, as Lemekh was the most outstanding among them and he took two wives. That is what is written: “Lemekh took for himself two wives; the name of one was Ada” – as she was removed [ada] from him; “and the name of the other Tzila” – as she was sitting in his shadow [tzilo]. “Ada bore Yaval; he was the forerunner of those who dwell in tents and raise livestock (mikneh). And the name of his brother was Yuval; he was the forerunner of all those who handle the harp and flute” (Genesis 4:20–21). “Ada bore Yaval; [he was the forerunner of those who dwell in tents and raise livestock (mikneh)]” – initially, they would infuriate (makneh) the Holy One blessed be He discreetly; then they proceeded to infuriate him publicly. That is what is written: “Where there was the seat of the infuriating (kin’a) image” (Ezekiel 8:3). “And the name of his brother was Yuval; he was the forerunner of all those who handle the harp and flute” (Genesis 4:21) – harpists and flutists. “And Tzila, too, gave birth, to Tuval Cain, a forger of every sharp instrument of bronze and iron, and the sister of Tuval Cain was Naama” (Genesis 4:22). “And Tzila, too, gave birth, to Tuval Cain.” Rabbi Yehoshua of Sikhnin said in the name of Rabbi Levi: This one improved upon [tibel] Cain’s transgression; Cain killed, but he did not have an instrument with which to kill, but this one was “a forger of every sharp instrument of bronze and iron.” “And the sister of Tuval Cain was Naama.” Rabbi Abba bar Kahana said: Naama was Noah’s wife. Why did they call her Naama? It is because her actions were pleasing [ne’imim]. The Rabbis say: Naama was someone else, [not Noah’s wife]. And why did they call her Naama? It is because she played the tambourine pleasantly [man’emet] for idol worship. “Lemekh said to his wives, Ada and Tzila: Hear my voice, wives of Lemekh, listen to my speech, for have I slain a man for my wound or a child for my injury?” (Genesis 4:23) “Lemekh said to his wives, Ada and Tzila: Hear my voice.” Rabbi Yosei bar Ḥanina said: He propositioned them for intercourse, but they said to him: ‘Tomorrow the Flood is coming [to destroy all mankind]. Shall we heed you and bring forth children only to be cursed?’ He said to them: ‘“Have I slain a man for my wound,” that wounds should befall me on his account? “[Have I slain] a child for my injury,” that injuries should befall me on his account?’ This was a rhetorical question: Cain committed murder and yet [his punishment] was suspended for him for seven generations; I, who did not kill anyone, all the more so [punishment] should be suspended for me for that. Rabbi says: This is a flawed a fortiori argument: If so, from whom would the Holy One blessed be He ever collect His promissory note? Rabbi Yaakov bar Idi asked before Rabbi Yoḥanan: If “a man,” why “a child”; if “a child,” why “a man”? He said to him: He [Abel] was a man in terms of his limbs, but a child in terms of years. He [Lemekh] said to them: ‘Let us go to Adam.’ They went to Adam [for consultation]. He said to them: ‘You do yours and the Holy One blessed be He will do His.’ They said to him: ‘Doctor, heal your own lameness.⁠ Have you yourself not separated from Eve for a hundred and thirty years so that you should not produce a son from her?’ This was a rhetorical question. When he heard this, he consorted [with Eve] to produce offspring. “Adam was further intimate with his wife and she gave birth to a son, and she called his name Seth: As God has provided me with another offspring in place of Abel, as Cain killed him” (Genesis 4:25). “Adam was further intimate with his wife,” extra desire was added for him to his desire. In the past, when he did not see her, he would not desire her. Now, whether he saw her or did not see her, he desired her. Rabbi Abba bar Yudan in the name of Rabbi Aḥa: This is an allusion for seafarers, that they will eventually remember their homes and come immediately. “She called his name Seth [Shet]: As God has provided [shat] me with another offspring.” Rabbi Tanḥuma said in the name of Rabbi Shmuel: She was looking ahead at that offspring who would come from a different place. Who is that? It is the messianic king. “In place of Abel, as Cain killed him.” Due to the sin of [killing] Abel, Cain was killed. This is analogous to two trees that were adjacent to one another. The wind felled one of them, and it fell on its neighbor and felled it. So, “in place of Abel, as Cain killed him” – due to the sin of [killing] Abel, Cain was killed. “To Seth, too, a son was born, and he called his name Enosh; then commenced [huḥal] the proclaiming of the name of the Lord” (Genesis 4:27). “To Seth, too, a son was born, and he called his name Enosh.” They asked before Abba Kohen Bardela: [Why does the Torah mention] Adam, Seth, Enosh, and then fall silent? He said: Until here [Enosh] they were in the image and in the likeness [of God]. From here on, the generations became corrupted and were created in a deformed state. Four matters changed during the days of Enosh son of Seth: The mountains became rocky ground; the dead began bringing forth worms; people’s faces became ape-like; and they became devalued [ḥullin] before malevolent spirits. Rabbi Yitzḥak said: It was they themselves who caused themselves to become devalued before the malevolent spirits, [as they declared:] ‘What is the difference between one who bows to an idol and one who bows to a person?’ “Then commenced [huḥal]” – Rabbi Simon said: In three places this term is stated as an expression of rebellion: “Then commenced the proclaiming of the name of the Lord”; “it was [heḥel] when man began” (Genesis 6:1); “he began [heḥel] to be a mighty one in the earth” (Genesis 10:8). They raised an objection: But is it not written [as well]: “This is what they began [haḥilam] to do”? (Genesis 11:6). He said to them: He struck upon the head of Nimrod and said of him: ‘This is the one who incited them to rebel against Me.’ Rabbi Levi said: This is analogous to a woman who said to her husband: ‘I saw in a dream (ḥalom) that you are divorcing me.’ He said to her: ‘Why in a dream? Here it is for you in reality.’ Rav Aḥa said: You made idolatrous objects of yourselves and called your own names [as divinities]. I, too, will call the seawater by My name and eradicate those people from the world. Rabbi Abahu expounded: The ocean is higher than the rest of the world. Rabbi Elazar ben Menaḥem said: Is this not an explicit verse? “He who calls forth the water of the sea and pours it upon the face of the earth”? (Amos 5:8). This was a rhetorical question. It is like something that is poured from above to below. “Who calls forth the water of the sea” is written twice, corresponding to the two times that the sea rose and inundated the world. Until where did it reach the first time and until where did it reach the second time? Rabbi Yudan, Rabbi Abahu, and Rabbi Elazar in the name of Rabbi Ḥanina: The first time it rose until Akko and until Yafo, and the second time it rose until the rocky peaks overlooking the Barbary Coast. Rabbi Ḥananya and Rabbi Aḥa in the name of Rabbi Ḥanina: The first time until the rocky peaks overlooking the Barbary Coast, and the second time until Akko and until Yafo. That is what is written: “I said: You shall come this far and not continue, and here the foam of your waves will be set” (Job 38:11). “You shall come this far and not continue” – to Akko, “you shall come this far and not continue.” “And here (ufo) the foam of your waves will be set” – in Yafo, “the foam of your waves will be set.” Rabbi Elazar said in the name of Rabbi Ḥanina: The first time it rose until Calabria, and the second time until the rocky peaks overlooking the Barbary Coast.

Texts in conversation

Compare Luke 4:23 and Genesis Rabbah 23:4

New Testament · Rabbinic

Share:

Summary

In Luke 4, Jesus quotes the saying “Physician, heal yourself,” also found in Rabbinic texts like Genesis Rabbah and Greek works such as Euripides. Its presence in all of these traditions shows how it was a popular expression used in many cultures.

Passages

Luke 4:23

New Testament
20 Then he rolled up the scroll, gave it back to the attendant, and sat down. The eyes of everyone in the synagogue were fixed on him. 21 Then he began to tell them, “Today this scripture has been fulfilled even as you heard it being read.” 22 All were speaking well of him, and were amazed at the gracious words coming out of his mouth. They said, “Isn’t this Joseph’s son?” 23 Jesus said to them, “No doubt you will quote to me the proverb, ‘Physician, heal yourself!’ and say, ‘What we have heard that you did in Capernaum, do here in your hometown too.’” 24 And he added, “I tell you the truth, no prophet is acceptable in his hometown. 25 But in truth I tell you, there were many widows in Israel in Elijah’s days, when the sky was shut up three and a half years and there was a great famine over all the land. 26 Yet Elijah was sent to none of them, but only to a woman who was a widow at Zarephath in Sidon.
75–85 CE (scholarly estimate) Read in Luke

Genesis Rabbah 23:4

Rabbinic · Aggadah
“Lemekh said to his wives, Ada and Tzila: Hear my voice, wives of Lemekh, listen to my speech, for have I slain a man for my wound or a child for my injury?” (Genesis 4:23) “Lemekh said to his wives, Ada and Tzila: Hear my voice.” Rabbi Yosei bar Ḥanina said: He propositioned them for intercourse, but they said to him: ‘Tomorrow the Flood is coming [to destroy all mankind]. Shall we heed you and bring forth children only to be cursed?’ He said to them: ‘“Have I slain a man for my wound,” that wounds should befall me on his account? “[Have I slain] a child for my injury,” that injuries should befall me on his account?’ This was a rhetorical question: Cain committed murder and yet [his punishment] was suspended for him for seven generations; I, who did not kill anyone, all the more so [punishment] should be suspended for me for that. Rabbi says: This is a flawed a fortiori argument: If so, from whom would the Holy One blessed be He ever collect His promissory note? Rabbi Yaakov bar Idi asked before Rabbi Yoḥanan: If “a man,” why “a child”; if “a child,” why “a man”? He said to him: He [Abel] was a man in terms of his limbs, but a child in terms of years. He [Lemekh] said to them: ‘Let us go to Adam.’ They went to Adam [for consultation]. He said to them: ‘You do yours and the Holy One blessed be He will do His.’ They said to him: ‘Doctor, heal your own lameness. Have you yourself not separated from Eve for a hundred and thirty years so that you should not produce a son from her?’ This was a rhetorical question. When he heard this, he consorted [with Eve] to produce offspring.
500 CE (scholarly estimate) Read in Genesis Rabbah

References

"... because Jesus began his ministry at about the age of thirty, it is also at least possible that he had acquired a higher level of education, given the span of time that would allow him to gain further education prior to his public ministry. Indeed, some Jewish boys attended the ephebeia (see above), if they had the financial means to do so. His use of parables may also suggest that he had learning beyond that of the primary, since only learned Jewish teachers would have known how to use this type of genre. Additionally, Jesus’ statement, “Surely you will quote this proverb to me: ‘Physician heal yourself’ (Πάντως ἐρεῖτέ μοι τὴν παραβολὴν ταύτην· Ἰατρέ, θεράπευσον σεαυτόν)” (Luke 4:23), may also suggest that he had some acquaintance with both Jewish and Greek literature. (This proverb is found in Greek literature, “A physician for others, but himself teeming with sores”, Euripides [480–406 BCE], Incertarum Fabularum Fragmenta 1086, as well as in Jewish literature, “Physician, physician heal thine own limp!”, Genesis Rabbah 23:4) The only thing that would mitigate us from considering this possibility that Jesus did attend an education beyond the primary is if he did not have the financial means to do so ..."
Hughson T. Ong, The Multilingual Jesus and the Sociolinguistic World of the New Testament, LBS 12 (Leiden: Brill, 2016), 254.

References are not endorsements of their contents. Read each reference in full to understand its author's intentions in using these texts.

Your feedback

Comments

  • Since almost all the memes and stories in the New Testament are rewrites of those in the Old Testament (the Jewish Torah) we should not be surprised to find that this one, commonly attributed to Jesus, actually comes from Genesis, written 500 years before Jesus was said to have been born. However i ...

    Kynszch Didales, October 25, 2024

Luke 4:23 and Genesis Rabbah 23:4

Leave a comment

Your questions and comments are welcome!

Comments

Glossary

Search the Library