Go to Related Reading
About this book

1 Enoch

Ethiopic Book of Enoch

About this book

Michael and Raphael Discuss the Judgment

Chapter 68

1 After that, my grandfather Enoch shared with me all the secrets from the book of Parables that had been given to him, compiling them into the words of the book of Parables for me.

2 On that day, Michael said to Raphael, “The power of the spirit overwhelms me and makes me tremble because of the severity of the judgment of the secrets, the judgment of the angels. Who can withstand the harsh judgment that has been imposed, which causes them to dissolve?”

3 Michael spoke again, saying to Raphael, “Who can remain unaffected by this judgment, whose heart is not softened and whose resolve is not shaken⁠ by this decree that has been issued against them because of their misleading ways?”

4 As he stood before the Lord of Spirits, Michael said to Raphael, “I will not support them in the presence of the Lord, for the Lord of Spirits is displeased with them because they act as though they were the Lord. 5 Therefore, all that is hidden will happen to them for eternity, for neither angel nor man will share in their fate, but they alone will bear their judgment forever and ever.”

Continue to 2 Enoch

Texts in conversation

Compare Aeschylus, Prometheus Bound 1–54 and 1 Enoch 68:3

Classical · Pseudepigrapha, Apocalypses

Share:

Summary

In 1 Enoch, Michael trembles with pity at the fallen angels’ sentence yet will not plead for them. This echoes Greek myth, where Aeschylus describes the same reluctant executioner in Hephaestus, who pities the bound Prometheus but is overruled by Zeus.

Passages

Aeschylus, Prometheus Bound 1–54

Classical · Prometheus Vinctus
1 We have come to the earth’s farthest limit,2 to the Scythian land, an untraveled wilderness.3 And now, Hephaestus, you must obey the commands4 laid on you by the Father—to these rocks5 high and craggy, clamp this criminal6 in shackles of adamant that cannot be broken.7 For your own flower, flashing fire, source of all arts,8 he has stolen and given to mortal creatures.9 Such is his offense. For this he must pay the penalty to the gods,10 so that he may learn to accept the rule of Zeus11 and cease his love for humanity.12 Power and Force, for you, Zeus’s command13 is now fulfilled, and nothing remains to stop you.14 But I do not have the courage myself15 to bind with force a related god on this rocky cliff, battered by harsh winter.16 Yet I must find the courage for this act.17 For it is perilous to disregard the commandments of the Father.18 Noble son of Themis, whose counsel is sound,19 against my will, no less than yours, I must rivet you with bronze bonds20 no hand can undo, on this deserted crag,21 where you will neither hear a human voice nor see a human form.22 But, scorched by the sun’s bright beams,23 you will lose your skin’s fair bloom. You will be glad24 when star-robed night hides his brightness and25 when the sun again scatters the frost of morning.26 The burden of your present suffering will always weigh on you and27 will wear you out. The one who will free you is not yet born.28 Such is the prize you have gained for your support for humanity.29 For, god though you are, you did not fear the anger of the gods, but30 you gave mortal creatures honors beyond what was due to them.31 Therefore you must keep watch on this joyless rock,32 standing upright, sleepless, without bending your knee.33 And you will cry out with many groans and useless laments.34 For Zeus’s heart is hard,35 and everyone is harsh whose power is new.36 Well, why delay and waste time on pity?37 Why do you not detest a god so hateful to the gods,38 since he has betrayed your privilege to mortals?39 Kinship and companionship are powerful bonds.40 I agree. But to refuse the Father’s commands,41 is this possible? Do you not fear that more?42 Yes, you are always pitiless and full of arrogance.43 Yes, for it does no good to lament this fellow.44 Stop wasting your labor on a task that does no good.45 How I hate this craft!46 Why hate it? The truth is that47 your craft is not to blame for these troubles.48 Even so, I wish it had fallen to someone else!49 Every job is troublesome except commanding the gods.50 No one is free except Zeus.51 This task proves it. I cannot deny it.52 Hurry then to put the shackles around him,53 so that the Father does not see you loitering.54 There! You can see that the bands are ready.

1 Enoch 68:3

Pseudepigrapha, Apocalypses · Ethiopic Book of Enoch
2 On that day, Michael said to Raphael, “The power of the spirit overwhelms me and makes me tremble because of the severity of the judgment of the secrets, the judgment of the angels. Who can withstand the harsh judgment that has been imposed, which causes them to dissolve?”3 Michael spoke again, saying to Raphael, “Who can remain unaffected by this judgment, whose heart is not softened and whose resolve is not shaken by this decree that has been issued against them because of their misleading ways?”4 As he stood before the Lord of Spirits, Michael said to Raphael, “I will not support them in the presence of the Lord, for the Lord of Spirits is displeased with them because they act as though they were the Lord. 5 Therefore, all that is hidden will happen to them for eternity, for neither angel nor man will share in their fate, but they alone will bear their judgment forever and ever.”
325 BCE – 100 CE Read in 1 Enoch

References

... Perhaps it not only reflected elements in the Parables but also imitated something like 1 Enoch 9-10, where the four archangels discuss, and then intercede for, the victimized inhabitants of the earth, and where they execute judgment against the fallen angels and their progeny. Here we catch a glimpse of a discussion about intercession in behalf of the fallen angels. See also 1 Enoch 13:4-7, where Enoch actually performs this task. The point of the 'dialogue' here is that it is not worth even attempting such intercession. There is also an interesting parallel between this narrative fragment and the opening scene in Aeschylus's Prometheus Bound (lines 1-54). Out of pity, Hephaestus hesitates to chain Prometheus to the rock, but Kratos finally persuades him that the wrath of Zeus is implacable. ...
George W. E. Nickelsburg, A Commentary on the Book of 1 Enoch Chapters 37-82 (Minneapolis: Fortress, 2012), 293.

References are not endorsements of their contents. Read each reference in full to understand its author's intentions in using these texts.

Your feedback

Last updated

Aeschylus, Prometheus Bound 1–54 and 1 Enoch 68:3

Leave a comment

Your questions and comments are welcome!

Comments

Glossary

Search the Library