Go to Related Reading
About this book

751a

Athenian: Well then, after everything that has now been said, you will next come, I suppose, to the task of appointing magistrates for your State. Clinias: That is right. Athenian: This involves two branches of civic organization. The first is the appointment of magistracies and magistrates, which includes fixing the right number required and the proper method of appointing them. The second is assigning to each magistracy the laws, and the number of laws, appropriate to it in each case. But before we make our selection, let us pause for a moment and make a relevant statement about it.

751b

Clinias: What statement is that? Athenian: It is this. Everyone can see clearly that legislation is a great undertaking. Placing unfit officials in charge of well-framed laws in a well-equipped State not only robs those laws of all their value and causes widespread ridicule, but is also likely to become the most fertile source of damage and danger in such States.

751c

Clinias: Undoubtedly. Athenian: Then, my friend, let us take note of this consequence as we now deal with your constitution and State. You see that, in the first place, those who are rightly to undertake official functions must in every case have been fully tested, both themselves and their families, from their earliest years up to the time they are selected. Second, those who are to do the selecting must have been brought up in law-abiding habits and be well trained for the task of rightly rejecting or accepting the candidates who deserve their disapproval or approval. Yet on this point, can we suppose that men who have only recently come together, who do not know one another and have had no training, could ever possibly select their officials without fault?

751d

Clinias: It is practically impossible. Athenian: Yet, as the saying goes, a contest allows no excuses. That is how it must be now with you and me. For you, as you tell me, have given your pledge to the Cretan nation that you, with your nine colleagues, will devote yourself to founding that State; and I, for my part, have promised to help you in the course of our present imaginative sketch.

752a

Athenian: And I would certainly be reluctant to leave our sketch without a head, because if it wandered about in that condition it would look entirely shapeless. Clinias: I heartily approve of what you say, Stranger. Athenian: And more than that, I will act as I say to the best of my ability. Clinias: By all means, let us do as we say. Athenian: It will be done, if God is willing and if we can master our old age to that extent.

752b

Clinias: God will probably be willing. Athenian: Probably he will. And with him as our leader, let us also observe this— Clinias: What? Athenian: How boldly and adventurously we will now have founded this State of ours. Clinias: What do you have particularly in mind just now, and what makes you say so? Athenian: The fact that we are legislating lightheartedly and boldly for inexperienced men, in the hope that they will accept the laws we have now enacted. This much at least is plain, Clinias, to almost everyone, even to the dullest mind: they will not readily accept any of those laws at the start. But suppose those laws could remain unchanged until those who absorbed them in childhood, were brought up in them, and grew fully used to them have taken part in elections to office throughout the State. Then, once this has been accomplished (if any means or method can be found to accomplish it properly), we have, I think, a strong guarantee that, after this transitional period of disciplined adolescence, the State will remain firm.

752d

Clinias: It is certainly reasonable to suppose so. Athenian: Then let us consider whether we might succeed in providing an adequate means to this end along the following lines. I declare, Clinias, that you Knossians, more than all other Cretans, not only ought to deal in no perfunctory way with the land you are now settling, but also ought to take the utmost care that the first officials are appointed in the best and most secure way possible. Selecting the rest of them will be a less serious task, but it is absolutely necessary for you to choose your Law-wardens first, with the utmost care.

752e

Clinias: What means or what rule can we find for this? Athenian: This. I assert, sons of Crete, that since the Knossians take precedence over most of the Cretan cities, they should join with those who have come into this community to select thirty-seven persons in all from their own number and from the community: nineteen from the settlers, and the rest from Knossos itself. The Knossians should hand these men over to your State, and they should make you personally a citizen of this colony and one of the eighteen, using persuasion or perhaps a reasonable degree of compulsion.

753a

Clinias: Why then, Stranger, have you and Megillus not also taken part with us in our constitution? Athenian: Athens is proud, Clinias, and Sparta is proud too, and both are far away. But for you this course is entirely appropriate in every respect, as it is likewise for the rest of the founders of the colony, to whom our recent remarks about you also apply. Let us assume, then, that this would be the fairest arrangement under present conditions. Later on, if the constitution still endures, the selection of officials shall take place as follows. All men who carry arms, as cavalry or infantry, or who have served in war as far as their age and ability allowed, shall take part in selecting the officials. They shall make the selection in whichever shrine the State considers most sacred. Each man shall bring to the altar of the god a tablet on which he has written the name of his nominee, with his father’s name, his tribe, and the deme he belongs to; and beside these he shall also write his own name in the same way. Anyone who chooses shall be permitted to remove any tablet that seems to him to be improperly written and to display it in the marketplace for not less than thirty days. The officials shall publicly display, for the whole State to see, the tablets judged to come first, up to 300 in number; and all the citizens shall vote again in the same way, each for whichever of these he wishes. From these, the officials shall again publicly display the names of those judged first, up to 100 in number. The third time, whoever wishes shall vote for whichever of the hundred he wishes, passing between the slain victims as he does so. Then they shall test the thirty-seven men who have received the most votes and declare them magistrates. Who, then, Clinias and Megillus, are the men who will establish in our State all these regulations about the magistracies and the tests for them? We see, do we not, that for States being harnessed together for the first time in this way, there must necessarily be some such persons; but who they could be, before any officials exist, is impossible to see. Yet somehow or other they must be there, and they must be men not of ordinary quality but of the highest quality possible. For, as the saying goes, well begun is half done, and everyone always praises a good beginning;

753e–754a

Athenian: but in truth, as I see it, a beginning is more than half, and no one has ever yet praised a well-made beginning as much as it deserves.

754a

Clinias: Very true. Athenian: Then let us not knowingly leave this first step unmentioned, or fail to make it quite clear to ourselves how it is to be brought about. I, however, am by no means rich in suggestions, except for one statement which, given the present situation, is both necessary and useful to make. Clinias: What statement is that? Athenian: I assert that the State whose settlement we are planning has no one to serve as a parent except the State that is founding it. I am well aware, though, that many colonies often have been, and will be, at odds with those that founded them. But now, on the present occasion, it is like a child in the helplessness of childhood. Even though he is likely to quarrel with his parents at some later date, he loves his parents and is loved by them, and he always runs for help to his family and finds in them, and them alone, his allies. In the same way, I assert, this relationship now exists ready-made for the Knossians toward the young State, because of their care for it, and for the young State toward the Knossians. I say once more, as I said just now (for there is no harm in repeating a good statement), that the Knossians must take a share in caring for all these matters. They must choose not less than 100 men from among those who have come into the colony, the oldest and best they are able to select; and let there be another hundred from the Knossians themselves. This joint body, I say, must go to the new State and arrange together that the magistrates are appointed according to the laws and tested after their appointment. When this has been done, the Knossians must live in Knossos, and the young State must try by its own efforts to secure safety and success for itself. As for the men who make up the thirty-seven, let us select them, both now and for all time to come, for the following purposes. First, they shall act as Wardens of the laws; and second, as Keepers of the registers in which every man records for the officials the amount of his property, leaving out four minae if he belongs to the highest property-class, three if he belongs to the second, two if to the third, and one if to the fourth. And if anyone is shown to possess anything else beyond what is registered, all such surplus shall be confiscated. In addition, he shall be liable to be brought to trial by anyone who wishes to prosecute: a trial that is neither noble nor of good name, but disgraceful, if he is convicted of despising the law for the sake of gain. So whoever wishes shall charge him with profiteering and prosecute him by law before the Law-wardens themselves;

754e–755e

Athenian: and if the defendant is convicted, he shall have no share in the public goods, and whenever the State makes a distribution, he shall receive no portion except his allotment. He shall be registered as a convicted offender, where anyone who chooses may read his sentence, for as long as he lives. A Law-warden shall hold office for no more than twenty years, and he shall be voted into office at not less than fifty years of age. If he is elected at the age of sixty, he shall hold office for ten years only; and by the same rule, the more he exceeds the minimum age, the shorter his term of office shall be. So if he lives beyond the age of seventy, he must no longer imagine that he can remain among these officials, holding an office of such great importance. As for the Law-wardens, then, let us state that these three duties are assigned to them; and as we proceed with the laws, each new law will assign to these men whatever additional duties they ought to take on beyond those now stated. And now we may go on to describe the selection of the other officials. Commanders must be selected next, along with their subordinates for purposes of war: hipparchs, phylarchs, and officers to marshal the ranks of the infantry tribes. The name taxiarchs, which is in fact the very name most people give them, would be especially appropriate for these. Of these officers, the commanders shall be nominated by the Law-wardens from among the members of our State only; and from those nominated, the selection shall be made by all who are serving or have served in war at their respective ages. And if anyone thinks that some man who has not been nominated is better than one of those nominated, he shall state the name of his nominee and of the man he is to replace, and, taking an oath on the matter, he shall propose his substitute; whichever of the two is preferred by vote shall be included in the list for selection. The three men appointed by the majority of votes to serve as commanders and supervisors of military affairs shall be tested as the Law-wardens were. The selected commanders shall nominate taxiarchs for themselves, twelve, one for each tribe; and here, in the case of the taxiarchs, just as in the case of the commanders, there shall be a right of counter-nomination and a similar procedure for voting and testing. For the present, before prytaneis and a Boule have been elected, this assembly shall be convened by the Law-wardens, who shall seat it in the holiest and most spacious place available: the hoplites in one section, the cavalry in another, and in a third section, next to these, all others who belong to the military forces.

755e–756e

Athenian: All shall vote for the commanders, and all who carry shields shall vote for the taxiarchs. The entire cavalry shall elect the phylarchs for themselves, and the commanders shall appoint for themselves the captains of the skirmishers, the archers, or any other branch of service. We still have the appointment of hipparchs left. They shall be nominated by the same persons who nominated the commanders, and the method of selection and counter-nomination shall be the same for them as for the commanders. The cavalry shall vote for them in full view of the infantry, and the two who receive the most votes shall be captains of all the cavalry. No more than two challenges of a vote shall be allowed; if anyone makes a third challenge, it shall be decided by those who were in charge of the count on that occasion. The Boule, or Council, shall consist of thirty dozen, since the number 360 is well suited to subdivision. They shall be divided into four groups, and 90 councillors shall be voted for from each of the property-classes. First, all the citizens shall be required to vote for councillors from the highest property-class, and anyone who disobeys shall pay whatever fine has been decided on. When these have been voted for, their names shall be recorded. On the next day, councillors from the second class shall be voted for, by the same procedure as on the first day. On the third day, anyone who chooses shall vote for councillors from the third class; voting shall be compulsory for members of the first three classes, but members of the fourth and lowest class shall be exempt from the fine if any of them do not wish to vote. On the fourth day, all shall vote for councillors from the fourth and lowest class. Any member of the third or fourth class who does not wish to vote shall be exempt from the fine, but any member of the first or second class who fails to vote shall be fined: three times the amount of the first fine for a member of the second class, and four times for a member of the first class. On the fifth day, the officials shall publish the recorded names for all the citizens to see, and every man shall vote from among these or else pay the first fine. When they have selected 180 from each of the classes, they shall choose half of this number by lot and test them; and these shall be the Councillors for the year.

756e–757e

Athenian: A selection of officials made in this way will strike a mean between a monarchic constitution and a democratic one, and our constitution should always stand midway between the two. For slaves will never be friends with masters, nor bad men with good, even when they hold equal positions. When equality is given to unequal things, the result will be unequal unless due measure is applied; and it is because of these two conditions that political communities are filled with factional strife. There is an old and true saying that equality produces friendship, and it is very rightly and fittingly said; but what kind of equality is capable of doing this is a very troublesome question, since it is far from clear. For there are two kinds of equality which, though they share the same name, are often almost opposite in their practical results. Any State or lawgiver is competent to apply the first of these in assigning honors—namely, the equality determined by measure, weight, and number—simply by using the lot to produce even results in the distributions. But the truest and best form of equality is not easy for everyone to discern. It is the judgment of Zeus. It never helps human beings except in small measure, but to the extent that it does help either States or individuals, it produces everything good. For it gives more to the greater and less to the smaller, granting due measure to each according to its nature. In the matter of honors too, it grants the greater honors to those who are greater in goodness, and the lesser to those of the opposite character in goodness and education, and so assigns to each, in proportion, what is fitting. Indeed, it is precisely this that constitutes political justice for us, which is the goal we must strive for, Clinias; this equality is what we must aim at as we settle the State that is now being planted. And whoever founds a State elsewhere at any time must make this same goal the aim of his legislation: not the advantage of a few tyrants, or of one, or of some form of democracy, but always justice. And justice consists in what we have just stated, namely, the natural equality given on each occasion to things that are unequal. Nevertheless, every State must at times use even this equality in a modified form, if it is to avoid involving itself in internal strife in one section or another. For the reasonable and considerate, wherever it is applied, is an infringement on the perfect and exact, since it departs from strict justice. For the same reason, it is necessary also to make use of the equality of the lot, because of the discontent of the masses; and in doing so we must pray, calling on God and Good Luck to guide the lot rightly for them toward the highest justice.

757e–758e

Athenian: That is why necessity compels us to use both forms of equality; but the form that depends on good luck we should use as seldom as possible. The State that means to survive must necessarily act in this way, my friends, for the reasons we have stated. For just as a ship sailing on the sea requires constant watchfulness both night and day, so too a State, when it lives amid the surge of surrounding States and is in danger of being caught by all sorts of plots, needs officials linked to officials from day to night and from night to day, and guardians succeeding guardians and being succeeded in turn, without a break. But since a crowd of people is never capable of performing any of these duties promptly, most of the Councillors must necessarily be left to spend most of their time on their private business, attending to their household affairs. We must assign a twelfth of them to each of the twelve months to supply guards in rotation. These will be ready to meet anyone who comes either from somewhere abroad or from within the State itself, if he wants to give information or to make inquiries about some matter that concerns the State’s relations with other States. They will give replies, and, when the State has asked questions, receive the replies. And above all, in view of the many kinds of innovation that constantly tend to arise in States, they will prevent these from occurring if possible, and, if they do occur, make sure that the State perceives and remedies what has happened as quickly as possible. For these reasons, this presiding section of the State must always have control over convening and dissolving assemblies, both the regular legal assemblies and those called in an emergency. So a twelfth of the Council will be the body that manages all these matters, and each such part shall rest in turn for eleven-twelfths of the year. Together with the rest of the officials, this twelfth of the Council must keep continual watch in the State over these matters. This arrangement of affairs in the city will prove reasonable. But what supervision and what system are we to have for all the rest of the country? Now that the whole city and the whole country have each been divided into twelve parts, must we not appoint supervisors for the city’s own streets, dwellings, buildings, harbors, market, and springs, and also for the sacred precincts and the temples, and all such things?

758e

Clinias: Certainly.

759a–759e

Athenian: Let us state, then, that the temples must have temple-keepers, priests, and priestesses. And for roads and buildings and their proper order; for people, and for animals too, to keep them from doing wrong; and to make sure that the order proper to States is maintained both within the city limits and in the suburbs, we must select three kinds of officials. Those who deal with the matters just mentioned we shall call city-stewards, and those dealing with the ordering of the market, market-stewards. Priests or priestesses of temples who hold hereditary priesthoods should not be disturbed. But if, as is likely to happen in such matters with a people being organized for the first time, few or none have such priesthoods already established, then we must establish priests and priestesses to be temple-keepers for the gods. In establishing all these offices, we must make the appointments partly by election and partly by lot, mixing democratic with non-democratic methods to secure mutual friendship in every rural and urban district, so that all may be as united in mind as possible. As for the priests, we shall entrust it to the god himself to secure what pleases him, by leaving their appointment to the divine chance of the lot. But we shall test each person who wins the lot: first, whether he is sound in body and legitimately born; and second, whether he comes from households that are as pure as possible, being himself clean of murder and of all such offenses against religion, and born of parents who have lived by the same rule. They ought to bring laws from Delphi about all matters of religion, appoint interpreters of those laws, and make use of them. Each priestly office should last for one year and no longer; and anyone who is to perform sacred rites properly according to the laws of religion should be not less than sixty years old. The same rules shall also apply to priestesses. For the interpreters, the tribes shall vote four at a time, in three rounds of voting, for four men, one from each tribe. When the three men who receive the most votes in each round have been tested, they shall send the nine to Delphi for the oracle to select one from each set of three; and the rules about their age and testing shall be the same as for the priests. These men shall hold office as interpreters for life; and when one of them is lost, the four tribes shall elect a replacement from the tribe he belonged to.

759e–760e

Athenian: As treasurers to control the sacred funds of each of the temples, and the sacred precincts with their produce and rents, we must choose from the highest property-classes three men for the largest temples, two for the smaller ones, and one for the least extensive. The method of selecting and testing them shall be the same as the one adopted for the commanders. These shall be the regulations concerning religious matters. As far as possible, nothing shall be left unguarded. In the city, the task of guarding shall be the responsibility of the commanders, taxiarchs, hipparchs, phylarchs, and prytaneis, and also of the city-stewards and market-stewards, once we have such officials properly selected and appointed. All the rest of the country must be guarded as follows. We have divided the whole country as nearly as possible into twelve equal portions. One tribe shall be assigned to each portion by lot, and each year it shall provide five men to act as land-stewards and phrourarchs (watch-captains). Each of the Five shall select twelve young men from his own tribe, not under 25 years of age and not over 30. The twelve portions of the country shall be assigned to these groups of twelve, one to each in rotation for a month at a time, so that all of them may gain experience and knowledge of every part of the country. The term of office and of service for guards and officers shall be two years. From the portion in which the lot first stations them, they shall move on month by month to the next district under the leadership of the phrourarchs, in a direction from left to right—and that will be from west to east. When the first year is completed, so that as many of the guards as possible may not only become familiar with the country in one season of the year but also learn what happens in each particular district at different seasons, their leaders shall lead them back again in the reverse direction, constantly changing their district, until they have completed their second year of service. For the third year they must elect other land-stewards and phrourarchs, the five overseers of the twelve.

760e–761e

Athenian: During their periods of residence in each district, their duties shall be as follows. First, to ensure that the country is fortified against enemies as well as possible, they shall dig channels wherever needed, excavate trenches, and build cross-walls, so as to keep out, to the best of their ability, those who try in any way to damage the country and its property. For these purposes they shall make use of the draft animals and the servants in each district, using the former and supervising the latter, and always choosing, as far as possible, times when these people are free from their own work. In every respect they must make movement as difficult as possible for enemies, but as easy as possible for friends, whether people, mules, or cattle. They shall do this by attending to the roads, so that all of them become as level as possible, and to the rainwater, so that it benefits rather than harms the country as it flows down from the heights into all the hollow valleys among the mountains. They shall dam the outlets of these flooded valleys with walls and channels, so that by storing up or absorbing the rains from heaven, and by forming pools or springs in all the low-lying fields and districts, they may make even the driest spots abundantly supplied with good water. As for spring water, whether streams or fountains, they shall beautify and adorn it with plantings and buildings; by joining the pools through cut tunnels they shall make them all abundant; and by using water-pipes they shall beautify, at every season of the year, any sacred precinct or grove that may be close at hand, by directing the streams right into the temples of the gods. And everywhere in such places the young men should build gymnasia both for themselves and for the old men, providing warm baths for the old. They should keep a plentiful supply of dry wood there, and give a kindly welcome and a helping hand to the sick and to those whose bodies are worn out by the labors of farming—a welcome far better than a doctor who is none too skillful. They shall carry on these and all similar works in the country districts both for ornament and for use, and also to provide recreation of a by no means ungraceful kind. Their serious duties in this department shall be as follows. The Sixty must each guard their own district, not only because of enemies but also with an eye to those who claim to be friends. And if anyone, whether a foreign neighbor or a citizen, wrongs another citizen, and whether the wrongdoer is a slave or free, the judges for the complainant shall be the Five officers themselves in petty cases, and in more serious cases the Five together with their twelve subordinates, where the damages claimed are up to three minae. No judge or official should hold office without being subject to an audit, except only those who, like kings, form a court of final appeal.

761e–762e

Athenian: The same applies to these land-stewards. If they commit any outrage against those they supervise—by imposing unfair demands, or by trying to take some of their farm produce without their consent, or if they accept a gift meant as a bribe, or decide cases unjustly—they shall be branded with disgrace throughout the whole State for yielding to flattery. For all the other wrongs they have committed against people in the district, up to the value of one mina, they shall voluntarily submit to trial before the villagers and neighbors. And if on any occasion they refuse to submit in this way, whether for a greater or a lesser wrong, trusting that by moving every month to a new district they will escape trial, then the injured party must bring proceedings in the public courts; and if he wins his case, he shall exact a double penalty from the defendant who slipped away and refused to submit voluntarily to trial. The officers and land-stewards shall live in the following way during their two years of service. First, in each district there shall be common meals, at which all shall eat together. If a man is absent from the common meals for even a single day, or sleeps away for a night, without orders from the officers or some urgent necessity, and the Five report him and post his name in the marketplace as guilty of deserting his watch, he shall suffer disgrace for betraying his public duty, and anyone who meets him and wishes to punish him may beat him without penalty. And if any of the officers themselves commits such an act, it will be proper for all the Sixty to keep an eye on him. If any of them notices or hears of such an act but fails to prosecute, he shall be held guilty under the same laws and punished more severely than the young men, and he shall be entirely disqualified from holding positions of command over the young men. The Law-wardens shall supervise these matters with the greatest care, to prevent such things from happening if possible, and, where they do happen, to make sure they meet with the punishment they deserve. Every man must hold this view about people in general: the man who has not been a servant will never become a master worthy of praise, and the right way to win honor is by serving honorably rather than by ruling honorably—serving first the laws, since this is service to the gods, and second, for the young, always serving their elders and those who have lived honorable lives. Next, whoever is made a land-steward must have shared the daily rations, which are coarse and uncooked, during the two years of service.

762e–763e

Athenian: For once the Twelve have been chosen, they shall meet with the Five and resolve that, acting like servants themselves, they will keep no servants or slaves to wait on them, and will not use any attendants belonging to the other farmers or villagers for their own private needs, but only for public requirements. In all other respects they shall resolve to live a self-sufficient life, acting as their own servants and masters, and, besides this, thoroughly exploring the whole country in summer and winter, under arms, for the purpose of both guarding and getting to know each particular district. For an accurate knowledge of one’s own country is probably a branch of learning second to none. So the young men ought to practice hunting with hounds and all other forms of hunting, as much for this reason as for the general enjoyment and benefit that come from such sports. As for this branch of service, then—both the men themselves and their duties, whether we choose to call them secret-service men or land-stewards or any other name—every man who means to guard his own State effectively shall carry it out zealously to the best of his ability. The next step in our choice of officials is to appoint market-stewards and city-stewards. After the land-stewards, who number sixty, will come the three city-stewards. They shall divide the twelve sections of the city into three parts, and, following the example of the land-stewards, they shall have charge of the city’s streets, of the various roads that run into the city from the country, and of the buildings, to see that all these conform to the requirements of the law. They shall also have charge of all the water supplies that the guards convey and pass on to them in good condition, to ensure that the water is both pure and plentiful as it pours into the cisterns, and may thus both beautify and benefit the city. So these men too must have both the ability and the leisure to attend to public affairs. Therefore, for the office of city-steward, every citizen shall nominate whomever he chooses from the highest property-class. When these have been voted on and the six who received the most votes have been determined, those whose duty it is shall select the three by lot; and after passing the scrutiny, these men shall carry out the office according to the laws established for them. After these, they must elect five market-stewards from the second and first property-classes. In all other respects the method of their election shall be similar to that of the city-stewards: from the ten candidates chosen by vote they shall select the five by lot, and after the scrutiny declare them appointed.

763e–764e

Athenian: Everyone shall vote for every official. Anyone who refuses to do so, if reported to the officials, shall be fined fifty drachmae and also be declared a bad citizen. Whoever wishes shall attend the Ecclesia and the public assembly. For members of the second and first property-classes attendance shall be compulsory, and anyone found absent from the assemblies shall be fined ten drachmae. For a member of the third or fourth class it shall not be compulsory, and he shall go free without a fine, unless the officials, for some urgent reason, order everyone to attend. The market-stewards must see to it that the market is conducted as the law prescribes. They must supervise the temples and fountains in the market to see that no one does any damage. If anyone does damage and is a slave or a foreigner, they shall punish him with blows and fetters; if a native is guilty of such misconduct, they shall have power to impose a fine of up to a hundred drachmae on their own authority, and to fine the wrongdoer up to twice that amount when acting jointly with the city-stewards. Similarly, the city-stewards shall have the power to fine and punish within their own sphere, fining up to a mina on their own authority, and up to twice that sum jointly with the market-stewards. It will be appropriate next to appoint officials for music and gymnastics, two grades for each department: one for education, the other for managing competitions. By education officials the law means supervisors of gymnasia and schools, responsible for their discipline and teaching and for overseeing attendance and accommodations for both girls and boys. By competition officials it means umpires for the competitors in both gymnastics and music, and these too are of two grades. For competitions there should be the same umpires for both men and horses; but in music it will be appropriate to have separate umpires for solo performances and for mimetic performances—I mean, for example, one set chosen for rhapsodists, harpers, flute-players, and all such musicians, and another set for choral performers. We ought first to choose the officials for the playful exercise of choirs of boys, men, and girls in dances and in all the regular forms of music;

764e–765e

Athenian: and for these one official is enough, and he must be not under forty years of age. For solo performances, too, one umpire of not less than thirty years is enough, to act as presenter and to pass adequate judgment on the competitors. The official and director of the choirs must be appointed in the following way. All who are devoted to these subjects shall attend the assembly, and if they refuse to attend they shall be liable to a fine—a matter the Law-wardens shall decide; any others who are unwilling to attend shall be under no compulsion. Every elector must make his nomination from among those who are experts. In the scrutiny, affirmation and denial shall be confined to one point only: on one side, that the candidate is expert; on the other, that he is not expert. And whichever one of the ten who come first in the voting is chosen by lot and passes the scrutiny shall be the official in charge of the choirs for the year according to law. In the same way they shall appoint, by lot, the official who is to preside for that year over those who enter competitions in solos and in joint performances on the flute; and the one so chosen shall refer the verdict to the judges. Next it is appropriate to choose umpires for the athletic contests of horses and men from the third and second property-classes. Attendance at this election shall be compulsory for the first three classes, but the lowest class shall be exempt from fines for not attending. Three shall be appointed: twenty having first been selected by show of hands, three of the twenty shall be chosen by lot, and they must also be approved by the vote of the scrutineers. If any candidate is disqualified in any drawing of lots or testing for office, they shall elect a replacement and carry out the scrutiny in the same way as for the original candidate. In the department we have been dealing with, we still have to appoint an official who will preside over the whole range of education for both girls and boys. For this purpose there shall be one official legally appointed. He shall be not under fifty years of age and shall be the father of legitimate children of either sex, or preferably of both sexes. Both the candidate who is put first and the elector who puts him first must be convinced that this office is by far the most important of the highest offices of State.

765e–766e

Athenian: For in the case of every living thing—plant or animal, tame and wild alike—it is the first shoot, if it sprouts well, that does the most to bring the essential excellence of the creature in question to its proper completion. Man, as we affirm, is a tame creature. Nevertheless, while he usually becomes the most godlike and gentle of animals when he happens to have a fortunate nature combined with right education, if his training is inadequate or bad he turns out the wildest of all the creatures the earth produces. So the lawgiver must not allow them to treat the education of children as a matter of secondary or incidental importance. Since the presiding official must be well chosen, the lawgiver must begin by instructing them to appoint as president, to the best of their ability, the citizen who is most excellent in every way. Therefore all the officials—except the Council and the prytaneis—shall go to the temple of Apollo, and each shall cast a secret ballot for whichever of the Law-wardens he thinks would best control educational affairs. Whoever receives the most votes, after passing a scrutiny held by the officials who elected him, other than the Law-wardens, shall hold office for five years; in the sixth year they shall elect another man to this office in the same manner. If anyone holding a public office dies more than thirty days before his term ends, those whose proper duty it is must appoint a replacement in the same way. If a guardian of orphans dies, the relatives on both the father’s and the mother’s side who are resident in the country, as far as cousins’ children, shall appoint a replacement within ten days; if they fail to do so, each of them shall be fined one drachma per day until they have appointed the guardian for the children. A State would indeed be no State if it had no properly established law courts. But a judge who was speechless and said no more than the litigants do at a preliminary hearing, as arbitrators do, would never prove effective at deciding questions of justice. Consequently it is not easy for a large body of judges to judge well, nor for a small one either, if its members are of poor ability. The matter in dispute on each side must always be made clear, and for clarifying the point at issue, time, deliberation, and repeated questioning are useful.

766e–767e

Athenian: So those who bring charges against each other must first go to their neighbors and friends who know most about the actions in dispute. If someone fails to get an adequate decision from them, he shall go to another court; and if these two courts are unable to settle the matter, the third court shall put an end to the case. In a sense we may say that the establishment of law courts coincides with the election of officials. For every official must also be a judge of certain matters, while a judge, even if he is not an official, may be said to be an official of no small importance on the day when he concludes a case by pronouncing his judgment. Assuming, then, that the judges are officials, let us declare who will make suitable judges, of what matters, and how many shall deal with each case. The court with the greatest authority is the one the two parties set up for themselves, choosing judges by mutual agreement. Of the rest, there shall be two forms of trial: one when a private person accuses another private person of wronging him and wants to obtain a verdict by bringing him to trial, and the other when someone believes that the State is being wronged by one of the citizens and wants to come to the aid of the common good. We must now explain who the judges are and what sort of people they are. First, we must have a court common to all private persons who are having their third dispute with one another. It shall be formed as follows. On the day before a new year of office begins—which begins with the month following the summer solstice—all the officials, whether they hold office for one year only or longer, shall assemble in a single temple and, after swearing by the god, they shall dedicate, so to speak, one judge from each body of officials: namely, the member of each body whom they consider the best man and the most likely to decide the cases of his fellow citizens in the best and holiest way during the coming year. Once these are chosen, they shall undergo a scrutiny before those who chose them; and if any are disqualified, a replacement shall be chosen in the same way. Those who pass the scrutiny shall act as judges for those whose cases have escaped the other courts, and they shall cast their votes openly. The Councillors and all the other officials who elected them shall be required to attend these trials, both to hear and to see, and anyone else who wishes may attend. Anyone who accuses a judge of deliberately giving an unjust judgment shall go to the Law-wardens and lay his charge before them. A judge convicted on such a charge shall be liable to pay the injured party double the amount of the damage; and if he is judged to deserve a greater penalty, the judges of the case shall assess what additional punishment he must suffer, or what payment he must make to the State and to the person who brought the case.

767e–768e

Athenian: In the matter of offenses against the State, it is necessary first of all to give the people a share in the trial. For when a wrong is done to the State, it is the whole people that is wronged, and they would justly resent having no share in such trials. So while it is right that both the beginning and the end of such a case should be assigned to the people, the examination shall take place before three of the highest officials agreed on by both defendant and plaintiff; if they are unable to reach an agreement by themselves, the Council must decide between the choices each of them has made. In private cases too, as far as possible, all the citizens must have a share; for the man who has no share in helping to judge thinks he has no part or lot in the State at all. Therefore there must also be courts for each tribe, and judges appointed by lot on the spur of the moment must judge the cases, unswayed by pleas. But the final verdict in all such cases must rest with the court that we declare to be organized in the most incorruptible way humanly possible, especially for the benefit of those who have failed to get their case settled either before their neighbors or in the tribal courts. So as concerns the law courts—which, as we say, cannot easily be called either offices or non-offices without ambiguity—this outline sketch describes them in part, though it leaves out a good deal; for detailed legislation and definition concerning lawsuits would most properly be placed at the end of the legislative code. So let these matters be told to wait for us at the end. I would say that the other official posts have received most of the legislation they need for their establishment. But a full and precise account of each and all of the State’s departments and of the whole civic organization cannot be given clearly until our review has covered every section of its subject, from the first to the very last, in proper order. So now, at the point where we stand—when our exposition has gone far enough to include the election of the officials—we may find a fitting place to end our previous subject and to begin the subject of legislation, which no longer needs any postponements or delays.

768e

Clinias: You have treated the previous subject, Stranger, entirely to our satisfaction; but we welcome even more heartily the way you have linked your past statements with your future ones—the end with the beginning.

769a

Athenian: It seems, then, that up to now our old men’s sober game of reason has been finely played. Clinias: You are showing, I think, how fine these men’s serious work is. Athenian: Very likely. But let us see whether you agree with me about another point. Clinias: What is it, and whom does it concern? Athenian: You know how the painter’s art, for instance, never seems to come to an end in depicting each particular subject. In its work of embellishment it seems as though it would never stop applying colors or removing them—or whatever professional painters call the process—and reach a point where the picture can no longer be improved in beauty and clarity.

769b

Clinias: I too recall hearing something of what you mention, although I am by no means practiced in that kind of art. Athenian: You are none the worse for that. We can still use this fact, which happened to occur to us, to illustrate the following point. Suppose a man set out to paint an object of extreme beauty, intending that it should never grow worse but always better as time went on. Do you not see that, since the painter is mortal, his endless toil will produce results that last only a short time, unless he leaves a successor who is able to repair the picture if it suffers from the passage of time, and also to improve it in the future by touching up any deficiency left by his own imperfect craftsmanship?

769c–769d

Clinias: True.

769d–769e

Athenian: Well then, do you not think the lawgiver’s purpose is similar? He intends, first, to write down the laws with complete precision, as far as he can. Next, as time goes on and he puts his decrees to the test of practice, you surely cannot suppose that any lawgiver will be so foolish as not to see that a great many things must necessarily be left over, which some successor will have to set right, so that the constitution and the order of the State he has organized may always grow better and never in any way worse.

769e

Clinias: Of course, this is what everyone naturally wants. Athenian: Suppose, then, that a man knew of a device showing how he could teach another man, by deed and word, to understand to a greater or lesser degree how he should preserve or amend laws. Surely he would never stop explaining it until he had achieved his purpose.

770a

Clinias: He certainly would not. Athenian: Must not we three act in this way on the present occasion? Clinias: What do you mean? Athenian: We are about to make laws, and Law-wardens have been appointed by us. Therefore, since we are in the evening of life and they are young compared to us, we should not only legislate ourselves, as we say, but also make these same men legislators as well as Law-wardens, as far as we can.

770b

Clinias: We should—if, that is, we are capable of doing so. Athenian: At any rate we must try, and try hard. Clinias: By all means. Athenian: Let us address them like this: Beloved Keepers of the Laws, in many areas of our legislation we will leave out a vast number of matters (we have no choice but to do so); yet even so, we will include in our outline sketch, as far as we can, all the important matters as well as the general description. You will need to help fill in this outline, and you must listen to what I say about the aim you should keep before you in doing so. Megillus, Clinias, and I have often stated that aim to one another, and we agree that it is rightly stated. So we want you to be in immediate agreement with us, as our disciples, and to aim at the goals at which, as we three have agreed, the lawgiver and the Law-warden ought to aim. The sum and substance of our agreement was simply this. Whatever the way may be in which a member of our community—whether male or female, young or old—may become a good citizen, possessing the excellence of soul that belongs to a human being, whether it comes from some pursuit or disposition, or from some kind of possession, or from desire or opinion or mental study, all his efforts throughout his whole life shall be directed to achieving this end. Not a single person shall show that he prefers anything that hinders this aim. In short, even where the State is concerned, he must let it be overturned, if that seems necessary, rather than voluntarily submit to the yoke of slavery under the rule of worse men; or else he must himself leave the State as an exile. Men must endure all such sufferings rather than change to a form of government that naturally makes people worse.

770e–771e

Athenian: This is what we agreed on earlier. So now, keep both of these goals of ours in view as you revise the laws. Criticize all the laws that are unable to achieve them, but welcome all those that are able to do so, and, embracing them wholeheartedly, live your lives by them. All other practices, which aim at so-called goods other than these, you must say goodbye to. To begin the laws that follow, we must start with sacred matters. First, we must reconsider the number 5,040 and the many convenient divisions we found it to have, both as a whole and when divided into tribes. The tribal number is, as we said, a twelfth of the whole, being by its nature exactly 20 × 21. Our whole number has twelve divisions, and the tribal number also has twelve. Each such portion must be regarded as a sacred gift of God, corresponding to the months and to the revolution of the universe. That is why every State is guided by natural instinct to hold them sacred, although some people have perhaps made their divisions more correctly than others, or consecrated them more fortunately. We, at any rate, now affirm that we are perfectly correct in first choosing the number 5,040, which can be divided by every number from 1 to 12 except 11. This exception is very easily remedied, since simply subtracting two households from the total restores a whole number as the quotient. That this is really true we could show, at our leisure, with a fairly short explanation. For now, then, we shall trust the oracular statement just made, and we shall use these divisions, give each portion the name of a god or of a child of gods, and grant it altars and everything that belongs to them. At these altars we shall appoint two assemblies every month for sacrifice—twelve (yearly) for the whole tribal division and twelve for its urban section only. Their purpose shall be, first, to give thanks to the gods and their attendants, and second, to promote fellowship among ourselves, the mutual acquaintance we spoke of, and association of every kind. For in view of the partnership and union of marriage, ignorance must be eliminated, both on the husband’s part about the woman he marries and the family she comes from, and on the father’s part about the man to whom he gives his daughter. In such matters it is all-important to avoid any mistake if possible.

771e–772e

Athenian: To achieve this serious purpose, playful dances should be arranged for boys and girls. At these they should both see and be seen, in a reasonable way and on occasions that offer a suitable pretext, with their bodies unclothed except as far as sober modesty requires. The officials of the choirs shall be the supervisors and directors of all such matters, and also, together with the Law-wardens, the lawgivers for everything we leave unregulated. As we said, in all matters involving a host of small details the lawgiver must necessarily leave gaps, and rules and amendments must be made year by year by those who have constant experience of them from year to year and are taught by practice, until it is decided that a satisfactory code has been worked out to regulate all such proceedings. A fair and sufficient period to assign for this experimental work would be ten years, both for sacrifices and for dances in all their particular details. Each body of officials, acting together with the original lawgiver if he is still alive, or by themselves if he is dead, shall report to the Law-wardens whatever has been left out in their own department, and shall supply it, until each detail seems to have reached its proper completion. When this is done, they shall decree these as fixed rules and use them along with the rest of the laws originally decreed by the lawgiver. They must never willingly make any change in these. But if it should ever be thought that a need for change has arisen, all the people must be consulted, as well as all the officials, and they must seek advice from all the divine oracles. If there is general consent by all, then they may make a change, but under no other conditions at any time; and whoever objects to change shall always prevail according to law. When any man of twenty-five, seeing others and being seen by them, believes he has found somewhere a mate who is to his liking and suitable for having children together, he shall marry, in every case before he is thirty-five. But first let him listen to the guidance on how he should seek what is proper and fitting; for, as Clinias maintains, each law ought to be introduced by a prelude suited to it.

772e

Clinias: A very appropriate reminder, Stranger—and in my opinion you have chosen a most opportune point in your discussion to make it. Athenian: You are right. So let us say to the son of good parents: My child, you must make a marriage that sensible people will approve of. They would advise you neither to avoid a connection with a poor family entirely nor to pursue a connection with a rich one, but, other things being equal, always to prefer an alliance with a family of moderate means. Such a course will benefit both the State and the families that are joined, since where excellence is concerned, what is evenly balanced and symmetrical is infinitely superior to what is undiluted. The man who knows he is unduly hasty and impetuous in all his actions should seek a bride from steady parents, while the man of the opposite nature should go and match himself with someone of the opposite kind. For marriage as a whole there shall be one general rule: each man must seek to make the marriage that will benefit the State rather than the one that most pleases himself. Everyone naturally tends to go after the mate who most resembles himself, and as a result the whole State becomes unbalanced both in wealth and in moral habits; and because of this, the consequences we least want are the very ones that generally happen to most States. To make explicit legal enactments about these matters—that a rich man, for instance, must not marry into a rich family, nor a man of great power into a powerful family, or that men of hasty temper must be required to seek alliances with those of slower temper, and the slow with the hasty—would not only be ridiculous but would also cause widespread resentment. For people do not find it easy to see that a State should be like a bowl of mixed wine: when the wine is first poured in, it foams wildly, but as soon as it is tamed by the sober deity of water, it forms a fine partnership and produces a drink that is good and moderate. That this is exactly what happens in the blending of children is something hardly anyone is able to see. So in the legal code we must leave out such rules and simply try, by the charm of words, to persuade each person to value the equality of his children more highly than equality in a marriage with excessive wealth, and, by means of reproaches, to turn away from his goal anyone who has set his heart on marrying for money, though we may not compel him by a written law.

773e–774e

Athenian: These, then, shall be the exhortations given about marriage, in addition to those given earlier, which declared that it is a duty to lay hold of the ever-living reality by providing servants for God in our place; and we do this by leaving behind us children’s children. All this and more might be said in a proper prelude about marriage and the duty to marry. If, however, any man refuses to obey willingly, keeps himself aloof and without a partner in the State, and reaches the age of thirty-five unmarried, an annual fine shall be imposed on him: a hundred drachmae if he belongs to the highest property-class, seventy if to the second, sixty if to the third, and thirty if to the fourth. This fine shall be consecrated to Hera. Anyone who fails to pay the fine in full each year shall owe ten times the amount, and the treasurer of the goddess shall collect this sum; if he fails to collect it, he shall owe it himself, and at his audit he shall in every case be held to account for such a sum. This shall be the money fine imposed on the man who refuses to marry. As for honor, he shall receive none from the younger men, and no young man shall willingly show him any deference. If he tries to punish anyone, everyone shall come to the help and defense of the person mistreated, and anyone present who fails to give such help shall be declared by law to be both a cowardly and a bad citizen. About dowries it has been said before, and it shall be said again, that an equal exchange consists in neither giving nor receiving any dowry, so that the poor do not grow old unmarried for lack of money; for all who belong to this State have the necessities of life provided for them. The result of this rule will be less arrogance on the part of wives, and less humiliation and servility on the part of husbands because of money. Whoever obeys this rule will be acting nobly; but whoever disobeys it, by giving or receiving for clothing a sum of over fifty drachmae, or over one mina, or over one and a half minae, or (if he is a member of the highest property-class) over two minae, shall owe the public treasury an equal sum, and the amount given or received shall be consecrated to Hera and Zeus, and the treasurers of these deities shall collect it—just as the rule was, in cases of refusal to marry, that the treasurers of Hera should collect the fine in each instance or else pay it out of their own pockets. The right of betrothal belongs first to the father, second to the grandfather, and third to brothers by the same father. If there are none of these, it rightly belongs next to relatives on the mother’s side, in the same order. In the case of any unusual misfortune, the right shall belong in each case to the nearest of kin, acting together with the guardians.

774e–775e

Athenian: Concerning the preliminary marriage sacrifice and all the other sacred ceremonies that should properly be performed before, during, or after a marriage, each man shall consult the Interpreters, and believe that by obeying their directions he will have done everything properly. As for wedding feasts, each party should invite male and female friends, not more than five on each side, and an equal number of the relatives and in-laws of both households. In no case must the expense exceed what the person’s means allow: one mina for the richest class, half that amount for the second, and so on in proportion as the property assessment decreases. Whoever obeys the law should be praised by all; but whoever disobeys it the Law-wardens shall punish as a man of poor taste and untrained in the nomes of the nuptial Muses. Drinking to excess is a practice that is improper anywhere—except at the feasts of the god who gave us wine—and it is not safe either. It is certainly not so for those who take marriage seriously. At such a time, above all, both bride and groom ought to be sober, since the change in their life is a great one, and so that, as far as possible, the child that is conceived may in every case be born of sober parents; for it is quite uncertain which night or day will, with God’s help, bring about its conception. Moreover, procreation should not be the work of bodies loosened by excessive wine; rather, the embryo should be formed firmly, steadily, and quietly in the womb. But the man who is steeped in wine moves and is moved in every direction, writhing in both body and soul. So when he is drunk a man is clumsy and bad at sowing seed, and is likely to father unstable and untrustworthy offspring, crooked in form and character. So he must be very careful throughout the whole year and his whole life—and above all during the time he is fathering children—to do nothing that involves either bodily sickness or violence and injustice; for he will inevitably stamp these on the souls and bodies of his offspring and produce children who are in every way inferior. He must especially abstain from acts of this kind on the day and night of his marriage. For the Beginning, enshrined as a goddess among mortals, is the savior of all, provided she receives the honor due to her from each person who approaches her.

775e–776c

Athenian: The man who marries must leave his father and mother and take one of the two houses on his allotment, to be, as it were, the nest and nursery of his chicks. There he must make his marriage and the dwelling and home of himself and his children. For in friendships the presence of some degree of longing seems to cement all kinds of characters and bind them together; but unbroken closeness, since it lacks the longing that comes from time apart, causes friends to drift away from each other through an excessive surfeit of each other’s company. So the married couple must leave their own houses to their parents and the bride’s relatives, and act as if they themselves had gone off to a colony, visiting and being visited in their own home, fathering and raising children, and so handing on life, like a torch, from one generation to the next, and always worshiping the gods as the laws direct. Next, as to possessions: what should a man own to have a reasonable amount of property? Most possessions are easy enough both to identify and to acquire; but servants present all kinds of difficulties. The reason is that what we say about them is partly right and partly wrong; for the language we use about them both contradicts and agrees with our practical experience of them.

776c

Megillus: What do we mean by this? We still do not understand, Stranger, what you are referring to. Athenian: That is quite natural, Megillus. For probably the most controversial problem in all Hellas is the Helot system of the Lacedaemonians, which some maintain is good and others bad. A less violent dispute surrounds the subjection of the Mariandyni to the slave system of the Heracleotes, and that of the Penestae class to the Thessalians. In view of these and similar instances, what should we do about this question of owning servants? The point I happened to mention in the course of my argument, and about which you naturally asked me what I was referring to, was this. We know, of course, that we would all agree that one ought to own slaves who are as docile and as good as possible; for in the past many slaves have proved better than brothers or sons in every form of excellence, and have saved their masters, their property, and their whole households. Surely we know that this kind of thing is said about slaves?

776e

Megillus: Certainly. Athenian: And is the opposite kind of thing not said as well—that there is nothing sound in a slave’s soul, and that a sensible man should never trust that class at all? Our wisest poet, too, speaking of Zeus, declared: Far-thundering Zeus robs of half their wits / those men on whom the day of bondage falls. (Hom. Od. 17.322) So each party adopts a different attitude of mind. The one places no trust at all in the servant class, but treats them like wild beasts and, with goads and whips, makes the servants’ souls not merely three times but fifty times enslaved; whereas the other party does precisely the opposite.

777a–777b

Megillus: Just so.

777b

Clinias: Since this difference of opinion exists, Stranger, what should we do about our own country with regard to owning slaves and punishing them? Athenian: Well, Clinias, since man is a difficult creature to manage, it is clear that he is not at all likely to be or become easy to deal with when it comes to the necessary distinction, in actual practice, between slave and freeborn master. Clinias: That is evident. Athenian: The slave is no easy possession. Actual experience shows how many evils result from slavery—as in the frequent revolts in Messenia, and in States where many servants who speak the same language are kept, not to mention the crimes of all sorts committed by the so-called Corsairs who haunt the coasts of Italy, and the reprisals for them. In view of all these facts, it is truly a puzzle to know how to deal with all such matters. Only two means are left for us to try. One is not to allow the slaves, if they are to tolerate slavery quietly, to be all of the same nation, but, as far as possible, to have them of different races and languages. The other is to give them proper treatment, not only for their sake but even more for our own. Proper treatment of servants consists in using no violence toward them and in wronging them even less, if possible, than our own equals. For it is the way a man deals with people whom it is easy for him to wrong that shows most clearly whether his reverence for justice and his hatred of injustice are genuine or hypocritical. So the man who, in his character and his actions toward slaves, proves himself unstained by anything unholy or unjust will be best able to sow a crop of goodness. And this we may say, and rightly say, of every master, or king, and of everyone who holds any kind of absolute power over someone weaker than himself.

777e–778a

Athenian: We ought to punish slaves justly, and not make them conceited by merely admonishing them as we would free men. What we say to a servant should be almost entirely a simple command. There should be no joking with servants, male or female; for by excessively foolish indulgence in their treatment of their slaves, masters often make life harder both for themselves, as rulers, and for their slaves, as those who are ruled.

778a

Clinias: That is true. Athenian: Suppose, then, that we are now provided, to the best of our ability, with servants sufficient in number and quality to help with every kind of task. Should we not next describe our dwellings? Clinias: Most certainly.

778b–778c

Athenian: It seems that our city, being new and until now without houses, must provide for practically all of its house-building, arranging every detail of its architecture, including temples and walls. These things really come before marriage, Clinias; but since our construction is now a verbal one, this is a very suitable place to deal with them. When we come to the actual construction of the State, we shall, God willing, have the houses come before marriage and crown all our architectural work with our marriage laws. For the present we shall limit ourselves to a brief outline of our building regulations.

778c

Clinias: Certainly. Athenian: The temples we must build all around the marketplace and in a circle around the whole city, on the highest sites, for ease of defense and for cleanliness. Next to the temples we will place the houses of the officials and the law courts, where, as in the holiest places, they will give and receive judgments—partly because they deal there with holy matters, and partly because these are the seats of holy gods. In these courts trials for murder and for all crimes deserving death will fittingly be held. As for walls, Megillus, I would agree with your Sparta in letting the walls lie asleep in the ground and not waking them up, for the following reasons. The poet has a fine saying, often repeated, that walls should be made of bronze and iron rather than of earth.

778e–779d

Athenian: But our plan, in addition, would deserve to be met with roars of laughter—I mean the plan of sending young men into the country every year to dig and trench and build, so as to keep the enemy out and prevent them from ever setting foot on the borders of the land—if we were also to build a wall around the city. For in the first place, a wall is by no means good for a city’s health; and moreover it usually produces a soft habit of soul in the inhabitants, by inviting them to take refuge inside it instead of driving back the enemy. Instead of securing their safety by keeping watch night and day, it tempts them to believe that their safety is assured if they are fenced in by walls and gates and go to sleep, like men born to avoid toil. They little realize that ease is really the fruit of toil, whereas a fresh crop of toils is, I think, the inevitable result of dishonorable ease and laziness. But if men really must have a wall, then the private houses must be built from the start in such a way that the whole city forms a single wall. All the houses must have good walls, built uniformly and in a similar style, facing the streets, so that the whole city will have the form of a single house. This will make its appearance not unpleasant, besides being by far the best plan for ensuring safety and ease of defense. Seeing that the original buildings remain will fittingly be the special responsibility of the occupants; and the city-stewards should supervise them, compel the negligent by fines, and also watch over the cleanliness of everything in the city, and prevent any private person from encroaching on State property, either by building or by digging. These officials must also keep watch over the proper drainage of rainwater, and over all other matters, whether inside or outside the city, that it is right for them to manage. All such details—and everything else the lawgiver is unable to deal with and leaves out—the Law-wardens shall regulate by supplementary decrees, taking practical needs into account. And now that these buildings and those of the marketplace, the gymnasia, and all the schools have been built and await their occupants, and the theaters their spectators, let us proceed to the subject that comes next after marriage, taking our legislation in order.

779d

Clinias: By all means. Athenian: Let us regard the marriage ceremony as now completed, Clinias. Next comes the period before childbirth, which will last a full year. How the bride and groom ought to spend this time in a State that will be unlike most other States—that is to be our next topic, and it is not the easiest of things to explain. We have said many hard things before, but the general public will find none of them harder to accept than this. All the same, what we believe to be right and true must by all means be said, Clinias.

779e

Clinias: Certainly. Athenian: Suppose someone proposes to publish laws for States regulating how the citizens should conduct themselves in State affairs and public matters, but thinks there is no need to make laws for their private conduct, even in necessary matters. He thinks everyone should be allowed to spend his day just as he pleases, instead of everything, public and private, being required to follow a regular rule; and he supposes that if he leaves private conduct unregulated by law, the citizens will still agree to regulate their public and civic life by law. That man is wrong in what he proposes. Why have I said this? For this reason: because we shall assert that married people must take their meals at the public messes neither more nor less than they did during the time before marriage. When the custom of public messes first arose in your countries—probably dictated by a war or by some event of equal force, when you were short of men and in dire straits—it seemed an astonishing institution. But after you had experienced these public messes and had been obliged to adopt them, the custom seemed to contribute admirably to security; and in some such way as that, the public mess came to be one of your established institutions.

780c

Clinias: That is likely enough. Athenian: So although this was once, as I said, an astonishing and alarming institution to impose on people, a man who tried to impose it as a law nowadays would not find it an equally difficult task. But there is a practice that follows from this institution and that would be truly successful if carried out. At present it is carried out nowhere, and so it makes the lawgiver, if he tries, practically card his wool into the fire, as the proverb says, and labor in vain at an endless series of tasks. This practice is neither easy to state nor, once stated, easy to put into effect.

780d

Clinias: Why do you show so much hesitation, Stranger, about mentioning this? Athenian: Listen now, so that we do not spend a lot of time on the matter to no purpose. Everything that takes place in the State, if it shares in order and law, confers every kind of blessing; but most things that are either without order or badly ordered undo the effects of the well-ordered. And it is into this predicament that the practice we are discussing has fallen. In your case, Clinias and Megillus, public meals for men are, as I said, rightly and admirably established by a divine necessity; but for women this institution is quite wrongly left unregulated by law, and public meals for them have not been brought into the light of day;

781a–781d

Athenian: instead, the female sex—that very section of humanity which, because of its weakness, is in other respects the most secretive and crafty—is abandoned to its disorderly condition through the misguided indulgence of the lawgiver. Because you have neglected that sex, you have had an influx of many consequences that would have been much better than they now are if they had been under legal control. For leaving women unregulated is not simply, as one might suppose, leaving half of our whole task undone. To the extent that women are inferior in goodness to men, the harm from neglecting them is more than twice what it would be from neglecting men. So it is better for the welfare of the State to revise and reform this institution, and to regulate all institutions for men and women in common. At present, however, the human race is so far from having reached this happy position that a man of discretion must actually avoid all mention of the practice in districts and States where even the existence of public meals has no formal recognition at all. How, then, will anyone try, without being laughed at, actually to compel women to take food and drink in public, exposed to the view of all? The female sex would more readily endure anything rather than this. Accustomed as they are to living a retired and private life, women will use every means to resist being led out into the light, and they will prove much too strong for the lawgiver. So elsewhere, as I said, women would not even listen to the right rule being mentioned without shrieks of indignation; but in our State perhaps they will. So if we agree that our discussion of the constitution as a whole must not, as far as theory goes, end in failure, I am willing to explain how this institution is good and fitting, if you are both equally willing to listen; but otherwise I will leave it alone.

781d

Clinias: Why, Stranger, we are both inexpressibly eager to listen. Athenian: Let us listen, then. And do not be surprised if you find me taking up the subject again from an early point. For we are now enjoying leisure, and there is no pressing reason to keep us from considering laws from every possible point of view.

781e

Clinias: Very true. Athenian: Let us go back, then, to our first statements. Every man ought to understand this much at least: either the human race never had a beginning at all and will never have an end, but always was and always will be; or else it must have existed for an incalculable length of time since it first began.

782a

Clinias: Undoubtedly. Athenian: Well then, do we not suppose that all over the world and in all sorts of ways there have been risings and fallings of States, institutions of every variety of order and disorder, appetites for every kind of food and drink, and all sorts of variations in the seasons, during which the animals probably underwent countless changes?

782b

Clinias: Certainly. Athenian: Are we to believe, then, that vines, which did not exist before, appeared at a certain stage, and olives likewise, and the gifts of Demeter and Kore? And that some Triptolemus was the minister of such fruits? And during the period when these fruits did not yet exist, must we not suppose that the animals turned, as they do now, to eating one another? Clinias: Of course.

782c–782d

Athenian: In fact, the custom of human beings sacrificing one another survives even now among many peoples. Among others, by contrast, we hear that the opposite custom existed: they were forbidden even to eat an ox, and their offerings to the gods were not animals but cakes of meal and grain soaked in honey, and other such bloodless sacrifices. They abstained from meat as though it were unholy to eat it or to stain the altars of the gods with blood. Instead, those of us human beings who lived then lived what is called an Orphic life, keeping entirely to food without life and, on the other hand, abstaining entirely from living things.

782d

Clinias: What you say is certainly widely reported and easy to believe. Athenian: Someone might ask us: For what purpose have you just said all this? Clinias: A correct guess, Stranger. Athenian: So I will try, if I can, Clinias, to explain the subject that comes next. Clinias: Go on. Athenian: I observe that among human beings everything depends on a threefold need and desire; if they are guided rightly in these, the result is goodness, and if badly, the opposite. Of these desires, they have those for food and drink as soon as they are born. In the whole sphere of food every creature has an instinctive lust and is full of craving, and is quite deaf to any suggestion that it ought to do anything other than satisfy its tastes and desires for all such things, and so rid itself entirely of all pain.

783a–783c

Athenian: Third comes our greatest need and keenest lust, which, though the last to emerge, inflames human souls with the most raging frenzy: the lust for sowing offspring, which burns with the utmost violence. We must direct these three morbid states toward what is best, instead of toward what is called most pleasant, trying to check them by means of the three greatest forces—fear, law, and true reason—reinforced by the Muses and the Gods of Games, so as to quench by these means their growth and influx. So let us place the subject of producing children next after that of marriage, and after their production, their upbringing and education. If our discussion proceeds along these lines, each of our laws may perhaps be brought to completion. And when we come to the public meals, by approaching them at close range we shall probably see more clearly whether such associations should be for men only or for women as well. In this way we shall not only lay down the preliminaries that are still without legal regulation and place them as fences in front of the common meals, but also, as I said just now, we shall discuss the character of the common meals more exactly, and so be more likely to lay down laws for them that are suitable and fitting.

783c

Clinias: You are perfectly right. Athenian: Then let us keep in mind the things we mentioned a moment ago; for we will probably need them all soon. Clinias: What are the things you are telling us to remember? Athenian: The things we distinguished by the three terms we used. We spoke, you recall, of eating, second of drinking, and third of sexual excitement.

783d

Clinias: We shall certainly remember what you are now asking us to, Stranger. Athenian: Very good. Let us now come to the newly married, so as to instruct them how and in what way they ought to produce children, and, if we fail to persuade them, to threaten them with certain laws. Clinias: How? Athenian: The bride and groom must set their minds on producing for the State children of the greatest possible goodness and beauty. All people who are partners in any action produce fine and good results whenever they apply their minds to themselves and to the action, but the opposite results when they either have no minds or fail to apply them.

783e–784e

Athenian: So the groom shall pay attention both to the bride and to the work of procreation, and the bride shall do the same, especially during the period when they have no children yet. The women-inspectors whom we have chosen shall be in charge of them—more or fewer of them, according to the number and timing of their appointments as decided by the officials. They shall meet every day at the temple of Eileithyia for a third of an hour or more, and at their meetings they shall report to one another any case they may have noticed of any man or woman of procreative age who is attending to other things instead of to the rules laid down at the marriage sacrifices and ceremonies. The period of procreation and supervision shall be ten years and no longer, whenever there is an abundant issue of offspring. But if any couple remain childless to the end of this period, they shall consult together with their relatives and the women officials to decide on terms advantageous to both parties, and be divorced. If any dispute arises about what is fitting and advantageous for each party, they shall choose ten of the Law-wardens and abide by whatever regulations these permit or impose. The women-inspectors shall enter the houses of the young people and, partly by threats and partly by admonition, stop them from their wrongdoing and folly. If they cannot do so, they shall go and report the case to the Law-wardens, and the Law-wardens shall restrain them. If they too prove unable, they shall inform the public authority, posting up a sworn statement that they are truly unable to reform So-and-so. The man who is posted in this way, if he fails to defeat in the law courts those who posted him, shall suffer the following disqualifications: he shall not attend any wedding or children’s birthday celebrations, and if he does, anyone who wishes may punish him with blows without penalty. The same law shall apply to women: if a woman has been similarly posted as disorderly and has lost her case, she shall have no part in women’s outings, honors, or invitations to weddings or birthday celebrations. And when they have finished producing children according to the laws, if the man has sexual intercourse with another woman, or the woman with another man, while the latter are still within the procreative age, they shall be liable to the same penalty as was stated for those still producing children.

784e–785b

Athenian: After that, the man and woman who are self-controlled in these matters shall be held in good repute in every way, but the opposite kind of esteem—or rather disesteem—shall be shown to persons of the opposite character. Sexual conduct shall be left unmentioned and unregulated by law when most people behave with due propriety in it; but if they are disorderly, then the rules prescribed in this way shall be enforced according to the laws then enacted. For everyone the first year is the beginning of his whole life, and it ought to be recorded as life’s beginning for both boy and girl in their ancestral shrines. Beside it, on a whitewashed wall in every phratry, there should be written the number of the archons who give their number to the years; and the names of the living members of the phratry shall always be written close together, and those of the deceased shall be erased. The limit of the marriage age shall be from sixteen to twenty years—the longest time allowed—for a girl, and from thirty to thirty-five for a boy. The age limit for official posts shall be forty for a woman and thirty for a man. For military service the age limit shall be from twenty up to sixty years for a man. For women, they shall prescribe whatever is possible and fitting in each case, after they have finished bearing children and up to the age of fifty, in whatever kind of military work it is thought right to employ their services.

Book 7

Intertextual Commentary on Laws, Book 6

0 commentaries

No commentary on this book yet.

Glossary

Search the Library