Go to Related Reading
About this book

The Origins of Government

Athenian
A stranger from Athens
Clinias
A Cretan from Knossos
Megillus
A Spartan

Athenian

676a That’s enough on that subject, then! Now, what are we to say about the origin of government? Wouldn’t the best and easiest way to discern it be from this standpoint?

Clinias

What standpoint?

Athenian

The one from which we should always observe the progress of states as they move toward either goodness or badness.

Clinias

What standpoint is that?

Athenian

676a–676b Observing, I suppose, an infinitely long period of time and the changes that occur within it.

Clinias

676b Explain what you mean.

Athenian

Tell me: do you think you could ever determine how much time has passed since cities came into existence and people began living under civic government?

Clinias

It certainly would be no easy task.

Athenian

But you can easily see that it is vast and immeasurable?

Clinias

That I most certainly can.

Athenian

676b–676c During this time, haven’t thousands upon thousands of states come into existence, and, by a similar reckoning, just as many perished? And hasn’t each of them exhibited every kind of constitution over and over again? And haven’t they changed at one time from small to great, at another from great to small, and also from good to bad and from bad to good?

Clinias

676c Necessarily.

Athenian

Let us discover, if we can, the cause of this process of change; for this might perhaps show us what the primary origin of constitutions is, as well as how they are transformed.

Clinias

You are right; and we must all make an effort—you to explain your view about them, and we to keep pace with you.

Athenian

677a Do you think there is any truth in the ancient stories?

Clinias

What stories?

Life After the Flood

Athenian

That the human world has often been destroyed by floods, plagues, and many other things, in such a way that only a small part of the human race survived.

Clinias

Everyone would consider such accounts perfectly believable.

Athenian

Come, then, let us picture to ourselves one of the many catastrophes—namely, the one that once occurred through the Flood.

Clinias

677a–677b And what are we to suppose about it?

Athenian

677b That the people who escaped destruction at that time must have been mostly herdsmen of the hills, small embers of the human race preserved somewhere on the mountaintops.

Clinias

Evidently.

Athenian

677b–677c Moreover, people of this kind must necessarily have been unskilled in the arts generally, and especially in the schemes that people in cities use against one another for purposes of greed and rivalry and all the other villainies they devise against one another.

Clinias

677c That is certainly probable.

Athenian

Shall we assume that the cities located in the plains and near the sea were totally destroyed at that time?

Clinias

Let us assume it.

Athenian

677c–677d And shall we say that all tools were lost, and that every important art or invention they may have had—whether concerned with politics or with other branches of knowledge—perished at that time? For if things had remained ordered all that time just as they are now, how, my good sir, could anything new ever have been invented?

Clinias

677d Do you mean that these things were unknown to the people of those days for thousands upon thousands of years, and that one or two thousand years ago some of them were revealed to Daedalus, some to Orpheus, some to Palamedes, the musical arts to Marsyas and Olympus, the art of the lyre to Amphion, and, in short, a vast number of others to other people—all dating, so to speak, from yesterday or the day before?

Athenian

Do you realize, Clinias, that you have left out your friend, who was literally a man of yesterday?

Clinias

Is it Epimenides you mean?

Athenian

677d–677e Yes, I mean him. For he far outstripped everyone you had, my friend, with that invention of his, which he actually produced, as you Cretans say, although Hesiod had foretold it and spoken of it long before.

Clinias

677e We do say so.

Athenian

677e–678a Shall we, then, say that at the time when the destruction took place, human affairs stood like this: there was a vast and terrible desolation, with an enormous abundance of land available; most of the animals had been destroyed, and the few herds of cattle and flocks of goats that happened to survive provided their herdsmen at first with only scanty sustenance?

Clinias

678a Yes.

Athenian

And as for the matters our present discussion is concerned with—states, statecraft, and legislation—do we think that those people could have kept any memory of such things at all, broadly speaking?

Clinias

Not at all.

Athenian

So from those people, in that situation, our whole present order has sprung—states and constitutions, arts and laws, with a great deal of evil and a great deal of good as well?

Clinias

678a–678b How do you mean?

Athenian

678b Do we imagine, my good sir, that the people of that age, who were inexperienced in many of the fine ways of city life and in many of the opposite kind as well, were fully developed in either virtue or vice?

Clinias

Well said! We grasp your meaning.

Athenian

As time went on and our race multiplied, everything advanced—didn’t it?—to the condition that exists now.

Clinias

Very true.

Athenian

678b–678c But in all probability they did not advance all at once, but little by little, over an immense span of time.

Clinias

678c Yes, that is most likely.

Athenian

For all of them, I imagine, had a dread of going down from the highlands to the plains still ringing in their ears, so to speak.

Clinias

Of course.

Athenian

678c–678d And because there were so few of them around in those days, weren’t they delighted to see one another? Yet the means of travel by which they might have visited one another by sea or by land had practically all perished along with the arts. So, I imagine, it was not very easy for them to meet. For iron and bronze and all the metals in the mines had been flooded over and had disappeared, so that it was extremely difficult to extract fresh metal; and as a result there was a shortage of felled timber. For even if a few tools happened still to be left somewhere in the mountains, these were soon worn out, and they could not be replaced by others until people had rediscovered the art of metalworking.

Clinias

678d They could not.

Athenian

678d–678e Now, how many generations do we suppose passed before this happened?

Clinias

678e A great many, evidently.

Athenian

And during all this period, or even longer, all the arts that require iron and bronze and all such metals must have remained in abeyance?

Clinias

Of course.

Athenian

Moreover, civil strife and war also disappeared during that time, and for many reasons.

Clinias

How so?

Athenian

678e–679d First, because of their desolate state, they were kindly disposed and friendly toward one another; and second, they had no need to fight over food. For there was no shortage of flocks and herds—except perhaps for some of them at the outset, and in that age these were what people mostly lived on. So they were well supplied with milk and meat, and they obtained further supplies of food, both excellent and plentiful, by hunting. They were also well furnished with clothing, bedding, and houses, and with vessels both for cooking and for other uses; for the arts of molding and weaving require no iron, and God gave these two arts to human beings to supply them with all these necessities, so that the human race might have the means to sprout and increase whenever it fell into such a state of distress. Consequently, they were not excessively poor, nor were they driven by the pressure of poverty to quarrel with one another; and on the other hand, since they had no gold or silver, as was their condition at that time, they could never have become rich. Now a community that has no share in either poverty or wealth is generally the one in which the noblest characters are formed; for in it there is no room for the growth of insolence and injustice, of rivalries and jealousies. So these people were good, both for these reasons and because of their simple-mindedness, as it is called; for, being simple-minded, when they heard things called bad or good, they took what was said as gospel truth and believed it. None of them had the shrewdness of people today to suspect a falsehood; instead, they accepted as true what was said about gods and human beings, and ordered their lives by it. So they were entirely of the character we have just described.

Clinias

679d Megillus and I certainly agree completely with what you say.

Athenian

679d–679e And shall we not say that people who lived in this way for many generations were bound to be unskilled compared with either those who lived before the Flood or the people of today, and ignorant of arts in general, and especially of the arts of war as they are now practiced on land and sea—including those warlike arts peculiar to cities, which go by the names of lawsuits and factions and are contrived with every device of word and deed to inflict hurt and injury on one another—and that they were also simpler, braver, more self-controlled, and in every way more just? And we have already explained the cause of this state of affairs.

Clinias

679e Quite true.

Athenian

679e–680a We must keep in mind that the whole purpose of what we have said and what we are going to say next is this: to understand what possible need of laws the people of that time had, and who their lawgiver was.

Clinias

680a Excellent.

Households, Custom, and Early Rule

Athenian

Shall we suppose that those people had no need of lawgivers, and that in those days it was not yet usual to have such a thing? For those born in that period of the world’s history did not yet have the art of writing, but lived by following custom and what is called patriarchal law.

Clinias

That is certainly probable.

Athenian

But this already amounts to a kind of government.

Clinias

680a–680b What kind?

Athenian

680b–680c Everyone, I believe, gives the name of headship to the government that existed then—and it still exists today in many places among both Greeks and barbarians. And of course Homer mentions its existence in connection with the household system of the Cyclopes, where he says: “They have no halls of council and no laws, / But in hollow caves on mountain heights / They live up high, each making his own law / For wife and child; they care nothing for others.” Hom. Od. 9.112

Clinias

680c This poet of yours seems to have been a man of genius. We have also read other verses of his, and they were extremely fine; though in truth we have not read much of him, since we Cretans do not go in much for foreign poetry.

Megillus

680c–680d But we Spartans do, and we regard Homer as the best of such poets; all the same, the way of life he describes is always Ionian rather than Laconian. And now he seems to be confirming your statement admirably, when in his legendary account he attributes the primitive habits of the Cyclopes to their savagery.

Athenian

680d Yes, his testimony supports us; so let us take him as evidence that polities of this sort do sometimes come into existence.

Clinias

Quite right.

Athenian

680d–680e Didn’t they originate among those people who lived scattered in separate clans or single households because of the distress that followed the catastrophes? Among these the eldest rules, because rule comes down to them from their parents; following them, they form a single flock, like a covey of birds, and live under a patriarchal government and a kingship that is the most just of all kingships.

Clinias

680e Most certainly.

Athenian

680e–681a Next, they gather together in greater numbers and form larger communities; and first they turn to farming on the hillsides, and build ring-fences of rubble and walls to keep off wild beasts, until finally they have constructed a single large common dwelling.

Clinias

681a It is certainly probable that this was the course of events.

Athenian

Well, isn’t this also probable?

Clinias

What?

Athenian

681a–681b That, while these larger settlements were growing out of the original small ones, each of the small settlements kept, clan by clan, both the rule of the eldest and also certain customs of its own that came from its isolation. Since those who fathered and raised them were different, these customs of theirs, relating to the gods and to themselves, also differed: they were more orderly where their ancestors had been orderly, and braver where they had been brave. And as the fathers of each clan in due course stamped their own cast of mind on their children and their children’s children, these people came—as we say—into the larger community, each group equipped with its own particular laws.

Clinias

681b–681c Of course.

Athenian

681c And no doubt each clan was well pleased with its own laws, and less pleased with those of its neighbors.

Clinias

True.

Athenian

Without realizing it, it seems, we have now set foot, as it were, on the starting point of legislation.

Clinias

We have indeed.

Athenian

681c–681d The next necessary step is for these people to come together and choose some members of each clan who, after surveying the legal customs of all the clans, shall publicly inform the tribal leaders and chiefs—who may be called their kings—which of those customs they like best, and shall recommend that they be adopted. These men will themselves be called legislators; and when they have appointed the chiefs as magistrates and have formed an aristocracy, or possibly even a monarchy, out of the existing plurality of headships, they will live under the constitution thus transformed.

Clinias

681d The next steps would certainly be as you describe.

The Founding of Troy

Athenian

681d–681e Let us go on to describe the rise of a third form of constitution, in which all kinds and varieties of constitutions, and of states as well, are blended.

Clinias

681e What form is that?

Athenian

The one Homer himself mentioned after the second, when he said that the third form arose in this way. His verses go like this: “He founded Dardania when / The holy citadel of Ilium was not yet built / Upon the plain, a town for mortal people, / But they still lived on the highland slopes / Of Ida with its many springs.” Hom. Il. 20.216 ff.

Athenian

682a Indeed, these verses of his, as well as the ones he speaks about the Cyclopes, are in a kind of harmony with the voices of both God and Nature. For the poetic tribe, being divinely inspired in its chanting, often grasps the truth of history with the help of the Graces and the Muses.

Clinias

It certainly does.

Athenian

682a–682b Now let us go still further in the tale that now occupies us; for it may possibly give some hint about the matter we have in view. Shouldn’t we do so?

Clinias

682b Most certainly.

Athenian

Ilium, we say, was founded after people moved down from the highlands to a large and beautiful plain, on a hill of no great height that had many rivers flowing down to it from Ida above.

Clinias

So they say.

Athenian

And don’t we suppose that this happened many ages after the Flood?

Clinias

Many ages after, no doubt.

Athenian

682b–682c At any rate, they seem to have been strangely forgetful of the catastrophe we just mentioned, since they placed their city, as described, beneath a number of rivers descending from the mountain, and relied for their safety on hills of no great height.

Clinias

682c So it is evident that they were separated from that calamity by a very long interval.

Athenian

By this time, too, as humankind multiplied, many other cities had been founded.

Clinias

Of course.

Athenian

And these cities also attacked Ilium, probably by sea as well as by land, since by this time everyone used the sea without fear.

Clinias

682c–682d So it appears.

Athenian

682d And after staying ten years, the Achaeans sacked Troy.

Clinias

Very true.

The Dorian Settlements

Athenian

682d–682e Now during this ten-year period, while the siege lasted, the affairs of each of the besiegers at home suffered greatly because of the seditious conduct of the young men. For when the soldiers returned to their own cities and homes, these young people did not receive them properly and justly, but in such a way that a vast number of deaths, massacres, and banishments followed. So the soldiers, driven out once more, returned under a new name: because Dorieus was the man who then gathered the exiles together, they were called Dorians instead of Achaeans. But as for all the events that follow from there, you Lacedaemonians relate them all fully in your traditions.

Megillus

682e Quite true.

Athenian

682e–683b And now—as if by divine guidance—we have come back once more to the very point in our discussion of laws where we made our digression, when we plunged into the subject of music and drinking parties; and we can, so to speak, get a fresh grip on the argument, now that it has reached this point—the settlement of Lacedaemon, which you rightly said was settled, like Crete, under kindred laws. From the wandering course of our argument and our excursion through various polities and settlements, we have gained this much: we have observed a first, a second, and a third state, all, as we suppose, succeeding one another in settlements that took place over vast ages of time. And now there has emerged this fourth state—or nation, if you prefer—which was once in the process of being established and is now established. Now, if from all this we can gather which of these settlements was right and which wrong, which laws keep safe what is kept safe and which laws ruin what is ruined, and what changes in what particulars would bring about the happiness of the state, then, Megillus and Clinias, we ought to describe these things again, making a fresh start from the beginning—unless we have some fault to find with what we have already said.

Megillus

683b–683c I can assure you, Stranger, that if some god were to promise us that, in making this second attempt to investigate legislation, we would hear a discussion no worse and no shorter than the one we have just been listening to, I for one would go a long way to hear it; in fact, today would seem quite a short day to me, even though it is actually close to the summer solstice.

Athenian

683c So it seems we must go on with our inquiry.

Megillus

Most certainly.

Athenian

683c–683d Then let us place ourselves in imagination at the time when Lacedaemon, together with Argos and Messene and the neighboring districts, had come completely under the control, Megillus, of your ancestors. Next, according to the tradition, they decided to divide their army into three parts and to establish three states—Argos, Messene, and Lacedaemon.

Megillus

683d Very true.

Athenian

And Temenus became king of Argos, Cresphontes of Messene, and Procles and Eurysthenes of Lacedaemon.

Megillus

Of course.

Athenian

683d–683e And all the people of that time swore that they would help these kings if anyone tried to wreck their kingdoms.

Megillus

683e Quite so.

Athenian

In the name of Zeus, is the dissolution of a kingdom, or of any government that has ever been dissolved, caused by anyone other than the rulers themselves? Or, though we asserted this a moment ago when we happened upon this subject, have we now forgotten it?

Megillus

How could we possibly have forgotten?

Athenian

683e–684b Shall we, then, confirm that assertion further now? For it seems we have come to the same view now while dealing with historical facts, so that we will be examining it not in reference to a mere abstraction, but to real events. Now what actually happened was this: each of the three royal houses and the cities under their rule swore to one another, according to the laws they had made, which were binding alike on ruler and subject. The rulers swore that, as time went on and the nation advanced, they would not make their rule more oppressive; and the subjects swore that, as long as the rulers kept their promise, they would never overthrow the monarchy themselves, nor allow others to do so. And they swore that the kings would aid both kings and peoples when they were wronged, and the peoples would aid both peoples and kings. Wasn’t that how it was?

Megillus

684b It was.

Athenian

In the polities legally established in the three states—whether by the kings or by others—wasn’t this the most important principle?

Megillus

What principle?

Athenian

That the other two states should always come to help against the third, whenever it disobeyed the laws laid down.

Megillus

Evidently.

Athenian

684b–684c And surely most people insist on this: that lawgivers shall enact laws of a kind that the mass of the people will accept willingly—just as one might insist that trainers or doctors make their treatments and cures of people’s bodies pleasant.

Megillus

684c Exactly so.

Athenian

But in fact one often has to be content if one can bring a body into a sound and healthy state without a great deal of pain.

Megillus

684c–684d Very true.

Athenian

684d The people of that age also had another advantage that did a great deal to make legislation easier.

Megillus

What was that?

Athenian

684d–684e In their efforts to establish equality of property, their legislators were free from the worst of accusations, the one commonly incurred in states with laws of a different kind whenever someone tries to disturb the ownership of land or proposes canceling debts, because he sees that without these measures equality could never be fully secured. In such cases, if the lawgiver attempts to disturb any of these things, everyone confronts him with the cry “Hands off,” and they curse him for introducing redistributions of land and cancellations of debts, with the result that every man is left helpless. But the Dorians had this further advantage: they were free of all fear of causing resentment, so they could divide up their land without dispute; and they had no large debts of long standing.

Megillus

684e True.

Athenian

Then how was it, my good sirs, that their settlement and legislation turned out so badly?

Megillus

685a What do you mean? What fault do you find with it?

The Failure of Argos and Messene

Athenian

This: although three states were settled, two of the three quickly wrecked their constitutions and their laws, and only one remained stable—and that was your state, Megillus.

Megillus

That is no easy question.

Athenian

685a–685b Yet surely, in considering and investigating this subject—indulging in an old man’s sober play with laws—we ought to proceed on our journey painlessly, as we said when we first set out.

Megillus

685b Certainly, we must do as you say.

Athenian

Well, what laws would offer a better subject for investigation than the laws by which those states were governed? Or what larger or more famous states are there whose settlement we might inquire into?

Megillus

It would be hard to name better examples than these.

Athenian

685b–685e It is fairly clear that the people of that age intended this organization of theirs to serve as an adequate protection not only for the Peloponnese but for the whole of Hellas as well, in case any of the barbarians should attack them—just as those who formerly lived around Ilium were emboldened to undertake the Trojan War by relying on the power of Assyria as it had been in the reign of Ninus. For much of the splendor of that empire still survived, and the people of that age feared its united power, just as we today dread the Great King. Since Troy was part of the Assyrian empire, the second capture of Troy was a serious grievance against the Greeks. It was in view of all this that the Dorian army was at that time organized and distributed among three states under princes who were brothers, the sons of Heracles; and people thought the plan admirably devised, and the army’s equipment superior even to that of the army that had sailed to Troy. For people considered, first, that in the sons of Heracles they had better leaders than the Pelopidae, and further, that this army was superior in valor to the army that went to Troy, since the latter, which was Achaean, had been defeated by the former, which was Dorian. Must we not suppose that it was in this way, and with this intention, that the people of that age organized themselves?

Megillus

685e Certainly.

Athenian

685e–686a Isn’t it also probable that they would suppose this arrangement to be stable and likely to last quite a long time, since they had shared many hardships and dangers together, were marshaled under leaders of a single family—their princes being brothers, and had, moreover, consulted a number of diviners, including the Delphian Apollo?

Megillus

686a That is certainly probable.

Athenian

686a–686b But it seems that these great expectations quickly vanished, except, as we said, in the case of that small part, your state of Laconia; and ever since, down to the present day, this part has never stopped making war on the other two. For if the original intention had been carried out, and if they had been in agreement about their policy, it would have created a power invincible in war.

Megillus

686b It certainly would.

Athenian

How, then, and by what means was it destroyed? Isn’t it worthwhile to inquire what stroke of fortune wrecked so great a confederacy?

Megillus

686b–686c Yes; for if someone passed over these examples, he would not be likely to find elsewhere either laws or constitutions that preserve such fine and great interests or, on the other hand, wreck them completely.

Athenian

686c So by a piece of good luck, it seems, we have embarked on an inquiry of some importance.

Megillus

Undoubtedly.

Athenian

686c–686d Now, my dear sir, don’t people in general, just like us at this moment, unconsciously imagine that every fine thing they set eyes on would produce marvelous results if only someone knew the right way to make fine use of it? But for us to hold such an idea about the matter before us would possibly be both wrong and contrary to nature; and the same is true in all other cases where people hold such ideas.

Megillus

686d What do you mean? And what shall we say is the particular point of your remarks?

Athenian

686d–686e Why, my dear sir, I was just laughing at myself. For when I looked at this armament we are talking about, I thought it an amazingly fine thing, and that, if anyone had made fine use of it at that time, it would have proved, as I said, a wonderful asset to the Greeks.

Megillus

686e And wasn’t it quite right and sensible of you to say this, and of us to agree?

Athenian

Possibly. I imagine, however, that everyone who sees something large, powerful, and strong is immediately struck by the conviction that, if its owner knew how to use an instrument of that size and quality, he could make himself happy by many wonderful achievements.

Megillus

687a Isn’t that a correct conviction? Or what is your view?

Athenian

687a–687b Just consider what one ought to have in view in each case to justify giving such praise. First, with regard to the matter now under discussion: if the men who were then marshaling the army had known how to organize it properly, how would they have achieved success? Wouldn’t it have been by establishing it firmly and preserving it forever, so that they would be both free themselves and masters over all others they chose, and so that both they and their descendants could do, in general, whatever they pleased throughout the whole world of Greeks and barbarians alike? Aren’t these the reasons they would be praised?

Megillus

687b Certainly.

Athenian

And in every case where someone speaks in praise on seeing great wealth or eminent family distinctions or anything else of the kind, wouldn’t it be true to say that in doing so he has this fact particularly in mind: that the possessor of such things is likely, just because of them, to realize all, or at least the most and greatest, of his desires?

Megillus

687b–687c That is certainly probable.

Desire, Wisdom, and Good Government

Athenian

687c Come now, is there one object of desire common to all people—the one our argument now points to?

Megillus

What is that?

Athenian

The desire that, if possible, everything—or, failing that, all that is humanly possible—should happen in accordance with the commands of one’s own heart.

Megillus

To be sure.

Athenian

Since, then, this is what we all always wish, in childhood, adulthood, and old age alike, it is necessarily this that we would pray for continually.

Megillus

687c–687d Of course.

Athenian

687d Moreover, on behalf of our friends we will join them in making the same prayer that they make on their own behalf.

Megillus

To be sure.

Athenian

And a son is a friend to his father—the boy to the man.

Megillus

Certainly.

Athenian

Yet the father will often pray to the gods that the things the son prays to obtain may in no way be granted as the son prays.

Megillus

Do you mean when the son who is praying is still young and foolish?

Athenian

687d–687e Yes, and also when the father, whether through old age or through the hot temper of youth, has no sense of what is right and just and indulges in the vehement prayers of passion—like those of Theseus against Hippolytus, who met an unhappy end, while the son, on the other hand, has a sense of justice—in that case do you suppose the son will join in his father’s prayers?

Megillus

687e I grasp your meaning. You mean, I suppose, that what a person ought to pray and strive for is not that everything should follow his own desire while his desire in no way follows his own reason; rather, it is the winning of wisdom that every one of us, states and individuals alike, ought to pray for and strive after.

Athenian

688a–688d Yes. And what is more, I would remind you, as well as myself, of what was said—if you remember—at the outset: that the legislator of a state, in settling his legal ordinances, must always have regard to wisdom. Your instruction was that the good lawgiver must frame all his laws with a view to war. I, on the other hand, maintained that, whereas under your instruction the laws would be framed with reference to only one of the four virtues, it was really essential to look to the whole of virtue, and first and above all to pay regard to the leading virtue of the four, which is wisdom and reason and opinion, together with the love and desire that accompany them. Now the argument has come back again to the same point, and I now repeat what I said before—in jest, if you like, or else in earnest: I assert that prayer is a dangerous practice for someone who lacks reason, and that what he obtains is the opposite of what he desires. If you want to take me as speaking in earnest, then do so; for I fully expect that, as you follow the argument we set out a little while ago, you will now discover that the cause of the ruin of those kingdoms, and of their whole plan, was not cowardice or ignorance of warfare on the part of either the rulers or those who should have been their subjects; rather, what ruined them was badness of every other kind, and especially ignorance about the greatest of human concerns. That this was how events went then, and still go whenever such events occur, and will go in the same way in the future—this, with your permission, I will try to discover as the argument proceeds, and to make as clear as I can to you, my very good friends.

Clinias

688d Verbal compliments are in poor taste, Stranger; but in deed, if not in word, we will pay you the highest compliment by following your discussion eagerly; and that is what best shows whether compliments are freely given or not.

Megillus

688d–688e Excellent, Clinias! Let us do just as you say.

Clinias

688e So it shall be, God willing. Just go on.

Ignorance and Claims to Rule

Athenian

Well then, to advance further along the path of our discussion: we assert that it was ignorance, in its greatest form, that destroyed at that time the power we have described, and that it naturally still produces the same results; and if this is so, it follows that the lawgiver must try to implant as much wisdom in states as possible, and to root out folly as far as he can.

Clinias

Obviously.

Athenian

689a What kind of ignorance would deserve to be called the greatest? See whether you will agree with my description; I take it to be ignorance of this kind—

Clinias

What kind?

Athenian

689a–689c The kind we see in a person who hates, instead of loving, what he judges to be noble and good, while he loves and cherishes what he judges to be evil and unjust. This lack of harmony between the feelings of pain and pleasure and rational judgment is, I maintain, the extreme form of ignorance, and also the greatest, because it belongs to the main mass of the soul—for the part of the soul that feels pain and pleasure corresponds to the mass of the populace in the state. So whenever this part opposes what are by nature the ruling principles—knowledge, opinion, or reason—I call this condition folly, whether in a state, when the masses disobey the rulers and the laws, or in an individual, when the noble elements of reason present in the soul accomplish nothing good, but quite the opposite. All these I would count as the most discordant forms of ignorance, whether in the state or in the individual, and not the ignorance of the craftsman—if you grasp my meaning, Strangers.

Clinias

689c We do, my dear sir, and we agree with it.

Athenian

689c–689e Then let it be resolved and declared as follows: no authority shall be entrusted to citizens who are ignorant in this way, but they shall be reproached for their ignorance, even if they are expert calculators and trained in all accomplishments and in everything that fosters quickness of mind; while those whose mental condition is the opposite of this shall be called wise, even if—as the saying goes—they can neither read nor swim; and to these latter, as people of sense, the government shall be entrusted. For without harmony, my friends, how could even the smallest fraction of wisdom exist? It is impossible. But the greatest and finest of harmonies would most rightly be considered the greatest wisdom; and whoever lives by reason has a share in it, whereas whoever lacks it will always prove to be a wrecker of his household and anything but a savior of the state, because of his ignorance in these matters. So let this declaration stand, as we said just now, as one of our axioms.

Clinias

689e Yes, let it stand.

Athenian

Our states, I presume, must have rulers and subjects.

Clinias

Of course.

Athenian

690a Very well then: what are the acknowledged rights or claims to ruling and being ruled, and how many are there, in states large and small alike, and in households? Isn’t the right of father and mother one of them? And in general, wouldn’t the claim of parents to rule over their offspring be a claim that is just everywhere?

Clinias

Certainly.

Athenian

And next to this, the right of the noble to rule over the ignoble; and then, following these as a third claim, the right of older people to rule and of younger ones to be ruled.

Clinias

690a–690b To be sure.

Athenian

690b The fourth right is that slaves ought to be ruled and masters ought to rule.

Clinias

Undoubtedly.

Athenian

And the fifth, I imagine, is that the stronger should rule and the weaker be ruled.

Clinias

A truly compulsory form of rule!

Athenian

690b–690c Yes, and one that is very widespread among all kinds of creatures, being in accordance with nature, as Pindar of Thebes once said. The most important right, it seems, would be the sixth, which commands that the person without understanding should follow, and the wise person lead and rule. And yet, my most wise Pindar, this is something I for one would hardly call contrary to nature, but rather in accordance with it—the natural rule of law, without force, over willing subjects.

Clinias

690c A very just observation.

Athenian

Heaven’s favor and good luck mark the seventh form of rule, in which we bring a person forward for a drawing of lots and declare that, if he wins the lot, he will most justly be ruler, but if he fails, he shall take his place among the ruled.

Clinias

690c–690d Very true.

Athenian

690d–690e Do you see, legislator—this is how we might playfully address one of those who lightly set out on the task of legislation—how many rights belong to rulers, and how they are naturally opposed to one another? Here we have now discovered a source of factions, which you must remedy. So, first, join us in inquiring how it happened, and through what violation of those rights, that the kings of Argos and Messene brought ruin both on themselves and on the power of Hellas, splendid as it was at that time. Wasn’t it through ignorance of Hesiod’s very true saying that often the half is greater than the whole? For whenever taking the whole is harmful while the half is the due measure, he considered the due measure to be more than the excess, as the better is more than the worse.

Clinias

690e Most true, indeed.

Athenian

Is it our view, then, that this causes ruin when it occurs in kings, rather than when it occurs in peoples?

Clinias

691a Probably this is, for the most part, a disease of kings, in whom luxury breeds an arrogant way of life.

Athenian

Isn’t it plain that what those kings strove for first was to get the better of the established laws, and that they were not in harmony with one another about the pledge they had approved both by word and by oath? And this discord—reputed to be wisdom, but really, as we affirm, the height of ignorance—through its grating dissonance and lack of harmony brought the whole Greek world to ruin.

Clinias

691a–691b It certainly seems so.

Limits on Royal Power

Athenian

691b Very well then: what precaution should the legislator have taken in his enactments at that time to guard against the growth of this disorder? In the name of the gods, to see that now requires no great wisdom, nor is it hard to state; but the person who foresaw it in those days—if it could possibly have been foreseen—would have been wiser than we are.

Megillus

What are you referring to?

Athenian

If one looks at what has happened among you Lacedaemonians, Megillus, it is easy to see, and having seen it, to state, what ought to have been done at that time.

Megillus

Speak even more clearly.

Athenian

The clearest statement would be this—

Megillus

691b–691c What?

Athenian

691c–691d If one neglects the rule of due measure and gives too much power to things too small to bear it—sails to ships, food to bodies, offices of rule to souls—then everything is overturned; and, through excess of insolence, some run into bodily disorders, others into that offspring of insolence, injustice. What, then, is our conclusion? Isn’t it this? There does not exist, my friends, a mortal soul whose nature, when young and unaccountable, will ever be able to bear holding the highest ruling position on earth without having its mind filled with that greatest of disorders, folly, and earning the hatred of its nearest friends; and when this happens, it quickly ruins the soul itself and wipes out all its power. To guard against this, by recognizing the due measure, is the task of the great lawgiver. So the most reasonable conjecture we can now make about what happened at that time seems to be this—

Megillus

691d What?

Athenian

691d–692c To begin with, there was a god watching over you; and he, foreseeing the future, confined the royal power within due bounds by making your line of kings twofold instead of single. Next, a man in whom human nature was blended with a certain divine power, seeing that your government was still swollen with fever, blended the self-willed strength of the royal stock with the moderating power of age, by giving the power of the twenty-eight elders equal weight with that of the kings in the most important matters. Then your third savior, seeing your government still fretting and fuming, curbed it, so to speak, with the power of the ephors, which came close to government by lot. So in your case, according to this account, because the kingship was blended of the right elements and possessed due measure, it not only survived itself but ensured the survival of everything else. For if the matter had been left to Temenus and Cresphontes and the lawgivers of their day—whoever those lawgivers really were—not even the portion of Aristodemus could ever have survived; for they were not fully expert in the art of legislation. Otherwise they could hardly have thought it enough to restrain by sworn pledges a young soul endowed with power that might grow into a tyranny. But now God has shown what kind of government there ought to have been then, and ought to be now, if it is to endure. For us to understand this after the event is, as I said before, no great sign of wisdom, since it is not at all difficult to draw an inference from a past example. But if at the time there had been someone who foresaw the result and was able to moderate the ruling powers and make one out of the three, he would have preserved all the grand designs formed then, and no Persian or other armament would ever have set out against Greece or held us in contempt as a people of little account.

Clinias

692c–692d True.

Athenian

692d–692e The way they drove off the Persians, Clinias, was disgraceful. But when I say disgraceful, I do not mean that they did not win fine victories on both land and sea in those victorious campaigns. What I call disgraceful is this: first, only one of those three states defended Greece, while the other two were so basely corrupt that one of them actually prevented Lacedaemon from helping Greece by making war on her with all its might, and the other, Argos—which ranked first of the three in the days of the Dorian settlement—when called on to help against the barbarian, paid no attention and gave no help. One would have to bring many discreditable charges against Greece in relating the events of that war; 692e–693c Indeed, it would be wrong to say that Greece defended herself. For if the slavery that threatened her had not been fended off by the joint policy of the Athenians and Lacedaemonians, practically all the Greek peoples would by now have been mixed up together, barbarians with Greeks and Greeks with barbarians—just as the peoples under the Persian empire today are either scattered or jumbled together and live in a miserable condition. These, Megillus and Clinias, are the charges we have to bring against the so-called statesmen and lawgivers, both of the past and of the present, so that, by investigating their causes, we may discover what different course should have been followed. So in the case before us, we called it a blunder to establish by law a government that is great or unblended, because our idea is that a state ought to be free and wise and at friendship with itself, and that the lawgiver should legislate with this in view. Nor should it surprise us that, although we have often already proposed aims at which, as we say, the legislator should aim in his legislation, the various aims thus proposed seem to differ. One needs to reflect that when self-control, or wisdom, or friendship is stated to be the aim in view, these are not really different aims but the same one; and if we meet with many other such terms, we should not let this disturb us.

Clinias

693c–693d We will try to keep this in mind as we go back over the arguments. But for now, regarding friendship, wisdom, and freedom—tell us what you meant to say the lawgiver ought to aim at.

Monarchy and Democracy

Athenian

693d–693e Listen, then. There are two mother forms of constitution, so to speak, from which one may truly say all the rest are derived. One of these is properly called monarchy, the other democracy; the extreme form of the former is the Persian polity, and of the latter the Athenian. Practically all the rest, as I said, are variations of these two. Now a polity must share in both of these forms if it is to have freedom and friendliness combined with wisdom. And that is what our argument means to require when it declares that a state that has no share in these can never be rightly constituted.

Clinias

693e It could not.

Athenian

693e–694a Since the one embraced monarchy and the other freedom, unmixed and in excess, neither has either in due measure. Your Laconian and Cretan states are better in this respect, as the Athenian and Persian states were in old times—in contrast to their present condition. Shall we set out the reasons for this?

Clinias

694a By all means—that is, if we mean to complete the task we have set ourselves.

Persian Kingship and Education

Athenian

694a–694b Let us listen, then. When the Persians under Cyrus kept the right balance between slavery and freedom, they first became free themselves and then masters of many others. For when the rulers gave their subjects a share of freedom and raised them to a position of equality, the soldiers were friendlier toward their commanders and showed their devotion in times of danger. And if there was any wise man among them able to give counsel, then, since the king was not jealous but allowed free speech and honored those who could help at all with their counsel, such a man had the opportunity to contribute the fruit of his wisdom to the common store. So at that time all their affairs made progress, thanks to their freedom, friendliness, and mutual sharing of reason.

Clinias

694b–694c That is probably more or less how the matters you speak of took place.

Athenian

694c How did it happen, then, that they were ruined in the reign of Cambyses and nearly restored again under Darius? Shall I use a kind of divination to picture this?

Clinias

Yes; that will certainly help us get a view of what we are looking for.

Athenian

What I now divine about Cyrus is this: although in other respects he was a good and patriotic commander, he had no proper education at all and had paid no attention to managing his household.

Clinias

694c–694d What makes us say this?

Athenian

694d He probably spent his whole life from boyhood on campaign and left his children to the women to raise. And they brought them up from earliest childhood as though they had already attained Heaven’s favor and happiness and lacked no heavenly gift; and so, by treating them as the special favorites of Heaven, forbidding anyone to oppose them in anything, and compelling everyone to praise their every word and deed, they raised them to be what they became.

Clinias

694d–694e A fine upbringing, I would say!

Athenian

694e Say rather a feminine upbringing by royal women who had recently grown rich, who raised the children while the men were away, kept busy by many dangers and wars.

Clinias

That sounds reasonable.

Athenian

694e–695b And their father, while acquiring flocks and sheep and plenty of herds, both of men and of many other possessions, did not know that the children to whom he was going to leave them were not being trained in their father’s craft. This craft was Persian—for the Persians were shepherds, offspring of a rugged land—and it was a hard one, fit to produce shepherds of great strength, able to camp in the open, to keep watch without sleep, and, if need be, to go on campaign. He overlooked the fact that his sons were trained by women and eunuchs in the Median fashion, and that the indulgence shown them as Heaven’s darlings had ruined their training; as a result they became just what one would expect of those raised in an upbringing that spared the rod. So when, at the death of Cyrus, his sons took over the kingdom, overindulged and undisciplined as they were, first one of them killed the other, out of resentment at being put on an equal footing with him; and soon afterward, maddened by drink and lack of education, he lost his own throne at the hands of the Medes, under the man then called the Eunuch, who despised the stupidity of Cambyses.

Clinias

695b–695c That is certainly the story, and it is probably close to the truth.

Athenian

695c Further, the story says that the kingdom was restored to the Persians through Darius and the Seven.

Clinias

It does.

Athenian

695c–695e Let us follow the story and see how things went. Darius was not a king’s son, nor had he been raised in luxury. When he came and seized the kingdom with his six companions, he divided it into seven parts, of which some small traces still remain today. He saw fit to govern it by enacting laws into which he introduced a measure of political equality, and he also incorporated into the law regulations about the tribute money that Cyrus had promised the Persians. In this way he secured friendliness and fellowship among all classes of Persians and won over the common people with money and gifts; and because of this, the devotion of his armies won him as much additional land as Cyrus had originally left behind. After Darius came Xerxes, who was again brought up with the luxurious upbringing of a royal house. Darius—for this is how one may rightly address the father—how is it that you ignored the blunder of Cyrus and raised Xerxes in just the same habits of life in which Cyrus raised Cambyses? And Xerxes, being the product of the same training, ended by repeating almost exactly the misfortunes of Cambyses. Since then there has hardly ever been a single Persian king who was truly, and not just in name, Great.

Athenian

695e–696b And, as our argument asserts, the cause of this does not lie in luck, but in the evil life that is usually lived by the sons of exceptionally rich men and of tyrants; for such an upbringing can never produce a boy or a man or a gray-haired elder of outstanding goodness. To this, we say, the lawgiver must pay attention—as must we ourselves on the present occasion. It is proper, however, my Lacedaemonian friends, to give your state credit for at least this: you assign no different honor or training whatever to poverty or wealth, to the commoner or the king, beyond what your original oracle declared at the command of some god. Nor indeed is it right that preeminent honors in a state should be given to someone because he is especially wealthy, any more than it is right to give them because he is swift or handsome or strong without any virtue, or with a virtue that lacks self-control.

Megillus

696b What do you mean by that, Stranger?

Athenian

Courage is, presumably, one part of virtue.

Megillus

Certainly.

Athenian

696b–696c Now that you have heard the argument, judge for yourself whether you would welcome as a housemate or neighbor a man who is extremely courageous but unrestrained rather than self-controlled.

Megillus

696c Don’t even suggest such a thing!

Athenian

Well then, a man who is wise in arts and crafts, but unjust?

Megillus

Certainly not.

Athenian

But justice, surely, does not grow apart from self-control.

Megillus

Impossible.

Athenian

Nor does the man we just put forward as our model of wisdom—the man whose feelings of pleasure and pain are in harmony with the dictates of right reason and obey them.

Megillus

696c–696d No, indeed.

The Proper Order of Honors

Athenian

696d Here is a further point we must consider in order to judge about the awarding of honors in states—when it is right and when it is wrong.

Megillus

What point?

Athenian

If self-control existed alone in a person’s soul, separated from all the rest of virtue, would it justly be held in honor, or the opposite?

Megillus

I cannot tell what answer to give.

Athenian

Yet in fact you have given an answer, and a reasonable one. For if you had declared for either of the alternatives in my question, you would, in my view, have said something quite out of tune.

Megillus

So it has turned out all right.

Athenian

696d–696e Very good. Accordingly, the additional element in things deserving honor or dishonor will be something that calls not for speech so much as for a kind of speechless silence.

Megillus

696e I suppose you mean self-control.

Athenian

Yes. And of the rest, the one that, with self-control added, benefits us most would most deserve to be held in the highest honor, and the one second in benefit should be second in honor; and so with each of the others in turn—it will be proper to assign to each the honor due to its rank.

Megillus

697a Just so.

Athenian

Well then, shall we not declare that distributing these things is the lawgiver’s task?

Megillus

Certainly.

Athenian

Would you like us to hand the whole distribution over to him, to deal with every case and all the details, while we—since we too are enthusiasts for law—confine ourselves to a threefold division and try to distinguish what comes first in importance, and what second and third?

Megillus

By all means.

Athenian

697a–697c We declare, then, that a state that is to endure and to be as happy as it is possible for human beings to be must of necessity distribute honors and dishonors rightly. And the right way is this: it shall be laid down that the goods of the soul are highest in honor and come first, provided that the soul possesses self-control; second come the good and fine things of the body; and third the so-called goods of substance and property. And if any lawgiver or state violates these rules, either by promoting wealth to honors or by raising one of the lower goods to a higher rank through honors, he will be guilty of an offense against both religion and statesmanship. Shall this be our declaration, or what?

Megillus

697c By all means let us declare this plainly.

Athenian

697c–697e It was our investigation of the Persian polity that led us to discuss these matters at greater length. We find that they grew still worse; and the reason, we say, is that by robbing the common people of too much of their liberty and introducing despotism to excess, they destroyed the bonds of friendliness and fellowship in the state. And when these are destroyed, the policy of the rulers no longer looks to the good of the subjects and the common people, but only to the maintenance of their own power. If they think it will profit them in the slightest degree, they are ready at any time to overturn cities and to overturn and burn up friendly nations; and so they both hate and are hated with a fierce and ruthless hatred. And when they come to need the common people to fight on their behalf, they find in them no patriotism and no readiness to risk their lives in battle. So although they have countless tens of thousands of men, all of them are useless for war, and they hire soldiers from abroad as though they were short of men, and imagine that their safety will be secured by hirelings and foreigners.

Athenian

697e–698a And besides all this, they inevitably display their ignorance, since by their actions they declare that the things considered honorable and noble in a state are never anything but worthless trash compared with silver and gold.

Megillus

698a Very true.

Athenian

So let this be the end of our account of the Persian empire, and of how its present bad administration is due to an excess of slavery and despotism.

Megillus

By all means.

Athens, Freedom, and the Persian Wars

Athenian

698a–698e Next we ought to examine the Attic constitution in the same way, and show how complete liberty, unrestrained by any authority, is far inferior to a moderate form of government under other magistrates. At the time when the Persians made their assault on the Greeks—and indeed, one might say, on nearly all the nations of Europe—we Athenians had an ancient constitution and magistracies based on a fourfold grading by property; and we had Reverence, which acted as a kind of queen, causing us to live as willing slaves of the laws then in force. Moreover, the vastness of the Persian armament that threatened us by both sea and land, through the desperate fear it inspired, bound us still more tightly in the bonds of slavery to our rulers and our laws; and because of all this, our friendliness toward one another and our patriotism were greatly strengthened. It was just about ten years before the sea battle at Salamis that the Persian force arrived under Datis, whom Darius had sent expressly against the Athenians and Eretrians, with orders to bring them back in chains, and with the warning that death would be the penalty if he failed. So within a very short time Datis, with his many tens of thousands, captured the entire Eretrian population by force; and he sent an alarming report on to Athens that not a single Eretrian had escaped him: the soldiers of Datis had joined hands and swept the whole of Eretria clean, as if with a dragnet. This report—whether true, or whatever its origin—struck terror into the Greeks in general, and especially the Athenians; but when they sent out embassies in every direction to seek help, everyone refused except the Lacedaemonians. And they were held back by the war they were then waging against Messene, and possibly by other obstacles we have no information about, with the result that they arrived one day too late for the battle that took place at Marathon. After this, endless threats and reports of huge preparations kept arriving from the Persian king.

Athenian

698e–699d Then, as time went on, news came that Darius was dead, and that his son, who had succeeded to the throne, was young and hotheaded and still determined on the planned expedition. The Athenians imagined that all these preparations were aimed at them because of what had happened at Marathon; and when they heard how a canal had been dug through Athos and a bridge thrown across the Hellespont, and were told of the vast number of ships in the Persian fleet, they felt that there was no salvation for them by land, nor yet by sea. By land, they had no hope that anyone would come to their aid; for they remembered how, when the Persians first came and subjugated Eretria, nobody helped them or ventured to join them in the fight; and so they expected that the same thing would happen again this time. By sea, too, they saw no hope of safety, with more than a thousand warships bearing down on them. They saw only one hope of safety—a slight and desperate one, it is true, but the only one—and they drew it from the events of the past, when victory in battle had seemed to spring out of a desperate situation. Buoyed up by this hope, they realized that they must rely for refuge on themselves alone and on the gods. So all this created friendliness among them toward one another—both the fear that gripped them then and the fear born of the past, which they had acquired through their subjection to the former laws. This is the fear that, in our earlier discussions, we have often called reverence, saying that a man must be subject to it if he is to be good—though the coward is free of it and unafraid of it. If this fear had not seized our people then, they would never have united in self-defense, nor would they have defended their temples and tombs and fatherland, and their relatives and friends as well, in the way they then came to the rescue; instead, we would all have been broken up at that time and scattered one by one in every direction.

Megillus

699d What you say, Stranger, is perfectly true, and worthy of your country as well as of yourself.

Athenian

699d–699e That is so, Megillus; and it is proper to mention the events of that period to you, since you share in the native character of your ancestors. But both you and Clinias must now consider whether what we are saying is at all relevant to our lawmaking; for I am not telling my story for its own sake, but for the sake of the lawmaking I speak of. Just think: since we Athenians suffered practically the same fate as the Persians—they through reducing their people to the extreme of slavery, and we, on the contrary, through urging our populace on to the extreme of liberty—what are we to say happened next, if what we said earlier has been anywhere near correct?

Megillus

700a Well said! But try to make your meaning still clearer to us.

Musical Lawlessness and Excessive Freedom

Athenian

I will. Under the old laws, my friends, our common people had control over nothing, but were, so to speak, voluntary slaves to the laws.

Megillus

What laws do you mean?

Athenian

700a–700e First, those that dealt with the music of that age—so that we may describe from the beginning how the life of excessive liberty grew up. Among us at that time, music was divided into various classes and styles. One class of song consisted of prayers to the gods, which were called hymns; opposed to this was another class, best called dirges; paeans formed another; and yet another was the dithyramb, named, I imagine, after Dionysus. Nomes, too, were so called as being a distinct class of song, and these were further described as citharoedic nomes. With these and other kinds classified and fixed, it was forbidden to set one kind of words to a different class of tune. The authority whose duty it was to know these regulations, and, knowing them, to apply them in its judgments and to penalize the disobedient, was not the pipe, nor, as now, the unmusical shouting of the mob, nor yet the clapping that signals applause. Instead, those in charge of education made it a rule that they themselves would listen in silence throughout, while the children, their attendants, and the general crowd were kept in order by the discipline of the rod. In the matter of music the populace willingly submitted to orderly control and refrained from presuming to judge by uproar. But later on, as time went by, there arose poets as leaders of unmusical lawlessness—men who, though poetic by nature, were ignorant of what was just and lawful in music. Frenzied and possessed more than was proper by a spirit of pleasure, they mixed dirges with hymns and paeans with dithyrambs, imitated flute tunes with harp tunes, and blended every kind of music with every other. And so, through their folly, they unintentionally bore false witness against music, as though it had no standard of correctness at all and its best criterion were the pleasure of the listener, whether he is a good man or a bad one.

Athenian

700e–701b By compositions of this kind, set to similar words, they bred in the populace a spirit of lawlessness regarding music and the effrontery of thinking themselves capable of judging it. As a result, theater audiences became noisy instead of silent, as though they knew the difference between good and bad music, and in place of an aristocracy in music there arose a kind of base theatrocracy. For if a democracy of free men had arisen only in music, the result would not have been so very alarming; but as it was, the universal conceit of universal wisdom and the contempt for law began in music, and on the heels of these came liberty. For thinking themselves knowledgeable, people became fearless; and audacity fathered effrontery. For to be unafraid of the opinion of a better person because of self-confidence is nothing other than base effrontery, and it is brought about by a liberty that is audacious to excess.

Megillus

701b Most true.

Athenian

701b–701d Next after this form of liberty would come the liberty that refuses to submit to the rulers; and following that, the avoidance of submission to one’s parents and elders and their warnings; then, as the next-to-last stage, comes the effort to disregard the laws; while the very last stage is to lose all respect for oaths and pledges and the gods—in which people display and reproduce the character of the Titans of legend, who are said to have returned to their original state, dragging out a painful existence with never any rest from misery. What, again, is our purpose in saying all this? Clearly I must, every time, rein in my discussion like a horse, and not let it run away with me as though it had no bridle in its mouth, and so take a tumble off the donkey—as the saying goes. So I must once more repeat my question and ask: for what purpose has all this been said?

Megillus

701d Very good.

Athenian

What has just been said bears on the purposes stated earlier.

Megillus

What were they?

The Aims of Legislation

Athenian

We said that the lawgiver must aim at three objectives in his legislation: to make the state he is legislating for free, at unity with itself, and possessed of good sense. That was what we said, wasn’t it?

Megillus

701d–701e Certainly.

Athenian

701e With these purposes in view, we selected the most despotic of polities and the most completely free, and we are now inquiring which of these is rightly constituted. When we took a moderate example of each—of despotic rule on the one hand and of liberty on the other—we observed that at that time they enjoyed prosperity in the highest degree; but when they advanced, the one to the extreme of slavery and the other to the extreme of liberty, neither the one nor the other gained anything.

Megillus

702a Most true.

Athenian

702a–702b With the same purposes in view we also surveyed the settlement of the Dorian army, the homes of Dardanus at the foot of the hills, the colony by the sea, and the first people who survived the Flood, together with our earlier discussions about music and revelry, as well as everything that came before these. The purpose of all these discussions was to discover how a state might best be managed and how the individual citizen might best live his life. But as for the value of our conclusions, what test can we apply in talking among ourselves, Megillus and Clinias?

The Plan for a Cretan Colony

Clinias

702b–702d I think, Stranger, that I can see one. It is a piece of good luck for me that we have dealt with all these matters in our discussion. For I myself have now nearly reached the point where I will need them, and my meeting with you and Megillus here came at just the right time. I will not hide from you what has happened to me; in fact, I count it as a sign from Heaven. Most of Crete is undertaking to found a colony, and it has put the Knossians in charge of the undertaking, and the city of Knossos has entrusted it to me and nine others. We are also instructed to frame laws, choosing whichever ones we please, either from our own local laws or from those of other countries, without objecting to their foreign character, provided only that they seem superior. So let us grant this favor to me and to yourselves as well: let us select from what we have said and build up in argument the framework of a state, as though we were establishing it from the foundation. In this way we will at the same time be investigating our subject, and I may possibly also make use of our framework for the state that is to be formed.

Athenian

702d Your proclamation, Clinias, is certainly not a declaration of war! So if Megillus has no objection, you may count on me to do all I can to grant your wish.

Clinias

That is good to hear.

Megillus

702d–702e And you can count on me too.

Clinias

702e Splendid of you both! But first, let us try to found the state in words.

Book 4

Connections in Laws, Book 3

0 connections

No connections in this book yet.

Glossary

Search the Library