Go to Related Reading
About this book

2 Enoch

Secrets of Enoch

About this book
Chapter 49

1 I swear to you, my children, but I do not swear by any oath, neither by heaven nor by earth, nor by any other creature which God created.⁠ The Lord said: 'There is no oath in me, nor injustice, but truth.' If there is no truth in men, let them swear by the words 'yes, yes', or else, 'no, no.' 2 And I swear to you, yes, yes, that no one has ever been in his mother's womb without a place already prepared for that soul to rest and a measure fixed for how much a person is to be tested in this world. Yes, children, do not deceive yourselves, for a place has been previously prepared for every soul of man.

Texts in conversation

Compare 2 Enoch 49:1 and Matthew 5:34

Pseudepigrapha, Apocalypses · New Testament

Share:

Summary

Matthew 5 and 2 Enoch 49 both emphasize honesty in speech, using the formula “yes, yes” or “no, no” to model honest communication. This resembles a tradition that would later be used throughout Rabbinic literature.

Passages

2 Enoch 49:1

Pseudepigrapha, Apocalypses · Secrets of Enoch
1 I swear to you, my children, but I do not swear by any oath, neither by heaven nor by earth, nor by any other creature which God created. The Lord said: 'There is no oath in me, nor injustice, but truth.' If there is no truth in men, let them swear by the words 'yes, yes', or else, 'no, no.' 2 And I swear to you, yes, yes, that no one has ever been in his mother's womb without a place already prepared for that soul to rest and a measure fixed for how much a person is to be tested in this world. Yes, children, do not deceive yourselves, for a place has been previously prepared for every soul of man.
1–100 CE (scholarly estimate) Read in 2 Enoch

Matthew 5:34

New Testament
33 “Again, you have heard that it was said to an older generation, ‘Do not break an oath, but fulfill your vows to the Lord.’ 34 But I say to you, do not take oaths at all—not by heaven, because it is the throne of God, 35 not by earth because it is his footstool, and not by Jerusalem, because it is the city of the great King. 36 Do not take an oath by your head because you are not able to make one hair white or black. 37 Let your word be ‘Yes, yes’ or ‘No, no.’ More than this is from the evil one.
70–90 CE (scholarly estimate) Read in Matthew

References

"... In the Jewish tradition the call to truth-telling is also common. The Jewish expert, Montefiore, comments: "I do not think that the 'unbedingte Wahrhaftigkeit im Reden' (unqualified truthfulness in speech) which Jesus demanded was not also demanded, and was not also regarded as part of the moral ideal, by the Rabbis.' Examples in Rabbinic literature include Ruth Rabbah 1:6 and Baba Mezia 49a. Finally, there is compelling evidence that 2 Enoch 49:1 should not be utilized to support the Jewish oath formulation "yes, yes" since 1) this passage is missing in the shorter recension; 2) the work shows Christian influence; 3) the MSS date only from the 16th and 17th centuries; and 4) the type of swearing which is commanded ("yes, yes" or "no, no") is explicitly stated not to be an oath. Therefore, based upon the close connection of Matthew 5:34a and 37 and the unanimous witness of the early church, it seems best to understand Matthew as passing on Jesus' exhortation to speak the truth without relying upon an oath ..."
Dean B. Deppe, The Sayings of Jesus in the Paraenesis of James (Academisch Proefschrift Vrije Universiteit Te Amsterdam, 1990), 241.
"... if there is no truth in human beings, then let them make an oath by means of the words ‘Yes, Yes!’ or, if it should be the other way around, ‘no, no!’ and I make an oath to you—‘Yes, Yes!’—that even before ...” Lawrence Schiffman regards this passage as a complete prohibition of oaths formulated under the influence of Matt 5:37 and James 5:12 on 2 Enoch, so as a Christian addition. In my opinion, 2 Enoch does not prohibit oaths but equates “Yes, yes” and “No, no” with swearing an oath. Christfried Böttrich has likewise noticed this in his commentary on 2 Enoch. In fact, the idea behind 2 Enoch 49:1–2 is not unlike a dictum by Raba found the Babylonian Talmud: “R. Eleazar said: ‘no’ is an oath; ‘Yes’ is an oath. Granted, ... said Raba: But only if he said, ‘no! no!’ twice; or he said, ‘Yes! Yes!’ twice ...” Accordingly, this text could have been written by a Jew or a Christian ..."
Daniel Stökl Ben Ezra, “Halakha, Calendars, and the Provenances of 2 Enoch,” in New Perspectives on 2 Enoch: No Longer Slavonic Only, ed. Andrei Orlov and Gabriele Boccaccini, Studia Judaeoslavica 4 (Leiden: Brill, 2012), 229–242.

References are not endorsements of their contents. Read each reference in full to understand its author's intentions in using these texts.

Your feedback

Comments

  • I would offer the International Critical Commentary as a corrective to the line of thinking offered by Dean Deppe above.

    Against interpreting 5:33–7 as excluding in casuistic fashion all oaths, the following observations are pertinent. (1) As Jeremias, Theology, p. 220, has affirmed, the example ...

    Tre Brickley, May 24, 2024

2 Enoch 49:1 and Matthew 5:34

Leave a comment

Your questions and comments are welcome!

Comments

Glossary

Search the Library